MICHAEL HAGAN: Why more than just a new coach is needed to fix Dogs' breakfast

By Michael Hagan / Expert

Now that the Bulldogs have moved on from Trent Barrett as coach, they need to look at the big picture before they can get back to being a successful club.

The club’s legendary leader Peter “Bullfrog” Moore would often say the most important people in the organisation are the players.

And the roster is the main area Canterbury need to fix to give whoever their next coach is a fighting chance.

With Phil Gould calling the shots, he has got the big picture capability to sort out most things that need to be put in place for the Bulldogs to be successful again but he’s going to have to work through all sorts of salary cap limitations.

They’ve let young Brent Naden join Wests Tigers already and I think there will be a few more leaving the kennel in the coming months.

Gus knew when he took the job on last year that he would have to make some tough decisions to reshape the roster but we also know he won’t be backward in coming forward on that front. 

He did similar when he started at Penrith when they had to release a few of their top players like Wade Graham, Luke Lewis and Michael Gordon because of their salary cap problems at the time.

(Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

His job at Canterbury has been made more difficult with some of the players who they signed to hefty deals over the past year or two. They’ve snookered themselves with some of the panic buys that they’ve made to try and generate results quickly. 

There’s some big numbers on the contracts of some of those guys like Tevita Pangai jnr and Luke Thompson. Even someone like Josh Jackson, who has been a loyal stalwart for a long time, they’re going to have to face a difficult decision with someone like him.

There will be several players and staff under review, not just the coach.

I can’t see how they can quickly trade their way out of it. It’s going to take a couple of years for the roster to truly take shape.

And that’s bad news for their frustrated fans who thought they were coming to the light of the end of the tunnel. It’s not Groundhog Day, it’s Bulldog Day.

People were quick to criticise Des Hasler for what he did at the club but he got them to two grand finals and they made the playoffs most years he was there.

With the ordinary results they’ve had with a couple of inexperienced coaches in Pay and Barrett since Dessie left in 2018, I think they have to go with someone with runs on the board.

In my view, there are three standout candidates in Shane Flanagan, Paul Green and Kristian Woolf.

Flanagan and Green won premierships at Cronulla and the Cowboys respectively and I think they will have both learned from how their time at those two clubs came to an end.

Shane Flanagan (Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

They will have reflected on what they did wrong at each of their teams and have the necessary pedigree to take on a role like this.

Woolf has spent the past couple of years with St Helens, he’s paid his dues as an assistant for a few years in the NRL and he’s racked up plenty of time and wins as Tonga’s coach so he’s someone who I think is worth a punt on by an Australian club in the next year or two.

Canterbury can’t afford to get this appointment wrong again. 

Flanagan, you would hope, could at least get the best out of his son Kyle although as we’ve seen this year with Jake Arthur at Parramatta, it can be an added problem when the coach’s son is in the team and there are questions around his position.

Some people aren’t starting halfbacks, some can handle that and some can’t and Flanagan is yet to prove he can be that person after three seasons of getting a chance at the Roosters and Canterbury.

The underlying problem with the Bulldogs’ roster is the key positions in the spine. They’ve got Matt Burton locked in at five-eighth and Reed Mahoney’s coming next year to be their hooker but halfback and fullback are ongoing issues. 

(Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

I was lucky enough when I was playing at Canterbury that we had a strong leadership from Barry Nelson as chairman, “Bullfrog” Moore as the secretary – what we used to call the CEO back in those days, Warren Ryan as coach and a guy called Dave Cooper who was our strength and conditioning coach who made sure we were fitter than everyone else.

It’s not until you look back on that organisation that you realise how blessed you were. 

“Bullfrog” was ahead of his time in the clandestine ways he would get players from other clubs to Belmore, whether that was Terry Lamb from Wests or Peter Kelly from Newtown or the time he invited all the other club bosses to a restaurant for a feast while he was off signing the best young player in the country before they realised he wasn’t in attendance.

Nowadays it’s way more transparent with the media and player managers having a big say on who goes where, which makes it so much harder to find that diamond in the rough that Canterbury are going to need.

Maybe they’ll have to look in the Super League to see if there’s a halfback over there who could be the playmaker they need. It worked for Canberra a few years ago to bring in some UK recruits so it could be an option for the Dogs.

Getting the right people in the right roles is the key to everything.

(Photo by Jason McCawley/Getty Images)

The Bulldogs fans are fanatical. They always have been, going way back to when I was a player in the 1980s. They’re diehards, rusted-on fans who expect their team to play well and win their share of games.

I’m glad that when I was playing and then coaching it was before the social media age. You’d still cop it in the letters to the editor or on talkback radio but it’s nothing like the vitriol the players and coaches of today cop in the online forums and social media free-for-alls.

Those people are often experts in hindsight. My old Bulldogs coach Warren Ryan used to say it was very easy to be wise after the facts but you’ve got to be clever before the start of the game.

As for Barrett, I remember saying on radio a couple of years ago that he was taking on the toughest coaching job in the NRL and wasn’t sure whether taking that job would be the best thing for his career.

Trent who has been through a couple of tumultuous coaching experiences at Manly and the Dogs has to re-assess whether he wants to be a head coach again and the demanding pressures of the role.

He’s got to decide whether it suits him better to be an assistant where he did a great job at Penrith because not everyone’s cut out to be a head coach. 

Hopefully he’s still got a long future in the game whatever role he ends up in because I feel for the bloke with the way things have turned out for him at Canterbury.

var request = new XMLHttpRequest();

request.open('POST', '/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php', true); request.setRequestHeader('Content-Type', 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded;'); request.onload = function () { if (this.status >= 200 && this.status

The Crowd Says:

2022-05-18T23:14:14+00:00

Chaff

Roar Rookie


The thing that I would weigh in when Coaches jobs are mentioned is how people say “who’d want to be one”? Whilst not devaluing the pressure that goes with the job, it’s certainly way better than a lot of gigs out there. Media says that Trent has walked away with 500 large in his kick, one would think that gives him some breathing space to sort the next chapter. As for the Bulldogs, my care factor is zero being a Chook supporter, but if they want a little tip, have a look at the CV of Rip Taylor as a Coach. In 50 years of carrying the Clipboard he was always busy come September!

2022-05-18T08:58:41+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


GH, 2nd tier refers to competition, i.e. NSW Cup, QLD Cup not tiered rankings for coaches or teams.

2022-05-18T07:05:33+00:00

Big Daddy

Roar Rookie


All these Canterbury players telling everyone what a great and well rounded coach Barrett was . Obviously none of them are on the same page .

2022-05-18T06:31:42+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


I’m pretty happy with Potter getting the interim job at least. He’s been coaching at Mounties so should have a decent idea on who at that level is ready to come up into first grade. Something needs to change…

2022-05-18T04:33:48+00:00

Noosa Duck

Roar Rookie


Michael I have no qualms with what you have stated, however there is a common denominator running through all struggling NRL Clubs at the moment. All have had severe stability problems at the top. Board Room factional fights and poor management appointments. The suitability and expertise of those at the top echelon of any large sporting organisation makes a huge difference to the success of the club. The boardroom brawling at the Bulldogs club has become legendary in recent years. Parramatta was no different but seemed to have well and truly steadied the ship and also stood by their coach as well. We keep hearing "when Bullfrog" ran the club how great it was, which is true. So stop lamenting and go find yourselves another Peter Moore because success starts at the top with a decent management team.

2022-05-18T03:45:36+00:00

Adam

Roar Guru


Was going to say the same thing. Strength and conditioning coach should walk too

2022-05-18T03:21:26+00:00

Dwanye

Roar Rookie


His ‘hype’ could be used to attempt to take eyes off any bad behaviour off field that ‘often’ happens. He may have created a ‘new role’

2022-05-18T03:02:56+00:00

no one in particular

Roar Guru


Success and over achieving at the lower grades and Super League is a better indicator then no experience or success

2022-05-18T02:56:02+00:00

no one in particular

Roar Guru


He was horrid, but he'll be an improvement

2022-05-18T02:55:29+00:00

no one in particular

Roar Guru


You'd pay attention to Glory Bound before you pay attention to Tedeschi. Matt Johns pushed for Brennan at the Titans, not Gould. Gould advised Barrett not to take the Dogs job.

2022-05-18T02:49:50+00:00

no one in particular

Roar Guru


1, 6, 7. 9, 13

2022-05-18T02:39:14+00:00

Cat Brown

Guest


I understand that Paul Green was the Coach when Cowboys won their Premiership but he was handed a pretty good team by Graham Murray

2022-05-18T02:34:41+00:00

Bloke7

Roar Rookie


I miss Billy Johnstone. These lads would die under his watch.

2022-05-18T02:32:36+00:00

andrew

Roar Rookie


Are you serious BD, Mundine wants to be a consultant. Geez, give me a break. Next thing he'll want is to coach Saints. Must be a full moon.

2022-05-18T02:30:11+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


You keep saying 6, 7 and 9… are you saying the 1 is sorted with Dufty…?

2022-05-18T02:25:53+00:00

Gray-Hand

Roar Rookie


The bunnies replaced a top tier halfback with a rookie. There was absolutely no way on earth they were going to remain a top tier team. Zero. And that’s not even taking into account the fact that the team had already been playing better than the quality of its roster would normally allow because it was being coached by a SuperCoach. They have a rookie coaching them now. South’s fans need to adjust their expectations of where their team should be down several notches. They aren’t a grand final quality roster anymore. A decent coach could realistically be aiming for bottom of the 8.

2022-05-18T02:22:28+00:00

criag

Roar Rookie


No-one’s mentioned Dean Pay as a potential replacement. But although his win rate was 33%, he was left with little to work with after their salary cap debacle. They played with a lot of character under him and he knows what it is to be a Bulldog…..maybe he deserves another shot?

2022-05-18T02:15:37+00:00

criag

Roar Rookie


You mean the 2012 Roosters team that finished 13th and had ONE State of Origin rep and a smattering of NZ reps (like most teams)? The team that had the same core members of their last-placed team of 2009, which was the youngest team in the NRL, who just needed a few more experienced players around them to help fulfil their potential? The three marquee signings for 2013 being Sonny Bill Williams, James Maloney (who would a few years later leave because he wanted more money than he could get at the Rooters because of salary cap pressures), and Michael Jennings, who was unwanted by Penrith and who were paying most of his salary? (Whose other signings were a 32-year-old Luke O'Donnell and Sam Moa). The 2013 Roosters team that had lost or moved on eight players: Braith Anasta, Joseph Leilua, Tom Symonds, Mose Masoe, Brad Takairangi, Anthony Cherrington, Peni Tagive and Justin Carney for salary cap reasons?....OK.

2022-05-18T01:44:46+00:00

RLFan

Roar Rookie


If I remember correctly Gould advised Barret against taking the job at Canterbury. It is one thing to coach a team full of talent who have come through the ranks together, like the Panthers and a team like the Bulldogs with obvious weaknesses across the park. A different approach had to be made and I was always frustrated that Barret could not see that.

2022-05-18T01:37:10+00:00

mach4

Roar Rookie


Gday TB, you might remember some months ago I mentioned Mick Potter as a possible coach, well that has happened if only interim, all they need to do now is to get the fox into a number one jersey and see what happens from there. interesting to see a halfback coming up from the lower grades.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar