It’s time for women’s Origin to move to a three-game series … so long as we pay players properly

By Mary Konstantopoulos / Expert

There are a couple of moments that will stay with me long after I forget that the New South Wales Blues beat the Queensland Maroons 20 points to 14 in the 2022 Women’s State of Origin.

The sound of hundreds of boys and girls after the game screaming names like ‘Jess’, ‘Corban’, ‘Ali’ and ‘Millie’, desperate to get a photo or autograph from their favourite women’s players.

Or the vision of Ali Brigginshaw and Chelsea Lenarduzzi, still on the field 40 minutes after Queensland lost, still signing autographs and taking photos graciously, giving away their boots and their scrunchies and socks, walking barefoot on the cold grass of GIO Stadium in Canberra.

Emma Tonegato being in the moment and talking like she was in it too, in her half-time interview with Emma Lawrence from Channel Nine.

The moment of redemption for Kirra Dibb, a woman who has been excluded from representative teams for close to two years.

But after being signed by the Newcastle Knights at the last minute for the 2021 NRLW season and having a stellar season with the North Sydney Bears in the Harvey Norman Women’s Premiership, she fought her way back, bursting through the line on Friday night with a fierce left-foot step to score a try under the posts.

Over the next few days, I’ll continue to bask in these little moments and reflect on just how far the women’s game has come and how much there is to look forward to.

(Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

But after such an incredible fixture, I can’t help but ask why the decision has been made by the Australian Rugby League Commission to make the women’s State of Origin a two-game series next year.

Growth for the women’s game is important and I absolutely want that growth to occur.

But in a shift to a two-game series, there is a very real risk that NSW win one game and Queensland win the other. In that situation, my understanding is that the reigning winner is awarded the series.

So as it stands, NSW only need to win one of the two games next year to be crowned champions again. It seems nonsensical.

In my view, it either stays as one game or we move to a three-game series. There should be no difference between the men’s State of Origin and the women’s.

But there is a difference. And that comes down to money.

The ARLC may have made this decision to grow the women’s game slowly. There is merit in that.

Until the women competing are appropriately compensated for their time, it’s simply not fair to keep asking them to get time off not just to play, but also to participate in camp.

The alternative is continuing to juggle work with elite sport and our athletes constantly feeling under pressure. This is not an appropriate alternative.

But this is the situation that exists now with pay disparity existing between NSW and Queensland and some women struggling financially just to participate in camp.

Maroons squad members are being paid $9000 with those that took the field receiving a $6000 match fee.

For the women in this squad, this has taken a load from their shoulders. It means they no longer have to worry about the juggle while in camp and can focus on what they are there to do: play footy.

This is not the case for the Blues squad members, who will be paid $2800 and those that took the field receive a $6000 match fee.

(Photo by Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

The gap in pay is also reflective of the Queensland players being contracted for a longer period of the year and attending more training sessions in the lead-up to State of Origin camp.

Due to time off work, some of the Blues squad members have taken a financial hit, with it being reported that those earning the match payments are trying to support those that have not.

With a two-game series, that hit becomes even greater and women will likely need more time off if they are to compete at an elite level.

This is compounded by the expansion of the NRLW next year, which will mean players are contracted for almost six months of the year. This is almost double the current state of play.

Growth is great. But it must come with appropriate financial compensation and medical support and the right facilities so that these women can compete an elite level.

Otherwise we are growing unsustainably.

Negotiation of the next collective bargaining agreement will commence in the next couple of months and it will include a historic CBA for the women’s game. This is important because at the moment there isn’t a CBA, which sets out minimum conditions for our female athletes.

Given the recent announcement by the AFL and AFLPA of a new CBA for the AFLW, which will see average salaries increase by 94 per cent across the board, there is precedent.

There is an opportunity here for the NRL and the RLPA to do the same and match the growth in the number of games with a growth in punnet.

It’s time for the women’s State of Origin to move to a three-game series. But let’s make sure we are paying our athletes appropriately for the exceptional display of footy that they treat us to.

The Crowd Says:

2022-06-27T11:56:38+00:00

sheek

Roar Guru


Astro, Read my comments to PNGEWC. My gawd, we're surrounded by sensitive folk around here.

2022-06-27T11:55:36+00:00

sheek

Roar Guru


PNGEWC, My last line was: "I also acknowledge the horse has already bolted." I'm not telling women what they should do, I'm just offering my opinion, which is not the sam thing. Besides, I also wonder WTF privileged, old, white men in the US are doing telling women what they can & can't do with their bodies. Please don't over-complicate my comments.

2022-06-27T01:55:59+00:00

astro

Roar Rookie


I'm assuming you didn't mean this comment to be as offensive as it is, but statements like "clever women knew how to exploit their femininity"...I mean...really? Have you considered that maybe these 'clever' women were just trying to survive in a man's world? That maybe they'd prefer not to have to 'exploit their femininity' in the first place and instead just be accepted as people, capable of doing and behaving as they'd like to, without being judged by men? As for women playing rugby league, and the impact on their bodies, have you seen a women give birth? My wife has given birth to my two kids and let me tell you, she's tougher than any man I've ever met. Women aren't 'delicate flowers' mate...that's just how a male dominated society likes to position them to maintain dominance.

2022-06-26T23:43:19+00:00

PGNEWC

Roar Rookie


Thanks Sheek I'm sure women will take note of what you think women can and cant do with their bodies. By your argument Men shouldn't play Rugby as they might get hit in the groin effecting effecting their reproductive future. Instead focus on what women chose to do. It is their choice.

2022-06-26T09:37:01+00:00

sheek

Roar Guru


This is just my opinion, but I think women should not play either rugby league or rugby union, the hits are far too brutal on their bodies. Even when administered by other women. By all means women should seek equality to men, especially equality of opportunity, but that doesn’t mean a need to mimic men in everything. The female body should be celebrated for being different, not wanting to be similarly bashed by a brutal sport. Before femininity became militant, clever women knew how to exploit their femininity, their physical & emotional difference to men. However, 7s rugby union & rugby league & touch footy are fine sports for women to be involved with. I also acknowledge the horse has already bolted.

2022-06-26T09:09:55+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


“And please explain why women’s rugby league has to “ align themselves with the sport.” They seem quite well aligned with women’s rugby league.” I’d love to, except I didn’t say or infer the part before you quoted me. If you re-read my post…. I never said the women have to align themselves… I’m saying they assist the NRL in the alignment of young girls with the sport. This in turn has a long run benefit, so rather than focus on just the commercial result of the women’s SOO match itself (post I replied to…) when determining value we need to acknowledge that it has longer term benefits to the broader game that should be valued.

2022-06-26T08:46:05+00:00

Leroy14

Roar Rookie


I think ping pong players should get paid as much as tennis players but that’s just not gonna happen. I want equality for all games with paddles and racquets.

2022-06-26T08:29:27+00:00

Working Class Rugger

Roar Guru


1.771m on FTA. But I suspect that doesn’t include regionals. Well, according to Media Week. Link here. Adding in Fox League with 65k apparently it was one of the lowest ratings Origins.

2022-06-26T08:26:18+00:00

PeterCtheThird

Guest


Just like the men’s SOO is, or should be, about junior player development? Or perhaps development of another area that needs serious attention AKA international rugby league. Oh that’s right, the men’s NRL attitude is FOFF. And please explain why women’s rugby league has to “ align themselves with the sport.” They seem quite well aligned with women’s rugby league.

2022-06-26T08:22:13+00:00

PeterCtheThird

Guest


What does this have to do with State of Origin, exactly?

2022-06-26T08:22:13+00:00

TEC

Guest


Cheers? The "non-birthing person" State of Origin hit 3 million. Please never be in charge.

2022-06-26T08:06:55+00:00

Dwanye

Roar Rookie


Hi WCR. What does the make one usually rate?

2022-06-26T07:56:03+00:00

Dutski

Roar Guru


Cheers :thumbup:

2022-06-26T07:27:32+00:00

Working Class Rugger

Guest


A touch over 300k across both FTA and PayTV.

2022-06-26T06:01:03+00:00

Dutski

Roar Guru


I’m an absolute fan so three games and equal pay is fine by me. I’d be interested to see the viewing figures for Friday night as a stand-alone event. That kind of showcase can only boost the profile but also boost returns.

2022-06-26T02:13:51+00:00

Choppy Zezers

Roar Rookie


It'll sort itself out. Just give it time. It's not like they are getting paid in Don't King vouchers and discount offers at The Reject Shop

2022-06-26T02:05:18+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


You also need to factor in that the purpose is, or should be, more about junior female participation and thus long-term alignment with the sport. It's unlikely to ever rate like three games of traditional SOO but could be a 10-15% total audience contribution for male nrl

2022-06-26T02:02:57+00:00

mushi

Roar Guru


Not for a start up, you'd want it on future profits if you're laying the ground work.

2022-06-26T00:53:53+00:00

Steven Harris


Jones. the 5/8 ki kicked .3/11 the Tongan girl converted both of thier tries,good kicks too.

2022-06-26T00:11:51+00:00

E-Meter

Roar Rookie


You’re focusing on kicking - admittedly an important factor in rugby league. I thought it was a really good game. End to end. Big tackles. Who was the Kiwi kicking?

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar