NRL NEWS: Papenhuyzen out of Origin, Sharks duo cop bans, Annesley ‘no excuse’ for Kikau blunder

By The Roar / Editor

Storm fullback Ryan Papanhuyzen will miss 4-6 weeks after the after suffering knee and hamstring injuries in Sunday’s big win over St George Illawarra.

Melbourne announced on Tuesday that he had a hamstring tear plus a PCL injury.

The in-form fullback, who was possibly closing in on his first NSW jersey as a bench utility for the Origin series opener on June 8, will miss at least a month, according to the Storm statement.

Due to injuries in the Storm’s outside backs, the NRL has granted approval for development squad member Marion Seve to be available for selection in the top grade from this weekend.

Storm centre Reimis Smith is out for 10-12 weeks with a pectoral tear.

Cronulla duo Will Kennedy and Jesse Ramien have been handed suspensions stemming from the Sharks’ 29-10 win over the Warriors on Sunday.

William Kennedy tackles Reece Walsh high. (Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

Both players entered early guilty pleas with the NRL’s match review committee after being involved in grade-three careless high tackles. Kennedy will miss two games after he was sent off for his coathanger tackle on Warriors fullback Reece Walsh in the first half.

Ramien will leave a void in the Sharks’ right centre spot for the next three games for his shoulder charge on Euan Aitken. The centre was handed the extra week’s suspension owing to previous offences.

Their absences will leave Cronulla coach Craig Fitzgibbon with a conundrum ahead of the club’s Magic Round game with Canberra on Sunday.

Halfback Nicho Hynes is likely to take the fullback berth vacated by Kennedy while Connor Tracey is expected to replace Ramien in the centres.

Rugby sevens convert Lachlan Miller is also thought to be in contention after impressing in the NSW Cup.

Annesley: No excuse for Kikau blunder

NRL head of football Graham Annesley has hit back at critics of the bunker getting involved by saying there would be a lot more errors if not for the video review system.

Raiders coach Ricky Stuart last week called for the bunker to be stripped back so it only ruled on contentious try-scoring plays while there were more incidents on the weekend which put the review system in the spotlight.

Jason Taumalolo was denied a try in North Queensland’s win over Newcastle.  Annesley was adamant it could not be proven that defender Lachlan Fitzgibbon initiated contact with decoy runner Jeremiah Nanai, and rejected claims the bunker should stay out of obstruction calls.

“If we don’t get the bunker involved in these decisions the referee will have many more incidents in the game to rule on,” Annesley said. 

“And when you’re on ground level … the odds of you getting it right are quite slim.”

Parramatta were fuming when officials missed Viliame Kikau’s clear knock-on in the play before Penrith’s try on half-time in what turned out to be a 22-20 Eels victory on Friday night.

Replays showed referee Gerard Sutton put the whistle to his mouth, before a sideline official advised him the ball went backwards.

Annesley said the fault lay with both officials.

“If he (the touch judge) was unsure or if he was unsighted, he should have let play go without an opinion,” Annesley said.

“There’s no doubt that was a knock on … It should not have been play-on.”

Cobbo sorry after losing driver’s licence

Brisbane NRL young gun Selwyn Cobbo has lost his driver’s licence for six months after appearing in court on traffic offences.

Cobbo was charged with driving an unregistered and uninsured vehicle while on a suspended licence after an incident in April. The 19-year-old appeared in Nanango court on Monday where he was disqualified from driving for six months and fined $700. No conviction was recorded.

“I know I’ve done the wrong thing and I take full responsibility for that mistake,” Cobbo said. “I’ll learn from this and I will strive to make better choices in the future.”

The drama is the latest off-field incident for the Broncos after Payne Haas and Albert Kelly both received a one-game ban and fines after video circulated of the pair in a fracas at a Sydney hotel.

Broncos chief executive Dave Donaghy, who conceded the club must start walking the walk after the Haas/Kelly incident, said the club would stand by teenager Cobbo.

“Selwyn has acknowledged to the club that he made an error in judgement on this occasion,” Donaghy said. “Selwyn understands he will need to make better decisions in the future, particularly when it comes to complying with road safety.”

Cobbo, who scored a double in Brisbane’s 32-12 win over South Sydney last weekend, is off-contract at the end of next season but is reportedly in talks with the Broncos to sign a new deal at Red Hill and keep rival clubs such as the Dolphins at bay.

Peters lands Hull KR coaching gig

English Super League club Hull Kingston Rovers have appointed Australian Willie Peters as their new head coach for 2023 on a three-year deal.

The 43-year-old will join the Robins after spending six years in the NRL as an assistant coach with Manly Sea Eagles, South Sydney and Newcastle Knights, where he has worked since 2020.

A former Souths and St George Illawarra halfback he played in England for Gateshead Thunder, Wigan and Widnes. 

Peters will succeed Tony Smith, who announced a month ago that he would not be renewing his contract at the end of the season.

Hull KR chief executive Paul Lakin said: “From the first time we spoke to Willie it was clear that he understood the progress we have made under Tony, our philosophy on recruitment, the quality of our squad, the passion of our fanbase and how he could build and develop our team further over the next three years.

“Willie knows Super League well. He’s a fan of the competition and he has six years NRL assistant coaching experience across three clubs with high-quality cultures, who have consistently reached the play-offs.

“He initially worked as a development coach and is clearly passionate about promoting youth at every opportunity, again a key discipline that we believe in as a club.

“Both former coaches and players who have worked with Willie spoke in such high regard of his coaching abilities.

“With Willie’s significant coaching experience, his initial development coaching background and his clear understanding of the Super League game, we believe he is the ideal fit for Hull KR, to progress from the firm foundation stones set in place.

“It is vitally important that we make this announcement now to enable retention and recruitment discussions to happen immediately whilst we remain fully focused on the 2022 season.”

Peters said: “I always had an ambition to go back and coach in the Super League. When the opportunity came up, it just felt right.

“I’ve got so many good memories of when I played in Super League, I’m just grateful for the opportunity and I can’t wait to come back over there.

“I’m joining a team that’s well established and definitely on the rise. I’ve worked with a number of quality coaches and taken a lot away from what their strengths are. But of course, I’m going to do it my way.

“We don’t need to change too much in the way we’ll play our footy. Naturally, I’ll have my spin on things and some principles that I think are important.”

“I’ve just got to build on the foundations that (owner) Neil (Hudgell), Paul, Tony and the staff have set on the back of their hard work. So for me, it’s just about building on the great work people have done so far.”

var request = new XMLHttpRequest();

request.open('POST', '/wp-admin/admin-ajax.php', true); request.setRequestHeader('Content-Type', 'application/x-www-form-urlencoded;'); request.onload = function () { if (this.status >= 200 && this.status

The Crowd Says:

2022-05-11T02:33:37+00:00

E-Meter

Roar Rookie


It's a celebrity sentence from a starstruck magistrate.

2022-05-10T11:37:57+00:00

adam smith

Roar Rookie


Also, Brett Finch has had further charges laid against him in relation to child abuse images on his phone…wow, disgusting…(if proven guilty of course) reported on FoxSports.

2022-05-10T08:38:37+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


And if you catch it before the inside shoulder you've f'ed up as the ball player, you can't keep going to the outside (looking at you Sam Walker) it effectively creates a touch line - don't run over it!

2022-05-10T07:52:57+00:00

JOHN ALLAN

Guest


Good afternoon Tony. What Cobbo & the conga line of NRL miscreants mean is “I’m really remorseful & truly sorry (for getting caught). I will now write 100 lines “I must not be an idiot”.

2022-05-10T06:45:44+00:00

Red Rob

Roar Rookie


Yep, suspended licence means he's already been naughty.

2022-05-10T06:44:29+00:00

Red Rob

Roar Rookie


Has anyone ever heard anything like those words come out of a 17 yo's mouth? Can't imagine he'll be catching the bus to training instead, he's just going to be chauffeured around by some poor sap for 6 months. Hope someone has given him an enormous kick up the backside.

2022-05-10T05:53:42+00:00

Dwanye

Roar Rookie


I need to get that memorised.

2022-05-10T05:44:55+00:00

jimmmy

Roar Rookie


Agreed, there is no excuse for a bunker howler.

2022-05-10T05:41:02+00:00

jimmmy

Roar Rookie


Yeah the one time he should hqve kept his mouth shut!

2022-05-10T05:24:18+00:00

Brendon

Roar Rookie


So Pap isn't allowed to play the Dragons anymore, that's two games, and two major injuries...

2022-05-10T04:48:43+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


Cobbo is bloody lucky he's getting off with an extremely light punishment by the court tbh. $700 fine and a six month ban for driving an unregistered, uninsured vehicle and on a suspended licence? $3000 and 12 months ban is generally more common.

2022-05-10T04:43:46+00:00

Nick

Roar Guru


It's just phenomenal that for 99 times out of a 100 the touchie is almost completely absent from a match, and then on the one time they want to do something, they bottle it.

2022-05-10T04:41:50+00:00

Andrew01

Roar Rookie


Referee’s onfield are going to make mistakes and as long as they learn from them, that is fine with me. But with all the decisions they have to make, and the total concentration they need to have, i can cut them some slack on individual calls. The bunker on the other hand. People sitting around in a room together. No crowd in their ear, no players in their ear, not physically tired or under duress and invariably they are senior, experienced referee’s. Okay there will be the odd call where you could argue, was he on side or not?, did he ground that or not?, but they shouldn’t be making howlers. Bunker howlers, by experienced officials should cost them a week and it should be a reflection on the leadership team when the same guys are making mistakes routinely and they do nothing about it.

2022-05-10T04:28:18+00:00

farkurnell

Roar Rookie


Tony is that not the Streakers Defence

2022-05-10T03:54:56+00:00

no one in particular

Roar Guru


“I know I’ve done the wrong thing and I take full responsibility for that mistake,” Dugan said. “I’ll learn from this and I will strive to make better choices in the future.” “I know I’ve done the wrong thing and I take full responsibility for that mistake,” Ferguson said. “I’ll learn from this and I will strive to make better choices in the future.” “I know I’ve done the wrong thing and I take full responsibility for that mistake,” Carney said. “I’ll learn from this and I will strive to make better choices in the future.” “I know I’ve done the wrong thing and I take full responsibility for that mistake,” Elliot said. “I’ll learn from this and I will strive to make better choices in the future.”

2022-05-10T03:37:16+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


“I know I’ve done the wrong thing and I take full responsibility for that mistake,” Cobbo said. “I’ll learn from this and I will strive to make better choices in the future.” Yawn...

2022-05-10T02:40:03+00:00

Randy

Roar Rookie


basically if you are just going to run into the defensive line without the ball then you need to make sure you don't get in any defenders way. Whether that defender could've, would've, should've made the tackle to save the try doesn't matter, they shouldn't have to contend with another player just standing there in the defence.

2022-05-10T01:59:10+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Yep, the obstruction one is simple. It's typically from a structured play and in the attacking team's control. It's no different to a forward pass that would have still connected if it went backwards. You know the rule, execute it. Rooster give back a fair few tries with that rule, but it's the players fault the ref's.

2022-05-10T01:36:24+00:00

jimmmy

Roar Rookie


OK, Kickau, yes a mistake ! A howler ? Probably , but I cant crucify the Ref for that. He made a mistake. He puts the whistle up then gets a call from his touchie. He thinks the touchie is closer than me . The touchie says it went backwards ( he was unsighted so he’s very silly for putting in his two Bob’s). He puts the whistle away. It’s a split second decision. . Just live with it. You think the bunker should rule on that ? Go straight to the naughty corner and stay there until the seson is over. Nanai. ? Well Mea Culpa! I blew up about that obstruction call . I was wrong. It truly was a 50/ 50 call under the current rules. Nanai runs a good line, inside shoulder. Fitzgibbon originally turns out , then turns in . But he doesn’t step towards Nanai. Does Nanai initiate contact ? Does Fitz make a poor defensive read.? Really it’s as close to 50/50 as you will ever get. Ref ruled no try. You couldn’t overturn that .

2022-05-10T01:22:18+00:00

Kent Dorfman

Roar Rookie


think all of the officials are too sh!tscared to make a decision in case she's a barry crocker so they rely on the bunker to make the right call - and hasn't that worked out well

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar