FLEM'S VERDICT: Lyon starts new tradition for us tailenders as Carey helps Aussies show no mercy on Proteas

By Bowlologist / Expert

Alex Carey was magnificent, Cameron Green took another of his giant steps towards becoming a world-class all-rounder and Anrich Nortje was again lionhearted for the outclassed South Africans but the highlight of day three was Nathan Lyon starting what I hope will become a long-standing tradition.

Australia are perfectly placed to finish off the Proteas on day four and head to Sydney with the series already wrapped up after Carey and Green combined for their lengthy partnership to snuff out any hopes the tourists have of salvaging a draw.

But for those of you who are unaware, Lyon raising his bat for making 25 is the culmination of an idea I had way back on the 2001 Ashes tour.

Unfortunately it was shot down at the time by the captain, Steve Waugh, not surprisingly a batter. Myself and the other members of the Fast Bowling Cartel on that trip – Glenn McGrath, Jason Gillespie and Brett Lee – put forward the idea that if a bowler took five wickets in an innings they should raise the ball to the crowd like the batters do for 50s and hundreds.

CLICK HERE for a seven-day free trial to watch cricket on KAYO

It was given the stamp of approval at the team meeting, we started doing it and it caught on and now you see bowlers all over the world perform the ritual when they take a five-for.

(Photo by Darrian Traynor – CA/Cricket Australia via Getty Images)

I was feeling encouraged by this getting the green light so at the next team meeting I suggested that if a tailender batting nine, 10 or 11 got to 25 they should be able to raise the bat but it didn’t get enough support from the guys higher up the order who poo-pooed it straight away.

I ran into Lyon earlier in the summer and told him about it and he was keen but he’d hardly got a bat until this match.

I reminded him again today and he didn’t let me down. He was a little apprehensive at first but then he unleashed a bigger bat raise.

The off-spinning GOAT is now also an honorary member of the FBC … they were very happy on the WhatsApp group.

To see the reactions on the faces of the other commentators, mainly batters like Ricky Ponting, Justin Langer, James Brayshaw and Simon Katich was priceless.

They tried to say that if a part-time bowler takes a wicket they should be able to celebrate by raising the ball. No chance. They’d have to take at least three to get that honour.

Carey well and truly deserved to raise his bat to the MCG crowd for his ton, joining an elite club of six other Australian wicketkeepers to achieve the feat.

It was also fitting that the only other keeper to do it at the G was Rod Marsh – who did it in the Centenary Test of all occasions – after he passed away earlier this year. This Test was about honouring Shane Warne’s legacy but he was another giant of Australian cricket.

After Nortje had knocked over Travis Head and David Warner with two very quick straight balls in a row, I thought the Aussie innings could be over pretty quickly.

But Carey got similar deliveries soon after and hit them both with the full face of the bat to mid-off and I remember thinking ‘gee he looks so compact’.

Alex Carey of Australia celebrates his century. (Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

All through his innings he looked like he had so much time, a bit like Warner the day before. He’s a very attractive batter to watch, his cover driving is classical, square of the wicket on both sides he is strong and his reverse-sweeping to Keshav Maharaj doesn’t look unsafe at all.

It’s a massive plus for Australia to have Head, Green and Carey in the five, six, seven slots. At the start of last summer there were a few question marks there but those three have made those spots their own.

I can see Green ending up higher in the order at No.4 and Carey could definitely do the job at six when Australia need to play an extra bowler. I thought Green could be bothered by having a broken finger on his bottom hand but he played an important knock as well in his unbeaten 51.

Mitchell Starc is also playing through a dodgy finger but even though he didn’t get a wicket, it’s promising to know he will be able to bowl some overs.

If rain hadn’t cut short day three, I thought we would’ve been into the middle order. The pitch is still good for batting but the ball is moving in the air and there should be good swinging conditions on day four.

South Africa’s only real positive was Nortje, again. He charged in and was always going to give 100%. He keeps his emotion in check but is good with the Dale Steyn-like celebration with the chainsaw. He deserves it and for Warner to say it was the fastest spell he’s faced, along with his steep bounce, shows the quality of quick that he has become.

Kagiso Rabada and Lungi Ngidi haven’t been at their best but they’ve got an attack that should get 20 wickets in most Tests around the world. As far as their batting goes, all I can say is they have an opportunity to prove their up to Test standard against a depleted Australian attack but still a tough one.

(Photo by Daniel Pockett/Getty Images)

The challenge is to show they have a future at this level.

Australia’s selectors have a few issues to resolve for the SCG Test with Starc and Green resting their finger injuries.

If the pitch doesn’t look like it’ll spin, I’d be bringing in young West Australian all-rounder Aaron Hardie for Green. He’s the closest like for like replacement in the country. Will Sutherland is a player of the future but he is more of a bowling all-rounder even though he’s got a ton at first-class level.

But if it looks like it’s going to turn, I’d go with Ashton Agar as the second spinner. As a a left-arm finger-spinner, Agar is the one who is most likely to play in India where orthodox tweakers like Ravindra Jadeja tend to do better than wrist-spinners.

Josh Hazlewood is the natural to come in but if his grunter is not quite right or Scott Boland needs a rest, I’d be happy to see “The Wild Thing” Lance Morris get a run.

The Crowd Says:

2022-12-29T05:40:11+00:00

Brett Allen

Roar Rookie


Correction, I meant Latham

2022-12-29T01:52:06+00:00

Ace

Roar Rookie


Not so sure about Blundell Brett if you are talking New Zealand Their in form openers are Latham and Conway Conway is as consistent as Baba Azam and Labuschagne Just my thoughts

2022-12-29T01:27:49+00:00

Pierro

Roar Rookie


Some great points in there Flem . I agree 25 for a low order batsmen is an outstanding contribution . think if some of the close tests Aus have been in over in uk that sort of contribution can win a match and add another 25 on to it from batsmen up the other end to make the runs critical. I also think in time head and green can move up order. head will just need some good foreign tours first . In fact head green Carey could all move up one place at least really . They will need to sort out the openers for foreign tours very soon though as well

2022-12-28T23:24:19+00:00

redbackfan

Roar Rookie


still here bah humbugging old scrooge Jeff! not as simple as the straight one your man Inglis put down in the Prime ministers 11! (or that one against the redbacks!) Happy New Year and keep looking for the worst in people! (oh and please dont start trolling me again with your glass jaw)

2022-12-28T22:59:18+00:00

Pierro

Roar Rookie


"good batting" a little unfair he's just become the second keeper to make a ton in history at McG . moreover , he was outstanding with catches on a a few days in the earlier tests against sa he took some blinders . up close to the stumps for pace bowling was unheralded

2022-12-28T22:52:46+00:00

Targa

Roar Rookie


Get Conway to open instead of Blundell. Blundell is keeping and batting now.

2022-12-28T21:24:17+00:00

Brett Allen

Roar Rookie


I think Jansen bowled well without luck

2022-12-28T21:12:19+00:00

Steele

Roar Rookie


Curator’s really did roll out a perfect pitch for the touring team in the first test. As I said, if we had proper pitch doctors, we would produce a pitch like this one. The biggest difference is obviously Australia’s superior batting, so why neutralise that by producing a green top? Cant believe Elgar complained, he was done a favour in Brisbane. On a good batting wicket, Aus beat Sth Africa 8 times out of 10.

2022-12-28T21:03:34+00:00

Takeadeepbreath

Roar Rookie


The good news is, the test at least made day 4....and think that will be it....wrapped up before tea. Consolation though...it will unlikely be their largest margin of defeat. That would be the one against Aus in 2002 in Johannesburg where they lost by an Inn's & 360 runs. Nortje and Verreyne are the only players so far that have stood up and shown any metal....even when external "drone forces" have tried to take out SA's only star. Good on him for shaking it off as he did....although, I wonder how that incident would have been handled by other touring teams and individuals. Imagine if it whacked him on his bowling arm and put him out of action....??. Anyway, sincerely hope that SA show some fight today and don't simply limp out to the inevitable.

2022-12-28T21:01:26+00:00

Choppy Zezers

Roar Rookie


While super quick bowling is always exciting, it's not always effective. Look at Devon Malcolm. In 1994 across two innings he took one wicket. Now I can't recall the unlucky player to be dismissed by the meaty spread, but surely he's a player who never deserved to raise his bat in an innings?

2022-12-28T20:18:56+00:00

Genius Selector

Roar Rookie


I know they won't but could play Cam Green as a batsman. Looked bloody good yesterday with a broken finger.

2022-12-28T19:19:41+00:00

Brett Allen

Roar Rookie


Yeah, sad but true. Freddie & KP were still hungover from the Ashes

2022-12-28T19:11:54+00:00

Choppy Zezers

Roar Rookie


I was there for a few days of that one. It was painfully boring. The World XI looked disinterested and at one stage Australia was 3/333. England offered more competition than that team, and that's saying something

2022-12-28T14:33:14+00:00

The Late News

Roar Rookie


Flem cheers again for taking the time to put your thoughts down. I appreciate it a lot. I run my own business and I know how hard it is to find the time to do extra stuff. Thanks again for your great perspective.

2022-12-28T13:50:21+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Well, he's taken some catches. But let's not get ahead of ourselves re Carey yet to do anything particularly special with the gloves on a regular occasion this summer. He has a simple drop against him as a black mark so far. Still not moving cleanly with footwork. Needs a bit of a way to go to make up for some ordinary glovework and footwork last summer. Good batting though.

2022-12-28T13:36:10+00:00

Pierro

Roar Rookie


taking a lot of good catches this series . I predicted his batting would always be worthy of a number 6 in the UK ashes after the world cup there . very happy to see the obvious now occuring. when’s the last time you heard from old general on here ? morevover Carey is only the second Aussie keeper to make a century st McG . rarified air he is breathing

2022-12-28T11:31:07+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


It did - and that was the grounding behind my suggestion. But can't see it happening atm - neither the ICC as a limp organisation - nor the individual members that actually set the ICC's agenda, would be up for it. Well at least not before 2032, if the recently released FTP is adhered to. Bur personally, I'd love to see the best of the best come together as a team and challenge the WTC final contenders, as a lead in to the final.

2022-12-28T11:26:46+00:00

Brett Allen

Roar Rookie


World XI Blundell (NZ) Chanderpaul (WI) Williamson (NZ) Root (Eng) Babar Azam (Pak) Stokes (Eng) (c) Pant (Ind) Ashwin (Ind) Archer (Eng) Bumrah (Ind) Nortje (SA) Reserves Pujara (Ind) Brook (Eng) Verreyne (SA) Holder (WI) Rabada (SA) Axar Patel (Ind)

2022-12-28T11:16:13+00:00

Brett Allen

Roar Rookie


Remember it happened in 2005 I think, we played against the World XI in Sydney, also 3 ODi’s I think. The Aussies won easily.

2022-12-28T10:01:56+00:00

Jeff

Roar Rookie


Maybe a World X1 Test against each of the WTC finalists, in the 2 or 3 weeks prior to the WTC final could be fun. Won't happen with contemporary scheduling obviously.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar