Stop calling once-mighty Roosters heavyweights - they're now featherweights

By Stuart Thomas / Expert

Trent Robinson has been the coach of the Sydney Roosters since 2013, celebrating a decade at the helm of one of the most successful contemporary NRL teams.

Across that period, the Chooks have won three premierships, appeared in a further three preliminary finals and two semi-finals, and were annexed from the finals on just one occasion in 2016.

That disastrous campaign was something of an anomaly and with an average finish of between third and fourth on the ladder across a full decade, it is easy to see why the boys from Bondi have developed a reputation as a consistent NRL heavyweight.

That record no doubt informed much of the Tricolours’ predicted chances heading into the current season, with many assuming that they would continue to be the force that has achieved so much in recent times.

While the odd rogue commentator might have looked for potential improvers in the form of teams like the Dragons and Broncos (both in my top eight at the start of the season), the low-hanging fruit was to hitch one’s wagon with the historically successful Roosters and lock them in for another appearance in the finals.

I did it, just like everybody else.

(Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

Thankfully, there is more to rugby league that a simple emulation of the past and the current reality appears to be that the Roosters are gripping desperately to a perch from which they have stumbled somewhat, despite much of the rugby league media appearing to still believe in a team that looks to be a shadow of its former self.

When the embattled Bulldogs scrapped and clawed their way to a 16-12 victory at Accor Stadium on Saturday evening, any doubts around the Roosters’ fall from heavyweight status had been confirmed.

Frankly, the Dogs were far from impressive: gutsy, but limited.

However, the Roosters were simply dysfunctional against a team that had lost six matches on the trot, were without their captain and had offered absolutely zero in attack across the first seven rounds of the competition.

Most stunning was the Cooper Cronk-coached halves pairing of the Roosters being able to offer little to threaten a Canterbury defence that had allowed 102 points in the three weeks prior.

(Photo by Jason McCawley/Getty Images)

Luke Keary and Sam Walker might well be touted and proven players at NRL level, yet against the Bulldogs they were far from instrumental in providing the polish to the end of Roosters’ attacking sets and at times looked nothing but ordinary.

The performance continued a pattern that had been clearly evident in 2022. Wins over the Sea Eagles, Broncos and Warriors were nothing to write home about and losses to the Knights, Rabbitohs, Dragons and now Bulldogs created something of an embarrassing profile as the competition heads into its ninth week.

The Titans, Eels, Panthers and Sharks await over the coming month and two wins across that period might be the best the Roosters can hope for, especially considering the form they are currently displaying and the growing reality that Robinson’s men appear well off the pace for the first time in six years.

Yet all the while, much of the rugby league community continue to refer to the Tricolours as an NRL heavyweight, in spite of the fact that they may well be grappling to make the top eight come September.

It appears to be such a shock to the collective consciousness that it may take some time before the reality sets in and seemingly opposition players also remain brainwashed into believing an historical fact that is far from a reality in 2022.

(Photo by Jason McCawley/Getty Images)

Jai Arrow appeared on the rather awkwardly titled Fox League program Benji on Monday night, applauding the efforts of Canterbury, up against what he referred to as one of the competition heavyweights, the Sydney Roosters.

Methinks Arrow might have merely been using clichéd language and ideas drummed into his psyche, all based on the Roosters’ efforts prior to 2022 and not the inept form currently being displayed.

Like many in a media landscape that continues to present the Roosters as an ever-present threat based on years gone by, poor Jai has also fallen victim to the historically favourable journalistic treatment afforded to the Chooks.

At least six NRL teams appear to be streets ahead of them at this stage of the season and losses to the seriously bereft Bulldogs and Knights add weight to the view that the Roosters will be making up the numbers this season.

Unfortunately, it may take a few more weeks before some begin to call a spade a spade and admit that the Roosters are not a serious threat to the heavy hitters in 2022.

Perhaps that just hurts a little too much for some to admit.

For others, it will be music to their ears.

var request = new XMLHttpRequest();

request.open('POST', '/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php', true); request.setRequestHeader('Content-Type', 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded;'); request.onload = function () { if (this.status >= 200 && this.status

The Crowd Says:

2022-05-06T17:33:01+00:00

timbo 59

Guest


I get that this platform is made up of wannabe contributors, but damn, I wish some would get the heck over themselves and stay within their limitations, rather than trying to impress one and all with their lame attempts at purple prose. Example - 'the low-hanging fruit was to hitch one’s wagon' - I mean, seriously? It's one thing to try and stretch out your vocabulary and writing, but quite another when it ends up looking painful and pretentious. Pros like Gideon Haigh can indulge themselves because they have a firm grasp of the English language. When you lack that expertise, it's best to simply stick within the boundaries of what you do know and make the best of it.

2022-05-06T00:58:56+00:00

Get_real

Roar Rookie


Surely they will be looking to offload Keary & go for Munster or Amone, hmmm maybe not even offload him, just put him in the reserves as a safety valve.

2022-05-05T21:58:51+00:00

Poss

Roar Rookie


Yes its been a pretty rough start for us my bug bear is goal kickers theres been a couple of games where if we'd got the goals we would of won the game..Sammies a great little kicker but not consistant from the outer edges,I don't know what the answer is, only practise I guess..

2022-05-05T21:32:10+00:00

Poss

Roar Rookie


:thumbup:

2022-05-05T21:30:10+00:00

Poss

Roar Rookie


Well said Portuguesechook I'm really hoping your correct... :thumbup: :thumbup: :thumbup: :thumbup:

2022-05-05T21:10:42+00:00

Censored Often

Roar Rookie


Perhaps the NRL have finally given the Chooks a salary cap....

2022-05-05T21:04:22+00:00

Nate

Guest


Never been a fan of the Keary/Walker partnership, saying that, I was a huge Flanno fan. Surely Sualli* ends up at the Tahs, sooner rather than later, Crichton and Radley too. Wouldn’t say no to Cam Murray while we’re at it :laughing:

2022-05-05T11:47:18+00:00

NSWelshman

Roar Rookie


Compare him to Selwyn Cobbo tonight. Selwyn then daylight to Suaalii….& he’s played less games!!!! Suaalii the myth sorry to say.

2022-05-05T09:46:08+00:00

Choppy Zezers

Roar Rookie


Kurt Gidley?

2022-05-05T09:45:04+00:00

Choppy Zezers

Roar Rookie


Please don't praise the Knights victory. It's too hard for us Knights supporters. Actually just leave them out of any conversation where praise is given. I think Suualli will be a star. He's shown plenty already. He's just playing in a team that's not playing as well as they would like. Sam Walker I'm not so sure about. I think his development isn't what Robbo would have expected or hoped for. I think for all the expectation on him, he hasn't done a great deal.

2022-05-05T09:11:16+00:00

London Panther

Roar Rookie


I think it is a tough road from here for the Chooks. Assuming you can only afford to lose 12 games (ie half) to make the finals, a 4-4 start isn’t the end of the world. But they have had a soft draw to start and so will need to win some games against the likes of Melbourne, Parra, Penrith and the Sharks. I know a lot has been said about the halves, but for me the pack looks soft; they are getting monstered…

2022-05-05T07:26:21+00:00

Heyou

Roar Rookie


Roosters are looking rusty. The weather has turned foul for our resident fowls. They are having trouble shaking their tail feathers, weighed down by the loss of some big feathered friends and a few youthful spring cocks are still working out how to crow. Their dance steps are looking heavy and somewhat lacking in style and grace. Can’t keep a pen of fowls down for long. When the sun starts to poke it’s nose out on a more regular basis, their plumes will again sparkle splendidly and they will be back in step and touch with the upper echelon and could even make it to the big dance.

2022-05-05T06:29:08+00:00

NSWelshman

Roar Rookie


We’ll see….

2022-05-05T05:15:08+00:00

Ja ja klazo

Guest


I have to disagree. His defence has been first class and his physicality in contact is incredible for an 18 year old. He's got a massive future from what I've seen.

2022-05-05T05:08:10+00:00

criag

Roar Rookie


The media use the term ‘star-studded’ about the Roosters a lot, and then there’s all the ‘rorters’ and ‘salary sombrero’ comments, but does anyone ever go through their squad? There’s not a whole lot of current rep players in there, and apart from Teddy, there’s no-one else who deserves to be picked (and I’m not so sure about Teddy at the moment, anyway). The truth is they are where I expected them to be this year – the bottom half of the eight. Uncle Nick made a huge mistake prioritising signing ageing forwards ahead of re-signing Lattrell (who’d have thought salary cap considerations could be a part of managing the Roosters!?) Losing him and Brett Morris in particular were disastrous, as they were vital in both attack and defence. Their forwards do the work but some are ageing and some have slippery hands. They just don’t know now to score a try. Go ahead and hate them if you want…..but there’s really no reason to.

2022-05-05T05:05:03+00:00

no one in particular

Roar Guru


because all 18yo's are at the same stage of development?

2022-05-05T04:35:49+00:00

Adam

Roar Guru


He's certainly playing with something...

2022-05-05T04:14:48+00:00

NSWelshman

Roar Rookie


Sorry to disagree Albo….I think Suaalii is overrated. Not saying he won’t achieve anything but the way everyone carried on about him I haven’t seen anything to suggest he’s a prodigious talent. Also 11 of those I’ve listed are regular 1st graders at their current clubs!!

2022-05-05T04:08:33+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


One thing he did incredibly well was take a ball under pressure, he was sure handed getting an imperfect ball whilst going through the line.

2022-05-05T03:42:47+00:00

Pickett

Roar Rookie


Good afternoon John Allan Max is too busy playing with his colored crayons to get smart.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar