Super Rugby Round 15: Time for some cream

By Brett McKay / Expert

A month out from the Super Rugby finals, I reckon it’s time we start seeing some cream rise to the top as expected. Enough of this anyone-can-beat-anyone business!

And if I’m going to really narrow this down, I reckon it’s time we saw the seven specific teams I’ve picked to rise to the top. This week specifically.

I’d say ‘maybe that’s just me’ here, but I know I’m not alone in battling with tips this year. So come on, rugby gods: it’s time to cut the unpredictability.

Round 14: Nobes 3; Harry 2; Geoff, Digger, Brett, and The Crowd 1

Overall: Nobes 57; Digger 54; The Crowd 52; Harry 51; Geoff 49; Brett 45.

Perfect rounds: No-one. Not even close. Not many had the Jaguares beating the Hurricanes. Even fewer had the Bulls beating the Rebels.

No-one had a draw in Cape Town.

Nobes

Tips: Chiefs, Brumbies, Rebels, Crusaders, Waratahs, Stormers, Lions

A very difficult weekend for the tippers and those who try to predict the results of the matches, who are more devalued than those that measure the polls of the politicians.

Things were going badly and on top of that the Crusaders, who are the easy bet, tied. But the good thing about all this is the great season of Super Rugby we’re having, in which nothing is defined, even with four rounds left, and nothing will be defined with three as well.

We will open the round with the Chiefs, who have had a very bad season, and the Reds, who do not finish defining what kind of team they want to be.

With this parity, I’ll play for the locals. The Brumbies and the Bulls are probably playing to maintain the lead in their respective conferences. Brumbies and their rolling maul on the Bulls.

Rebels cannot afford to leave points behind and have a match against the only team that has nothing to gain or lose, and that makes it very dangerous, but I am confident that visitors will move the party forward.

There are two very important derbies this round. In the first Blues that have to win to continue aspiring to a play-offs position and have to face a well-travelled Crusaders with certain extra-curricular things, but AMI Stadium seems an inexpugnable bastion.

The Waratahs will receive an exultant Jaguares who will rotate several players, but a Tahs team hit by off-court situations – but they have a lot of experience and will be dangerous given their need for points.

Jaguares will take a bonus point. The Highlanders will face the Stormers knowing the result of the Blues game, and that is a great advantage. Stormers are coming back. The second Derby finds the Sharks having to beat the Lions, and the only problem is that the locals have a very bad record at home. Lions.

Sure thing: No ref issues this weekend. They are all aware that all eyes are watching them.

Matt Philip of the Rebels (AAP Image/Julian Smith)

Harry

Tips: Chiefs, Brumbies, Rebels, the Church choirboys, Jaguares, Stormers, Sharks

Huge move I made on Digger ‘Bedwetter’ Cane in Round 14. Get your scented tissues ready. Here I come.

The gravelly Chiefs versus the grafting Reds: tough offload versus rough pick-and-go. I’ll take the Hamiltonians, with niggle. The Bulls go to Canberra without their field general on the field. Will their headless infantry survive? No! They are too happy about Melbourne, and the Will Genia wicket nutmeg.

The Rebels will probably win in Tokyo, but it’ll be the worst match of the round, just ahead of the slaughter of the Blues way down south: a (George) bridge too far. Can a local research scientist study why McDonald’s always seems to rob All Blacks of couth and sense?

The Jaguares-Waratahs match is the one to watch. Real, proper, snapping punches will be thrown. And the Jags will win it all: the fights, the match and the lovely lasses on Row D.

The Stormers at home with a mean pack and drunk fans: easy.

The Lions and the Sharks, oh my! Nobody knows. The Sharks hate to play at home. The Lions pack has less gravity than Alan Jones. Hmm… Sharks by a Bosch nether hair.

Sure thing: Digger will call me his Big Daddy Dumpling after this round.

Thomas du Toit of the Sharks. (Photo by Steve Haag/Gallo Images/Getty Images)

Digger

Tips: Chiefs, Brumbies, Rebels, Crusaders, Jaguares, Stormers, Sharks

It was great to avoid tipping the Sharks last week – it saved me from a perfect round of zero! Never thought I would say this, but thank goodness for the Blues!

So to start on Friday, I will back the Chiefs at home, and my guess is they will bounce back after a disappointing outing, as has been their tendency this season. I’ll also say the Brumbies at home, who I think are on a bit of a roll and have the forwards to combat the Bulls.

The Rebels may do it tough in Tokyo but should be good enough to get over a Sunwolves side that seems to be getting progressively worse as the season rolls on, while the Crusaders at home should account for the Blues and will be itching to get the last week behind them.

Jags are in some good form, and assuming that continues I cannot see the Waratahs competing well at the breakdown, so another win for the touring side in Sydney and the Stormers and Highlanders? I just don’t know. I want to pick the clan but I suspect they may struggle up front, so the mild cold front it is.

Which brings me to my nemesis, the Sharks, who I will pick because surely if you can thrash the Lions away, you will beat them at home, right? Am I right?

Sure thing: The overall penalty count from the republic must be a due a square up by now while DJs show the way for TMOs across all the grounds with disappointing decisions.

Brett’s note: Haha! They’ve picked the same teams! Ha!

Angus Cottrell of the Rebels. (Michael Dodge/Getty Images)

Geoff

Tips: Chiefs, Brumbies, Rebels, Crusaders, Jaguares, Highlanders, Lions

In what is already an excremental tipping year, last week was the Ganges, North Bondi and Yellow River all rolled into one. Yes, when the Blues are your one and only banker for the round you know it’s time to start tipping Lacrosse instead.

Nevertheless, boss-man Brett says that we must plough on, so plough on we will. Starting with the Chiefs, followed by the Brumbies who had Handre Pollard sent home this week.

It’s must-win time for the Rebels, so they will. And because the Crusaders seem to suffer from memory loss, someone will have to wake them up afterwards and tell them that they beat the Blues.

Even though the Waratahs keep hanging tough, I fancy the Jaguares again this week, which leaves two tricky games in the republic. The first will go to the Highlanders in a mild upset and the second to the Lions in, well, if the Sharks win or lose, it’s always an upset!

Sure things: Forced to sit things out on the field, Tolu Latu will put his hand up to drive the Tahs team bus to Parramatta. With the Test season looming, Ned will be the first to politely decline and order an Uber instead.

Sevu Reece (Kai Schwoerer/Getty Images)

Brett

Tips: Chiefs, Brumbies, Rebels, Crusaders, Waratahs, Stormers, Sharks

As picked last week, and with no reason to change.

I do look forward to the Reds proving me wrong, but the Chefs will be smarting after last week and won’t lose to a primary colour two weeks in a row. Bulls without Handre Pollard equals a massive opportunity for a Brumbies statement win.

Rebels are a club in crisis on the field; Crusaders and Waratahs are clubs in crisis off the field. Don’t pick against a crisis.

The Stormers don’t lose at Newlands, see last week for proof. And the Sharks are now wanting to impress ahead of the preseason for the English Premiership clubs they’ve all signed for, so that should be enough to top the Lions.

Sure thing: These tips are not inexpugnable. See weeks one to three, and five to 14, inclusive.

Get your votes in now – The Crowd’s tips will be revealed Friday afternoon AEST.

Who have you got, Roarers? Who gets your tip this weekend?

The Crowd Says:

2019-05-26T20:55:50+00:00

Riccardo

Roar Rookie


Yeah, stuck with them Brett; same on Superbru too. A lucky week in that, like Digger and Harry managed to get em all and margin points for all but one. A triple yellow cap week. Flukey, but I'll take it...

2019-05-25T11:41:15+00:00

Carlos the Argie

Roar Guru


It was!

2019-05-24T12:40:00+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


But now you are BACK in the SADDLE!

2019-05-24T11:03:25+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


I could be Carlos ... wouldn’t be the first time

2019-05-24T10:55:26+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


No I was indisposed .. didn’t see one game last weekend .. but I love that Willemse .. he puts bums on seats

2019-05-24T07:57:41+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


It’s in the bag Brett!

2019-05-24T07:56:50+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


TM, I’m on! Should have waited, now out to +14.5 ... I might double up!

2019-05-24T06:09:17+00:00

ThugbyFan

Roar Guru


Round 14 and back to the Tipping Disaster that is SR2019. Only 2 right from6 games. :( No time to waffle so in short: Chiefs, Brumbies, Rebels, Crusaders, Jaguares, Stormers, Sharks. (Note, will Reds show other tactic now that S.Kerevi isn't there). Sure Thing. Big Rory will sort out a couple of Bull Bullies. :)

2019-05-24T00:38:24+00:00

WithTheDawn

Roar Rookie


Shockers last week, but at least my 2 had me better off than some. I’d actually be curious how someone who had no idea about rugby and tipped randomly, or based on how they like the name of the team, would be going this year. Couldn’t be much worse than some of us, and might be a fun experiment for next time. Anyway, on to this week... Chiefs Brumbies Rebels Crusaders Tahs Highlanders Lions Should be a couple of crackers tonight, and upsets are certainly possible, but I’ll stick for the home teams in those ones. The Sunwolves are just too hard to tip, even though they put up a good show from time to time. The Crusaders are impossible not to tip, even though their aura of invincibility is starting to show cracks. If a desperate Blues can beat them or even push them close, some questions might be asked about just how easily the Crusaders could win this year. Tempted to pick the draw, but nah, Saders. Tahs / Jags in the late game should be good, with the Jags one of the form teams lately. Despite by better instinct I still find it hard to tip them when they are away, and will stick with the boys from Sydney. I’ll go for what is likely an upset by backing the Highlanders over in SA again, and hopefully they will get the result for me this time. In the last game, I can’t tip the Sharks, who have been hopeless at home, against a desperate Lions side with plenty to prove in the final rounds. Should be good fun.

2019-05-24T00:26:56+00:00

taylorman

Roar Guru


Only thing Im worried about is whether to take RT’s 13.5 for the win ???? Saders side looks ominous so a lot on Plummers shoulders. Id like to see more of Aumua and Sotutu off the bench and getting more minutes. Just feels like the sort of match Blues might get up and surprise all from under the radar…or that could just be the usual wishful thinking.

AUTHOR

2019-05-24T00:19:05+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


The Friday morning update: Well over 300 Crowd votes received already, to go with 150+ comments - for no particular reason, this weekend is generating plenty of discussion, which is obviously very welcome. Maybe it's because no-one knows what to expect any more? Maybe it's because you all want to see what manner of hair-brained explanations we can come up with this week?!? That's pretty much all that keeps me coming back, for what it's worth... Stormers-Highlanders is by some margin the closest Crowd pick, with less than 20 votes (around 5%) between the two teams. Late yesterday afternoon, the gap was only four or five votes, and there has already been at least one change of lead. Will The Crowd be stung by a close pick again, a la the Reds last week?

2019-05-24T00:18:27+00:00

terrykidd

Roar Pro


Hey Brett I just found out that the Chiefs will be missing Anton Lienert-Brown and Angus T'aavao. Therefore the Chiefs lose quite a bit of play making and defence from their midfield and their scrum is likely to be vulnerable. I am happy to stick with my Reds pick.

2019-05-24T00:16:28+00:00

jeznez

Roar Guru


Wait a minute is this a bed flutes at the ready kind of thing? I’m not sure I signed up for this!

AUTHOR

2019-05-24T00:06:58+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Too many Tahs...

AUTHOR

2019-05-24T00:05:19+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


Welcome Charly, great to hear from you!

AUTHOR

2019-05-23T23:58:28+00:00

Brett McKay

Expert


We prefer 'Stark. Raving. Mad', Tsuru..

2019-05-23T21:40:03+00:00

Machooka

Roar Guru


Korrect Muzzo... I been a couple of times. Before and after apartheid was abolished. Beautiful scenic city. Great food. Friendly people. And that's the problem... ;)

2019-05-23T21:32:26+00:00

Machooka

Roar Guru


Tah Harry... tah ;)

2019-05-23T21:31:07+00:00

Machooka

Roar Guru


... pants off!!

2019-05-23T20:53:58+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Tipping is about numbers. Rugby is about tackling, or not. 16 players have made 120 or more tackles this season in SR. Almost all forwards. Actually all. 12 are tackling at 90% or better. Of those, five have more than 10 DOMINANT tackles: Letjes, PSDT, Brown, Todd, and Rob Simmons!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar