The Liebke Ratings: Australia vs New Zealand, first Test

By Dan Liebke / Expert

International cricket’s most beloved team New Zealand arrived on Australian shores to once again show up the home side with their effortless displays of sportsmanship, affability and completing one’s overs more or less within the scheduled time.

Heck, they tackled an umpire, but somehow managed to do so in a charming fashion. How do they do that?

Here are the ratings for the first Test between Australia and New Zealand.

Heat
Grade: D
The big talking point heading into the Test was heat. No, not the 1995 crime thriller starring Robert de Niro and Al Pacino. (Although The Godfather, Part II, starring those same actors was on SBS during the evening session of the third day. This tempted some fans unimpressed by Australia’s lack of declarations to switch over and watch the classic mob masterpiece instead. Which was a little odd. If you want to watch parallel stories of ruthless men rising to power and dominating all those who dare oppose them, why not stick with Steve Smith and Marnus Labuschagne?)

(But I digress.)

No, the heat in question here was the forty degree forecast for every day of the Test. This was to be a sweltering weapon in Australia’s match-winning strategy of a) winning the toss, b) batting until New Zealand dissolved into a puddle of extremely polite sunscreen and then c) mopping up from there.

Injured fast bowlers
Grade: B-
Operation Melt-A-Kiwi prospered even further when debutant Lockie Ferguson tore his calf on the first day, leaving the Black Caps a bowler short.

Luckily for New Zealand, they had Neil Wagner in their side, a ready-made fast-bowling lunatic willing to shoulder the bulk of the bowling despite the conditions. The kind of man who responds to the threat of 38 degree heat by performing push-ups before a spell.

Wagner, a cricketer who loves bouncers more than an early-90s Neighbours devotee, bowled 37 overs in total in Australia’s first innings.

He took 4/92, including David Warner, Steve Smith and Marnus Labuschagne for 43, 43 and 143 respectively. This was presumably some kind of l33t-speak-encoded message begging for further hydration.

New Zealand’s Neil Wagner. (AP Photo/Mark Baker)

This powerhouse display in the blistering Perth sun led most people to conclude that Neil Wagner is solar powered. Like Superman. Or a Casio fx-300A Scientific Calculator.

Later in the Test, Josh Hazlewood evened things up by following Ferguson’s lead and suffering a match-ending hamstring injury. Based on this Test’s evidence, it’s virtually impossible to split Ferguson and Hazlewood for who is the most sensible fast bowler in world cricket.

For a while, it looked as if each team might lose one bowler per innings until by the Third Test we’d see pace attacks of Billy Stanlake, Dan Christian and a recalled Shaun Tait facing off against Jimmy Neesham, a random All Black and one of those Flight of the Conchords lads.

Alas, that now seems unlikely.

Umpires
Grade: C+
New Zealand’s pursuit of Australia’s first innings total of 416 all out was hampered by a brutal opening spell under lights on the evening of the second day.

It was hampered even further when Colin de Grandhomme was given out caught in slips from a ball that bounced off his helmet.

Luckily, he had a review available which he used to send the decision upstairs. Less luckily, the third umpire chose to uphold the decision despite a lack of any mark on either Snicko or Hot Spot, claiming he didn’t have enough evidence to overturn the original call.

A wonderful moment for fans of confusing ‘evidence of absence’ with ‘absence of evidence’. That’s a niche audience, for sure. But they were both very satisfied.

Still, it’s good to give New Zealand a decision to be aggrieved by early. It lets them settle into the series.

Marnus Labuschagne
Grade: B+
With the umpires’ assistance, New Zealand ended a mere 250 runs short on the first innings, bowled out for 166.

Tim Paine chose not to enforce the follow on, allowing Marnus Labuschagne to score another half-century and, in the process, become the first Test batsman to reach a thousand runs in 2019. As they like to say in Rome, Marnus had M’ed up.

The moment when Marnus stole Steve’s cricketing prowess. (AP Photo/Matt Dunham)

Still, despite the runaway success of the Marnus Cinematic Universe, the Australian number three remains highly relatable.

In between his epic run-scoring and the occasional leg break that turns sharply out of the rough, you can still find him screaming nonsensical appeals for edges that nobody else hears, getting in the way of the keeper during panicky run out attempts and ordering KFC via the Fox Sports drone.

Marnus is truly one of us. Or, more precisely, given that ‘Marnus Labuschagne’ is the only Test cricketer in history to have ‘us’ in both first and surnames, he’s two of us.

Not Using A Bat
Grade: D
Australia eventually declared their second innings closed on 9/217, setting New Zealand 468 to win, a target approximately 297 runs too big. And by ‘approximately’, I mean ‘precisely’.

The highlight of Australia’s second innings was Matthew Wade, who spent an inordinate amount of time allowing Wagner’s short balls to strike him on the body.

One can only assume Wade’s refusal to use his bat was a natural response to being called upon to replace Hazlewood in the bowling attack during New Zealand’s first innings.

A whole-hearted contributor is Wade, so if he’s going to be the new Hazlewood – Hazlewade, presumably – he’s going to emulate all aspects of the fast bowler’s game, including not being able to lay bat on ball.

I look forward to Wade’s further bunnification and can’t wait to see him opening the bowling and batting at eleven during the Boxing Day Test.

The Crowd Says:

2019-12-16T14:04:17+00:00

Gee

Roar Rookie


https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hH2zx9lcV44 . Bouncers Dream, the greatest minute in broadcast TV history.

2019-12-16T09:56:59+00:00

Rossi

Roar Rookie


Would love to have seen Jemaine bowl some sugarlumps at Hazlewade

2019-12-16T07:49:37+00:00

dungerBob

Roar Rookie


Fair question but I didn't see him take his hand off the bat BM. There were actually 2 marks. The one on the glove and the one on the helmet. It looked pretty conclusive to me. I reckon the side on view would have shown it nicely but it wasn't available for most of the match for some reason.

2019-12-16T07:05:26+00:00

badmanners

Roar Rookie


I thought I saw that too but was his hand still on the bat when it was hit? He took a long time to review whereas in the second dig he was right on it and proved correct.

2019-12-16T07:03:24+00:00

The Late News

Roar Rookie


well there you go!

2019-12-16T06:47:31+00:00

tsuru

Roar Rookie


And, come to think of it, there was the couple in England who were enormous fans of Liverpool F.C. They had a son just after Liverpool won the championship and gave him the eleven first names of the Liverpool team.

2019-12-16T06:42:26+00:00

tsuru

Roar Rookie


Not so sure of that, TLN. I once worked with a woman whose family name was Head. Named her son Richard.

2019-12-16T04:14:02+00:00

Diamond Jackie

Roar Rookie


No... I showed mine (unfortunately! ! :crying:

2019-12-16T03:46:02+00:00

Blackfoot

Guest


And here I was thinking , what’s all the fuss about, there’s a big round white patch on his glove , but I then questioned what I had seen , as it seemed I was the only one that saw it. Well there’s at least one more who did .

2019-12-16T02:46:03+00:00

Mango Jack

Roar Guru


Very sporting of Australia to offer NZ a "pair" in the form of Hazlewood.

2019-12-16T01:54:46+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


The Black Caps got first advantage from the Umpires with the call on Burns first innings. I just can't warm to the idea that it was Australia's fault for not reviewing. Clearly missing, we all saw it, yet the wrong decision was held because Australia didn't review. I know, it cancels out in the long run, but surely the the DRS system is at fault for allowing wrong decisions to stand.

2019-12-16T01:08:32+00:00

The Late News

Roar Rookie


NO parents could be that stupid!

2019-12-16T01:06:57+00:00

The Late News

Roar Rookie


Brought several smiles out Dan! Great read...

2019-12-16T00:56:26+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Showing my age :)

2019-12-16T00:47:26+00:00

Diamond Jackie

Roar Rookie


Bouncer the lovable Labrador from neighbours!

2019-12-15T23:59:16+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


Are we sure there were no Usman Usmans or similar from Pakistan though?

2019-12-15T23:58:36+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


I was leaning towards a B+ plus for this article, but had to give it an A after the reference to Erasmus’s third umpiring as a “wonderful moment for fans of confusing ‘evidence of absence’ with ‘absence of evidence’ . Despite feeling inadequate that I didn’t get the reference to bouncers in Neighbours. Erasmus’s approach to epistemology confused me in the second innings when he gave Watling out despite their being only the tiniest hint of a mark on hotspot and nothing on Snicko, yet felt not only was this convincing evidence he had gloved it (the proper standard) but convincing enough to overturn the ump on the field (the standard he used in the first innings). Wade’s use of the body and initial movement onto the front foot when every ball was short was truly weird.

2019-12-15T21:20:12+00:00

dungerBob

Roar Rookie


Operation 'Melt-a-Kiwi' was a success. Just a little more and you could have served them up with some baked potatoes and pumpkin. .. I'm starting to believe I'm the only one who spotted the evidence that TheBigMan was indeed out fairly and squarely. The final time they showed the front on hot spot they allowed the vision to roll through a few more frames and when he'd dropped his hands there was a big, beautiful, cricket ball shaped mark on the wristband of his left glove. I put it on freeze frame and pointed it out to the wife, the cat and the big huntsman on the ceiling. It was crystal clear and obvious. Dar got it right.

2019-12-15T20:23:20+00:00

JGK

Roar Guru


I’ll never forget the day they took Bouncer “to the farm”. Loved the Us Us reference.

Read more at The Roar