AFL Trade News: Eddie Betts, Ollie Wines, James Aish, Brad Hill and more

By Josh / Expert

After six years, 132 games and 310 goals with the Adelaide Crows, Eddie Betts is back in navy blue once again after being traded home to Carlton for a bargain price on Monday.

The Crows and the Blues lodged a deal this afternoon which sees Betts move to Carlton for the price of the club’s 2020 future fourth-round selection.

It’s understood that Adelaide will pay a portion of Betts’ 2020 wage, but only a minor one. The star small forward was contracted for another year at the Crows.

Betts turned down the offer of a three-year contract at the Gold Coast Suns to instead pursue an emotional homecoming.

“It is good to be home,” said Betts.

“The Carlton Football Club has always had a special place in my heart. I cannot wait to pull on that navy blue guernsey again and run out in front of our passionate members and supporters.

“What excites me is the special feeling building at this club. To now be part of a forward line that includes some of the best young talent in the game – I want to help those guys take their game to the next level, so 2020 cannot come quick enough.

“I want this football club to be successful and I want to be part of setting a standard and building that successful culture. Bring on day one of pre-season so we can put in the hard work to get there.

“I would also like to thank the Adelaide Football Club for its understanding and especially to the Crows fans for their incredible support over the last six seasons: it was a privilege to play for you every week.”

Arguably the most intriguing news of the day was a report that Port Adelaide co-captain Ollie Wines’ management made an approach several weeks ago to Carlton, suggesting the Blues make a play for Wines’ services.

Already targetting two significant players in Tom Papley and Jack Martin, as well as looking to bring home Betts, the Blues decided not to pursue the opportunity.

This story prompted Port Adelaide to release a statement during the afternoon, clarifying that Wines had never requested a trade from the club, nor had Port considered trying to trade him.

The statement did not directly address the matter of Wines’ management’s reported contact with Carlton, however, Port’s management was later quoted denying they had made any approach to the Blues.

The trade period is of course often colloquially known as the AFL’s ‘festival of lies’ and theses statements don’t all add up together, so make of it what you will.

At the very least, it seems certain Wines will remain at Port Adelaide in 2020. Whether or not this becomes a story again next year is far less clear.

It was also reported that several Victorian clubs had held an interest in another Port Adelaide star, Robbie Gray. Port made no comment on this, but it’s understood he will be at the club next year.

(Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

In other news, it appears that James Aish is likely to play for a third AFL club in 2020, following reports that Fremantle has offered the Collingwood midfielder a three-year contract.

Aish has spent time in the backline at Collingwood which over the last two years has been coached by Justin Longmuir, who is of course now the new senior coach at Fremantle.

It’s understood that Collingwood are under serious salary cap pressure and willing to move players on in order to relieve that.

The Pies have Brodie Grundy, Jordan De Goey, Darcy Moore and skipper Scott Pendlebury all coming out of contract at the end of next year.

Aish is one of several names that has been linked to a move out of the club to relieve some of this pressure, along with Rupert Wills, Matt Scharenberg and Mason Cox.

While it’s unclear at the moment if there’s a serious suitor for any of the latter three, it seems likely that Aish will become a Docker in 2020.

Brad Hill still appears St Kilda bound despite reports on the weekend that Geelong had entered as a late challenger for his services, and were willing to send Sam Menegola to Fremantle as part of a deal.

It’s understood that St Kilda’s financial offer to Hill, in the realm of $900,000 per season, is more than the Cats would be able to match, making it difficult to see Hill agreeing to the move after already nominating St Kilda as his preferred destination.

St Kilda’s attempts to get a deal done for Hill may have been helped by the news that Gold Coast’s Ben King signed a two-year contract extension with Gold Coast, through till the end of the 2022 season, earlier this morning.

The Saints had publicly confirmed an interest in King should he be available at the end of next season, and it was widely speculated that they had ruled out using next year’s first-round selection in any trade deal, believing they might need it in a 2020 trade for King.

With that prospect now appearing to be firmly off the table, it gives St Kilda a larger range of assets from which to negotiate a deal, important given they also need to broke trades for Zak Jones, Dougal Howard, Paddy Ryder and Dan Butler.

(Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

In other news from the day, it’s understood that Sydney will secure the services of Lewis Taylor on a three-year deal, which does suggest they’re planning for life without Tom Papley.

Another fringe Lion, Tom Cutler, is set to find a new home at Essendon, with the Bombers and Bribane having already engaged in trade talks.

It’s also understood that Hawthorn ruckman Marc Pittonet will be traded to Carlton on a two-year deal, with a likely knock-on effect of Andrew Phillips leaving the Blues to join Essendon.

Geelong’s Zac Smith, who had also been linked to Essendon, will accept a two-year deal to return to the Gold Coast Suns, where he began his career.

The Crowd Says:

2019-10-15T07:52:24+00:00

Pedro The Fisherman

Roar Rookie


Yep. It has been interesting standing on the outside and watching the discussion of Hill's value. I have never seen him in that class and (IMHO) if he does go for 2 First Rounders then Geelong have been burnt in the Kelly trade.

2019-10-15T07:50:04+00:00

Pedro The Fisherman

Roar Rookie


So do Carlton it seems.

2019-10-15T07:48:24+00:00

Pedro The Fisherman

Roar Rookie


12 in 2 against the Suns actually. 37 in 21 games, so that means 25 in the other 19 games. 6 games where he kicked none and 4 where he kicked 1. 11 in his last 8 games, including 6 against the Gold Coast and 3 against St Kilda. By the end of the season he looked slower and had lost all penetration in his kick. Sides have worked out that if he is more than 40m out he will attempt to hand it off to a longer kick. Apart from that he was good :stoked:

2019-10-15T07:09:32+00:00

LoveDaGame

Roar Rookie


Forget trading James Aish....Collingwood should be pushing Reid, Varcoe, Scharenberg, thomas, cox, they add no value or injury prone and will free up the salary cap and also improve our position in the draft. Wild call, but maybe throw sidebottom (although I love him) to attract some high end draft picks.

2019-10-15T03:09:34+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


Not saying Hill is a bad player but no where near the price being bandied about

2019-10-14T23:55:58+00:00

The Brazilian

Roar Rookie


Yet to hear one good reason for keeping him.

2019-10-14T23:48:32+00:00

Aransan

Roar Rookie


Technically that is correct, I can't imagine Essendon matching $10m over 7 years but would Sydney be able to offer that?

2019-10-14T22:10:47+00:00

The Brazilian

Roar Rookie


Spot on. Pity they didn't 'play hard ball' in season. Might've won more games. Their demands during the trade period are ridiculous, at best. Give 'em nothing.

2019-10-14T21:59:05+00:00

The Brazilian

Roar Rookie


Essendon's demands for Daniher are absolutely outrageous. Way over the top. The club, and its fans, are putting a totally unrealistic price on Daniher's head. Little wonder clubs hate dealing with this mob. Freo, too, are becoming 'Essendon-like' at the negotiating table. Many people here are criticising the Saints yet they have acted in good faith in trying to secure a player who wants to join them. Shame on the Dockers. It is the behaviour of clubs like these two that make the draft period such a drag. Time for them to get real as opposed to screwing over opposition clubs. But I suppose a win or two during the off season helps them get over all those losses during the season proper.

2019-10-14T21:41:49+00:00

Vicboy

Roar Rookie


Apparently Adrian Dodoro is a good fella. But really since there has been a trade period Essendon have not done well. Hawthorn, by comparison are seen to pay “overs”, but get their man. Essendon seen as hardarses, so few will cry if they lose him for bugger all next year. Get the trade done like Geelong did!

2019-10-14T11:55:23+00:00

Maurice Mclernon

Guest


I rate Hill better than Kelly . Menagola although a good player comes no where near Hills class . The Cats for a chance next year would need him as their window is closing. And Yes this does get said every year but I do think it is this time.

2019-10-14T09:55:59+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


Sydney could offer a contract that Essendon would be unwilling to match.

2019-10-14T09:54:41+00:00

Jonboy

Roar Rookie


Just in, Hill deal is done with Saints.

2019-10-14T09:48:12+00:00

Cat

Roar Guru


That's a big pass.

2019-10-14T09:47:31+00:00

Cracka

Roar Rookie


If Essendon trade Daniher, why don't they go for Patton they could offer pick 31 or 33 for him GWS would jump at that, the Hawks would have to use pick 30 then to get him.

2019-10-14T09:46:45+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


You wanted Newnes...or had you forgotten? He won't be 26 forever. Freo keeps a person young but not Peter Pan young.

2019-10-14T08:34:28+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


Evidence of the socialism that pervades AFL governance.

2019-10-14T08:33:03+00:00

Jonboy

Roar Rookie


Gold Coast do make desperate decisions.

2019-10-14T08:31:00+00:00

Rowdy

Roar Rookie


I've been thinking that.

2019-10-14T08:28:31+00:00

Jonboy

Roar Rookie


Thought's on Hill ? Brad for picks 14-17 and Menagola ?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar