Zimbabwe's all-time Test XI

By Two Slips and a Gully / Roar Rookie

The landlocked African nation known as Zimbabwe is a young nation in the cricketing landscape. Formerly known as Rhodesia, the country was fairly active in the international cricket community.

After transitioning from Rhodesia to Zimbabwe in 1980, it didn’t take long for the country to join cricket community as an official associate member in 1981.

Zimbabwe were active in the ODI game, taking part in the 1983, 1987 and 1992 World Cups, before being granted full membership in 1992 and being able to take part in Test cricket.

Despite only a short tenure in Test cricket, they have a number of international quality players.

They are players like David Houghton, their first Test captain, and Heath Streak, their leading wicket taker all time and a fantastic all-rounder.

But the most prominent of them all was Andy Flower, who at one point was considered the best batsman in the world.

Zimbabwe never enjoyed a great deal of success in the Test arena, only achieving a Test ranking of eighth and only winning 13 of the 117 Tests they have played.

Zimbabwe were a competitive side in the ODI format, in fact they won their first ever game against Australia in the 1983 World Cup in a stunning upset.

Kevin Curran of Zimbabwe. (Photo by PA Images via Getty Images)

Their Test start wasn’t as successful. Their first Test win wouldn’t come until January of 1995, a resounding innings defeat of Pakistan powered by hundreds from the Flower brothers.

However, it was the only win in their first 30 matches.

By the mid 1990s as Zimbabwe began to mature as a cricket nation, they began to unearth some international quality talent and their successes in both Test and ODI cricket became more consistent.

They won more regularly and generally were a competitive nation.

Unfortunately, the rise of Zimbabwean cricket coincided with a deterioration of the political landscape at home, culminating in players, including Andy Flower, protesting the death of democracy in Zimbabwe in 2003.

These players were promptly banned and it heralded an era of player protests and walkouts, political interference and severe financial stresses – all of which crippled what was looking like a promising future.

Despite a short history in the Test arena and a tumultuous history post-2003, there have been a number of great players to have represented Zimbabwe and I have attempted to whittle them down to an XI.

Alistair Campbell (60 Tests, average 27.21, highest score 103)
He was an elegant, attacking, left-handed batsman. He was at one point the youngest Zimbabwean to score a first-class hundred.

He made the World Cup side at the age of 19. While his Test career wasn’t as strong as his ODI career, he was still a very talented player and even captained the side during its rise towards the end of the 1990s.

Grant Flower (67 Tests, average 29.54, highest score 201*)
Statistically he is Zimbabwe’s most successful opener. His highest score was a pivotal part of Zimbabwe’s first Test match win.

He was known for playing the anchor role and allowing stroke players to play around him. He was a mainstay of the batting order for over a decade.

He was an excellent fielder and a competent left-arm spinner. He brought many skills to the table for his national side. He is also the only batsman to carry his bat in both Test and ODI cricket.

(Photo by Anthony Au-Yeung-ICC/ICC via Getty Images)

Hamilton Masakadza (38 Tests, average 30.04, highest score 158)
He had a Test career that was impacted by Zimbabwe’s six-year exile from Test cricket. He erupted onto the scene, becoming the youngest Zimbabwean to score a first-class hundred at just 16, beating Campbell’s earlier mark.

He was also the first black Zimbabwean to do so. In 2001 he became the youngest player to score a century on debut against the West Indies, at just 17 years old.

He scored his second Test century a decade after his first in Zimbabwe’s first Test match back after their exile against Bangladesh.

He was a fine front-foot player who added a fantastic hook and pull shot to his game as he got older. He finished his career as the country’s sixth highest run scorer.

Murray Goodwin (19 Tests, average 42.84, highest score 166*)
He had a career that was cut short due to his family having trouble settling in Zimbabwe. Goodwin made quite a mark in just 19 matches.

He grew up in Perth. He was a phenomenal back-foot player and his quick feet made him effective against spin.

He debuted in 1998. He is a tale of what could have been when you look at his healthy Test average. He scored 23,000 first-class runs and 71 hundreds.

A long career with the likes of the Flower brothers and Heath Streak could have yielded impressive results for Zimbabwe.

Andy Flower (63 Tests, average 51.54, highest score 232*)
He is by far and away Zimbabwe’s most credentialed international cricketer. One of the most technically correct players of all time, he was effective against pace and spin bowling, once scoring 550 runs from just four knocks against India.

He holds the highest batting average for a Zimbabwean Test batsman and the most runs. He is the only Zimbabwean batsman to feature in the ICC’s top 100 all-time batting rankings.

His peak ranking had him ahead of players like Brian Lara, Sachin Tendulkar and Steve Waugh. He holds the highest score for a wicketkeeper batsman.

Unfortunately, political tensions cut his career short in 2003. For my team, I haven’t given him the gloves and I hope that it has a Kumar Sangakkara-like effect on his batting.

(Photo by Anthony Devlin/PA Images via Getty Images)

David Houghton (captain) (22 Tests, average 43.05, highest score 266)
Zimbabwe’s first Test captain, he had to wait until he was 35 before he could finally lead his nation in Test cricket.

He is regarded as one of the finest batsmen Zimbabwe produced. He went on to score four hundreds and four 50s in his short career.

He scored a century on debut in Zimbabwe’s maiden Test, which was a draw against India. He was the oldest debutant to score a century until Australia’s Adam Voges.

After retiring at 40, he went on to coach his nation and was known for staying loyal to his country in the face of lucrative offers.

Tatenda Taibu (wicketkeeper) (28 Tests, average 30.31, highest score 153)
Despite having an impressive enough statistical resume, I also selected Taibu for what he represented socially for his nation, serving as its first black captain.

He was the youngest captain in Test history until Afghanistan’s Rashid Khan. His career was beleaguered by many of the external pressures surrounding the team.

He left the side for two years and returned in 2007. After the six-year Test exile, Taibu was a productive lower order batsman and excellent keeper until he once again retired in 2012.

Heath Streak (65 Tests, 216 wickets, average 28.14)
Other than Flower, Streak was the next most credentialed international cricketer. With a batting average of 22 to go with his bowling, he was a very good all-rounder globally, not just for his country.

Given the lack of Test cricket Zimbabwe currently plays, his impressive wicket tally – which is 136 more than second place – may never be beaten.

He was known for extracting seam movement on even the most docile pitches. Streak carried a weak Zimbabwe attack all through their golden period.

He is the only Zimbabwean cricketer to feature on the Lord’s honours board with a 6-87.

(Photo by Clive Mason/Getty Images)

Andy Blignaut (19 Tests, 53 wickets, average 37.05)
One of the few Zimbabwean bowlers who could crack 145 kilometres per hour, Blignaut was a bit of a wildcard, especially in the ODI game.

In the Test arena he took a five-wicket haul on debut and is also the only Zimbabwean to take a Test hat trick. He was also a powerful striker of the ball and a fine fielder, highlighting his skill.

His career was another one that was punctuated by standoffs with the corruption in the Zimbabwean cricket board and various pay disputes.

Paul Strang (24 Tests, 70 wickets, 36.02 average)
He was a fine leg-spin bowler who had an impressive arsenal at his disposal. Leg breaks, the googly, top spinners and the flipper were all at his disposal.

He improved his accuracy and control as his career went on. A chronic muscular injury to his hand cut that career short but not before he was the third leading wicket taker for Zimbabwe.

He is considered one of the finest fielders in a very good fielding side. He was also a fine lower-order batsman, completing the double of a Test match hundred and a five-wicket haul in the same game. His 8-109 are the best Test figures by a Zimbabwean bowler.

Henry Olonga (30 Tests, 68 wickets, 38.52 average)
Similar to Taibu, in addition to Olonga’s cricket exploits, what he represented to the nation was particularly special, being the nation’s first black cricketer.

He made his debut in Zimbabwe’s first ever win against Pakistan. He was known for bowling with impressive pace but struggled for accuracy.

He finished his career with the fourth highest wicket tally for Zimbabwe. He was another player whose career was cut short because of issues with the board when he joined Andy Flower protesting the death of democracy.

(Photo by Jed Leicester/EMPICS via Getty Images)

12th Man: Brendan Taylor (34 Tests, 36.25 average, highest score 171)
He is very unlucky not to have made the final XI. He was a very fine wicketkeeper-batsman in his own right.

He captained Zimbabwe after their self-imposed Test exile and scored a second-innings 100 in their return Test, becoming the second player since Houghton to score a 100 in their captaincy debut for Zimbabwe.

In the end, he missed the cut as the bulk of his best performances were against just the one team, Bangladesh. He is still a fine player and would not look out of place in the final XI.

Honourable mentions: Guy Whittall, Ray Price, Kyle Jarvis, Neil Johnson

Much of Zimbabwe’s cricket story could be summed up with ‘what could have been’.

After early struggles and accusations of being awarded Test status too early, they had begun to develop some high calibre talent and looked to be building for a stronger decade during the 2000s.

It was not to be as the precarious political situation in their home country had a devastating effect on all aspects of life, including the national cricket team.

Zimbabwe was also unlucky to miss out on some very good cricketing talent.

Graeme Hick is the most notable example, but also players like Gary Ballance, Colin de Grandhomme and the Curran brothers have all represented other nations in international cricket despite having represented Zimbabwe at some level in their youth.

(Photo by Mark Metcalfe/Getty Images)

Despite all the hardship in their short history, Zimbabwe have unearthed some special talent and forged a reputation for being an excellent fielding side and a team that will always compete.

Today there are some bright lights coming through. Blessing Muzarabani looks to be a very impressive international quality bowler with numbers that stack up as well as anyone in his short fledging career.

Wesley Madhevere is a young all-rounder who looks quite promising as well.

Hopefully the youth brigade can complement veterans like Sikandar Raza, Sean Williams and Craig Ervine and we can start to see another Zimbabwean resurgence and we can see them become competitive again.

The Crowd Says:

2022-06-28T04:19:52+00:00

Sedz

Guest


As a kid I've watched how good Andy Flower as a batsman and its important ICC (India/Eng/Aus) and other nations take steps to bring back them to cricket. But I also believe they had issues with Government which ICC can't intervene. Andy Flower always kept India under mat with his bat.

2022-06-27T23:32:33+00:00

Mezz

Roar Rookie


Good article. Thanks for covering something different! I have always wondered what would have been for Zimbabwe if all the political issues didn't destroy their team in the early 2000s.

2022-06-27T06:51:29+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


That may be the case, but if so, then a guy like Rashid Khan will struggle to get to ten tests and as such, aren't likely to trouble the statisticians with 'inflated figures'. It's also unlikely that these one off tests will only be against other minnows, presumably you'll schedule them against real test nations from time to time and their figures would get 'evened out' then. The danger with too many test teams, from a statistical perspective, only exists if those teams are all keen to play multiple multi-game series per year and you end up with a system whereby Ireland, Afghanistan, Zimbabwe, West Indies and Bangladesh (plus whoever else wants to) pay frequently against themselves and some individuals rack up good looking statistics. The reality is this doesn't happen - take right now where Bangaladesh and West Indies are playing a two game "series" - just enough to meet their requirements for the Test Championship, but no more.

2022-06-27T02:49:50+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


They will play one-off tests every year or two as a traditional add on to their brad and butter which is (and should be) ODI's and T20.

2022-06-27T02:18:19+00:00

All day Roseville all day

Roar Guru


Mansell born in England, Traicos in Egypt. So useful "imports" just like Procter.

2022-06-27T02:14:02+00:00

All day Roseville all day

Roar Guru


He was born in South Africa and later finished school in England. His father Kevin was Zimbabwean.

2022-06-27T02:12:09+00:00

All day Roseville all day

Roar Guru


Mike Procter (born in Natal) played for Rhodesia in it, as did John Traicos (born in Egypt), Henry Fotheringham, Vincent van der Bijl (best cricketer to never play a Test ?), Barry Dudleston, Brian Davison (who captained Tas), Paddy Clift, Robin Jackman (who played for Eng)...

2022-06-27T01:20:20+00:00

The Bush

Roar Guru


I doubt the Afghani or Irish players will play enough Tests to even reach the minimum cut off for most statistics. In fact, it'd be amazing if many Zim players make that cut off at this rate. The traditional cut off is 20 innings, which is at least 10 tests and possible more. Considering Afghanistan - the most likely team to join the major nations - has only played 6 in four years and hasn't played any in over a year, it'll be amazed if too many Afghani players even play 10 tests at this rate. Their best player, Rashid Khan, has only played 9 FC games ever. You can forget the Irish at this rate - they haven't played a test in three years and I'm not aware of them even having any on the horizon. With an expanded IPL window, more leagues in places like the UAE and the USA, the endless T20 World Cups year after year, test cricket is going to be under pressure to maintain the nine 'regular' teams it has now, let alone properly expand to have the twelve eligble teams playing regularly.

2022-06-26T23:43:27+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


Did Rhodesia and/or Northern Rhodesia have sides in the old Currie Cup?

2022-06-26T23:14:16+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


Lefty Leach 10/166, a fine effort.

2022-06-26T14:46:39+00:00

Tigerbill44

Roar Guru


296 is the Eng Target. Good chance that they reach the target this evening.

2022-06-26T14:28:19+00:00

Tigerbill44

Roar Guru


Off topic Rare failure for Daryl Mitchell this summer; getting out for 56.

2022-06-26T13:49:31+00:00

David Calvey

Guest


You forget, among others, Percy Mansell, Chris Duckworth, Goofy Lawrence, Jack du Preez, John Traicos and I think David Pithey.

2022-06-26T13:09:50+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Didn't realise he was Zimbabwean.

AUTHOR

2022-06-26T13:09:28+00:00

Two Slips and a Gully

Roar Rookie


Curran unfortunately never played test cricket for Zimbabwe. He was an incredible player though. 36 with the bat and 27 with that ball in 300+ FC games

AUTHOR

2022-06-26T13:07:11+00:00

Two Slips and a Gully

Roar Rookie


Eventually. Haven’t covered that on my podcast yet, but we’ll get there.

AUTHOR

2022-06-26T13:06:31+00:00

Two Slips and a Gully

Roar Rookie


Tom Curran

2022-06-26T12:49:44+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


One of the best sledge comebacks too! :laughing:

2022-06-26T12:48:29+00:00

Micko

Roar Rookie


Are we supposed to know the guy in the photo (BBL player)?

2022-06-26T12:24:39+00:00

Timmuh

Roar Guru


So he was, my mistake.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar