Experts Roar: Who'll be NRL bottom four - Tigers, Warriors, Dogs, Cowboys, Raiders, Broncos?

By The Roar / Editor

We’ve had two rounds in the NRL and already some trends are emerging about which teams look set for finals contention and which ones are heading the other way.

Four teams are yet to win a game – South Sydney, Manly, the Warriors and Wests Tigers – and while there’s plenty of optimism for the Rabbitohs and Sea Eagles to break out of their funk, the other two look like they’re in for a long winter ahead.

But it’s only early days – the Tigers are hoping the return of Adam Doueihi will spark a mid-season resurgence while the Warriors also have a key playmaker in Shaun Johnson on the injured list who should make a difference when he returns.

Last year’s wooden spooners Canterbury have shown improvement by splitting their first two games of 2022 while North Queensland, who finished in second-last spot last season, have done likewise.

As always, let us know in the comments who you think will be the cellar dwellers for this season.

Experts Roar: Who will be bottom four teams?

Michael Hagan (premiership-winning player and coach)

Raiders, Dragons, Warriors, Tigers: It’s been a tough start for these teams and they’ve got a few players unavailable which will make it tough for them as the season goes on.

Paul Suttor (Roar expert)

Warriors, Tigers, Broncos, Bulldogs: All signs point to the Wests Tigers collecting the wooden spoon but the Warriors are a Reece Walsh injury away from giving them a run for their money. Brisbane and Canterbury are better than last season but the Dogs still lack an on-field organiser and discipline while the Broncos are uber reliant on Adam Reynolds’ ageing frame.

(Photo by Mark Metcalfe/Getty Images)

Mike Meehall Wood (Roar expert)

Bulldogs, Cowboys, Warriors, Tigers: The Dogs will be better than 2021, probably by quite a lot, but will still be a few years off actually being good. They’ll finish with around eight wins, which is big improvement on their three last time out.

The Cowboys are going to struggle because they struggle to win outside of Townsville and are very dependent on certain players being fit, especially Jason Taumalolo. 

The Warriors are set to struggle a lot based on their first two rounds. If they get everyone on deck that might be different but a third year on the road might well end up being too much for them. The outside backs lack a lot and all the Walshs and Johnsons in the world can’t save that.

The Tigers are the worst team in the league on the evidence of two weeks and will probably be the first to sack their coach too. If they do that they might improve in the long run but likely not enough to lift themselves off the bottom of the table.

Joe Frost (Roar expert)

Tigers, Warriors, Bulldogs, Raiders: The Raiders are my surprise packets to drop to the bottom four but they’re missing key personnel and have been on the slide for a few years now. The Warriors will continue to struggle under a coach who hasn’t had success in seemingly ever, while the Bulldogs are better than last year but remember how bad they were in 2021?

As for the spoon, it’s the Tigers’ turn to take home the dreaded timberware – they were dreadful against the Knights and ‘brave’ against a seriously undermanned Storm but still couldn’t win. It’ll be a pattern.

Mary Konstantopoulos (Ladies Who League)

Cowboys, Tigers, Warriors, Bulldogs: After the first two rounds, the Tigers look like the team most likely to get the wooden spoon. The Bulldogs and Cowboys do seem to have shown signs of improvement, but the Tigers look disinterested already and it’s only Round 2.

On paper, the Warriors have a good squad, but it’s remains to be seen whether sure their coach has the ability to take advantage of the talent in the team. 

Josh Curran. (Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)

AJ Mithen (Roar expert)

Raiders, Warriors, Cowboys, Tigers: A caveat: 6-14 will be pretty tight so finishing bottom four won’t necessarily mean a season is a true shocker. In saying that – Canberra are in a world of hurt with severe ‘spinal’ injuries and are now stuck with journeymen and kids in key positions for the rest of the season. They need on-field leaders to really stand up.

New Zealand, as usual, are battling but lacking polish. They need to be able to play at home. North Queensland haven’t evolved as much as expected under Todd Payten. Wests Tigers have fallen on their face and can’t get up. Their whole set-up needs a true knockdown/rebuild, which isn’t easy to do in the NRL.

Stuart Thomas (Roar expert)

Tigers, Warriors, Cowboys, Bulldogs: The worst kept secret in rugby league is the fact that the Tigers will finish last on the NRL ladder in 2022. Wests simply do not have the talent pool to do much better, are likely to have a sacked coach at some point in the season and the inept performance against the Knights on Sunday was just one of plenty more to come.

The Warriors continue to be a side of which many remain unconvinced. Brave against the Titans on the weekend, the long-term forecast appears to be another season of inconsistency where their best is pretty good and their worst befitting of a bottom-four side.

While the Cowboys look likely to develop, there does appear to still be a long way to go when it comes to potentially cracking the top eight. The Raiders’ scalp was a good one to claim, yet a tough stretch of matches over the next month or so could well see them found out and back mired in the battling pack.

Everybody seems convinced that the Bulldogs will be better in 2022, however there has been little evidence of that so far. Sure, the win against the Cowboys in Round 1 was gutsy, yet it was also littered with all the clunky attack of recent seasons. Until a reliable solution at halfback takes over the helm, Canterbury may well settle in 13th come season’s end.

(Photo by Albert Perez/Getty Images)

Danielle Smith (Roar expert)

Cowboys, Bulldogs, Tigers, Warriors: The coaches of these four teams are under the most pressure. Underperforming players, inconsistent efforts, new combinations that will take a while to click and outside noise that will eventually have an impact.  Warriors look like they’ll be taking home the spoon. Another year away from home will take its toll. 

Tim Gore (Roar expert)

Canterbury – 13th: They will surely improve on previous seasons, but a rebuild takes time.
Cowboys – 14th: They’ll pull off some wins against higher teams but they still have limited cattle.
Warriors – 15th: They’ll put up some good fights, and even win some, but another year on the road is just too much to overcome.
Tigers – 16th: Gee, it is really hard to see where the wins are coming from. There’ll be one or two but the spoon looks to be theirs in 2022.

var request = new XMLHttpRequest();

request.open('POST', '/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php', true); request.setRequestHeader('Content-Type', 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded;'); request.onload = function () { if (this.status >= 200 && this.status

The Crowd Says:

2022-03-27T03:50:10+00:00

3 R M

Roar Rookie


All done with the so called limited cattle of 7 test or origin players and 2 of the most rated young 2nd rowers in the comp while they field 3 of our juniors we didn't sign.

2022-03-25T03:05:43+00:00

Rob

Guest


LOL,How are the experts tips going at present? At the start of 2020 the Raiders were considered a big chance of going one better, Queensland held the Origin trophy and the Panthers were coming off 11th with Maloney leaving. The rule changed and the random 6 again suddenly resulted in scores blowing out. I still question the use of the 6 again and how some teams suffered while others thrived? Take last years finalists and all the other finals teams, they all seemed to be getting awarded more penalties consistently. Other clubs particularly the one at the bottom of the ladder were receiving fewer? Tigers, Broncos and Warriors all finished in the top 5 for offloads, Bulldogs had the best completions and top 3 in kick metres, whilst Roosters and Manly had poor completions and ranked highly on the errors. Turbo was DM and made the most errors of any fullback? The Titans and Storm were leaders in tackle busts. A few things stood out. Like the Cowboys had the least ball movement with the Raiders, Bulldogs and Broncos. The Rabbits, Penrith and Manly received the most penalties with Penrith and Manly leading the way in the passes thrown stat. You would probably expect a team coming out of their back field to throw fewer passes, just like you would expect teams in the attacking end to throw more? The point I’m making is the tweaking of the 6 again so it’s a penalty for everyone not the select few? has already evened up the contest. Since 6 again the Raiders, Dogs, Cowboys and Broncos weren’t getting down the field as easily as the top 4 teams. Maybe those teams will score more tries when they are comfortable to move the football. The Cowboys had the worse kicking stats but when Clifford in control of the kicking they won 6 from 8 for instance all due to some better field position. The influence of Reynolds game management, Townsend kicking control, Burton’s passing, Raiders field position and Clifford in charge may effect the standings on the ladder especially if they start getting an even share of penalties. Sharks are already benefiting from Haynes kicking and penalties to get in scoring positions.

2022-03-25T02:55:06+00:00

Choppy Zezers

Roar Rookie


Sea Eagles Bulldogs Storm Sea Eagles again

2022-03-24T10:23:14+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


Quite probable. But given their recent record against the Roosters their fans should be more than a little concerned.

2022-03-24T10:02:26+00:00

Duncan Smith

Roar Guru


I'm only joking about Souths, but they might have to build from a 0-4 start.

2022-03-24T08:50:46+00:00

jimmmy

Roar Rookie


I have no idea where the Cows finish this year . In my preseason tips I had them 12th but they certainly looked a class above the Raiders last week Tim.

2022-03-24T08:45:54+00:00

jimmmy

Roar Rookie


And I thought you were a half decent bloke.

2022-03-24T08:40:07+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


Souths won't be dropping out of the top 8 HW. They probably won't be dropping out of the top 4. It's a LONG season. Buckle up!

2022-03-24T08:38:23+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


Souths AND Manly botrom 4? :laughing: Souths at their worst for 70 mins still almost beat your Melbourne Storm Duncan. Perhaps you should throw them into the mix as well?

2022-03-24T08:35:19+00:00

Glory Bound

Roar Rookie


How's the fishing DPS? Any bites yet? I already said, given their start to the season, I don't see Souths turning a corner until round 5 or 6. No need to panic though there are plenty of games ahead and they are only likely to be missing 3 players to Origin this year (Latrell, Murray and Arrow).

2022-03-23T12:15:42+00:00

Brett Allen

Roar Rookie


The Dragons have started the season well in the past. They may not be bottom 4, but I don’t see them getting much higher. Sorry.

2022-03-23T10:39:35+00:00

Adam Bagnall

Roar Guru


Dragons won't be bottom 4. Much better side this year. Probably could have beaten Panthers if it was 13 vs 13 for 80 minutes

2022-03-23T09:50:31+00:00

NSWelshman

Roar Rookie


Lolololol….ok.

2022-03-23T08:49:26+00:00

Nico

Roar Rookie


Paul talks about reliance on Reyno like it was a bad thing. Just how are Souths doing right now without Reyno to rely on?

2022-03-23T08:28:07+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


2 weeks in is a particularly early revision

2022-03-23T07:18:26+00:00

andrew

Roar Rookie


Yeah well, what are the odds of one of the bottom 4 teams picked by the experts winning the premiership. Long odds,but Leicester City's odds of winning the EPL a few years ago at the start of their season must have been astronomical.

2022-03-23T07:12:24+00:00

Brett Allen

Roar Rookie


Stop it, you’re killing me

2022-03-23T07:05:25+00:00

Adam Bagnall

Roar Guru


Absolutely clueless. We pushed the Panthers all the way and were dudded by a couple of bad calls and beat the Warriors the week before. Clearly bound for the bottom 4.

2022-03-23T07:03:16+00:00

Adam Bagnall

Roar Guru


I think we can lock in Tigers and Bulldogs even at this early stage. Tigers are a mess in attack and offer nothing in defence. The Bulldogs haven't really improved at all. The Raiders are really going to struggle with all the pressure on Wighton who isn't a game manager and CNK has limited playmaking skills. The Broncos will improve and probably finish outside the bottom 4.

2022-03-23T06:48:08+00:00

JennyFromPenny

Guest


Bulldogs, Tigers, Raiders, Eels

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar