Smith’s petulant run-out tantrum tarnishes the hard work he’s done to repair public image

By Paul Suttor / Expert

Steve Smith has done so much to repair his public image in recent years but he undid a lot of that good work in a matter of seconds with his petulant reaction to being run out in the first Test.

Smith has been exemplary since returning to the national set-up after his one-year ban for the ball-tampering dramas in South Africa in 2018 and was rightfully returned to a leadership position at the start of last summer when named Test vice-captain to Pat Cummins.

But the blow-up after being run out for six against Sri Lanka in Galle was the kind of stuff you see in junior cricket when the kid who thinks he’s better than the rest of his teammates chucks a tantrum when they are dismissed. 

The first thing Smith did as he sprang to his feet after sprawling in vain to make his ground was to spin around and remonstrate with his batting partner, Usman Khawaja, who was savvy enough to have turned around and not looked back after making the safety of the non-striker’s end.

Steve Smith reacts after being run out. (Photo by Buddhika Weerasinghe/Getty Images)

Shaking his head and waving his hands demonstrably as he stormed off the wicket, the 33-year-old looked like a 10-year-old. 

Whenever there’s a run-out, the dismissed batter on the field is best served by a rueful shake of the head and then keeping it down with mouth shut as they make their way to the pavilion.

Anything more than that, particularly Smith’s histrionics, only reflects badly on them, irrespective of who was at fault.

Khawaja, level-headed as always, didn’t seem to be affected one bit by Smith’s outburst and calmly guided Australia to 3-98 at stumps on day one in reply to Sri Lanka’s 212.

There will probably be an apology from Smith in the next day or so, perhaps the modern sports star’s method du jour for such stuff-ups, a carefully scripted social media post, but the damage has been done.

Pro tip: The particularly cunning ones deliver their “apology” via Instagram stories so it disappears after 24 hours and can’t be embedded by online media outlets.

The stupid part about all of it is that there was no need to scramble for a quick run anyway.

Smith had been hit on the pads by spinner Ramesh Mendis. It looked kind of close but umpire Kumar Dharmasena had given it not out, which doesn’t necessarily mean that it was the case with some of his judgments – he earlier turned down a Nathan Lyon LBW shout which the replay showed was hitting middle stump.

After being struck on the pad, Smith instantly held his hand up in a way many modern batters do, like a pre-emptive stop signal to the umpire in case they were thinking about raising the finger.

The ball squirted out to short cover and Smith set off for what was always going to be a dicey single, putting his head down as he lurched into a sprint and not seeing that Khawaja had stopped.

If you freeze the frame Zapruder style, Smith actually delivers a WTF gesture to Khawaja as he skids to a halt before trying to hotfoot it back to the striker’s end. 

There would have been no need to go for that single in a white-ball match let alone late on day one of a Test when you are in command at 2-83 after rolling the home team.

It wasn’t the case in this mix-up but batters in modern cricket do themselves no favours by varying from the three words that should be used when letting your partner know of your intentions – yes, no, wait.

All this “no mate”, “no run”, “one”, that you hear through the stump mikes has the potential to cause confusion.

(Photo by Buddhika Weerasinghe/Getty Images)

If a batter can’t convey their call succinctly with yes, no or wait, they shouldn’t be in the professional ranks.

Australia’s top order were positive in their approach on what is already a sharply turning surface. Opener David Warner unfurled a series of classy shots on the way to 24 off as many balls before he was caught in front by a Mendis arm ball that was so plumb he didn’t bother reviewing it.

Marnus Labuschagne then bashed 13 off 19, with a couple of ungainly looking sweeps to the boundary, before he needlessly tried a reverse sweep which found the only fielder backward of point. 

The modern batter has mastered the reverse sweep and it still carries risk, but that’s not the point entirely – he didn’t need to be trying to score at such a rapid rate with 10 overs left before stumps.

Smith also looked more skittish than usual in his brief stay at the crease. It’s like the Australians thought the prodigious turn of the pitch was eventually going to claim their wicket so they may as well try to smash as many runs as possible before there was a ball with their name on it.

Khawaja, who since his recall late in the Ashes series has become Australia’s most reliable batter, showed his teammates how it’s done by scoring at a decent rate – he will resume on 47 from 86 deliveries – while also not giving the opposition unnecessary chances to claim his wicket.

The Crowd Says:

2022-07-19T08:55:06+00:00

Steven E Norris

Guest


What sets them apart for me though is performance in England and India, Smith is miles ahead of Ponting.

2022-07-06T07:50:43+00:00

Akitas

Roar Rookie


The current captain is too impressed with himself to be impressed by anyone else.

2022-07-06T07:44:37+00:00

Akitas

Roar Rookie


He should never have played again after the sandpaper incident. Not only was he involved, but lied about it when confronted with the facts. He has serious character issues.

2022-07-06T07:42:33+00:00

Akitas

Roar Rookie


The second best ? Seriously ?

2022-07-02T09:26:51+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


Na, you’re wrong

2022-07-02T09:22:36+00:00

Stuckbetweenindopak

Roar Rookie


wow, looks like I missed something, this reaction is not even rare following run outs. Either I have missed something or it is being blown out of proportion

2022-07-01T04:51:14+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


I think so. You don't simply maintain a test average 15 runs higher than a FC average. He basically was the perfect selection - came in on a hot streak of form, cashed in. Now he is probably a solid 40's type guy. A bit like Usman now.

2022-07-01T04:49:47+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


2022-07-01T04:47:11+00:00

Clear as mud

Guest


haha coffee snort!

2022-07-01T04:32:23+00:00

Clear as mud

Guest


play the ball, not the superman (champ)

2022-07-01T03:54:06+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


Based on his career first class form, maybe he is regressing to the mean a little bit.

2022-07-01T03:52:00+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


Maybe he needs to train smarter.

2022-07-01T03:51:11+00:00

matth

Roar Guru


Ponting had an average over 60 for a decent part of his career as well. Here is a comparison with Smith that I did back in May 2021, before Smith's current troubles: Ricky Ponting Top 52 tests (the 'Bradman') 74.53 Top 20 test block 89.79 10% off either end of career 55.76 Steve Smith Top 52 tests (the 'Bradman') 75.04 Top 20 test block 86.21 10% off either end of career 67.11 (this will be down a bit now) So neck and neck, but absolute peak Ponting was ever so slightly higher, before factoring in game situation, opponents, etc.

2022-07-01T01:56:46+00:00

Peter Farrar

Roar Pro


I appreciated and enjoyed this article although am in a slightly more forgiving mood that Paul who wrote it. That Smith showed his exasperation was quite human I thought, and something I do when the kids dent the car, don't help with the washing or don't put away the dirty dishes (because I'm busy watching the cricket). Whilst Smith was upset, my expectation was that there'd be a quiet word from either Andrew McDonald or Pat Cummins to let him know by all means talk about what happened but no angry exchanges that might put someone off their game. Although I'm sure Smith in his role as former captain and a leader is well aware of this.

2022-06-30T23:30:59+00:00

Phil

Roar Rookie


There is no one size fits all with personal temperaments. I think Smith should have had better control over his emotions, but, that's Steve Smith. Someone here earlier referred to him as the 2nd greatest batsman. The greatest of them all was more measured when given out, even when he wasn't out, simply tucking his bat under his arm and departing the wicket.

2022-06-30T23:10:26+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


I don't think it would have impressed the current captain.

2022-06-30T20:06:50+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


It was a bit of a pork chop effort, but nothing more. He’ll probably have a word with Khawaja and that should do it The problem isn’t so much Smith’s mildly petulant behaviour - players have been p’d off at getting out - particularly run out - forever. It’s this slavering demand to see players publicly self flagellate any time they show a bit of emotion. There’s zero need for any sort of public apology from Smith - twitter or otherwise…

2022-06-30T16:10:16+00:00

Choppy Zezers

Roar Rookie


DTM when I was a junior I used to call "Go GO" when calling a run. My team mates loved it. Especially when I mishit it straight to gully, called "Go" and started running.

2022-06-30T15:04:23+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Yeah. With his time in the game, you'd expect better than a tantrum. Which is what that was. Made worse by him actually being at fault in the first place.

2022-06-30T15:00:13+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


No. No. That's being ridiculous. Your analogies are simplistic (at best) and then going on to talk about murders...? Stop over-simplifying by over-complicating. Smith's call was in the wrong purely from a cricketing position. His histrionics thereafter were indeed just child-like, reflecting a poor ability to recognise fault. Smith was 100% in the wrong both technically and emotively.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar