Parramatta were as dour and uninspiring as they come in 2018.
From top-four finalist in 2017 to wooden spoon just a season later, it is hard to see when Eels fans will finally get some sustained success.
They were the worst attacking team for the season, and failed to notch a win until Round 6, by which time their fate was effectively sealed. They would win just six times throughout the season, with highlights hard to come by.
Story of the off-season
Jarryd Hayne returned to Parrmatta last year with much fanfare but failed to spark the Eels early in the season. His strong end to the season however meant that their was plenty of push to re-sign him for 2019 and beyond.
Before that could eventuate, the fullback became the subject of sexual assault allegations. It leaves the Eels with one less option at fullback for 2019, and without the impact that Hayne could provide when in top form.
Recruits
Dylan Brown (2020), Andrew Davey (2019), Blake Ferguson (Sydney Roosters, 2021), Shaun Lane (Manly Sea Eagles, 2020), Junior Paulo (Canberra Raiders, 2022), Maika Sivo (Penrith Panthers, 2020), Stefano Utoikamanu (2019)
The Eels desperately needed some punch in the forwards last season and have added that with Junior Paulo returning from Canberra and Shaun Lane coming across from the Sea Eagles.
They also sorely missed the impact of Semi Radradra in 2018, and have tried to rectify that with premiership winner Blake Ferguson joining from the Roosters
Losses
Kirisome Auva’a (retired), Kenny Edwards (Catalan Dragons), Cameron King (Featherstone Rovers), Suaia Matagi (Huddersfield Giants), Corey Norman (St George Illawarra Dragons), Beau Scott (retired), Tony Williams (released)
After an underwhelming season partnering Mitch Moses in the halves, Corey Norman moves to the Dragons, leaving the door open for rookie half Dylan Brown. Veteran forward Beau Scott retired last season, while the other departures are hardly noteworthy.
How does their roster rate?
In a word: underwhelming. The Eels are lacking in a number of key areas, in experience and success.
They will go into the season with an inexperienced halves pairing that has played virtually no representative or finals football.
Mitch Moses was impressive in his first season with the Eels, but never really took control last season as his combination with Corey Norman never really got off the ground. They will probably have to put some faith in rookie recruit Dylan Brown in the halves, but at 18 he will be tested out at the elite level.
Brad Arthur tries to squint the pain away. (AAP Image/Brendan Esposito)
The loss of Hayne means the fullback jersey will be the property of either Clint Gutherson, Bevan French or Will Smith. Gutherson was shifted around the park last season, but always looked to be trying his guts out, and is likely to get first crack. French burst onto the scene in 2016, scoring 19 tries in 13 appearances.
A mixture of injury and poor form has hampered him since, a full pre-season may see him return to his best. Smith is unlikely is get the nod but has done a job for the Eels in the past.
With Cameron King departing the club the hooking role will go to Reed Mahoney who enjoyed a strong end to last year, playing nine games for the Eels. Whatever combination the Eels look to in the spine, the lack of experience is glaring.
These four positions are responsible for the creativeness of a football team, as well as game management. The Eels desperately need both and it is hard to see them getting it from such a young bunch.
The outside backs for the Eels are a highlight. They have George Jennings coming off a strong season, Blake Ferguson has played at the highest level. Bevan French has been a real attacking threat at his best. Brad Takarangi and Michael Jennings probably have their best football behind them but at least offer some experience and leadership.
Parramatta have made steps to improve their pack after they were frequently dominated last season. Junior Paulo and Nathan Brown are some aggression up front. Shaun Lane comes off a season where he scored nine tries for the Sea Eagles as their top try-scorer.
You get the feeling they still lack some size up front. Tim Mannah and Daniel Alvaro are consistent but lack any real spark or impact. Peni Terepo, Tepai Moeroa and Manu Ma’u are all similar in their stature and style of play. It is a pack that isn’t really dynamic or threatening to oppositions in attack and may again struggle for metres.
Key Man
Mitch Moses. Moses came to the Eels after a fairly acrimonious mid-year split with the Tigers in 2017. He was an instant success, helping the Eels to a top four finish and also taking over as goal-kicker.
With the departure of Corey Norman, Moses becomes the chief playmaker, with the responsibility squarely on his shoulders if the Eels are to do anything in 2018.
At 24 years of age and having already played over 100 NRL games, now is his time to shine. With an inexperienced side around him, this needs to be his team.
The Eels are struggling. (AAP Image/Dean Lewins)
Where do they need to improve?
On seven occasions the Eels were limited to a single try or less in a match. They scored the least point of any team in the competition and with five of their losses coming down to a converted try or less, their inability to score points left them unable to compete in matches.
They won just the six matches in 2018, and only managed to trouble a top 8 opponent on one occasion. They could slip away alarmingly in defence too, being routed by 20 points or more on four occasions. The Eels also failed to win away from home in 2018. Finding some spark in attack is a must for the Eels if they are to do anything in 2019.
Highlight of the season
After two seasons at ANZ Stadium, the Eels will return to Parramatta on Easter Monday to open Bankwest Stadium. It is a stadium that Western Sydney deserves, and will definitely be a sellout as the Tigers try to spoil the Eels party. Eels fans have had a tough decade and the Stadium hopefully will represent a new era for the club that has been trying for so long to find some long-term success.
Verdict
The Eels are in for another tough season, and it may very well cost Brad Arthur his job. While Arthur has done remarkably well to navigate some really tough seasons for the club, he has also failed to notch a finals win or bring a team together that looks capable of winning a premiership.
It is now obvious that 2017 was a flash in the pan, and that this roster has some really glaring deficiencies, considering Brad Arthur’s long tenure at the club, and admission last year that he was happy with the roster at his disposal.
The Eels go into 2019 with a spine that is likely to have less experience combined than Cameron Smith does himself.
Moses is the most experienced member of that spine and has spent much of his career promising so much but delivering so little.
Their outside backs are enigmatic, with many of them on their day genuine attacking threats, but with such recent inconsistency, it is hard to depend on any of them to provide the spark in attack they so desperately need.
Their headline recruit, Blake Ferguson is an indication of where the club is at. A winger is not going to save a club, or provide an attacking game to lift a team off the bottom of the ladder. They need an experience game manager to complement the rest of the young spine and have failed to chase that kind of player in recent times.
The Eels will improve on last season. A horror injury toll saw them use a league high 31 players and they are unlikely to face that sort of hardship once again.
The big occasion of a new stadium in their heartland will prove a highlight, and with teams maybe taking them lightly, they will improve on their tally of six wins. But Parramatta needs a serious rebuild, the likes of which the Panthers and Knights have had in recent time, and another wooden spoon may be the catalyst.
Predicted Finish: 16th
Damien
Guest
That’s great because they will definitely be under the Dogs at the end of the year 15th and 16th respectively.
Adam Bagnall
Roar Guru
One of their biggest issues is they have a lot of players no one wants. Norman went to Saints once Widdop was leaving, but what club would buy any of the other players, so they are stuck with a lousy roster for the forseeable future
Nat
Roar Guru
I'd imagine they had knowledge of his off-field behaviour. Looking at their roster, money couldn't be a huge issue but losing a player without the option of buying another may have been on their mind. Not sure he was asking though.
Charles
Guest
Hayne gone. They will do better this year, 14th.
WarHorse
Roar Rookie
A mathematical equation can solve this question..... Spoon = eels
Nat
Roar Guru
While I'm always one to say 'look how right I am...' :) The influence of Robbie beside him in the WC may have had a calming influence. That said, he is a quality player and sometimes a victim of trying too hard. However, he is far beyond the talented rookie these days, he should be the mature half (albeit 24yo) but +100 NRL starts has to account for something.
Nat
Roar Guru
Very true and I'm far from suggesting he'll take them anywhere near contenders. Just 'silver lining' I guess.
uglykiwi
Roar Pro
It has a lot to do with the juniors! From what I’ve heard; it is that the junior ranks stink of politics!!! They don’t pick the best players!! Mates sons, etc get picked over talent! You need an edge these days; with teams so evenly balanced; you need your cheap 100-200k juniors to step up; would the Roosters have won the competition last year if Radley hadn’t of stepped up?? I don’t think so... where are these players for Parra????
Big Daddy
Guest
Yeah, tend to agree with you about Smith. He's a bit of a hard but. I think French would struggle a bit. He needs to bulk up. There's some big winger's out there. I think Moses is better at five eight but who plays half. I think Norman is better off out of there as him and Moses were very similar. They really need some forwards.
Kilgore Trout
Roar Rookie
Team spirit and harmony is a big factor in success . They may well be a better team without the Hayne and Norman influence . Sometimes it only takes a few changes to totally alter a team dynamic . If Arthur can get them putting in for each other they could be way ahead of where they were in 2018 . If he can't , as much as I like him as a coach , his days could be numbered . I can see Brown getting a run in the halves however , Gutherson to 6 and Smith at fullback could be the way to go . If they cop a few long term injuries , another spoon could well be on the cards .
Big Daddy
Guest
Interesting take at Parramatta how they wanted to off load Norman, Moses, Jennings and didn't have enough money to resign Hayne. Also there are people still trying to get a new board. Makes you wonder what's going on. They have no forwards bar Nathan Brown and are still paying big money for someone like Tim Mannah. My tip wooden spoon again.
Paul
Roar Guru
I agree Shane, once you win 5 or more wooden spoons that should be it, so let's give the heave ho to the Bulldogs (5), Bunnies (8) and Roosters (5)
RandyM
Guest
Spoon contenders for 2019 are Parra, Canterbury, New Zealand and maybe Wests. You never know though, someone always has a horror season that no one predicted (cowboys last year) I think Manly have too much class and will get a boost with Des back. Knights and Titans seem to be on the up but both teams very capable of falling in a heap. Raiders seem to have a mortgage on 9th - 12th quarter of the table. I expect Cowboys to bounce back..
Wayne Turner
Guest
I agree with a. in a certain way. In pre-season for the 2018 they were expected to fight for the premiership. Yet they failed terribly. While 2017 pre-season not much was expected,and they made the top 4. Yes,after losing quite a few games in 2018,they then would have started to have lower expectations,and been underdogs that then continued to fail. But,I consider they are better at underdogs in pre-season expectations. The pre-season expectations effect the Eeels. They prefer being underdogs.
Wayne Turner
Guest
Since their last premiership in 1986 Parramatta have this,among other issues,happen quite often:- *When expected to go well - They massively disappoint. *When written off and expected to go badly - They surprise,and finish alot higher than expected. Parramatta seem to feel uncomfortable in being expected to go well.Instead they prefer low expectations,and being "underdogs". So,by this conclusion.Everyone is writing them off for 2019,so the outside pressure is off,and I expect them to surprise people,and I boldly predict they will come bottom half of the top 8.
Shane
Guest
The whole club is, always has been, and always will be, a joke. Total embarrasment to themselves and the game. With their large junior base, they should be regularly in the mix, but because their recruitment sucks, their staff have no idea and the whole organisation has the smell of loser about it, they will forever be living off the coattails of one decent side in the 1980's. I reckon once you win a certain amount of wooden spoons, you are either relocated or booted out permanently.
Paul
Roar Guru
I thought the Tigers were a lock for the wooden spoon last year and look what they did with a limited roster but some very good coaching, well executed game plans and guys who were willing to leave everything on the paddock. There's no reason Parra can't do something similar this year. I think they have a better roster than the Tigers did last year, so it's down to the coach to develop the right game plans and the players to execute. If they do, the Eels should comfortably avoid the wooden spoon. If not, Arthur goes and Parra are doomed.
BA Sports
Roar Guru
Moses has the potential - he showed it at the back end of 2017 and was pretty handy in the World Cup. But last year he got into this habit of playing his hand way too early and giving defences times to adjust and stop his attack. He needs a good halves coach to work with him and get him playing in the line where he has the talent to do damage. Last year he got frustrated with his lack of success and it resulted in ill-discipline. No doubt he needs to improve dramatically, but like many of the Eels players - there is upside to just about all of them, but it is whether they can get there.
Albo
Roar Rookie
Last year Fergo was playing with the spine of Tedesco, Cronk, Keary & Friend and with a few other handy types around like Cordner, Mitchell , Manu, Radley etc. He is now in for a real shock this season. It will be interesting to see how well he has matured under the coming pressure he has jumped into at the Eels.
Nat
Roar Guru
You know you're in trouble when your Key Man is Moses. Who would have thought it would be Brooks that stepped up in their parting ways? It does go to show the benefit of having a bit of experience/youth in the halves. Something a lot of teams could take heed of. Fergo, on last yrs form, is a decent buy but just hope he doesn't fall back into the 'boys club' mentality. That said, on paper, they shouldn't have come as close as they did in '17 so who knows.