State of Origin 2 player ratings: NSW Blues

By Daniel Jeffrey / Editor

The NSW Blues have kept the 2020 State of Origin series alive with a commanding 34-10 win over the Maroons in Game 2.

After struggling to get much from them in Adelaide, the entire spine for NSW was absolutely outstanding, and the forwards came out with a clear intent to dominate the contact zone.

Here’s how each of the 17 Blues rated in Sydney.

1. James Tedesco: 10/10
Another typically brilliant Origin performance from the NSW fullback. Tedesco looked to relish the Blues captaincy, putting himself in the front line in attack more often and constantly threatening the Queensland defence. Finished with two line breaks, two try assists, a try, and a game-high 238 running metres.

James Tedesco with Tyson Frizell. (Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

2. Daniel Tupou: 8
After hardly kicking to him in the second half of Game 1, the Maroons went to Tupou’s side plenty at the start of Game 2, and the big winger made them pay. He was damaging running the ball back, then nabbed his first Origin try after halftime.

3. Clint Gutherson: 6
A quiet night, but Gutheron was solid in defence, and fairly reliable in attack, even if he did come up with a couple of errors.

4. Jack Wighton: 6
A bad read from Wighton helped Xavier Coates cross early for the Maroons (although take nothing away from the outstanding finish), but he redeemed himself by bursting through a Dane Gagai tackle for a try to start the second half which put the game to bed.

5. Josh Addo-Carr: 8
One of the Blues’ best in Game 1, nothing changed for Addo-Carr in Sydney. Provided two outstanding long-range chases to force drop-outs and help turn the momentum in the first half, and another Origin double was thoroughly deserved.

6. Cody Walker: 8
Scored a try, had a hand in a few more, and combined well with Cleary. Some of his last-tackle kicks in the first half weren’t great, but they improved in the second to round out a good performance from Walker.

7. Nathan Cleary: 10
This is the Nathan Cleary Blues fans have been waiting for. His kicking game was unrecognisable from last week, as he controlled the game superbly with the boot. He took the line on more often as well, and laid on the last pass for James Tedesco’s first-half try. Add in some good defence and it was a great outing from Cleary.

(Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

8. Daniel Saifiti: 8
Made ten metres a run and didn’t miss a tackle. Gave away a penalty, but it was another good Origin outing from Saifiti.

9. Damien Cook: 8
Cook was busy all night around the ruck with the ball in hand, helping the Blues gain good metres through the middle. The little hooker was efficient in defence as well.

10. Payne Haas: 8
Haas produced a strong shift early on from even as the Blues struggled out of the gates. Wasn’t at his smartest when he was baited into exchanging fisticuffs with Tino Fa’asuamaleaui and sent to the bin for his troubles, but still finished with more metres than any other Blues forward. Justified his promotion to the starting side.

11. Angus Crichton: 8
Massive effort from the second-rower, particularly in the first half. With his improved physicality, he looked like the Angus Crichton of South Sydney times.

12. Tyson Frizell: 6
Frizell’s biggest impact came early in the game when his challenge on Cameron Munster forced the Maroons five-eighth out of the game. Didn’t have a huge role in attack, and was his usual excellent self in defence.

13. Jake Trbojevic: 8
Trbojevic’s stats line might make for meagre reading, but it doesn’t reveal the lock’s full impact. He laid on a number of crunching tackles, including one bone-rattler when he picked out poor Xavier Coates, to help NSW gain physical dominance, and is an important ball-player for the Blues around the middle of the park.

14. Dale Finucane: 7
Finucane hardly had to make a tackle in what was a relatively short stint, so he had plenty of energy to put into his ball-running – and it showed, with the Melbourne lock almost making ten metres every time he went on the charge. Should have played in the series opener.

15. Junior Paulo: 7
Paulo ran hard and offloaded well. Wasn’t superb in defence, but his impact in attack outweighed his few tackle misses.

16. Nathan Brown: 6
Turned Jake Friend into a speedbump with his very first run, but didn’t have all that much work to do in less than 20 minutes on the field.

17. Isaah Yeo: 8
Like Finucane, Yeo should have played in Game 1. His footwork going into contact was excellent, helping him to the second-most running metres of any Blues forward (127, equal with Saifiti). Throw in a flawless tackling scorecard and it was an excellent debut from the Panthers star.

The Crowd Says:

2020-11-13T04:58:43+00:00

Gun Dog

Roar Rookie


Yep..lots of go forward ..that is what was missing in game 1..

2020-11-12T11:22:14+00:00

Gun Dog

Roar Rookie


Yep..he took the ball up hard and straight..the NSW forwards won the game for them.. They were excellent..loads of grunt...

2020-11-12T09:33:57+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Haha...yeah it’s usually the people who say the NRL is inept, incompetent and couldn’t organise a chook raffle who in the next breath claim this multi tiered, wide reaching conspiracy theory so efficiently run that there’s never been a whisper or a whistleblower...

2020-11-12T07:02:16+00:00

Gun Dog

Roar Rookie


Agree they both should have been given an 8!!!

2020-11-12T06:04:59+00:00

Muzz

Guest


NSW were near perfect.

2020-11-12T04:25:48+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


Yep ! It Seems we are trying to copy Rugby’s Gordon Bray for inane bits of information like his Twickenham history : “The former cabbage patch has been the home of rugby for over a century. A great theatre, it hosted the 1991 World Cup final won by Australia. Twickenham has hosted U2 and the Rolling Stones. It’s even hosted the Jehovah Witnesses.” Or for background on Japan’s Amanaki Mafi : “There’s Mafi; he’s the 15th of 16 kids in his family!”

2020-11-12T04:12:20+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


I agree Harry. But then most edge forwards don't pass the ball either, whether under instruction or through lack of ability ? Crichton, just like Cordner who he replaced, rarely pass the ball, but they both do plenty of tough hit ups, chasing of kicks and strong defensive work.

2020-11-12T04:00:54+00:00

Harry

Guest


Crichton almost never looked to his outside though - pretty much every time he got his hands on the ball he ran it back on an angle. They were good, tough runs, and he did it really well, but a second-rower these days also has to be a link man between the halves and the outside backs. It was pretty telling that on the one occasion Wighton got space to do his thing, and scored a try, it was because of an early ball from Walker which cut out Crichton entirely.

2020-11-12T02:54:04+00:00

Ja ja klazo

Guest


Totally agree Crichton was sensational. But not sure where these 'crichton of old' comments are coming from. Thought he was one of the roosters best this year

2020-11-12T02:51:22+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


Won us the game...controversially admittedly.

2020-11-12T02:28:35+00:00

Tight-Head

Roar Rookie


I think there was a bit of confusion last week between keary and Cleary as to who was running the team - one of them probably had to go, and walker complements Cleary a bit better I think despite keary being a better all-round player.

2020-11-12T02:14:38+00:00

Dwanye

Roar Rookie


Lol. If this was a thing there is no way the organisation could keep it a secret. What, Four Corners or whoever wouldn’t find the linesmen or ref that was giving a brown paper bag? Lol

2020-11-12T02:09:06+00:00

Noosa Duck

Roar Rookie


Cleary certainly surprised me with that performance, best I have ever seen him play. The extra point for Teddy was for leading by example and he was certainly inspirational so I agree with the 10, however I reckon Crichton was at least a 9 he really was in everything and he was taking on a leadership roll last night which I have never seen in him previously. As you said Daniel he looked like the Crichton of old and it was terrific to watch.

2020-11-12T01:39:40+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


Yeo = 40 minutes - 11 runs for 127 m ( 61 post contact) best of the NSW forwards but for Haas & he had 15 tackles & no misses. Crichton = 76 minutes - 15 runs for 124 m (64 post contact) & 28 tackles ( 2nd most behind Cook) with 2 misses. I'm happy with the 8 ratings.

2020-11-12T01:33:13+00:00

Andrew01

Roar Rookie


An '8' for Yeo! Did you know his parents used to bring him down from Dubbo to Sydney every weekend to play his rep footy?! That tid bit has become the "Damien Cook was a beach sprint champion" of 2020....

2020-11-12T01:07:48+00:00

Adam Bagnall

Roar Guru


Not sure I agree with Yeo and Crichton as an 8.

2020-11-12T00:57:33+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


And his defence on the try line saved a couple of QLD tries

2020-11-12T00:21:45+00:00

Sideline Commentator

Roar Guru


A 6 Tyson Frizell is a little harsh. He added an intensity early that seemed to set a tone for the blues, and returned pretty well after getting his eyebrow split. I'd argue for a 7, as that aggression was missing in the first game and he clearly came out ready to get stuck in.

2020-11-11T23:39:22+00:00

Pete

Guest


Have to feel for Keary. If he had that platform from the forwards in Game 1 he and Teddy could of caused all sorts of damage.

2020-11-11T23:35:27+00:00

Don

Roar Rookie


The NSW forwards worked a lot harder and their kick chase was superb, particularly Crichton and Trbojevic. But there was also some good sneaky work by all players in positioning themselves in the line as blockers whilst Cleary kicked. Last week QLD got a lot of clearer shots at the halves. Boy QLD missed Munster and Welch!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar