Australia seems to be living in another world when it comes to the All Blacks

By joker_in_the_pack / Roar Rookie

When Australian scrumhalf Nic White was walking off the field after the whistle blew for halftime in the third Bledisloe Cup game on 31 October, he was given a headset and microphone by Fox Sports and asked for his take on the game up to that point.

Australia had been outplayed by New Zealand in the first 40 minutes and were trailing 0-26, meaning that the horse had well and truly bolted and any chance of them making a fight of it had disappeared.

But White seemed to be in an alternate universe. “No disrespect, but they haven’t done a whole lot, it’s just been all our mistakes. We’re just gifting them points,” was what he had to offer.

When commentator Phil Kearns, a man who played 67 Tests for the Wallabies, came back with “67 percent possession they got, mate,” White quickly took off the headphones, handed them to a man on the Fox Sports team and walked away into the change rooms.

The exchange reminded me of the way the American tennis player Serena Williams reacts when she loses during a Grand Slam – it’s because she played badly, not because her vanquisher played a good game.

One offers this exchange to illustrate one point: unless one acknowledges one’s mistakes, it is not possible to correct them.

True, White may have been indulging in spin as many people do when confronted by the media, but had he acknowledged that Australia was behind because it had come up against a side that was doing all the basics extremely well, he probably would have been more accurate.

Like many other Australians, White seems to have a big blind spot when it comes to acknowledging that one has been outplayed.

Nic White. (Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

To the match itself, it was practically over after the first half. Few teams can come back from such a deficit – and bear in mind that two additional tries were not awarded to the men in black. One was due to a marvellous save by Australian winger Marike Koroibete, who got under the ball when Kiwi wing-three-quarter Caleb Clarke, no easy customer to tackle, was trying to force down.

The other try that was disallowed was debatable; hooker Dane Coles charged onto a kick into the in-goal area by flyhalf Richie Mo’unga, and tried to get his hands on the ball and effect a touchdown. From some angles, it looked like he had succeeded. From others, it appeared that he did not have full control of the ball.

But even then, the All Blacks ran in four tries, some of which should never be allowed at the international level. Mo’unga was in top form and used all his guile and skills to cross for two of the four tries which his team scored before halftime.

The great West Indies teams of the 1980s and early 1990s had a tactic of targeting bowlers who either were becoming a threat to them, or else thought they were becoming a threat, and demoralising them. The main method used was for Viv Richards to attack the bowler in question and take him to the cleaners. It worked in many cases.

Similarly, the All Blacks appear to have a strategy of making newcomers in opposing teams feel out of place and this often results in the newbie suffering a major crisis of confidence. In the case of Noah Lolesio, picked to make his debut as standoff, perhaps their task was easier for the pint-sized flyhalf seemed to be intent on making himself a small target.

(Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

The No 10 is normally the playmaker, but Lolesio seemed content to operate from where a fullback normally positions himself/herself, and kick when he got the ball. His kicking was poor, and in one case, when kicking for touch, he landed the ball in the in-goal area.

It looks like picking him for his international debut against the All Blacks was not the most judicious move by Australian coach Dave Rennie.

The fact that Rennie had to pick Lolesio to fill the No 10 spot is a glaring admission that Australia has very little depth when it comes to players.

Bernard Foley, a reliable if unspectacular flyhalf, went off to Japan after the 2019 World Cup, but it is doubtful he would have been picked this year given his disastrous performance in the one game he played during that tournament.

One wonders what Rennie will do in the remaining game against New Zealand. He cannot drop Lolesio for it would destroy the man’s confidence. He will have to bring back James O’Connor to fill this pivotal role as he is now fit to resume playing. But Lolesio will have to be in the match-day 23.

One hopes that Rennie will bring Tom Banks who did a decent job at fullback in the first two Tests against New Zealand before being suddenly dropped for the third.

The coach should also pick Isi Naisarani in the No 8 position and jettison Harry Wilson; the latter appears to be a hot-head and woefully short of common-sense and ability. Exactly why Naisarani, a Fijian who did a wonderful job last year, has been kept out of the team is not known.

Brisbane has been a somewhat happier hunting ground for Australia against New Zealand. But the scars suffered in the third game — where they went down by the biggest margin in any game against New Zealand — may not be so easy to heal. But at least this time there will be no overblown expectations that Australia will make a contest of the game.

The Crowd Says:

2020-11-05T00:34:13+00:00

valleybeanie

Roar Rookie


Agree Keg, Hannigan and neither of the Aussie locks/second rowers look test standard - Rory Arnold a big loss.

2020-11-04T10:37:55+00:00

Mike

Roar Rookie


We did lose to the ABs before Hooper became captain. Rather a lot. I don't have a problem with changing the captain, but the idea that Hooper is somehow responsible for us losing games to the All Blacks seems far-fetched

2020-11-04T10:31:49+00:00

Mike

Roar Rookie


“Hooper is the weakest flanker out of the following: Smith, Waugh, Gill, Fardy, Pocock…….” You forgot David Wilson, Tony Shaw and Simon Poidevin. Hooper is worse than all of them and that is why he must be dropped from the team in 2020.

2020-11-04T10:15:41+00:00

Mike

Roar Rookie


I think it depends on who does the half-time talk. AAC used to be good at saying some words to the microphone which said nothing and offended nobody, but sounded good. There's a real art to doing that.

2020-11-04T07:43:57+00:00

andyfnq

Roar Rookie


"The exchange reminded me of the way the American tennis player Serena Williams reacts when she loses during a Grand Slam – it’s because she played badly, not because her vanquisher played a good game." The difference is that when Serena says it, it's true... and she has the record to back it up :laughing:

2020-11-04T05:17:51+00:00

Wombatz

Roar Rookie


The ticket pricing is too high. RA is still charging premium rates for a product which is getting less popular, which is understandable given the game's financial position, but probably the wrong approach. Drop the pricing by 50% and you might get double the fans and still make the same money, but get more atmosphere, fan exposure and kids attending. Need new fans all the time, not just well heeled die hard supporters....

2020-11-04T02:28:05+00:00

Tree Son

Roar Rookie


Oh man Higs was my guy. In light of the alternatives at 6/8 it was one of the worst selection decisions of the past administration, among many.

2020-11-03T23:07:33+00:00


Also RA has the opportunity to do a major promotion but apart from FOX adds on FOX I did not see one other advert or promotion for the game......They need to step up and stop relying on FOX to promote anything. I do hope ch 9 gets the rugby but I fear they will only get part of it and us fans will still need FOX to watch the OS stuff. I dont see anything RA has to offer NZR at the moment. Both will benifit financially from a crossover at the end of their own domestic comps but thats about it...

2020-11-03T21:42:40+00:00

Dean

Roar Rookie


I see, you expect a committed tackler with exceptional timing, to use his micro jet boosters (whilst out of contact with the ground) to halt his momentum mid air - in the nano second prior to pre determined impact. I’m interested in the physics of this, please explain. Don’t let his exceptional timing and technique cloud your judgement just because he isn’t wearing black. Perhaps you are a bot sent by NZ to destroy a players reputation when they are too good? The only Australian player with questionable technique (not timing) has been Paisami. I guess Barrett was unfairly penalised as well?

2020-11-03T17:46:44+00:00

Ad-O

Guest


What did you expect Nic White to say? Advise all Aussies to change the channel cos we're crap and don't deserve to be on the same pitch as the All Blacks. And because he didn't that's some sort of evidence of a national character deficit? Seems people will write any old trash to get a rise up.

2020-11-03T14:59:54+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Kiwis were outnumbering aussie supporters at Sydney matches since the late 70's apparently. Bob Dwyer apparently wanted a cap on kiwis because it was essentially turning into an NZ home game. :laughing:

2020-11-03T13:57:43+00:00

The Neutral View From Sweden

Roar Guru


The main point is, all three stadiums are really poor for rugby but the Kiwis did not care, they filled the stadiums almost (despite some really poor weather in Wellington). And I am pretty sure that I have been to a lot more stadiums around the world than you, so I can make the call if a stadium is good or not.

2020-11-03T13:51:11+00:00

nroko

Roar Rookie


There could be a multitude of reasons, rain was a factor also in Wellington, but it got more crowd. The issue that I have is RA, specifically Hamish McLennan, has been saying that NZ rugby needs Australia, because it's a larger population, economy etc but the fact is rugby is still in a downward trend in Australia, as the crowd suggests. So what exactly can it offer to NZ rugby apart from the potential (or hope) that rugby ticks upwards?

2020-11-03T12:42:15+00:00

Wigeye

Guest


Wallaby's keep the young guns,building remember. -whites mo must go -Hooper dropped for a match to see how they go as don't see him talk much but combes hair a lot. Don't choose hodge for late long range penalties just take them during match

2020-11-03T12:13:51+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Don't get your Jokers mixed up. Only one has consistent contact with planet earth.

2020-11-03T12:07:09+00:00

Loosey

Roar Rookie


Well you know that in the land of the blind, one-eyed man is king. What you Enzud fellas lack in tact you sure make up for in conviction.

2020-11-03T12:00:16+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


They were pushed close together Moa to contain the virus. And for mine, the Wallabies practiced too much social distancing when the ABs had the ball in broken play.

2020-11-03T11:57:22+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


'pandemic running rampant"...........? Agree with the rest. It's a concrete elephant out at Stadium Australia.

2020-11-03T11:42:40+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


I'm looking forward to hearing about it for another decade or so on here!!

2020-11-03T11:33:16+00:00

Double Agent

Guest


"Smith, Waugh, Gill, Fardy, Pocock" - are they available for selection?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar