Which Maroons players earned a shot at 2020 Origin redemption?

By Adz Sportz / Roar Guru

The 2020 State of Origin series might be ten months away, and there are plenty of variables when it comes to how Queensland may line-up for Game 1, but at the conclusion of their second straight Origin series defeat, selections based on loyalty should no longer be a factor.

Let’s look at a brief overview of each players series performance and whether they should be considered for Game 1 next year.

Daly Cherry-Evans (Captain)
He gave 110 per cent all series and fans should be proud of his effort. But there were a number of areas which showed that Cherry-Evans isn’t on the same level as his halves predecessors, Johnathan Thurston and Cooper Cronk.

He lacked creativity with only one try assist for the series. His kicking game was solid for the most part, but there were too many ineffective kicks and fifth tackle options. Can’t fault his leadership though, he’s an excellent captain.

Being appointed captain virtually guarantees his selection for Game 1 next year, but it remains to be seen if he is genuinely the best halfback option for Queensland.

Ben Hunt
Probably Queensland’s best available option for hooker and did an admirable job. He made more tackles than anyone else in the series with 137. Missed 17 but you could excuse that figure for a little bloke defending in the middle-third in Origin.

A try assist, only one error, solid kicking game out of dummy-half including a 40/20, the only criticism would be that he didn’t run enough, therefore wasn’t as influential as Queensland would have liked.

Hunt will face challenges for his spot from Jake Friend and rising star Reed Mahoney, it may come down to who’s in the best form prior to Game 1 next year.

Ben Hunt of the Maroons sits on the pitch as NSW Blues players celebrate winning Game 2. (AAP Image/David Moir)

Cameron Munster
A genuine footballer who threatened every time he touched the ball in games one and three. His Game 2 performance however, like many of his teammates, was a game he’d rather forget.

A few defensive lapses throughout the series but 17 tackle busts, two line-breaks and an excellent kicking game, he was easily one of Queensland’s best. A certain selection for Game 1 next year.

Christian Welch
Made his Origin debut off the bench in Game 3, making 64 metres, an offload and 17 tackles.

He deserves more opportunities at Origin level and should be picked on the bench for Game 1 next year.

Corey Oates
Another strong series for Queensland’s left winger. Only one try but wasn’t given much space and opportunities from his playmakers.

Averaged 153 metres across the series including some powerful kick returns and always safe at the back. Did his state proud though and is a certain selection for Game 1 next year.

Corey Norman
Making his debut in Game 3, it was a game of two-halves for Norman. The first half saw him heavily involved, a try-assist with a neat grubber for Felise Kaufusi to score the opening try, a solid kicking and some nice runs.

His second half was not as impressive, kicking the ball out on the full and a few costly missed tackles. Will likely need to be in excellent form leading into Game 1 next year in order for him to retain his spot in the team.

Dane Gagai
man of the match in Game 1 with two tries to continue his unbelievable form at Origin level.

However, he didn’t have the same influence in games two and three, not to say he played poorly though. Averaged 142 run metres including strong kick returns and backing up the forwards with strong ball carries. A certain selection for Game 1 next year.

David Fifita
The 19-year-old firebrand impressed on debut in Game 1, running for 82 metres, two tackle breaks, three offloads and 12 tackles coming off the bench. Failed to have the same impact in games two and three though, running for just 46 metres and 20 metres, and missed tackles in the decider which proved costly.

Queensland should persist with him off the bench, as he’ll only get better with experience.

Dylan Napa
Napa wasn’t in great for before he was selected in Game 1, and although he made 90 metres from his 29-minute stint, he missed seven tackles. A poor performance in Game 2 where he only ran for 27 metres and missed two tackles, saw him dropped for the decider.

An enforcer at club level but doesn’t bring the same intensity to Origin. He’ll need to be in irresistible form to be considered for Game 1 next year, otherwise Queensland should look to other options.

Ethan Lowe
From being unwanted at the Cowboys and languishing in reserve grade, to an Origin player. Lowe was a late inclusion after Matt Gillette went down injured and was unbelievable in his debut in the decider.

He had 90 run metres, 52 tackles, a charge down which resulted in a try a few plays after and was handed goal kicking responsibilities, meaning he needed to slot a clutch conversion to level scores in the final minutes and he nailed it.

If he’s in reasonable form leading into Game 1 next year, he should retain his spot in the team.

Felise Kaufusi
Another reliable series from Queensland’s ever reliable edge back rower. Averaged 100 metres, ran good lines and made 72 tackles. Scored the opening try of the decider.

He was occasionally ill-disciplined though, giving away crucial penalties and a couple of costly errors, but overall his effort can’t be understated. A certain selection for Game 1 next year.

Jai Arrow
Missed games two and three due to injury. Made 104 metres including four tackle busts in his Game 1 appearance. A workhorse who is a certain selection for Game 1 next year and has a long Origin career ahead of him.

Jarrod Wallace
In the month leading up to Game 2, Wallace was averaging over 200 run metres for the Titans so his selection was definitely warranted. Unfortunately, he again was unable to bring his club form to Origin and an ill-disciplined performance has added to his underwhelming Origin resume, which should see him overlooked for Game 1 next year, regardless of his club form.

Joe Ofahengaue
Played games one and three, missed Game 2 due to injury. Ofahengaue was solid, running for 99 metres and 90 metres in his two games. Needs to tighten up with his defence and play with more intensity. He should be selected for Game 1 next year, with a view that he’ll be a long-term Origin player.

Josh McGuire
Although his run metres were well down compared to what he’s produced for the Cowboys this season, he was a brick wall in defence all series against a highly energised and enthusiastic New South Wales forward pack, making 127 tackles and amazingly only missed one tackle in Game 2 when the Blues were running riot.

A certain selection for Game 1 next year.

Josh McGuire of the Maroons (Photo by Ryan Pierse/Getty Images)

Josh Papalii
Averaged 100 run metres for the series including a total of seven tackle busts and a try. But he, like many of his teammates, had a regrettable Game 2, registering only 69 run metres for a staring prop.

Now an experienced campaigner at Origin level, he was required to become a forward leader in a team with many new faces and did a good job. A certain selection for Game 1 next year.

Kalyn Ponga
Admitted that it took time to get use to the speed and intensity of Origin in the first half of Game 1, the young superstar was arguably the difference in the second half, laying on two try assists and was a threat right across the park.

He had little effect in Game 2, but he was playing behind a badly beaten forward pack and misfiring halves. Certain selection for Game 1 next year and still viewed as Queensland’s fullback for the next 10 years.

Matt Gillette
Ruled out of Game 3 with a groin injury. Hasn’t been the same since returning from his fractured neck and was well below his best leading into the series. Selected purely on loyalty which is understandable.

He made 86 tackles but missed 10 and lacked potency in attack. Averaging only 45 run metres, one tackle break and zero off-loads, he might be under pressure to keep his spot for Game 1 next year, after the stellar performance from his replacement, Ethan Lowe.

Michael Morgan
Played out of position at left centre for the first two games, then used from the bench in Game 3. Morgan was mismanaged and wasted this series. His 18 try assists for the Cowboys wasn’t enough to secure the five-eighth jersey for the decider which raised a few eyebrows considering Queensland had struggled to create try scoring opportunities.

Probably a certain selection for Game 1 next year but needs to be better utilised.

Moses Mbye
Selected purely because of his utility value but was out of form for the Tigers prior to the series opener.

Played only 20 minutes total over the first two games with no effect, before being promoted to the starting side at left centre, where he had little influence. Queensland should be looking to someone with a little more ‘X-factor’ as utility. Anthony Milford or AJ Brimson come to mind.

Tim Glasby
Reliable, but lacked aggression and punch off the bench, therefore had little influence. Someone like Korbin Sims, a player with a bit of mongrel might be better suited.

Will Chambers
It might be fair to say the 31-year-old is now past his prime. He was dominated by Latrell Mitchell in the 2018 series, and although he got one back on his rival with a solid performance in Game 1, he again struggled in games two and three.

Most missed tackles and most errors for the series. Once a certain selection, it might be time for Queensland to look at the likes of Kyle Feldt for 2020.

The Crowd Says:

2019-07-15T03:21:39+00:00

Zavjalova

Roar Rookie


I'm sure you're loving it. Nsw bashed poor ol pearce for years and years and years. Dce's only try assist all series bro, anyone would have put papallii in that gap. Its not like dce drew defenders lol you should learn rugby league champ!

2019-07-13T03:34:00+00:00

Larry1950

Guest


Qld is just going through the normal drought where quality centres are scarce & the impact backrowers are either too old (Cooper), too young (Fifita) or haven't come on (Hess) as expected. They all look good with Smith, Cronk & Thurston putting them in space but so did guys like Guerra. Excluding Hodges in recent years, Qld has manufactured centres using Inglis & Morgan so there's an opportunity there for a young prospect. At the moment there's only O'neill, Opacic, Brenko Lee & Brendan Elliott from manly guy who also covers fullback in top grade. Remember that Chambers busted NSW pretty often in game 1 without reward. I reckon what everyone has overlooked is the penetration & finish Qld lost when Holmes left the game, Oates is good but there's no substitute for sheer pace. I think Gagai was a bit down on form in game 3 after the accidental knees in the back early on, it impacted his speed & effectiveness. That said, Qld probably go close to winning the series if DCE just played for extra time & a field goal or more likely, if Cam Smith came back for that decider because his middle defence & game management probably negates Cook to a large extent. It was 20-20 at the 79th minute even with the blues seeming dominance for most of the game so the talk of dynasties is a bit premature. Hunt played ok but you need a quality dummy half nowadays to win tight games & Cook had the clear edge over the full series. I like Morgan's big body at 5/8 & he hasn't been fully fit during this entire season.

2019-07-13T02:43:26+00:00

Larry1950

Guest


All very well writing off Chambers & Mbye but a check of the eligible players who are centres doesn't give confidence of a stand out. Maybe Munster has to do an Inglis for a year with Ponga at fullback & Morgan in his rightful role at 5/8. I'd go left field for hooker with Granville or Friend as a starter & AJ Brimson as the bench back up.

2019-07-12T21:34:14+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


Adam I think that QLD fielded the best side they had available. Let’s face it they tried hard with what they had but as happens in most matches at this level , the team with the best cattle generally wins these series . We saw QLD had the cattle for the previous decade , currently NSW has the better group and may have it for a few more years .

2019-07-12T10:00:07+00:00

Farkurnell

Guest


Gee Ethan there goes that Maroons pick n stick policy.If you get Benny back forget Munster at FB , Darius will get that job.I was quite confident DCE would be blamed if you lost.Just remember who set up the Papali try to get you to 20-20,but go ahead an sack him ,we're loving this down south.DCE is no Cronk or JT but neither is Pearce and who threw the cut out pass that lead to the winning try.If I was QLD I wouldn't be sacking DCE he's one of your best players.

2019-07-12T07:17:21+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


DCE had one try or try assist for the series. The NSW halves had zero tries or assists for the series. Munster had no tries or try assists for the series but was QLD'S best player.

AUTHOR

2019-07-12T06:55:44+00:00

Adz Sportz

Roar Guru


Who replaces him? Left field option... Cooper Cronk?

AUTHOR

2019-07-12T06:54:19+00:00

Adz Sportz

Roar Guru


As I said, Peter, plenty of variables between now and then. I'm basing my piece on who I believe did enough to warrant selection next year, based solely from this series. Sure players can get injured or lose form, they're variables. But if you wish to trash me and my article, well I guess you're entitled to do so, if that's what you feel you need to do. I only write because I love writing and love to add to the discussion about Origin and rugby league. My next piece, I don't know... maybe I'll write about who's a sure thing to win this years premiership.

2019-07-12T05:38:36+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


It's a little bit early to rate anyone a certain selection in almost a years time. Latrel Mitchell was a ''certain' selection a couple of months back. A great Roar Guru responded to me recently when I was backing the NSW centres as good picks that neither will make the Australian team and he didn't lack any support. Apparently Mal will pick Chambers in the team I was told. They seem to have missed that he's been on the down hill wobble for a fair while now but I'd say Mal has noticed.

2019-07-12T05:31:35+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


hi Adam, I'm a tad confused about the outcomes. I realize this is a piece about the Maroon players likely to be named in next years SOO game 1 squad, but can these guys be looked at in isolation or should they be compared with their counterparts? What I'm getting at is, this Blues squad will probably change maybe one or two players in the coming 12 months, because over the course of this series, they were mostly on top or equal with their opposites. The NSW team will effectively go to a "pick & stick" squad, because they know they can only get better, the more they play with each other, which means the gap between where the two teams are now, will only widen in the future. I don't know how many more cattle Qld has in the shed, but if they keep trotting out these guys, without a real injection of quality, the Blues just might create a little dynasty of their own.

2019-07-12T05:29:59+00:00

Mushi

Roar Guru


The issue is who comes in. Looking at DCE for example: He's not cronk or Thurston? Wow that is a piece of new information, who would have thought the guy that couldn't beat them out for a decade wasn't the same class of player. Is the alternative Cronk or Thurston, no they're retired, so it's a pointless start to the analysis. To paraphrase Rick Pitino "Jonathan Thurston isn't walking through that door..."

2019-07-12T05:29:55+00:00

Dutski

Roar Guru


Napa is a tackle bag in attack and a laterally immobile liability in defence. Since they outlawed the shoulder charge he’s not been an enforcer. Hard to see him back in the maroon.

2019-07-12T05:22:45+00:00

Mushi

Roar Guru


Was he though? Which spine, left side, right side, and middle would you take. Me I'd pick NSW players in each category. Maybe a push on the spine game 1 but outside of that NSW were more talented across the park.

2019-07-12T05:20:46+00:00

Peter

Guest


Hey, I’m so cool you could run a fridge off me, Ethan old mate. No, I just think it’s silly to be writing predictions now for SOO 2020, and that using “redemption” is even sillier. Which is an opinion I am free to express.

2019-07-12T04:46:06+00:00

U

Roar Rookie


Walters has to go

AUTHOR

2019-07-12T04:31:14+00:00

Adz Sportz

Roar Guru


If Bennett took over, he's got a pretty handy replacement in Andrew Demetriou to look after the club while he's away. Bennett is 70 and wants to take on fulltime NRL coaching, England and Qld. Crazy!

2019-07-12T02:42:17+00:00

Zavjalova

Roar Rookie


You are right, but its so bizarre that a 3 game series is a fulltime job. Never used to be before mal meninga.

2019-07-12T01:51:06+00:00

Brian_K

Roar Rookie


He was really only out coached in the second game. NSW bringing in mobile forwards for the wet weather conditions was ace. Walters had the better of G1 and at least half of G3. I was relieved QLD finally had a plan in G3 to stop Cook and Tedesco through the middle, though only managed to pull it off for 40 or so minutes. Some selections were strange but you also have to work with what you've got.

2019-07-12T01:06:31+00:00

Mick Jeffrey

Roar Rookie


Reality is that the game has gone past appointing club coaches for representative teams, and that Walters is probably going to be coach for the Titans next year.

2019-07-12T00:46:04+00:00

Zavjalova

Roar Rookie


Yeah spot on. Selections were very poor I though. Lockyer and miles need to take responsibility there too but I’m sure kev would have got the teams he wanted. Korbin sims was mentioned in the article, he should have been picked, the bloke is a loose cannon which they could have used off the bench. I thought Fifita didn’t do anything all series. Made no real impact. Perhaps too young and didn’t understand that he had to step up for origin

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar