Let the A-League battle for Sydney begin

By Stuart Thomas / Expert

Sydney’s significant population and associated financial clout makes it a key market for all Australian sporting competitions.

In A-League Men terms, 2021-22 was a major disappointment for the city, with all three clubs hailing from the New South Wales capital failing to qualify for the finals.

They won just 23 of 78 home-and-away matches between them and played generally poor and uninspired football during the latter stages of the season.

For Sydney FC fans, it was confronting and alarming after consistent success across an extended period. Those fans’ faces expressed disgust and disbelief as the reality of mediocrity sank in. For supporters of other clubs it was a satisfying sight, with the feelings of entitlement rightfully earned by the A-League’s most successful club rocked at their very foundations.

It is hard to imagine the Sky Blues being down for too long and emotionally, things have already rebounded positively, with a shiny new stadium set to host its first Big Blue on October 8.

Fans are frothing at the arrivals of 28-year-old Spaniard Diego Caballo, Slovakian international Robert Mak and Englishman Joe Lolley, who leaves Nottingham Forest and looms as one of the most significant signings of the upcoming season.

Former Brisbane Roar attacker Alex Parsons is another addition, yet even more significant in the battle for Harbour City bragging rights is the acquisition of former Western Sydney Wanderers import Jack Rodwell, who showed glimpses of real class in his 14 league appearances for the red and black in 2021-22.

With Sydney FC’s arguably greatest and most popular player, Milos Ninkovic, having ventured to Wanderland, the battleground established for the derby to be played on November 12 is explosive – something the city and league needs.

Milos Ninkovic. (Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

With Western Sydney and Sydney FC having suffering extended periods of nomadic existence that tested fans’ patience and commitment, both now enjoy digs that, once the number of wins increase, will see much-improved attendances and re-fire a rivalry that has fallen flat in recent times.

The Wanderers will be looking to veteran Brazilian Marcelo, Bosnian striker Sulejman Krpic, Democratic Republic of Congo winger Yeni Ngbakoto and Frenchman Romain Amalfitano to provide the improvement that leads to wins.

A squad of immense depth also features a host of newly signed Australians including Lawrence Thomas, Kusini Yengi, Calem Nieuwenhof and Oliver Bozanic, who along with Ninkovic make Western Sydney, on paper, as talented as any team in the league.

Whilst Sydney’s ‘old’ rivals will already have each other in the crosshairs, Macarthur FC fans would be keen to remind everyone that it was they who were the pick of the big city crop last season.

Just three wins from the Bulls’ final 14 matches saw what had begun as a promising campaign turn to disaster late and a seventh-place finish was little consolation for a team that had looked a serious threat after a promising start to the season.

Unlike their Sydney rivals, Macarthur’s recruitment has been, to this point, domestically focussed.

Daniel Arzani arrives with everything on the line and a potential last chance before those left believing in him are forced to give up the ghost like so many already have.

Former Mariner and Jet Matthew Millar will provide run and energy from the back half, Anthony Carter will undertake his first stint in the A-League after spending time abroad in numerous countries, and Kearyn Baccus could be a handy acquisition.

Championship winner with Western United, Jerry Skodatis adds some real poise to the midfield and Jonathan Aspropotamitis will anchor the back four. Both young signings will go some way towards making up for the loss of the promising Lewis Miller.

While there is some real promise joining the club, it is the members of the squad that remain who potentially make Macarthur the most settled of these teams.

Filip Kurto is clearly one of the best gloveman in the A-League, Aleksandar Susnjar and Tomislav Uskok will enjoy the extra support down back, and Craig Noone, Ulises Davila and Daniel De Silva will now have Skodatis and Baccus to help share the load.

The Bulls may still be a man short up-front, with Lachlan Rose and Al Hassan Toure now joined by Arzani, yet should coach Dwight Yorke have one more signing ace up his sleeve, the balance in the squad could well look the equal of their cross-town rivals.

Dwight Yorke (Photo by Brendon Thorne/Getty Images)

After what ended up being miserable campaigns in 2021-22, football’s biggest market is set to – and must – bounce back this season.

Frankly, there will be no excuse for all three.

Macarthur will once again enjoy the splendidly presented surface at Campbelltown Stadium for home matches, Sydney FC will use an emotional return to Allianz Stadium as a potential kick-start to their season, and Western Sydney will hope early-season results match the quality of CommBank Stadium, which would see the fans flooding back to Parramatta.

The recruitment has been extensive, fan expectation is high and the opportunity now exists for a Sydney team to grasp superiority and make ground on the Melbourne clubs that so dominated last season.

While tough to read which club that will be at this stage, the A-League owners will all be secretly hoping that Sydney’s teams do put up a better showing this time around.

As irritating as the place can be, the A-League needs at least one Sydney team in and around contention.

The Crowd Says:

2022-09-01T03:44:39+00:00

chris

Guest


Interesting but not surprising as to where the vouchers are spent. Now if only the governments allocated funds fairly. The people have spoken.

2022-09-01T03:10:54+00:00

Simmo

Roar Rookie


Not just Griffith, but a load of NSW country towns host entire leagues, not just individual clubs. Tamworth, Armidale, Lismore, Port Macquarie, Coffs Harbour, Bathurst, Orange, Dubbo, Parkes, Nowra, Goulburn would fit the definition as well. Soccer has quietly crept into 1st place among the football codes in Wagga as well. Country NSW is definitely under-appreciated for its football culture For anyone who's interested in the granular detail of where different sports have their strongholds in NSW, the NSW Government has a very useful dashboard with loads of detail on where the active kids vouchers are spent on which sports: https://www.sport.nsw.gov.au/active-kids

2022-09-01T02:59:18+00:00

Simmo

Roar Rookie


And why Real Madrid are turning the Bernabeu into a shopping centre with a football stadium in the middle

2022-09-01T01:20:16+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


agree with you there. Possibly why they are looking at Kruse and Zulo, both recovering from injury according to a recent article by Marco. Jack Hingert may lose his starting spot but will be good off the bench.

2022-09-01T01:11:51+00:00

Sheffield WesDay

Roar Rookie


Watching last nights Aus cup I was filled with some hope for the Roar boys. But it hinged on the fact that I think Moon finally played the boys in the best formation and team selection possible. Austin at False 9 is great, he seems to work harder in defense than attack, but I am confident of they can get the ball to him in the box, he will hit the goal more times than he misses, plus he is very good add slipping those cheeky passes through the defense to fellow attackers. He works well with Danzaki running off him playing a more traditional striker role. Hore on the left and Mileusnic on the right (or vice versa) are always dangerous. And finally Akbari back in the engine where he can quietly keep the ball moving across the pitch, shielding the denfense and releasing the attackers. A Strong makeshift back 4, but I still don't see where Trewin and Neville fit back in. Trewin needs be on the pitch to continue his developemtn and Nevill was by far the best Center back the team had last year, and thought he was unlucky not to get a Socceroos call up at some point?? What really concerns me is the bench. Only really Ivanovic now there who could potentially make a difference. Unless Dehmie bulked up in the off season ready to go toe to toe physically with some of those Big center halves. Still yet to see Lofthouse really contribute or effect anything on the pitch other than running fast and losing the ball. First 11 looks great, depth is the issue.

2022-08-31T13:09:27+00:00

Roberto Bettega

Roar Rookie


This is certainly true...but...the decline in newspapers started over 15 years ago. As we stand here today, their decline is not the newsworthy part...that they still appear to carry so much weight - that's the newsworthy part. 15 years ago - on this forum, on the once excellent 442 forum, on the once excellent TWG forum, on the many football blogs and forums which were cropping up everywhere - we were all patting ourselves on the back, proudly declaring that it did not matter that the traditional newspapers were not supporting football. We had found our own way of providing that very same support amongst ourselves! We had overtaken newspapers in importance! Well, 15 years on, and that now seems a rather foolish declaration.

2022-08-31T09:29:52+00:00

Grem

Roar Rookie


You’re right about newspapers - about to go down the same path as black and white televisions and video recorders.

2022-08-31T09:24:48+00:00

Grem

Roar Rookie


And I go to a few MacArthur games - the cow bells are good and unique.

2022-08-31T07:48:16+00:00

Dumbo

Roar Rookie


I think they are not against soccer. They - like every other newspaper - are struggling to stay afloat. They don't have the reporters any more to cover all the topics they used to cover or would like to cover. I think that they see soccer as very much a minority interest sport in Australia, so they don't allocate scarce resources to cover it. No more to it than that.

2022-08-31T03:27:13+00:00

Midfielder

Roar Guru


++++++++++++++++999999999999999999

2022-08-31T01:13:16+00:00

Garry

Roar Rookie


"Casual ticket sales will be on sale roughly 4 weeks prior to the first game, this is normal practice. Moving into a fresh new stadium and on the back of the Community Open Day over the weekend, there is a big push and opportunity to fill seats through Memberships prior to casual ticket"

2022-08-30T23:43:20+00:00

Hoolifan

Guest


It's funny, the people in Geelong and in Victoria in general would say soccer is not very entertaining. But then again, if you go to Sydney people watch rugby league. Maybe all that sun and rain does something to your I.Q., drains it perhaps?

2022-08-30T23:32:05+00:00

Lionheart

Roar Rookie


no fee for A League transfers, the clubs oppose it apparently (makes you ask, which clubs?). Roar did recently get paid a fee for a young centre-back who had been with the Roar Academy for five years, from U14s, on transfer to Danish club AGF. Good luck to him.

2022-08-30T23:22:10+00:00

Kewell

Roar Rookie


Nothing in the Australian or other News Corp rags. This mob won’t be happy until they cremated and buried football in this country.

2022-08-30T23:07:29+00:00

At work

Roar Rookie


That's a whole other discussion isn't it. Ideally youngsters like those should have been at least locked into contracts so that Roar gets a fee from them leaving, otherwise yeah free education and see ya.

2022-08-30T20:52:51+00:00

Christo the Daddyo

Roar Rookie


That shows a fundamental misunderstanding of how and why Sydneysiders attend events. There will be thousands of people who want to go to the first game at a new stadium who have no intention of getting a membership. The club has potentially missed out on many of these people by trying to push something they have no interest in buying.

2022-08-30T12:07:26+00:00

Buddy

Roar Rookie


That would make an interesting topic on its own. Many of us feel that the design of the stadium in Parramatta is way too corporate and has changed the focus of the incumbents from fans in general to a select few and WSW in particular appear to be chasing corporate dollars rather than fan engagement. Whilst undoubtedly that is where the money is, it appears to forget or ignore what sport is really all about and having been to numerous games at many stadiums as a guest in a corporate box, I genuinely have the worst time you can have at an event. Few people actually interested in the game. Many don’t watch at all and most don’t understand the rules - and I’m not just talking the round ball game. So at the new stadium you have virtually one side of the ground that has minimal interest or interaction with the game and it all helps to kill the atmosphere.

2022-08-30T11:45:51+00:00

338

Roar Rookie


One of the best things we can all do in addition to getting to games is support channel 10 and paramount.

2022-08-30T10:57:16+00:00

Marcel

Guest


All good Buddy.....Alas 3 year election cycles are not conducive to forward thinking. In the last 5-10yr Stadia have gone through a generational change in design... Strangely people just are not happy anymore with a seat and a sporting contest....large hospitality concourses behind the terraces have become the ideal....get people to come early and stay late...have them onsite longer so they can spend more $ It's the real reason that Inter and AC are looking to leave the San Siro .

2022-08-30T09:58:33+00:00

Buddy

Roar Rookie


Sorry Marcel, it was not designed as an attack on architects and designers but more the politics of it all that allowed it to happen. I’m aware there were alternative plans back in the 80’s for Parramatta stadium but politics got in the way of a far more forward thinking design that should have lasted a lot longer. Local councils are responsible for plenty of appalling planning decisions but it seems that as long as people are making money, it’s ok.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar