With the NRL regular season kicking off at the end of next week with its fragmented starting round, 17 clubs are putting the finishing touches on their summer training and trialling, dreaming of lifting the premiership trophy.
Realistically, only around half of the competition has anything greater than a snowball’s chance of being the premiers for 2024.
While the remaining clubs will need a lengthy list of very fortunate events to be the last team standing.
It can happen – the Panthers of two decades ago were 100-1 long shots at the start of that season and the Wests Tigers a couple of years later were also viewed as wooden spoon contenders before they shocked the NRL world by winning it all.
Penrith these days are an insatiable trophy-gobbling juggernaut and Ivan Cleary’s troops will start the new year as the bookies’ favourites to become the first team in nearly six decades to win four straight titles.
Premiership windows don’t last forever. And for some teams, time is running out to convert their current upward trajectory or their ageing roster into a trophy before the cyclical nature of professional sport kicks in and they have to start building towards another title run.
From top to bottom, here is the Premiership Pressure Index for all 17 NRL clubs on which club is under the pump the most when it comes to getting the job done in 2024.
1 Rabbitohs: Time is running out for the ageing key components of this team to go all the way. Cody Walker and Damien Cook are showing signs of age and while Jack Wighton’s arrival is a major boost, he is no spring chicken either at 31.
The Bunnies are trying to hit a sweet spot where Walker and Cook are still performing at an elite level while halfback Lachlan Ilias matures into the dominant chief playmaker role.
Ilias needs to take a massive leap this year in his development with Cook and Walker in the tail end of their careers although the Latrell Mitchell factor is the biggest determinant on whether they’ll be contenders like 2021 or pretenders like last year.
If he stays on the park, Souths have the strikepower to challenge Penrith, Brisbane and anyone else. But if he is again injured or suspended at crucial stages of the season, they’ll struggle to compete at the business end of the year.
Oh and there’s also the not insignificant matter of coach Jason Demetriou needing to deliver after his assistant coaches Sam Burgess and John Morris questioned his authority late last season. They are no longer there so Demetriou needs to prove he has the command of the dressing room and ability to convert a stacked roster into silverware.
(Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)
2 Roosters: like the Bunnies, they’ve got a few old-timers who are on the way to the retirement lounge plus they have got a couple of above-average Joes heading to rugby in messrs Manu and Suaalii.
They are also banking on a young playmaker elevating his game alongside a veteran five-eighth with Sam Walker riding sidesaddle with Luke Keary.
With two trophies in the past six years it’s hardly panic stations at Bondi Junction but when you have a team that, on paper, is a legitimate title threat, you can’t let those seasons go to waste.
3 Broncos: oh so close last year, teams usually go one of two ways when they finish runner-up, rarely remaining static. Brisbane will probably only have another year or two with Adam Reynolds on deck to organise their talented team before a new on-field maestro is needed to orchestrate the Mam-Walsh-Cobbo-Staggs quartet.
4 Eels: with a drought as long as the Parramatta River, the pressure won’t ease until the dam wall bursts. Mixed aquatic metaphors aside, coach Brad Arthur enters the season under the pump after a decade-plus in charge and only the 2022 Grand Final appearance to show for it. Parra fans will hate this comparison but they’re starting to resemble a poor man’s Panthers – a couple of good props, clever halves, a tireless fullback but they’re not the best of the best in their positions.
Storm coach Craig Bellamy and assistant Jason Ryles. (Photo by Bradley Kanaris/Getty Images)
5 Storm: the Craig Bellamy swansong is filling the Melbourne air again. One of these seasons it will turn out to be the final time we hear it. The Storm have defied the near universal trend of professional sport by avoiding cyclical peaks and troughs but that can only last so long especially with a coaching change afoot.
6 Raiders: it has now been 30 years since their last title. No one outside of Green Machine HQ gives them a chance this year but after going so close in 2019 the last few remaining members of that team are dwindling and a slow climb to the top of the ladder over the course of several seasons awaits.
7 Panthers: you’ve got to make the most of a dynasty in the moment so although they’re dining out on three straight premierships, Ivan Cleary needs to manufacture hunger in his troops however possible.
Feasts can morph into famines – Parra have been waiting 37 years since winning four out of six while the Dragons in both their guises have claimed just three trophies since their unprecedented 11-year undisputed reign ended in 1966.
8 Sea Eagles: if you dump a club icon in Des Hasler, you need to get results. Anthony Seibold is in year two of his tenure and with Tom Trbojevic in what should be the prime of his career and Daly Cherry-Evans still an elite halfback, this year could be their best chance for the foreseeable future.
Jason Taumalolo. (Photo by Andy Jackson/Getty Images)
9 Cowboys: No real pressure but improvement is expected in the tropics after a big step back last year. The dial in the intensity meter would be revved up to 11 if they hadn’t broken through on GF night in 2015 in the one of the most dramatic of deciders in history.
10 Sharks: they are also still basking in the afterglow of their breakthrough premiership and like the Cowboys have been there and thereabouts in recent years. But they need to show they can take the next step with their current bunch.
11 Bulldogs: Surely the revolving door has now closed at Canterbury on high-priced recruits lured to the club to turn the fortunes around. At some point the existing coaches and players need to take ownership rather than waiting for yet another messiah to clean up the Dogs’ mess.
They haven’t made the playoffs since 2016, the second-worst finals drought in Cantebury’s proud history and Phil Gould has a history of moving on when he thinks he can make no further headway at a club.
12 Warriors: the goodwill generated in 2023 will quickly fade if the club reverts to type and becomes a hot and cold outfit which varies from world beaters one week to the dregs the following round.
This is their 30th season and there’s still no trophy in the cabinet so there comes a point when the club needs to no longer be satisfied with doing well enough to give the Aussie sides a run for their money and start taking their trophy off them.
13 Knights: The 2001 premiership odyssey is a long time ago and although Kalyn Ponga and Adam O’Brien restored their reputations last season, the Newcastle fans want to see more with the pain of three straight wooden spoons still embedded in their recent memory.
14 Titans: Des Hasler looks like Ted Danson in The Good Place. His first coaching foray at Manly was Cheers (success and critical acclaim), his Bulldogs stint was Becker (better than most people remember) but his trip to the Titans could be the most forgettable role of his career.
15 Tigers: It’s Groundhog Day/Season for fans of this club who are now hoping a sixth coaching regime since the last finals appearance can get them back somewhere near contention.
Pressure has eased on Benji Marshall given the latest round of boardroom bloodshed has lowered expectations even further but he’s got a decent roster at his disposal compared to the past couple of years so being in wooden spoon territory again should not be accepted.
All going well they could rise five or six rungs on the ladder to be close to a 50-50 record – a mediocre feat they’ve achieved once (2018) since their last playoff tilt 13 long winters ago.
16 Dragons: Short-term expectations are so low they’re subterranean but there’s always a weight of history at the club to deliver success. Shane Flanagan has a free swing this year to remove deadwood and sprout a few green shoots before real growth is likely.
17 Dolphins: There is zero expectation of them going all the way. Building on last year’s better-than-expected promising start and paving the way for a smooth coaching transition from Wayne Bennett to Kristian Woolf is pretty much all that matters at their team base at The (also known as Redcliffe).
Dualcode
Roar Rookie
Storm or panthers for me
blacktown leagues
Roar Rookie
Zero pressure on the Panthers, pressure was off when they beat the bunnies everything else a bonus, without a doubt there is expectation, but no pressure.
Duncan Smith
Roar Guru
Pressure on Penrith. If they don't win the comp, their threepeat was obviously a fluke.
Hard Yards
Roar Rookie
Exactly. Also, Des might have a year’s grace with the Titans - or does he ? They have outstanding forwards, pretty tidy backs. But they just never play proper footy. Unless they play Manly when they always put it together. Bloody Titans.
Succhi
Roar Rookie
Yes I’d say Rabbitohs and Sea Eagle coaches are at risk if their teams don’t fire. Both have got full strength teams, made a key player purchase and had disappointing 2023.
Maxtruck
Roar Rookie
Will be interesting to see how clubs spent their cap in 2024 by position, as results come in. Top earners Panthers - 7 Cleary, 1 Edwards , 13 Yeo ? Broncos- 7 Reynolds,8 Hass, 13 Carrigan ? Manly- 7 DCE, 1 Turbo, bench Schuster ? Titans, 1 Brimson, 12 Fafita, 13 Tino Bulldogs, 3 Crighton, 6 Burton, 5 JAC,9 Mahoney, 12 Kiku Souths, 1 Mitchell, 3 Wighton, Murray 13 Knights, all in on 1 ??????????????????
steveng
Roar Rookie
Yes, fully agree Albo, as that is what I meant, as really that Havili and Tatola are big enough but do nothing and put in some very ordinary games with no intensity for my liking. The Bunnies forwards need some real and mean mongrel like SammyB used to give them and they have to have a real go. I think that Wighton will be in the centers when he comes back in R3 until Graham comes back from injury mid-season, but he could be a utility too, as imo Milne is a good choice out wide, he’s done pretty well against the Dragons (which aint no big warp :laughing: ) but anyway, I fully agree with you for the Bunnies imo its this year or never, look at the Bronx and how they have bounced back while the Bunnies are gone backwards.
Panthers
Roar Rookie
I don’t see it that way. Penrith have made 4 GF’s in a row. Won 3 which hasn’t been done for decades. The top side & lower grade sides have been picked apart for the last few years, by other clubs. What the bookies think means nothing. The Panthers have only won 5 GF’s altogether. The coach & players of this era can dine out on the 3 Wins for the rest of their careers ,at Penrith. If they happened to pick up another GF or GF Win in the next few seasons. Just icing on the cake.
Albo
Roar Rookie
Souths need to get their pack dominating the middle otherwise we will end up seeing Murray & Cook knackered from overwork by about round 15. Their front row needs to show some consistency, not just a couple of good games a year. I'd even consider playing Wighton on an edge and maybe swapping with Murray from time to time in the middle third. Get some more impact through the middle, otherwise the Panthers & Broncos packs will have them going backwards. Get some more new blood through as well, like Tallis Duncan. Forget the likes of Host & Chee Kam, they have had plenty of chances for little result.
steveng
Roar Rookie
The Bunnies need an 100% improvement and that is especially in the forwards who didn’t have a go last year, injuries every two weeks and the whole side was a rabble, no wonder their spine broke mid-way and from R12, that was a very disappointing effort and we don't want that again. If the Bunnies are to achieve anything and win the GF, they need a mighty effort and a total reversal as doing things like they have done for the last 10 years and since the GF just aint good enough. Lets see what happens, ill get back to all of you in R12 :laughing: Go You Bunnies :thumbup:
NSWelshman
Roar Rookie
Lolololol ok !
mushi
Roar Guru
Bit harsh... It has 97% on rotten tomatoes, won multiple awards. To put Becker above it is unfortunately on brand
Andrew01
Roar Rookie
Obviously there will be pressure on various coaches to get results but in terms of pressure to win the whole thing,; While every team gives themself a chance and realistically, as you say, there are only a handful that really do have a chance, in terms of actual pressure to win, I think there are only two clubs: Pressure to win: Penrith and Brisbane Pressure to make the GF and then anything is possible: Souths, Roosters, Eels, Storm Pressure to make the 4 and then anything is possible: above plus Newcastle, maybe the Warriors and Cowboys Pressure to make the 8 and then hope for the best: The rest. Of course if say a Roosters win 16 of 18 to start the year, then of course the pressure becomes win the comp or fail.
BigGordon
Roar Rookie
What's interesting is to compare this list, which seems pretty right, with the odds the bookies are suggesting. I think it gives a good idea about the genuine chances for sides, hence the levels of disappointment team supporters are likely to feel. The Bunnies for example are clearly expected to do well and at $9.50 are among the better chances to actually win it. Spare a thought for Raiders; lots of expectation they'll win it but no chance at 61 bucks. Ditto for Manly, Cronulla and the Eels
Arcturus
Roar Rookie
Bit harsh on Ted Danson. I thought he was excellent in The Good Place, in fact the whole cast was pretty stellar. Which got me looking at the Titans assistant coaches Lenihan, Monaghan and Brett White and which in turn had me lowering my expectations a bit. Agree pretty much on all the rest.