WILL GENIA: It's vital the Wallabies beat Argentina otherwise self-doubt will creep in, three key selections

By Will Genia / Expert

I’ve got to admit, I didn’t see last weekend’s result coming. We got physically dominated and the scoreline showed that.

The most worrying part is that it wasn’t even South Africa’s best team.

Like it or not, and clearly Eddie didn’t, they were missing several players who would have started if it was a World Cup knockout match.

I’ll touch more on the game later, but looking ahead, it’s vital the Wallabies bounce back quickly.

This weekend against Argentina is going to be huge just for the fact that we’ve got to build a bit of self-belief in what we’re trying to do.

Eddie’s obviously come into the environment wanting to play a different way, create a different structure of rugby, change their mindset and their psyche, so it’s really important that we get a result this week and get some positive positivity from that, that can give us some confidence for the rest of the Rugby Championship and Bledisloe leading to the World Cup.

Will Genia says it’s vital the Wallabies bounce back against Argentina. (Photo by Sydney Seshibedi/Gallo Images/Getty Images)

I’m not saying that they’ll lose belief, but if you lose this weekend, in wanting to try and bring in a new style and a new game with the World Cup around the corner, you start feeling the pressure thinking ‘jeez, it’s getting closer and closer, but we’re not getting the results that we want.’

It’s not that you don’t believe in the coach, or you don’t believe in his vision, you just start to question everything.

Trust me, they’ll say that they have full belief and stuff like that. And again, it’s not that you question the coach, but you start to question little things along the way, you start to have reservations and hesitate a little bit because you’re not getting the results, and that affects team alignment.

If you don’t have everybody on the same page, you’re going to struggle.

One thing is for sure, the way South Africa played on the weekend is the perfect template for how you’re going to play competitive World Cup rugby.

The Springboks calved up the Wallabies off the back of a dominant set-piece and gain line battle. (Photo by Sydney Seshibedi/Gallo Images/Getty Images)

It’s about dominating the set-piece, making sure that you’re playing in the right parts of the field and identifying when you have space to use the ball. The Wallabies didn’t do that in Pretoria.

But in order to be able to use the ball effectively at Test level, you’ve got to have ascendancy or parity at your set-piece because that generates pressure.

If you’ve got a good lineout and you’re winning your lineout, the defence has to be aware of the lineout, so they stay.

If you’ve got a good maul, the defensive maul has to stay tight which creates opportunities at the seam. You saw South Africa do that to us.

If you don’t have a good maul, teams sort of tend to bounce out a little bit on the defensive maul and can cover that seam a lot easier.

Same thing with the scrum, your flank probably needs to stay on a little bit longer, which creates space inside and outside the No.10 channel which then creates the space further out wide.

So, the set-piece is going to be crucial and it’s going to be a huge area that we need to improve on.

As a nine or 10, it’s incredibly tough to have a lot of control over the game when your forwards are dominated, getting parity at the set piece and when you’re getting dominated in defence.

But it’s more a case of when we have the ball, what do you do with it?

The Wallabies were smashed at the gain line battle. (Photo by Sydney Seshibedi/Gallo Images/Getty Images)

A couple of times where we were putting up bombs when we were about 30-40 metres out or when kicking long when we were about 40-45 metres out, it would have been a good opportunity to put them under some pressure, build some phases and make them work.

The way it looked to me was they went into that game wanting to kick a hell of a lot.

You heard Dave Rennie speak about it during his tenure around how we don’t kick well or kick effectively or know when to kick, so the way I was analysing it was it seems like he’s said, ‘let’s kick the hell out of the ball to try and change our mindset about kicking, so we can compete with the Frences, Irelands and New Zealands’ and then he’ll rein it in as we get closer to the World Cup.

Eddie doesn’t strike me as the type of bloke that’s desperate.

I think he understands the bigger picture around wanting to be as well prepared as he can for the World Cup.

Even in the loss, he obviously mentioned that there weren’t a lot of positives that come from it, but I feel like he’s definitely got a plan in mind for what he wants to do.

It makes it a bit more difficult because of the nature of the loss, but I honestly believe he’ll want to give guys an opportunity that played well.

There weren’t a lot of guys who played well, maybe that means Carter Gordon gets maybe 20 or 30 minutes, or potentially even start.

The halfback selection will be difficult as well.

I thought Tate McDermott did pretty well coming on. As we know, he brings a bit of spark, a bit of energy, a bit of speed and tempo.

Nic White obviously has tactical nous and game management skills, then Ryan Lonergan’s probably a combination of both of them. I rate him incredibly highly.

It might even be one of those things where he gets an opportunity to start this week.

I’d like to see Pete Samu at seven. He probably brings a bit more bulk.

Will Genia believes Pete Samu could be a solution for the Wallabies at openside flanker. (Photo by Will Russell/Getty Images)

Michael Hooper is a champion player and a champion bloke and a great leader. But Eddie’s even said it, rugby these days is more about the power game, the ball in playtime isn’t as long as what it used to be, and it’s about having a bit more size to be able to contend at the top level.

Pete Samu’s been excellent the last couple of years for the Brumbies and for the Wallabies. Again, he brings a bit more size, a bit more dynamism in like the carry, and it’s a good combination that’s worked at the Brumbies with Bobby Valetini.

I’d hate to be a selector because part of me wants to see a White-Quade Cooper-Samu Kerevi combination because I know they’ll do well, particularly against Argentina, but there’s also a part of me that would like to see Carter get an opportunity to give him more confidence, if called upon because of injury to Quade during the World Cup.

It’s a big weekend. 

The Crowd Says:

2023-07-13T13:06:16+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


I bet it comes down to a kick or two. Boks have no kicker.

2023-07-13T08:17:48+00:00

cs

Roar Guru


And 'negative negativity'? A Rumsfeldian moment.

2023-07-13T08:12:19+00:00

Phil

Roar Rookie


Hard to believe it’s the same coach that came up with the game plan for last Sat!

2023-07-13T08:05:03+00:00

Wallabies_Larkham

Roar Rookie


Hehe I think Eddie J is planning another Brighton takedown for the Boklings if we ever meet in WC

2023-07-13T07:57:01+00:00

Aiden

Roar Rookie


They beat them playing possession based rugby, they tackled extremely well and they kicked their penalties.

2023-07-13T06:26:48+00:00

Wizz

Roar Rookie


We don't kick well and don't defend well after kicking deadly combo...it's not our style never will be..with this lot anyway.

2023-07-13T06:08:58+00:00

RD

Roar Rookie


Khun, absolutely its the 2015 WC. :-))

2023-07-13T06:05:26+00:00

Khun Phil

Roar Rookie


RD,perhaps you mean the 2015 WC?Nobody was "sublime" in 2019!

2023-07-13T06:01:21+00:00

tomfredlee

Roar Rookie


I suppose there is also ‘negative positivity’ (over estimating yourself) and ‘positive negativity’ (critical reflection) too

2023-07-13T06:00:13+00:00

tomfredlee

Roar Rookie


“positive positivity“—nice song or book title there.

2023-07-13T04:53:23+00:00

Don

Roar Rookie


2015 was a year of miracles... After all, we won the Rugby Championship and made a RWC final.

2023-07-13T03:32:40+00:00

Leroy14

Roar Rookie


All good mate. I didn’t think to differentiate with Gordon’s cause Jake is with Australia A currently.

2023-07-13T03:02:09+00:00

RD

Roar Rookie


Will, I have always wanted to know why you rate QC over Foley, given that in the 2019 WC, your pairing off with Foley, was sublime. Foley plays flat at the line, defends well and is a far better place kicker. Apart from a state mates bias towards QC, I am intrigued to know

2023-07-13T02:51:17+00:00

Dean

Roar Rookie


My error mate, sorry. I should have read what you said properly. The hint was in "pair" :laughing:

2023-07-13T00:47:43+00:00

Hambone

Roar Rookie


hardwick would have been a massive point of difference for us. especially if he could pick up that form from start of super season..

2023-07-13T00:28:04+00:00

Tooly

Roar Rookie


You are right about one thing old fella ; this is a big week , if we don’t improve with this team against the Pumas we will be up ship creek against the AB next week . As Will well knows , he and Quadie were very ineffective playing behind losing packs as they mostly were . George Smith and Pocock made a lot of difference to their prospects and ours . With Holloway , Valentini , Samu and McReight off the bench we have a good start . We need Skeleton and he needs the best possible partner we can find . I’m surprised that Comical hasn’t pulled old Will back in . We have a lot worse . White can play behind a dud pack . He and Lonergan do enjoy playing behind the real men at the Brumbies . McDermott goes well when the Reds are going forward . He’s not so hot when they are under pressure . Fines to me is the man for the future .

2023-07-13T00:04:34+00:00

jcmasher

Roar Rookie


I'm not sure it matters who is in the back line if the game plan is for the 9 and anyone else to kick the ball away every time you get it. The Wallaby kickers are inaccurate, don't kick far and don't seem to make good decisions about what type of kick to use and when. We can all blame the lack of contest but it's hard when even the kicker doesn't seem to know where the ball will be going. I do find all the criticism of Cooper a bit much, I think he got 5 passes from White all game and at least 3 of those were with Bok players arriving at the same time. Not sure that anyone else could have done any better. I do agree giving Carter Gordon more time, but I think he'll struggle under the same pressure. lets hope the forwards step up a bit better this week.

2023-07-12T23:41:27+00:00

jcmasher

Roar Rookie


Pfft! Ain’t going to happen. Boks will be going home with their tails between their legs

2023-07-12T23:37:49+00:00

TheOvalBall

Roar Rookie


Even if the players buy into Eddie's plan its not enough He is picking some of the wrong players and being loyal to the old guard. Just as he did when he managed our England team. Nic W is too slow for No 9 and made some terrible decisions. Those missed kicks by Hodge. And the open play Kicks for territory. Hopeless. And the lineout throws :( You can't win major tests or competitions without a great kicker. As for the wingers, they never had a chance with the pack being dominated. It was like men vs boys. Change 9 and 10, drop Hooper as too small and old now, maybe put Hodge at 15, and Kerevi to start. Its a must win game now against Argentina. In reality no Aussie team was going to be within 20 points of the boks last weekend, at that stadium, with all the emotion, the brute force of that team and its ability to play to their strengths, and not inflict so many mistakes on themselves the way Australia did. Suddenly I dont feel so bad about England's chances. Good luck Aussie cousins !

2023-07-12T23:31:05+00:00

Link

Roar Rookie


I agree re Gordon but QC is lacking game time too. Might need to be a pick and stick scenario either way and think QC is a safer option this close to the WC. But can see it going either way.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar