Just for kicks, 'incredible' Cleary fires for Panthers, Manly terrific even without Tom

By News / Wire

Nathan Cleary played a starring role as Penrith laid to rest any concerns about their form as the NRL finals approach, ending South Sydney’s 10-game winning streak and making a statement with a 25-12 victory at Suncorp Stadium.

After the Rabbitohs bolted out of the blocks to lead 12-0 after 23 minutes, last year’s grand finalists Penrith produced a near-perfect second half to show they are back near their best.

Cleary was back to his old self as he terrorised former teammate Josh Mansour with his bombs, while Paul Momirovski was an unlikely hero with his boot.

“They were getting dominated early by Souths but some brilliance from Cleary has had him in complete control,” said Mick Ennis on Fox Sports.

“He has taken everything away from Souths, his kicking game has been incredible. Suffocating… Nathan has been outstanding, he needed a big night confidence-wise.

“He’s been the Nathan Cleary of earlier in the season and this last 50 minutes he’s been great.”

The only worry for Penrith was a concussion suffered by fullback Dylan Edwards, leaving Stephen Crichton to make his mark at fullback.

While the two sides will almost certainly face each other again in a qualifying final next month, Penrith showed they loom as a title challenger to defending premiers Melbourne after their first game at anywhere near full strength since June.

And it was Cleary who had his fingerprints all over it, creating something out of nothing for the Panthers’ first points.

The halfback put on a two-man cut-out ball for Kurt Capewell, before winger Paul Momirovski kicked back in field for Cleary to score.

Momirovski’s boot had Penrith back to 12-10 down on halftime, when he got cramped for space on the right before a shallow chip helped Crichton score.

Then it was Cleary’s kicking game that was the difference in the second half.

The Panthers No.7 kept Penrith locked in on the Rabbitohs’ line, with a Tom Burgess high tackle allowing Cleary to kick the Panthers level.

Moments later they found themselves in the lead when Mark Nicholls was pinged for a downtown penalty, letting Cleary kick Penrith two clear.

And after Matt Burton put winger Brent Naden over unmarked, it was a Cleary field goal from 20m out that wrapped up the game before a late Api Koroisau try.

The result means South Sydney will enter the finals without a win over either the Panthers or Melbourne this season.

While they conceded 50 against both those sides earlier this year, Friday night at Suncorp Stadium at least showed how far they have come.

But at the same, they still have some way to go

Their first try came after an Edwards error and their second through Latrell Mitchell was after a perfect Adam Reynolds 40-20, but they lacked the impetus in the second half.

Playmaker Cody Walker was unable to make the same impact he has in the past three months, while none of their forward ran 100 metres.

They also ended the night with Keaon Koloamatangi on report, potentially in trouble for a crusher tackle on Naden.

Meanwhile, Manly have shrugged aside the absence of Tom Trbojevic, conjuring a second-half revival to beat Canberra 19-18, boost their NRL top-four hopes and deny the Raiders entry to the top eight.

The Raiders looked to have the measure of the Turbo-less Sea Eagles in a gritty first spell that played into their hands as they ran up a 12-0 halftime lead.

But hard-running pair Moses Suli and Haumole Olakau’atu ignited the Sea Eagles while Jake Trbojevic laid two match-changing tackles and captain Daly Cherry-Evans sealed the win with his boot.

Trbojevic knocked the ball loose from Charnze Nicholl-Klokstad’s first carry in his return from neck surgery, Morgan Harper scoring from the next play to level proceedings.

Then he somehow managed to halt Josh Papalii as the Raiders prop stormed within reach of an equaliser.

Either side of that tackle Cherry-Evans laid on a pinpoint grubber for a Curtis Sironen try and then nailed the decisive late field goal to put them seven ahead.

Introduced for the last 25 minutes of the match, Nicholl-Klokstad did go over with 30 seconds to play.

But, after being piggy-backed up field by a penalty, Jordan Rapana scuffed his two-point field goal attempt from 45m that would have snatched a win.

“I don’t think they were thinking about it like that,” Manly coach Des Hasler said of his side finding a way to win without their star fullback, who he said would return from his cheek injury next week.

“They knew they had a game tonight with plenty of cause for both sides, both had goals.

“It was tough game of footy and I think we needed that game actually, it’s come at a good time.”

The result put the Sea Eagles level with the Sydney Roosters, who have a game in hand, in fourth with two games remaining while the Raiders missed their chance to jump from ninth to seventh.

“We’d be in the grand final if it was down to courage and effort,” frustrated Raiders coach Ricky Stuart said.

“Unfortunately we needed a bit more than that and in certain periods of play we didn’t have it.

“It’s hard losing that way when you put so much courage and effort into 80 minutes of footy.”

Manly looked offensively lost in their first scoreless first half of the season, seven errors to the Raiders’ four not helping their cause.

Harley Smith-Shields scored after Joe Tapine had stripped possession then Jack Wighton put Bailey Simonsson over in the corner to set up Canerra’s halftime lead.

Olakau’atu, denied a try in the first half after replays found an obstruction, wasn’t turned away a second time though.

He twisted out of a tackle to score after Suli (career-high 217 run metres) had made the break to begin the Sea Eagles’ resurgence.

The Crowd Says:

2021-08-22T23:36:50+00:00

steveng

Roar Rookie


Firstly, the men of the match in this game was surely "Atkins and Perenara" as and after the 20min mark these two just took this game over! IMO, if the refereeing is going to be refereed like this game was in the finals games then I won't have anything to do with watching the NRL. This game could have been one of the best games of 2021 and it was spoiled as usual by ridiculous refereeing and not by refereeing that should have let the game flow , this is nothing new and/or unusual as its been part of the course in the NRL for many decades.

2021-08-22T08:38:19+00:00

Pomoz

Roar Rookie


I think adding Fisher Harris and Brian To'o might add a little bit to the team.

2021-08-22T05:39:04+00:00

Bingo

Roar Rookie


Watched him in Brisbane for years. He’s a cream puff when it gets tough. Just like his mate David Fifita.

2021-08-22T05:36:20+00:00

Bingo

Roar Rookie


Grant Atkins should be dropped to reserve grade after that one sided performance. Very inconsistent and the bunker didn’t help him. Naden backs into a tackle and then goes down with a “crusher” to con Atkins into giving Penrith a piggy back penalty. Absolutely naive refereeing. Milked the ref like a big jersey cow. To compound that Kaloamatangi is charged by the match review and the “system” is against him. The dominos that fall because Atkins was milked by Naden. An average player milking and an equally average referee.

2021-08-21T23:56:50+00:00

Joey

Guest


‘..no more excuse, the Rabbitohs will be up for it next time’ . 1/ admission of excuses made 2/ admission Souths weren’t up to it. Defence Rests.

2021-08-21T10:33:07+00:00

Joey

Guest


Maybe instead of going to the Bunker - it should be Ask Albo ?

2021-08-21T09:56:26+00:00

Joey

Guest


Good on you, (no one). Panthers fan base is only 2%’if the total fan base, hence the prickliness when we win. Every bit of admiration from other fans is most welcome.

2021-08-21T06:41:16+00:00

Adam

Roar Guru


You'll have to live a lot longer than all of us...its been 110 years and it still hasnt happened

2021-08-21T06:18:02+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


You're right Albo, but I'm not sure how that matches up with Stuart's comment about courage? If anything, it's deflecting from the decision to bring CNK into the game, which resulted in the errors you described.

2021-08-21T06:05:59+00:00

no one in particular

Roar Guru


swings and roundabouts. Just take the loss on the chin. It's an inconsequential loss. The same 2 teams will play each other week one of the finals on a neutral field

2021-08-21T06:04:27+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


Completely agree about the finals. I'm not sure Penrith has another intensity notch but I suspect your boys do. They didn't show it last night but then again, when you're not getting the rub of the green or even a fair shake, it's hard to lift. When it's all to play for in a few weeks time, I reckon we'll be watching a very different Bunnies outfit.

2021-08-21T05:48:06+00:00

Joey

Guest


16/16. The only undefeated player in 2021. He’s now won 33 games out of 34. There’s not much doubt the team goes ok when he’s playing. Those balls don’t go stupid in the air because Ivan picked his son to wear #7, or because the refs allowed the ball to spin that way. Give the guy some credit at some point.

2021-08-21T05:42:46+00:00

Big Mig

Roar Rookie


….or that Penrith score two tries which clearly should not have been, or that Tom Burgess gets penalised for the lightest of touches but Luai knees Mansour in the head and nothing happens, or a blatant knock on by Crichton on his 20m line, or that Naden milks a crusher tackle….the list is long, and all legit. Atkins influenced the game in a way that has been rarely seen since the Roosters – Raiders GF…

2021-08-21T04:55:36+00:00

Greg

Roar Pro


The jist of the downtown rule is you cant be involved in play if you are in front of the play the ball when the ball is kicked. Downtown (and other out of play rules) are seperate to offside rules, so you dont become onside that play by any of the standard measures, including an opposition error.

2021-08-21T04:43:11+00:00

no one in particular

Roar Guru


you do that, just make sure I become a panthers fan first It must be tough when the refs take it easier on Souths over the season then 14 other teams. But it wasn't like Souths led 12-0 or anything and didn't score a point for the next 60 minutes, or Penrith lost their fullback a quarter way through the game, or that Mansour can't catch, it was all the refs doing

2021-08-21T04:25:04+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


26mins...

2021-08-21T03:58:16+00:00

Nathan Absalom

Roar Guru


Yeah, it's hard to call consistently though and I feel that's asking a bit much from the officials. One reason that very few are called is that the referee generally tells the player to keep out of the play, particularly Atkins who is very active in calling players offside. This time he either didn't hear the call from the touchie or it was called from the bunker. If it's the former, that's unfortunate and bad luck for Souths, but hopefully they're not calling some from the bunker as that's going to be a bit bemusing for all concerned.

2021-08-21T03:49:57+00:00

Joey

Guest


Round 11 was pretty clear cut, but they have this way of gaslighting you into thinking it never happened. Bl—dy tricky bugg-rs.

2021-08-21T03:48:36+00:00

Big Mig

Roar Rookie


It must be a first! That TPJ has played a game where he was not penalised. Not surprising given Atkins wasn't looking at Penrith for any...perhaps TPJ will live a charmed life while on his sojourn at the panthers.

2021-08-21T03:19:54+00:00

Gee up

Guest


Only the most one sided panfer couldn’t concede that the ref seriously helped their team last night. When it happens to you and it will, I’ll be here to tell you, I told you so.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar