Melbourne Demons vs Sydney Swans: AFL Friday night forecast

By Adrian Polykandrites / Expert

Surely you have something better to do than read about this dreadful match-up? No? Neither do I, I suppose, so who am I to judge.

In a raging endorsement for the AFL floating the fixture for more than just the final round, tonight’s penultimate Friday night of the home-and-away season is an absolute stinker.

Their two remaining games is at least one too many for Melbourne, whose miserable 2019 can’t come to an end soon enough. I can’t remember a season that promised so much and delivered so little.

There’s not a lot at stake, but that Carlton vs St Kilda game looks like a fun one. I reckon the Blues will snatch another win.

For the Swans, it’s been a pretty generic rebuilding year, only unique in the fact that it’s been the Swans doing the rebuilding. With a couple of winnable games to finish, they could end the season with eight wins and a very respectable percentage in the 90s and still land a top-four pick – perfect.

How exciting is the Lions-Cats clash at the Gabba? Not sure if it’s a bigger test for Brisbane or Geelong. Brisbane should be too strong at home. I can’t wait.

Last time Sydney and Melbourne met was back in Round 5 at the SCG, when the Demons scored their first four points of the season with a 22-point victory. Nathan Jones had 21 touches and three goals, while Jayden Hunt, Christian Petracca and Braydon Preuss each kicked two.

(Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

Adelaide versus Collingwood at the Adelaide Oval is a fascinating match-up. It’s almost do-or-die time for the Crows, who looked pretty sharp last week against West Coast, and the Magpies desperately need to find some form ahead of September. I can’t split them – toss a coin.

One thing the Swans haven’t lost is their ability to defend deep. John Longmire’s men are conceding a goal on just 20.5 per cent of their opponents’ forward-50 entries, which is the fourth-best rate in the league, and bad news for Melbourne whose 19.1 per cent forward-50-to-goal conversion rate is dead last – yep, worse than Gold Coast.

North Melbourne vs Port Adelaide at Marvel Stadium has surprisingly high stakes. The Roos – and new coach Rhyce Shaw – will be desperate for a better showing after a dismal performance in Geelong, and Port can put one foot in the September door with a win. Port for me.

Sydney have made one change, with veteran Kieren Jack coming in for the injured Zak Jones.

Ross Lyon vs John Worsfold could just about be a loser-leaves-town match. Freo should account for the Bombers at home.

Melbourne have swung the changes with Marty Hore, Billy Stretch, Charlie Spargo, Alex Neal-Bullen and debutant Kade Chandler coming into the 22 for injured trio Harrison Petty, Oscar McDonald and Steven May, plus Oskar Baker and Jayden Hunt, who have both been dropped.

Richmond vs West Coast shapes as one of the best games of the season. The Tigers should get it done and the MCG.

Tonight’s midfield battle shapes as an interesting one. Max Gawn should dominate fifth-gamer Hayden McLean and defender-turned-ruckman Aliir Aliir.

It’s a shame the Giants-Bulldogs game starts before the blockbuster at the G is over. The Dogs couldn’t have been more impressive a week ago and should be too good for GWS, who are still undermanned.

Both of these sides have had a hard time finding goals. The Demons have plunged off a cliff after being 2018’s highest scoring team. Christian Petracca is their leading goalscorer this season with 22 – he’s actually had a pretty good season and leads the league for forward-50 groundball gets.

Hawthorn vs Gold Coast might be the only game this round that’s an easy tip and also the only game less interesting than tonight’s – and even that’s debatable with it serving up Jarryd Roughead’s farewell game. Hawks by plenty.

Sydney should have more forward options with Daniel Menzel, Sam Reid, Tom Papley and Isaac Heeney all more than capable.

I’m tipping the Swans by two goals. That’s my Friday night forecast. What’s yours?

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

The Crowd Says:

2019-08-17T06:12:43+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


Only stadium owned by the afl is marvel.

2019-08-16T12:40:13+00:00

ScottyJ

Roar Rookie


You mean the AFL stadiums? Where they make the bulk of their income in winter from the AFL. Tonight the stadium was almost empty for a Friday night game. I'm sure the tv viewers was way down too so a loss of income for many involved. So yes marquee games required for prime time spots.

2019-08-16T09:14:10+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


but then you'll just complain that the 6th last round was fixtured wrong. Stadium operators are not just going to hold the entire footy season open for whatever day the AFL deems worthy of using the ground.

2019-08-16T07:21:01+00:00

Paul D

Roar Guru


My masters game is on at 630 this weekend so will have to give watching the Lions a miss - so long as we finish top 6 we will definitely have a home final either week 1 or 2 (maybe week 3 if we win an away qualifier!) so am saving my coins for that when it goes on sale

2019-08-16T06:58:46+00:00

ScottyJ

Roar Rookie


The way the Dees have played of late they appear to be tanking and now Goodwin is kicking up a stink regarding GC and their request for a priority pick. It would mean Melbourne would miss out on one of those top 2 draft picks they've had their eyes on. Clearly those 2 are head and shoulders above the rest of the pool.

2019-08-16T06:33:09+00:00

ScottyJ

Roar Rookie


At least the last 5 rounds

2019-08-16T05:41:29+00:00

DingoGray

Roar Guru


Friday night show..... "Who Tank's Wins ? " hosted by Mike Whitney..... What odds last season would of you got on these two team being in the Bottom half a dozen teams?

2019-08-16T05:14:15+00:00

Omnitrader

Roar Rookie


float the fixtures after the bye rounds

2019-08-16T03:59:42+00:00

Omnitrader

Roar Rookie


Kinda reads like Dory wrote this, the Dees season is similar to Adelaide last year when their wheels fell off. I'm excited for the top 4 teams playing each other this weekend and can only see the premiership winner coming from this 4.

2019-08-16T03:58:11+00:00

RT

Roar Rookie


And your proposal?

2019-08-16T03:08:22+00:00

Liam Salter

Roar Guru


I'm blogging the Lions' game tomorrow arvo, and yeah, it's weird comprehending that it's second versus first. Gonna be a fun one to blog!

2019-08-16T03:07:59+00:00

Liam Salter

Roar Guru


Heading along to the Lions game tomorrow, Paul? Surely this is one you'd wanna be at!

2019-08-16T02:57:59+00:00

Unknown Quantity

Roar Rookie


And this, ladies and gentleman, is why the current AFL fixturing is garbage...

2019-08-16T01:40:02+00:00

TomC

Roar Guru


Something of a thankless job for Adrian, having to write this article. It's a very strange feeling for the Lions to be the centre of attention. Just over a year ago when we last played the Cats we barely got mentioned in the 'expert' tips, while the Demons and Swans were both involved in critical games that would shape the finals. https://www.theroar.com.au/2018/07/26/roars-afl-expert-tips-predictions-round-19/ I must admit I'm finding it very hard to focus on any of the other games.

2019-08-16T00:38:27+00:00

Paul D

Roar Guru


Great article, as you allude to there are 8 other far more watchable games scheduled this weekend. I agree that this will be one of the easiest Friday games to miss since 2018 Carlton were scheduled

2019-08-16T00:22:41+00:00

Doc Disnick

Roar Guru


I love the second paragraph.

Read more at The Roar