UNBELIEVABLE! Bulldogs snatch one-point win in semi-final for the ages!

By The Roar / Editor

The Western Bulldogs are through to the preliminary final after emerging victorious in one of the all-time great semi-finals, defeating the Brisbane Lions by a single point.

But the big talking points from the match could be crucial injuries to Marcus Bontempelli and Cody Weightman. Weightman exited the game at half time with a head knock after an accidental collision with Marcus Adams, while Bontempelli copped a knock to his knee in the last quarter and came off under duress.

The Bulldogs skipper returned to the field, but the Dogs will be monitoring his knee closely.

Coming into the final quarter down ten, it was Bulldogs who’d start the last term the better. Lachie Hunter sent an excellent centreing ball to Jack Macrae, who kicked truly to reduce the margin to four points.

Then, it was ex-Lion Josh Schache’s turn to hit the scoreboard with a snap from point blank after Harris Andrews lost touch with him. Bailey Smith, who set Schache up just seconds earlier, then made it four in a row for the Dogs with a floating ball that somehow eluded the hands of Marcus Adams on the goal line.

The Dogs had the Lions hemmed in their own defensive 50, but some fantastic composure from Bailey helped them break through and start to set up camp at the other end of the ground instead. Tom Fullarton finally provided the break through after marking Daniher’s wobbling kick from the pocket at the top of the square to make the margin a solitary point.

From there, both sides peppered the goals to level the scores – with the Lions missing the lot on two occasions when they would’ve killed for a behind.

Brisbane had the ball in their forward 50 more, but the Dogs got the all-important goal with two minutes remaining courtesy of an incredible kick on the run from Bailey Smith – his third of the evening.

But just as that looked to be the winner, the Lions struck with 74 seconds remaining. Lincoln McCarthy took a great mark in the back half of the centre square to kick off the rebound, before Zac Bailey took a ground ball inside 50 and phased through defenders to kick a tying goal on the run.

The Bulldogs got a controversial free kick from the ensuing centre stoppage, however, and Laitham Vandermeer was able to hurry the ball through for an important behind with 54 seconds remaining.

The Lions got the ball forward with seconds remaining, but Dayne Zorko’s hurried kick inside 50 with six seconds left sailed out on the full to decide the match.

After last night’s semi-final left a bit to be desired in the entertainment department, both sides put on an absolute show in a memorable first quarter.

Tom Liberatore kicked the first of the match with a quick looping snap from half-forward through the vacant goal square, but the Lions held firm down back and prevented more initial damage.

A great tackle by Jarryd Lyons on Marcus Bontempelli at half-back set Brisbane off on a counterattack and the penetrating kick inside 50 found a free Charlie Cameron. He nailed his set shot to level it up.

Liberatore sent his second snap through the big sticks – this one much more impressive than the first – to get the Dogs back out by eight soon after.

The Dogs were winning the ground ball, but Brisbane were looking lethal on the rebound and got in behind again when a long kick to full forward saw Lincoln McCarthy awarded a free kick.

He nailed the easy set shot and the Lions were back on level terms, before another goal out the back from Joe Daniher off the ensuing centre clearance put the Lions up despite being on the back foot in general play. Cameron then nailed his second – Brisbane’s third goal from four kicks – to give the home side a surprise 12-point lead.

The goals weren’t just flowing one way. The Bulldogs got an instant reply at the other end after Bailey Smith’s soccer amidst the chaos split the outstreched hands of two defenders.

But Charlie Cameron was intent on getting himself back on the highlight reel after kicking one of the goals of the finals in another instant reply. He turned on the afterburners, leaving Easton Wood in his wake, before nailing a very difficult running shot across the body to re-establish the 12-point buffer.

The second quarter had a lot to live up to and it was the Dogs who’d strike first through Aaron Naughton.

It was a far more subdued second quarter after all the electricity in the first, but Mitch Hannan was able to level the scores at the 11-minute mark after taking a surprisingly easy grab from a high, shallow kick inside 50 and nailing the tough set shot.

Cody Weightman was then able to put the Bulldogs in front two minutes later. He looked to have taken a superb mark inside 50, before dropping it, but was able to receive the handball from Naughton and slam through one he deserved.

Brisbane had no interest in being blown away, however. They took advantage of a turnover at half-back and held the ball in after the Dogs regained possession, with Mitch Robinson finishing the play off with an excellent running goal.

The margin was a slender one point in favour of the Bulldogs at the main break, but they were rocked during half time after Weightman was subbed out with a head knock – and they came out flat in the third quarter.

The Lions hit the scoreboard first in the after Hugh McCluggage took a great grab under a high ball next to the point post, before finishing it off with a good kick around the corner.

Zac Bailey was able to put the home side out by two goals almost ten minutes later with a great set shot from just inside 50.

Meanwhile, the sprinklers could’ve been turned on in the Bulldogs forward 50 and nobody would’ve been inconvenienced.

The Bulldogs did eventually start to generate some chances and were unlucky to have a Bontempelli goal taken off the board after the ARC found it was touched off the boot.

Medical sub Ryan Lester kicked his first goal in four years to give the Lions four in a row and a commanding 18-point lead, but Jason Johannisen, the Bulldogs’ medical sub, replied instantly with a ripping goal on the run.

Alex Keath had a golden opportunity to kick a rare goal and bring the margin back within a goal thanks to a 50-metre penalty, but his relatively simple set shot drifted to the left.

Controversy reigned in the last few second of the quarter, with two contentious free kicks – one for deliberate out of bounds and one for holding the ball – gave Johannisen a chance to make it five points at the final break, but his set shot sailed right to see the margin reduced to ten instead.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Full time

Brisbane Lions – 11.12 (78)
Western Bulldogs – 11.13 (79)

Goals

Lions: Cameron 3, Bailey 2, McCarthy, Daniher, Robinson, McCluggage, Lester, Fullarton
Bulldogs: B. Smith 3, Liberatore 2, Naughton, Hannan, Weightman, Johannisen, Macrae, Schache

The Crowd Says:

2021-09-06T07:17:49+00:00

Thom Roker

Roar Guru


Cheers for that. I have given it some thought and what angle to take. If I watched a Suns game and dissected the dodgy calls, I don’t think I’d get much support because fans just aren’t going to go back and watch the same game. I also noticed that watchers of the Lions vs Dogs game we’re happy to admit that there were umpiring howlers on both sides. Going to give it further thought. Thanks again for the support.

2021-09-05T22:51:58+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


That's a fair point. English also was holding McInerney's jumper.

2021-09-05T20:07:30+00:00

Doc

Guest


Agree, shouldn't have been a mark to Bont, but he threw English out of the way beforehand which should have been a free kick against him.

2021-09-05T19:57:09+00:00

Doc

Guest


Yes, Zorko block on Keith to allow Fullerton to mark and goal in the last quarter was a clear free kick not paid, the umpires wanted to review every Bulldogs goal in the hope of overturning them, eventually denying Bont from a blurry frame. Umpires kept the Lions in the match, no doubt.

2021-09-05T12:11:40+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


What is AFLM???

2021-09-05T12:09:26+00:00

RT

Roar Rookie


But why just focus on critical stages of the game? There are non-calls throughout a match, but if you only focus on certain ones, you will do you head in. To suggest a single non-call could cost a game is unreasonable when any other different decision earlier would have changed the course of the match.

2021-09-05T12:08:22+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Who do you support???

2021-09-05T11:53:50+00:00

Maxis Pastit

Roar Rookie


Thom, you write good articles on the Roar. You should explore this aspect of the game and do an article. Not to criticise umpires, but to high-light the impact of inconsistencies on the game. I think umpires do a pretty good job over all. However it is these sort of things, such as the examples you have stated, that I find very frustrating when watching a game.

2021-09-05T09:23:27+00:00

Thom Roker

Roar Guru


Yes, this. Non calls are the worst. There's no stat for it and the demoralising impact it has on players is underestimated. Without going into detail, there were calls in last night's game early on that were tough but fair interpretations of holding the ball, yet consistency on it went out the window. The infuriation for is that AFL, as with all sports, has amazing technology at its disposal that could very easily allow for excellent umpiring decisions much more often and yet they hamstring themselves by failing to utilise it. How much better is the game with the ARC?! Touched balls getting called behinds instead of falsely being awarded goals and goal-line reviews that are much more accurate. If there was one rule I'd take out of the game it is the 15m kick length. Umpires are terrible at it and every game is affected by it, but for over a hundred years it was never a factor. Even if they changed the length to less than 10m, it would be more accurately called and players could anticipate better instead of this inconsistency. Surely a touched ball or short kick that ends in a player thinking they've marked it ending in holding the ball could be jus balled up.

2021-09-05T09:05:59+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


Weightman was the liveliest subbed out player of all time. Meanwhile Bailey Smith was encouraging the Brissie supporters to shoot up.

2021-09-05T09:00:55+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


Definitely a free in the ruck against McInerney. Where he was unlucky was the mark snatched from him by Bont.

2021-09-05T06:32:52+00:00

Maxis Pastit

Roar Rookie


I think it is the non calls at a critical stages at the end of a game that are an issue. I think this is where the umpires get caught up in the moment and become inconsistent. I know it also happens during the game, but this is where their non-decision can decide a game as it is hard to recover from it. A free should have probably been paid but wasn't and this has given an advantage to the offending side that they should not have gotten. Examples of this in the last couple of minutes of a game are: 2017 AFLW Grand Final - holding the ball, 2018 AFLM Grand Final - blocking, 2019 Semi Final Lions vs GWS - throwing the ball, early 2021 Geelong vs Lions - holding the ball and last night holding the ball against the Bulldogs. Had any of these been called then the result could well have been different. I am sure there are lots more examples and it doesn't mean the result would have been different, but they all had a critical impact on the game and potentially changed the outcome. I would also point out that it is, in reality, not a free kick if the umpire doesn't call it and it is only my subjective opinion that it should have been called.

2021-09-05T05:50:06+00:00

dab

Roar Rookie


No sour grapes here. It is good the the weaker sides get to the prelims.

2021-09-05T05:41:24+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


You're right about the whingefest from some people. It not only reflects sour grapes on them, switches the focus irrationally and detracts from the winning team's performance (on purpose); it also diminishes the site.

2021-09-05T04:44:27+00:00

RT

Roar Rookie


I don’t remember what the commentators had to say about that incident, but they have terrible habit of creating controversy by not knowing the rules themselves. The number of times BT in particular goes on about an incorrect decision when infact the decision is correct is ridiculous. It is no wonder this site is turning into a constant whinge fest every live blog.

2021-09-05T04:37:50+00:00

RT

Roar Rookie


No maybe about it

2021-09-05T03:49:29+00:00

robertbrob13226

Roar Rookie


Zorko ,MaCarthy , great home @ away players Cannot produce on the big stage again , clubs resigns player mid year poor list management these players need to be moved on

2021-09-05T03:24:02+00:00

Goalsonly

Roar Rookie


Umpires are creating a new high average of calls per game so overcalling is being normalized.

2021-09-05T03:18:47+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


You're delusional.

2021-09-05T03:17:31+00:00

Pumping Dougie

Roar Guru


Why call it a controversial free kick, when it wasn't? The free was blatant for anyone who knows the ruck rules – you can jump but you can’t walk past the centre line at centre bounces (not to mention then sticking his knee into Tim English’s thigh). Bad, tired error by Oscar. There were a few umpire errors (mostly in Brisbane's favour), but that wasn't one of them. Is it unreasonable to expect balanced reporting from the author?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar