Walsh's weapons, 'beautiful' Harry Grant - NRL regular season Team of the Year

By The Barry / Roar Guru

That’s it. The regular season for 2023 is in the can. September footy is a whole new competition.

Before we reset and the tension ratchets up, let’s reflect on season 2023 with my team of the year.

Fullback – Reece Walsh

Fullback is normally the most competitive position. Injuries and form slumps have seen maybe a changing of the guard in 2023. What I like most about Walsh is that he has so many weapons in his arsenal.

In the Broncos’ Round 2 game against the Cowboys, with the score at 10-10, Walsh laid on one try with a kick, set up another one with a pass from a kick return and then scored one himself with his slashing speed.

Honourable mentions: Kalyn Ponga, Dylan Edwards, Charnze Nicoll-Klokstad, Clint Gutherson

Wingers – Jamayne Isaako and Dallin Watene-Zelezniak

Since coming into first grade, Isaako has looked like a player with all the physical gifts but rarely able to put it all together at the same time. He’d have a blinder and then look ordinary for the next month.

He’s been a model of consistency in 2023 and will finish the season as the NRL’s leading try-scorer and leading point-scorer. He’s also third among wingers for run metres, third for line breaks and fourth for tackle breaks.

The second wing spot could have gone to any of half a dozen players. DWZ is another player with all the attributes who has struggled for consistency. 2023 is without doubt his best season in the NRL. He’s benefited from having Shaun Johnson and CNK running beautiful plays inside him, but his finishing has been spectacular

(Photo by Phil Walter/Getty Images)

Honourable mentions: Greg Marzhew, Dom Young, Brian To’o, Mikaele Ravalawa, Selwyn Cobbo, Sunia Turuva

Centres – Stephen Crichton and Kotoni Staggs

Crichton plays left and right centre equally well and plays whichever side Ivan Cleary needs him. He’s arguably the best defensive centre in the competition and takes intercepts for fun. Could be accused of having ‘glue hands’ in the past, but has eight try assists this season (nine is the highest for a centre) to go with his 14 tries.

Staggs’ attacking prowess has been well known, but I’ve had a knock on his defence in the past. Clearly he’s worked on it because he’s arguably the best defensive centre in the comp this season, with his 85 one-on-one tackles making him far and away the league leader for centres.

Honourable mentions: Bradman Best, Herbie Farnworth, Dane Gagai, Valentine Holmes, Izack Tago

Five-eighth – Ezra Mam

Nuggety five-eighth built low to the ground. Great front on defender and brilliant support player… you know that’s in my wheelhouse!

Mam is a key ingredient to the Broncos’ attacking game. He plays link man and support player equally well, but is also a threat running at the line himself. Absolutely sweet timer of a front-on hit with perfect technique.

(Dis)honourable mentions: Dylan Brown, Tyson Gamble, Kieran Foran

Halfback – Shaun Johnson

I wouldn’t be in a rush to offload a 7 on the wrong side of 30 (if we had one). The game seems to slow down for them and you could argue Daly Cherry-Evans, Adam Reynolds but especially Shaun Johnson are in career-best form.

Johnson has always been a brilliant attacking and support player who clocks up plenty of attacking stats. This year he’s first in the competition for try assists, try involvements and leads kick metres by a mile. For halfbacks he’s second for line breaks and third for line break assists. His best contribution has been his ability to direct the Warriors around the park. Should be a shoo-in for the Dally M.

Honourable mentions: Daly Cherry-Evans, Nathan Cleary, Nicho Hynes, Jackson Hastings, Jahrome Hughes

Props – Addin Fonua-Blake and Tino Fa’asuamaleaui

AFB has taken his game to another level this season and has become a genuine leader. Leads the stats for front-rowers in runs, run metres, runs over eight metres, line breaks, tries and try involvements. A phenomenal season.

Big Tino averages more minutes than any other prop and plays every second with total intensity. Third for props in average run metres. He’s also developed a nice offload and a knack for scoring tries through the middle. Big, fit, tough, mobile, skilful. I’d say he’s the prototype for the modern front-rower but you so rarely see all those things in the one package.

(Photo by Mark Nolan/Getty Images)

Honourable mentions: Payne Haas, James Fisher-Harris, Moses Leota, Toafofoa Sipley, Lindsay Collins

Hooker – Harry Grant

Not a stellar year overall for the 9s. Grant gaps the field by a margin.

I’ve always said the mark of a good hooker is his first movement from dummy half. Did he pick the right option? Has he drawn in the markers and a defender? Has he created space or trouble for his first receiver? Cameron Smith was the best I’ve ever seen and I thought it would be a while before another came along, but Grant is beautiful to watch.

Honourable mentions: Jeremy Marshall-King, Mitch Kenny, Billy Walters, Blake Brailey, Phoenix Crossland, Wade Egan

Second row – David Fifita and Liam Martin

Fifita has finally delivered the season we’ve all suspected he’s capable of. The Titans – and more particularly Kieran Foran – have found a way to unlock Fifita and get him involved. Who’d have thought that using him as a decoy or attacking down the other side of the field wasn’t the way to get the best out of him?

Obviously, I’ve used statistics to support why I’ve selected certain players here. Liam Martin is a player it’s impossible to do that for. He doesn’t produce big numbers anywhere on the stats sheet.

What he does do is make all the effort plays. Watch him through the semi-finals. He’ll pick one or two players on the opposition and target them as mercilessly as Glenn McGrath targeting an opposition skipper. When his team needs it, he’ll take the tough carry, make the big hit or run the suicide line.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Honourable mentions: Briton Nikora, Jacob Preston, Eliesa Katoa, Nat Butcher, Isaiah Papali’i

Lock – Patrick Carrigan

Lock is always an intriguing position that probably evolves more than any other. Across my footy-watching life at different times locks have been defensive experts, extra second-rowers, ball-players or a third middle forward.

Modern locks arguably have to do a bit of all of it, which is why Carrigan gets the nod. Need a forward running the hard yards in the middle? Tick. Big motor, big minutes? Tick. Brutal front on defender? Tick. Genuine ball-player and link man? Tick. Great communicator and leader? Tick. Doesn’t kick goals… as far as I know.

Honourable mentions: Isaah Yeo, Cameron Murray, Tohu Harris, J’maine Hopgood

So, what do you reckon? Have I got any of these right? How badly have I got them wrong? Who have I forgotten?

The Crowd Says:

AUTHOR

2023-09-06T10:43:21+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Thanks for the ringing endorsement… it’s my team of the regular season, not semis. Who do you think I’ve missed?

2023-09-06T07:46:15+00:00

Andrew

Roar Rookie


Reasonable assessment I guess. Will be interesting to see how the finals rearrange this list as you have left out some players with big game experience here.

AUTHOR

2023-09-05T21:36:14+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


I’d never try and talk anyone out of Hopgood but Carrigan would go close to the best in the NRL for mine I went to Fox Sports lab to crunch their numbers, but they’re remarkably the same. Carrigan more metres, Hopgood more tackles. Hopgood more offloads, Carrigan slightly better attacking stats elsewhere Two great seasons…

AUTHOR

2023-09-05T21:25:45+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


I listened to this week’s bloke in a bar podcast yesterday afternoon The rugby league guru said something along the lines of “if you want to know whether someone knows anything about rugby league, ask them their opinion on Liam Martin. If they start saying he’s over rated and quoting stats to you, you know they’ve got no idea”

2023-09-05T06:39:28+00:00

Duncan Smith

Roar Guru


Can't argue with it. Picked purely on form.

2023-09-05T06:19:03+00:00

Red Rob

Roar Rookie


Great stuff TB :thumbup: Always pleased to see the unfashionable ones get out a shout out - Walters and Crossland in particular.

2023-09-05T06:12:41+00:00

Cam

Roar Rookie


J'maine Hopgood would be my 13. The bloke had a sensational season, incredible work-rate and is 5th in the league for tackles made, clocked up almost 1000 tackles at 93.4% completion (Carrigan has 667 for the season). Hopgood is 1st in the league for offloads (56) and carries for 123m per game. I'm also not sure I can get behind Ezra Mam as the best 5/8th in the comp, not when he has missed 101 tackles in 22 matches. Munster or Walker for mine.

2023-09-05T03:50:15+00:00

astro

Roar Rookie


Yeah, the halves under 25yrs of age are an interesting group... A lot of them seem to be coming out of the same mould. They have talent, but lack either the confidence or skill, to play with creativity. That, or, they're guys who want to play halves as a way of getting paid more, but are better suited to other positions. Illias, Deardon, Boyd, Metcalf, Trindall, Sexton etc all have solid kicking and passing games, but everything seems pre-meditated. They run 'plays' rather than improvising...They're ok if they have a creative halves partner, but alone, cant do much. All need to attend a workshop with Cliff Lyons to learn how to be creative at the line, or watch a tonne of Cam Munster footage. Matt Burton, Daine Laurie, Jayden Campbell and whatever Josh Schuster is, are all better suited to positions not in the halves. Watching Burton is tough...He's so much better in the centres. Sigh. BUT, there are good halves under 25yrs. Mam and Dylan Brown are the stand outs. Katoa and Sam Walker will be great, but need to get bigger. And there are a few guys like Jayden Sullivan, where its just too early to know... Anyway, 6s and 7s tend to get better with age, so it might not be as dire as it looks now.

2023-09-05T03:23:40+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


I personally think Manly are close to the spoon without DCE

AUTHOR

2023-09-05T02:08:48+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


DCE’s been great, but this one surprises me a bit. I’d possibly argue that other than Grant, Johnson is further ahead of number 2 in his position than any other player…

AUTHOR

2023-09-05T01:39:27+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Interesting thought… based on a standard bench of two middles, a utility and an edge forward my bench would be Hass, Fisher-Harris, Ponga and Nikora If you’re asking me to pick who have been the four best specialist bench players, that’s a LOT tougher. D Walker, McInnes, Leniu and Curran spring to mind but that’s very much off the top of my head…

AUTHOR

2023-09-05T01:35:25+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


yeah for sure. If I was picking a team to play for my life this isn’t the team I’d pick. Munster’s the best example. I think his form has been a little down this year compared to his own high standards, but if I was picking a team to play the martians tomorrow, he’d be in it Same with Holmes, plus Cleary, To’o, etc. This exercise was more about the form players for a very finite period rather than who are the best players overall. Again, Munster plays his best football in big games, so I suspect we”re about to see his best I thought about doing left and right, but decided to just pick my two best in each position. As it’s turned out it’s only wing that’s been an issue. Staggs can play right, Critta left. Fifita left, Martin right… but that’s definitely more luck than judgement

2023-09-05T01:29:05+00:00

3 R M

Roar Rookie


I don't think it would be too far a reach for all of them to be in 1 roster. The backs are bargains TB but the forwards do blow the budget considering the need for another 6-8 good first grade players and then the rest of the top 30 being capable of 1st grade. Loose 1 marquee forward and its doable I think. Or boats or Mercedes, shares in a pub even. any 3rd of the party deals and it could be possible?

2023-09-05T01:10:40+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


You will never achieve anything if haters put you off

2023-09-05T00:41:09+00:00

Tony

Roar Rookie


Can’t disagree with your run on team. But there are 17 in the current teams, so who would be your 4 bench players to make the full team of the year?

2023-09-05T00:38:11+00:00

Noel

Roar Rookie


Mate, who'd want that noise? Generally smaller blokes that get deliberately targeted in defence, then absolutely smashed by the peanut gallery for not being future immortals. Case in point - Illias.

2023-09-05T00:34:42+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


:stoked:

2023-09-05T00:29:31+00:00

souvalis

Roar Rookie


All well justified Barry. Just wonder if your top 13 were picked to actually represent ( play Super League Best for eg) would you bring in any of your Hon. M's in (must have '23 form) ? Theoretically DWZ has done well this year but practically, he's not Dom. Same with Jamayne ( 2 right wingers ?) and to a lesser extent Kotoni, fully deserving of lip recognition, but Val is still your form go to center and Fittler medalist To'o best winger in actuality. Same with Coach of the Year. The Blues coach didn't ask for Webby or Payten to come to camp and advise. He asked for the bloke who in spite of his team being whiddled away each year still finishes 'first or equal first' 4 consecutive years. PS He wont win any award for it but thought Patty was the best player in the NRL this year.

2023-09-05T00:28:52+00:00

Pedro

Roar Rookie


Very good. Maybe To’o on the wing for mine. He is just so consistent and so good bringing the ball back. Also Api at hooker. I think he has been a stand out every week in an otherwise very ordinary team.

AUTHOR

2023-09-05T00:09:51+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Cheers mate I considered Tapine, but overall I thought he was down on his form from last year That might be unfair because his 90% is probably better than most players 100, but that’s why I didn’t put him in

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar