The 23 Wallabies to win a RWC quarterfinal - and the 10 others who should be in Eddie Jones' squad

By John Ferguson / Expert

It’s the week we have all been waiting for, where World Cup squads around the world – including Australia – are starting to be revealed.

Slowly but surely, we have seen Eddie Jones’ 33-man squad come together and finally some combinations are arising.

CLICK HERE TO SEE THE RWC SQUADS AS THEY’RE NAMED

While Rugby Editor Christy Doran has predicted the squad Jones will pick for the tournament, I have named a 23 I would pick for a quarter final clash – plus the other 10 men who should make up the squad.

The QF 23

1. Angus Bell (VC)
2. Matt Faessler
3. Taniela Tupou
4. Nick Frost
5. Will Skelton
6. Tom Hooper
7. Fraser McReight
8. Rob Valetini
9. Tate McDermott (c)
10.Carter Gordon
11. Marika Koroibete
12. Samu Kerevi (VC)
13. Len Ikitau
14. Mark Nawaqanitawase
15. Andrew Kellaway (VC)

Replacements

16. Dave Porecki
17. James Sliper (VC)
18. Pone Fa’amausili
19. Richie Arnold
20. Langi Gleeson
21. Ryan Lonergan (VC)
22. Quade Cooper
23. Jordan Petaia

Now we are searching for the 10 players that are not pulling on the jersey on game day.

Jones has always been clear not all those players outside the 23 will play, however he has also been clear about the fact that they have a job to do.

The job is holding both the standards and the mood of the matchday 23 up and driving both positivity and aspirations.

(Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

“Then the next group of players we pick is the bottom five. And the bottom five players are the five blokes who are going to be the best teammates. They’re the guys who might not even play a game at the World Cup or might play a cameo role, but the way they conduct themselves on and off the field is crucial to a World Cup campaign success,” Jones told the Evening Standard Rugby podcast in May

“You can’t have your third hooker or your third fly-half kicking stones, they are the ones who cause problems, so you need them to be good characters, positive characters.”

But I won’t be starting with the bottom five, we will start up front. In a tournament such as the World Cup you must be three deep in props and hookers.

At loosehead you would have to think it’s between non-capped Blake Schoupp and Tom Lambert who are both in the squad currently. However, Matt Gibbon had a good Super Rugby Pacific season, and has played at international level before.

The fact that this is even open for debate in a World Cup year is insanity but personally, a Gibbon or a Lambert gives you a ball running threat.

Jones, however, likes the “brick sh*thouse” that is Schoupp, but size matters and so untested Schoupp stays, and Gibbon goes, Lambert is an unknown quantity building for the future.

At tighthead, Zane Nonggorr has had a meteoric rise to the top after a solid season for an undermanned Queensland Reds side. The 22-year-old is building nicely but is still a year or so from being proper international standard.

I would bring in the experienced and versatile Sam Talakai, he can play both sides and even hooker at a pinch. He played a fast-paced game with the rebels all year and kept up.

Third place hooker will likely go to Jones’ passion project Jordan Uelese, but if it were up to me, I would bring in Brandon Paenga-Amosa.

This gets us to 26.

Moving into the locks, you need at least four genuine options, we have Matt Philip and Jed Holloway as premier candidates or perhaps Jones looks to a Lukhan Salakai-Loto who comes into discussion.

Jones has a lot of information players must digest so I can’t see him going outside the group for these positions. Philip and Holloway retain their spots as motivators and the men able to drive standards. Both are capable if called upon.

We are now at 28.

Now comes the backrow game of Tetris. Rob Letoa has done well to go from 10 months on the sidelines straight into the cauldron of international rugby.

However, if one was to be critical of form as one must be, especially in a world cup year; he has been prone to mistakes and has failed to do some basics well, lineout takes particularly.

Pete Samu was omitted from the most recent squad for reasons undisclosed by Jones. It would appear he is too short to play starting six and lacks some sting in defence, and yet not being a genuine seven. He can forget about starting as he won’t usurp the likes of Valetini, so where does he fit in if at all?

You take him for the same reason you take any utility player, you need a person who will hold the standards of the squad, can cover a variety of spots (even wing) and it’s something Samu can do.

Then comes the question the burning question, whether to carry injured co-captain and Wallabies legend Michael Hooper.

Currently the count is at 30 players, so only three players left. Hooper has not been in peak form in either international or Super Rugby Pacific. He was also severely outmuscled at Loftus Versfeld.

McReight and T Hooper are flying the flag for the workhorses, both getting through outrages amounts of tackles each game and more. What the young duo lack is M Hooper’s experience.

Make sure of your place in the stands to see the British and Irish Lions in 2025. Tour packages on sale now at Wallabies Travel

Experience in a World Cup counts for a heck of a lot, but one cannot help feeling the ambiguity surrounding his calf injury for even those closest to him may be so murky that he misses the flight to Paris and instead plays in the Barbarians teams abroad under Jones.

It’s either Samu or M Hooper, it feels like a basic but nonetheless a tough decision.

The count is still at 30, three spots open for the backs.

The backs would always be tight, but a specialist position like halfback must always be covered.

Jones may feel he can plug the Barbarians side in Europe with a few extra halfbacks like Issak Fines-Leleiwasa and a soldier like Ryan Lonergan and therefore save a spot for other positions.

But, if he picks three, Lonergan must be lining-up at customs headed for Paris Charles de Gaulle Airport.
Count is now at 31.

The centres are tricky. Assuming as I have, Len Ikitau will be good to go for the tournament then who is next in line?

Lalakai Foketi is the only centre option in the squad that hasn’t played any minutes in Wallaby gold under Eddie. The fact he only covers 12 and 13 at a pinch may count against him as his main rival, Izaia Perese is a more damaging ball runner and covers jerseys 11-14.

However, if Kerevi is injured, Foketi may be thrust into the side as injury cover, at the time of writing this, all reports suggested Kerevi would be good for game 1.

Although it feels bizarre to be at the last spot for the squad and mentioning someone like Suliasi Vunivalu who Jones name dropped last week and hinted he was close to play in Bledisloe 2. Jones has so far stuck with his passion projects but were it up to me on form he wouldn’t be going.

The final squad member is difficult, as somehow, he feels more important than the previous 32. This player is by no means the 33rd most important member but being at the end of the line feels daunting for an armchair selector like myself.

Despite Tom Wright’s rocks and diamonds nature he is a great attacking threat, and he has played some serious minutes at fullback, all the while improving his defence.

If Jones is scarred, he could pick high IQ footballer Jock Campbell who is tactically sounder and has an elite kicking game as well as having played 10 for club and state on numerous occasions.

However, Jones won’t have time nor need to use precious stock to take another specialist fullback or 10 but he will need someone who has played both positions before at international level. This is where Reece Hodge should re-enter the fray.

Despite Jones having name dropped Ben Donaldson ever since he returned to Australia, the young Waratah is yet another player not seen under Eddie.

Hodge genuinely covers positions 10-15 as he’s lined up as a starter in those positions before. Many former and current players vouch for Hodge’s value as a team member and Mr Versatile will surely keep those men in the 23 accountable.

There you have it, my 33-man Wallabies squad to take on the world.

It’s not the players I would have picked a year ago and not at the close of last World Cup cycle.

Nevertheless, the matchday 23 have proven themselves to be willing to work hard for every inch and the other 10 players have experience and power to inject if called upon. Exciting times ahead.

John Ferguson’s 33-man Wallabies squad for Rugby World Cup 2023 in France. (C and VC nominates captain options).

Props (6): Angus Bell (VC), Taniela Tupou, James Slipper (C), Pone Fa’amausili, Matt Gibbon, Sam Talakai
Hookers (3): Dave Porecki, Matt Faessler, Brandon Paenga-Amosa
Second row (5): Will Skelton, Nick Frost, Richie Arnold, Matt Philip, Jed Holloway
Backrow (6): Tom Hooper, Fraser McReight, Rob Valetini, Langi Gleeson, Pete Samu, Rob Leota
Halfbacks (3): Tate McDermott (C), Ryan Lonergan (VC), Nic White
Five-eighths (2): Carter Gordon, Quade Cooper
Centres (3): Samu Kerevi (VC), Len Ikitau, Izaia Perese
Outside backs (3): Marika Koroibete, Mark Nawaqanitawase, Andrew Kellaway (VC)
Backs utility (2): Jordan Petaia, Reece Hodge

20 forwards, 13 backs.

Official squad to be released on Thursday afternoon (August 10th).

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2023-08-14T02:35:13+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


So much has happened Ken! More pieces will be out this week to look ahead to RWC!

2023-08-13T18:11:06+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Yes John. This article needs a post- Eddie bomb edit, perhaps?

AUTHOR

2023-08-10T03:29:04+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


Hey Wiganboy I can't see us needing another hooker who doesn't throw straight.

2023-08-09T14:11:06+00:00

CW Moss

Roar Rookie


Good 23 if we can just get through the Pool stage without imploding. Michael Hooper must hold the record for playing well in a losing team. Lose him!

2023-08-09T07:42:52+00:00

sheek

Roar Guru


The Wallabies are the well that keeps on giving fantasy dreams to Wallaby fans. My litmus test is to compare the 2023 Wallabies squad to that of 1991 (won, rank 2), 1999 (won, rank 1), 2003 (runners-up, rank 3) & 2015 (runners-up, rank 4), & the 2023 mob don't compare to any of those 4 teams. So unless there's some kind of mystical electrical storm as happened in the movie Yesterday, the Wallabies won't be winning this year's RWC. Not even a biased draw in their favour should see them deserve, or fluke, to win. But hey, dream on.....

2023-08-09T06:28:30+00:00

Dusty10

Roar Rookie


Yeah sorry mate, got a bit carried away and wrote an essay! Thanks for the article, always stimulating reading :)

AUTHOR

2023-08-09T03:53:37+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


Cheers for the Yarn Dusty10! All will be revealed tomorrow! Then we may all be eating words.

AUTHOR

2023-08-09T03:51:22+00:00

John Ferguson

Expert


Thanks for the wraps Sofa Coach! You make a lot of good points particularly around OS selection thoughts. It will be telling who Jones selects in a little over 28 hours.

2023-08-09T03:36:03+00:00

Dusty10

Roar Rookie


Hi John, love the way you think and I agree with almost all of your selections. M Hooper has been an absolute aussie stalwart and always gives everything, BUT... When you say he has experience, well, yes, but his experience is of multiple losses. Hooper has never captained a winning team. He's had a few wins here and there, sure, but under his reign the Wallabies have been a losing team. His decisions as Capt have also been highly questionable over the years. He's respected for his doggedness and the fact that he's just a genuinely good man, but he's also just not that good a player. Sorry, Hooper fans, but he's just not. And lately, he's been playing particularly poorly. I suspect that Jones knows he screwed up in naming Hooper Capt, and he's simply avoiding the topic with his vague and evasive reports about Hooper's calf injury. I suspect he won't play. If he does, he's a liability and it will probably backfire. With regard to Hodge, again, yes, he has loads of experience in multiple backline positions, but that does NOT mean he's been any good in those positions. He's terrible and always has been. I know I keep saying this but; slow, poor hands, no step, no fend, dies in contact, never (ever) makes breaks or bends the line. He's a cork who fills a hole, and that's all he is. Even his kicking game, supposedly a 'weapon', has never been seen at test level. If Eddie wants to play a fast, aggressive, effective brand of attacking rugby, Hodge is the OPPOSITE of that. So, Wright gets the nod. As an aside, Wright can and does play at 10 for the Brumbies, regularly stepping in showing Lolesio how it's done. He's also a fantastic attacking threat at 14 and 15, as you say. Anyway, we all have our opinions and favourites I suppose. If Hooper and Hodge are both selected and play well, I'll happily eat my words. I wish them all the best because they're good men and I love the Wallabies. I just wouldn't select them.

2023-08-08T22:37:41+00:00

TheTruth08

Roar Rookie


Mcreight goes down in the first 5mins and bring in Gleeson, You lose right there. THooper is not a 7, yeah he can cover that position but doesnt complete the core role of a 7. Im a big fan of Hooper at 6.

2023-08-08T22:17:51+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


They are both specialist 10s though and both wore 22.

2023-08-08T21:10:57+00:00

Tim

Roar Rookie


Another great article Johnny, can't argue with your selections/reasoning. Keen to see the squad tomorrow!

2023-08-08T21:03:55+00:00

Objective Observer

Roar Rookie


QC is no Mo’unga.

2023-08-08T20:21:57+00:00

Dean

Roar Rookie


Excellent comment Sofa Coach.

2023-08-08T19:28:58+00:00

Sofa Coach

Roar Rookie


Thanks John, another excellent contribution from you, true to form. You back up your opinions well with astute observations. A refreshing change from those schooled at Newscorp in agenda driven assertion masquerading as insightful journalism. You remind me of Brett Mc and imo it would not be a bad thing for this forum were you to follow his trajectory. Anyway enough of the sunshine blowing. It seems most on here are largely in agreement with your selections, as am I mostly, however my 2c to you and our fellow Roarers would be to keep front of mind the importance that Eddie has made of those 5 players picked for the importance to squad energy and cohesion. For this reason in particular, and also because Eddie and his assistant coaches have had so little preparation time to get to know players and create cohesion, M Hooper and N White will travel if fit and selections from outside the current squad such as BPA, Sio, LSL, Kerr-Barlow, and Simone are Roarer fantasy, no matter how sound the arguments on here be for their inclusions. Personally I too would have BPA and Simone in my match 23, and also Sio for Slipper if the latter is not fit, which it appears he clearly is not. (I haven't seen enough of LSL or K-B recently to be able to rate them over the other options.) So given the current options that Eddie has left us with, Porecki and the Fez have performed well in the last two outings, Ulese is yet to deliver this season. Fa'amausili manned up in Dunedin and is a daunting physical prospect combined with Bell. Hopefully Tupou and Slipper can remain fit enough to play at least 20 mins each once we get to the must win stage of the tournament, but their fitness is clearly a high risk as things currently appear. I can't see that Eddie has brought Arnold and Skelton back to play every game of his second coming, not to select them now. Frost and Philip are EJ's obvious preference to join them, with Holloway (also a leadership pick by Eddie) and T Hooper the lock/backrow hybrids. Valentini is locked in. T Hooper looks like the favourite at 6. Especially after McReight proved his importance on Saturday. The mobile jackling 7 is too entrenched in Wallaby rugby to change at this late stage. We are not quite ready for the Bok or England style 6/7 hybrid openside. But I'm not sure that Eddie will walk away from M Hooper’s experience in favour of McReight unless he has no choice. Both go unless Hooper cannot. I agree with many on here that Samu, Gleeson and Leota are fighting for the same #20 spot. Samu is the bench game changer who has the playing time with Valentini, T Hooper and Frost, but for some reason Eddie isn't impressed. Gleeson is the future, but he is well underdone in a team already well underdone. I personally see Samu as the best bench impact but Leota seems to be Eddie's preferred choice. The 4 halves used against the Darkness will be the match 23. Lonegran will be the 3rd 9. Any other talk is personal delusion. Eddie hasn't entertained any other options so far and to do so now is too late, failing an injury repeat ala Stephen Donald in 2011. Kerevi is so important to this team's prospects (did any player other than Bell make it past the gain line more last weekend?) but he is constantly breaking. Eddie didn't seem impressed with Hodge as his backup which leaves Foketi as the only other genuine option at inside centre. As equally important but far more underrated is Ikitau at 13. I suspect that the positional issues that we are seeing with Koribete's defence may have a lot to do with Ikitau's absence. Petaia, Hodge and Perese are all reasonable replacement options, but none are as good. For mine the current back three is locked in, which means if Ikitau is fit, Hodge and Petaia are fighting for the #23 due to their genuine utility. Given the current goal kicking weakness and the fine margins of knock out tournament rugby, Hodge's boot may be the point of difference that gets him the nod.

2023-08-08T15:44:59+00:00

Honest Max

Roar Rookie


I’m confused - you say you want strong, reliable players and then speak about Hodge as if he’s somehow that. Hodge is a born journeyman who’s shown no form in years.

2023-08-08T15:42:20+00:00

Honest Max

Roar Rookie


The lineout looks a bit shaky. Id also prefer Samu over Gleeson on the bench.

2023-08-08T14:32:50+00:00

MO

Roar Rookie


QC’s can play 12 and 15

2023-08-08T14:31:56+00:00

MO

Roar Rookie


Yeah Bf can’t carry even a legend who’s not playing and was underdone when he last was. No time. Fraser is the man now. Matt p has to play. He is better than Richie and Jed. Pete samu a proven finisher good pace and good lineout and when you sub him on the locks should be two of Philip frost and lsl so lineout well covered

2023-08-08T14:23:27+00:00

MO

Roar Rookie


Hooker lonegran is too small but does cover 7 really well.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar