The six-again rule is here to stay, and so are the Eels

By Scott Pryde / Expert

How good was that? Footy is back. The Brisbane Broncos and Parramatta Eels put on an exhibition of rugby league on Thursday night as the NRL season relaunched in splendid fashion, although the final score, reading 34 points to 6 in favour of the blue and gold, may not tell that story.

The result almost didn’t matter for starved footy fans. It had been nine weeks since a ball was kicked in anger, and a couple since the teams went back to training.

All seemed right in the world again for a couple of hours as the teams ran out onto Suncorp Stadium, and while you could look at any number of big-name performances from the contest – whether that be the Brodie Croft kicking game in the first half, Maika Sivo’s miracle try, Junior Paulo’s incredible performance, or Dylan Brown’s excellent game – but it’s the six-again rule which was always going to dominate the discussion coming out of the game.

And while it might need more than one game to tell us exactly how good it’s going to be, based on the evidence presented thus far, it’s something worth persevering with.

The game was faster, the players were more fatigued, and it created a much better spectacle with the ruck actually policed properly by referee Gerard Sutton.

Whereas a referee would normally hesitate in blowing a ruck penalty because it might slow the game down far too much, none of that occurred on Thursday night, because it was only going to speed the game up and likely create more points.

In short, the rule seems to empower the referee the officiate to the rule book, which has long been a gripe for fans. Sure, referees need to have a ‘feel for the game’, but it’s no good having a feel for the game if that makes the ruck look like a joke, which it has on more than a few occasions over the years.

It may have also looked good because of the quality of rugby league being dished out by both teams in the first half, and Parramatta in the second, who deserve full marks for the magnificent game of rugby league they put on to reboot the competition.

Michael Jennings scores a try. (Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

The six-again rule took just a matter of minutes to become involved in the contest, with the Eels receiving two in the lead-up to their first try, where the fatigued defence allowed Marata Niukore to chop through like they weren’t even there.

It was also evident later in the first half when Croft made a splendid run to score in the corner, beating the defence from about 35 metres out.

While fatigue and pace of the game has been talked about as the main advantages of speeding the ruck up with this new rule addition, it will also advantage the little guys, create more attacking rugby league, and reward players for creativity, which defences simply won’t have the energy or composure to shut down like they normally would.

That is exactly what we saw in Croft’s try towards the end of the first half.

The other major impact the rule had was in cleaning up the ruck.

I wrote a couple of weeks ago when the rule was first announced that the aim had to be to get the players to buy in and clean up the ruck themselves, to do it because they were concerned with the potential penalty. It seems just that has happened.

It was one of the fastest games of footy that has been played in this competition for years, with both teams clearly peeling off tackles and refusing to wrestle as much as they once did, creating a spectacle for fans as creative players were able to have their way.

While the Broncos would have been fatigued during the second half regardless given the amount of defence they had to do – not helped by their ridiculously high error count – Reed Mahoney and Dylan Brown were allowed to have their way with the footy in hand, running off quick play the balls and a much faster ruck.

Reed Mahoney goes for a run. (AAP Image/Darren England)

Parramatta will be thrilled with their performance though, no matter what rules were in place. Mahoney continues to put his hand up for a Queensland jersey, Junior Paulo played possibly the best game of his career, and Clint Gutherson was heavily involved throughout the contest.

The men in blue and gold came into the season with premiership potential written all over them, and Thursday night’s NRL season reboot has done nothing to dispel that theory.

For Anthony Seibold and the Broncos, there is work to be done, but it looked to be fitness which was their undoing, so they may well come good in a few weeks.

The six-again rule will change the game as we know it for the better, and with referee no worse than two – for now – it’s hard to argue with Peter V’landys, who seems to be on another winner.

Right now, though, we celebrate. Footy is back, and that’s all that matters.

The Crowd Says:

2020-05-31T10:34:19+00:00

zonecadet

Roar Rookie


No, actually they ‘slipped up’ and gave us a wide view and both teams were offside every single time. It will be the norm with one ref

2020-05-31T03:42:09+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


As a Dragons fan watching with one eye I noticed one tackle in progress with Smith on his knees near a tackled Raider on his back under a Storm player. Smith couldn't help himself and leaned over and laid his hands on the Raider but quickly realised he could be penalised and jumped up and resumed play. It was only one moment in the game and I wasn't keeping count.

2020-05-30T18:10:23+00:00

Tim Buck 3

Roar Rookie


It was a stuff up from the two referees that lead the Raiders to run it on the last tackle when they were in a good position to kick a match winning field goal. Did Easts' belief extend to the referees?

2020-05-30T07:38:57+00:00

BustlingBillDunn

Roar Rookie


Nah, it's application is already random, as a fan you're left with no idea what the call was for, and the poor team on the receiving end is left fatigued long afterwards. It effectively turns RL into a random 6/12/18? tackle game. And, it doesn't work as advertised. It did not stop the gang tackling Roosters slowing down the play the balls as the ruck rules remain the same. In fact, it rewards teams like the Roosters and Storm that slow the tackle with 4 defenders in defense, and surrender instantly in drop to the knees hit ups in attack. Souths got hit with six agains last night trying to slow down the typical Rooster drop to the knees hit up as soon as a defender touches you, while the Roosters were left to slow down the tackle all night long. Storm & Roosters, the wrestle/surrender kings, will love this rule.

2020-05-30T04:06:47+00:00

ScottWoodward.me

Roar Guru


Hi Scott, I am keen to see if the "6 again" rule is adopted internationally. While on the subject of changes, if PVL brings in a Player Draft, then it should be extended to include Super League. That would be great for the game globally.

2020-05-30T03:55:56+00:00

Red and Blue

Guest


just a thought, maybe it is about time they dump "diving to the ground" as a surrender tackle and apply the law book and deem it for it is .. a voluntary tackle and be penalised accordingly?

2020-05-29T11:17:08+00:00

Bunny Reilly

Guest


Ist Parra try. I see some of you blokes attribute the try to the six again rule and fatigue. The game had been going 3 minutes and Parra was on 8 tackles. That's fatigue?

2020-05-29T08:38:52+00:00

TIGER

Roar Rookie


Don't know what game you were watching.

2020-05-29T08:13:00+00:00

Adam Bagnall

Roar Guru


Isn't there a cloud you should be yelling at you angry old man?

2020-05-29T08:11:39+00:00

Adam Bagnall

Roar Guru


Really enjoyable game and I thought Broncos had some good moments defensively despite the scoreline. Love the new 6 again rule and one ref the game flowed much better

2020-05-29T07:46:26+00:00

Joe

Roar Rookie


Yep, agreed...except the Raiders 2016 didn't make the GF. The Raiders 2019 which did make the GF I think are more of a belief team but came up against a better belief team in the chooks.

2020-05-29T07:26:32+00:00

Dwanye

Roar Rookie


Lol, I thought that’s what you were also hassling.

2020-05-29T07:25:07+00:00

The Late News

Roar Rookie


cool. enjoy your fix!

2020-05-29T07:21:23+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


That'll be interesting to watch. He usually does meander behind the ruck playing his chess game. Benji will have no where to hide. On the other hand, we'll see if it's such a big advantage to Cook as 100 articles have professed.

2020-05-29T05:39:24+00:00

Cadfael

Roar Guru


Great to see the one ref back. Big tick. Refereeing more via the rule book than before though still too many tackles around the neck and head. Referee was one of the reasons for the success of the game and he needs to be applauded, Six again looked good but I would like to see a few more games first.

AUTHOR

2020-05-29T05:02:11+00:00

Scott Pryde

Expert


Haha, I'm a 98 baby. So I just made it in the 90s. But I certainly don't remember any of it! Pretty hard to mess up my isolation afro though. I wish you the best of luck!

2020-05-29T04:54:51+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


Yeah...honestly, after watching last night, the days of him playing 80 minutes are done. The new rules and speed will be savage to those of his age. And without the ability to hold play for 30 minutes while he hosts a roundtable with the refs, he may not last the season. Benji Marshall is also going to suffer from this.

2020-05-29T04:39:47+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


Herbie plays wing as well in the QRL

2020-05-29T04:38:27+00:00

Red Rob

Roar Rookie


Yeah I have a good feeling about the 1 ref change. Having 2 decision-makers of equal authority can cause them to be indecisive, drop focus and be collectively inconsistent. One head chef, one judge, one lead singer ... it seems to work best in other areas.

2020-05-29T04:29:24+00:00

Red Rob

Roar Rookie


I wasn’t around in the 90s Geez, don't say thing like that around old blokes please, young Scotty. (And I'm calling you "young Scotty" from now on, and messing up your hair, too. Now go get me a beer and don't let your mother see you do it.) So you were born when playing vinyl LPs came back in!

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar