Six talking points from Super Rugby Round 15

By Oliver Matthews / Expert

In exciting news, this weekend was the first for a while where it was almost all about the rugby.

With the finals less than a month away now nothing matters but the results on the field and this week saw a number of teams take important steps to secure their chances beyond Round 18. And with the focus on just the rugby, there is plenty to talk about so let’s get stuck in.

A lot to like about the Brumbies right now
The men from Canberra have been playing some good rugby recently and their win against the Bulls this weekend was impressive. They dominated the Bulls and sent a message to all of those who had dared to suggest that the Brumbies can only score tries from their driving maul.

They ran in four against the Bulls and all were scored by their powerful centres – Tevita Kuridrani and Irae Simone – who put on an impressive show.

It was impressive to see as well the confidence and patience that they’ve developed. With their opening try, the Brumbies made a great line break but instead of Tom Cusack looking for the miracle pass he went to ground, the Brumbies recycled the ball quickly and two phases later they had scored in the corner.

They’ve got the second-best form in the competition right now and their three remaining games are against the Sunwolves, Tahs and Reds – all teams out of form and below them on the ladder.

With this momentum and confidence they should be targeting three wins from three games, taking the Australian conference and a home final. Right now, with the way that they are playing, they will be a threat to most sides in the finals, especially at home on a chilly Canberra night.

It’s also very exciting to see Irae Simone having arguably his best game so far and striking a good partnership with Kuridrani. Is it too early to start talking about Simone as a Wallaby? Yes, probably but it won’t be long.

Siya Kolisi is getting even better
The Stormers back row and Springbok skipper had a great game this weekend to add to his recent impressive form. Already a fantastic talent, he’s really come on both in his play and his leadership this season and that’s good for all Stormers and Springbok fans.

(Photo by David Rogers/Getty Images)

His work at the breakdown and set-piece has always been strong, but he’s now also a devastating runner with ball in hand and scoring some great tries over the past couple of weeks.

He’s an important man in South Africa formany reasons and his form is peaking at just the right time for the Stormers. If they are going to make the Finals they need Kolisi to repeat these performances in their final three matches.

Kurtley Beale has similar flaws to Folau at full back
With the end of Israel Folau’s career at the Tahs, Beale has been playing in the #15 jersey and has looked very exciting in attack. The extra time and space has allowed him to show of his skills and he’s been running some lovely lines.

However, on Saturday against the Jaguares he did demonstrate that he’s got some defensive issues in common with the man who wore the jersey before him.

For the opening Jaguares try there was a grubber put in behind the Tahs defensive line just outside the 22. While some of the Tahs tried to turn and sprint back, Ramiro Moyano was faster than them all and collected the ball to score the try. But as he dived for the score, Beale appeared in the shot and was still a good couple of metres away from being able to make a tackle.

For Moyano’s second try Beale was there and had the chance to hit the Argentinian winger at pace about ten metres from the try line and just a foot in from touch. But instead of ploughing into the winger’s side he went high, almost took off the guy’s head, missed the tackle and Moyano was in.

Beale can be very, very good in attack but it’s clear that neither the Tahs nor the Wallabies can depend upon him in defence yet.

We need to get the TMO stuff sorted
There’s been increasing frustration over the past few weeks with the standard of refereeing in the competition. Sadly it isn’t just the men with the whistles that are causing frustrations among players, fans and coaches alike – the TMOs are getting in on the act.

This weekend there were some controversial decisions where views that aren’t available to anyone else but the TMO were used to overturn on-field decisions. Now if the right decision is reached in the end then that’s a good thing, but the lack of transparency isn’t.

Last week there was biased language used from a TMO that put the referee in a very tricky situation. While the ref should have perhaps pushed back against the TMO, as we approach the finals and then the World Cup later in the year, we need there to be consistency and clarity with how the TMOs get involved in the game.

Could the South African conference get a finals clean sweep?
With just three rounds left, the South African conference is excitingly close with just six points separating top and bottom. Add to that the fact that currently four of the five teams are in the top eight on the overall ladder and the fifth is in ninth position and only missing out on points difference.

It is possible that come the end of the regular season we have all five teams in the finals and that would be incredible.

Forgetting stories about suspicious penalty counts while playing at home for the time being, the South African teams have battled hard this season to be competitive. Early in the season, they were very up and down from week to week and it looked like the conference was a bit of a shambles. But as the season has progressed, the teams have all built some momentum and are looking tough to beat.

Interestingly though – while all five South African conference sides could make the finals, it could be that none of them play in South Africa. This must be a confusing set of emotions for the South African bosses at SANZAAR.

What more does Richie Mo’unga need to do?
Oh, to be Steve Hansen. As the World Cup draws ever closer, he’s able to enjoy watching some fantastic players going head to head in the race for 15 All Black jerseys.

At the top of this list is the race for the flyhalf spot as Beauden Barrett and Richie Mo’unga keep pushing each other. Over the past few weeks, the Crusaders #10 has put in some really special performances and against the Blues this weekend he played a lovely game.

(Photo by Kai Schwoerer/Getty Images)

In a tough game he made all the difference – he kicked well from hand and used his boot to create the opportunity for Bryn Hall to score and he also slotted important penalties/conversions.

But what more does he have to do to steal the starting role from Barrett? It will be interesting to see how Hansen handles them both in the upcoming internationals ahead of the World Cup.

Either way, the All Blacks are in a very fortunate position with two fly-halves who would arguably walk into most other sides around the world.

The Crowd Says:

2019-05-30T23:21:35+00:00

soapit

Roar Guru


A lot to like. I'd have Hodge at full back with banks on a wing and a tie for the other atm. Powell and cll have been easily the standout halves for me (not without blemish of course). Hodge to be permanent goal kicker

2019-05-30T21:09:40+00:00

Kashmir Pete

Roar Guru


Nice cover thanks Oliver. Appreciate comment on Kolisi as have not seen match. My wallabies coming into better focus: Front row = brumbies. Can do 16, 17 as well. Then add Kepu (no Tupou). 2nd row = Arnold & Rodda. Skelton if eligible for bench, otherwise Phillips. Back row starts = Jones @ 6, McCaffrey @ 7, Samu @ 8; bench is Naisarani & Hooper. Pocock no games all winter??? Game strategy based on winning more set piece less breakdowns. Subs on by 60 min. 9. Powell with genia on bench 10. Quade or christian (will watch form... ) 11. Hodge (all line kicks) 12. Kerevi 13. Kurindrani 14. Speight 15. Haylett petty 23rd: Beale for wide cover (6-2 bench). Game strategy more kick it, plenty line out seeking to disrupt opposition throw. Stuff running rugby till a new "coach who can". Cheers KP

2019-05-29T07:25:29+00:00

Paulo

Roar Rookie


“but no need for second #10 without flexibility” Yea, I think that’s the issue, I don’t see Mo’unga taking up a bench spot when he only really covers #10. That’s why I think if we want him, which I do, then he starts and BB, with his flexibility at #10 or #15 can take a bench spot. If he needs to come on, at #10 it’s like for like, at #15, same same, if a wing needs replacing, BB goes to #15, Bender to the wing. Another Back on the bench can cover the centres and then your sorted.

2019-05-29T05:56:55+00:00

FatOldHalfback

Roar Rookie


Tooly -- yes we need the spark of these 2 but not on the field at the same time. Maybe start with Cooper and DHP and then with 30 to go bring on Foley and Beale

2019-05-29T03:53:36+00:00

tuohyred

Roar Rookie


Pretty sure Shag said something like, "If Dan wasn't there Lima Sopoanga would be - but no need for second #10 without flexibility". Bit stiff after he generalled a pretty good victory against Saffas.

2019-05-29T03:40:28+00:00

Hoy

Roar Guru


Beale's missed tackle was one of the softest efforts I have seen in a while... that I can recall anyway. Pretty poor.

2019-05-29T02:53:05+00:00

Tooly

Roar Rookie


True Beale and Folau aren’t Trevor Gillmiester in defence. Nor are DHP, Hodge or any other contenders. Simple ; we need either Kurtley or Quadie on the field surrounded by good defenders, not both at the same time. No Kurtley, no Quadie, no sparkle. Generally the things that make them great in attack, like being light on their feet are not conducive in defence.

2019-05-28T21:16:20+00:00

soapit

Roar Guru


Powell of playing very well for the Bruns at the moment. Decision making second to none including Genia. Best option taken from the ruck always makes for a likely good outcome

2019-05-28T21:13:56+00:00

bigtree.smallaxe

Roar Rookie


Haha. “Yes, I believe the ayes have it”

2019-05-28T21:08:13+00:00

bigbaz

Roar Guru


Or the crowd could have a vote, maybe a show of hands, yes or no .

2019-05-28T18:02:30+00:00

AC

Guest


"If he chooses to" ? Mate, it's a big part of his job. I'd love to be able to pick and choose when to do a half added job at work, but something tells me my bosses wouldnt be as forgiving after a while. Surely you want a guy giving 100% in both attack AND defence in a Gold jersey ?

2019-05-28T15:28:46+00:00

The Neutral View From Sweden

Roar Guru


Have anyone seen BBBBB play poorly from the fullback position? I can't remember anything specific. He has all the skills required.

2019-05-28T14:17:52+00:00

QED

Roar Rookie


Why do we need a TMO ? All Super rugby and test matches have grounds with big screens. If unsure or unsighted The on field ref can call for a replay watch it on the big screen and make his own judgement. Perhaps the sideline assistant refs ( i still call them touch judges as until they consistently get that one role right they don’t deserve any more responsibility) I digress. Or the TMO can recommend to the on field ref to take a look at something. The TMO ques up all the replay angles. The on field ref views them on the big screen then he makes his own call. Done.

2019-05-28T14:14:16+00:00

Paulo

Roar Rookie


A Champion team beats a team of Champions. Although, in saying that, I think there are a few players that’s ‘make’ things happen. I think that makes them ‘x factor’ players?

2019-05-28T12:49:43+00:00

Geoff

Guest


When you really think about it, how much x-factor do the crusaders have?? The y are just a team where everyone does their job very well. I will take that any day

2019-05-28T12:27:31+00:00

Tuc Du Nard

Roar Rookie


Brumbies doing all the basics well, with each role being done well but...One reason they won't win the whole shebang is not enough X factor. Close, but will be outclassed at some point I think. Really love the way they are playing though. I could be wrong though as I think the all 15 all court game they seem to be playing is a plus for beyond at least. Very adaptable.

2019-05-28T12:09:50+00:00

Tuc Du Nard

Roar Rookie


I also think BBBBB AT 15 for ABs is putting him out of position, but because he is IPY, he has to run on. If RM at 10 then who at 15? Ok BBBB...As a diehard Wallaby supporter, I would prefer RM at 10. Then they have a guy who if .....well I'm dreaming he will not be amazing, someone who has to "adapt". Wake up! Having both on the field at the same time is a nightmare?....perhaps.

2019-05-28T11:58:59+00:00

Tuc Du Nard

Roar Rookie


Beale certainly not a starter imo. Backline ATM should be Genia if still running, MCD if not, Phipps if we run out. Foley maybe, but I reckon Christian is the answer. He took a hit last week that would render a roided up moose in hospital...he is a tough rooster and can defend at 10. A luxury. Kerevi then TK is a nobrainer. DHP at15. Undecided on wingers....Hodge must feature.

2019-05-28T11:23:56+00:00

Harry Jones

Expert


Very good summary.

2019-05-28T10:43:41+00:00

Waxhead

Roar Rookie


@Ken Yes I agree Beale can defend when he chooses to put his body on the line but....... No one should select a "maybe when he feels like it" defender in any Test match. It's no where good enough for a supposedly international player. Plus his kicking is crap too so he's not worthy of a WB squad position imo. Australia has much better fullbacks and centres - they don't need him :)

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar