ANALYSIS: 'Fearless' Nicho is ready for Origin after putting battered Bulldogs to the sword - and Burton looks at home in the 7

By Mike Meehall Wood / Editor

They might not have any players, but the Dogs have a lot of heart. They went down fighting to the Sharks, losing 33-20 in the end to a Will Kennedy hat trick and a couple of pieces of Nicho Hynes magic.

For his part, the reigning Dally M Medallist is making an Origin case that Brad Fittler simply cannot ignore. If there’s any intention of picking on form, Nicho is in at 6. You can add another two try assists to the year’s total, plus another perfect night off the tee.

“He’s ready,” declared Sharks coach Craig Fitzgibbon. “I’ve said it a few time that it’s not up to me to select the team but I think he’s ready and can handle it. He’s fearless.

“Sometimes a bit too fearless and I wish he’d rein it in a little bit, but he’s fearless in the way he plays in big moments. Big occasions don’t scare him and it’s Origin. You might not get an opportunity in Origin, but if it comes, he’s going to take it.”

Canterbury are in the middle of one of the worst injury crises in recent memory, with nine first graders out, and were always long shots against a Sharkies team that is finally finding form.

While that was how it played out in the end, with Cronulla coming home strong in the second half after being repeatedly dragged back in by the Dogs.

The big move from Canterbury had been to swap the roles of Kyle Flanagan and Matt Burton, which was a qualified success. They’ll get to go again next week against the Dragons, where their new order might get more space to work in.

“We tried hard but we killed ourselves at times against a team that’s very good,” said Cameron Ciraldo. “You can’t give them opportunities like that. 

“We started both halves poorly and got outcompeted a number of times and were made to pay for it. It’s disappointing in that regard but very happy with how we hang in there. We try hard but we don’t know when to go after a game with and without the ball.”

Cronulla can be as good as anyone

Before today, the Sharks had failed to string two wins together. Their attacking levels have never been questioned and were spectacular at times again, but the defence has been fairly suspect at times. Not today.  

The seam between edge and middle has been a considerable weak point, and while it didn’t look great for Corey Waddell’s second half try, it was notably better.

Teig Wilton in particular sent in some jarring shots and Hynes added to his Origin case with two trysavers. Briton Nikora, too, pulled off a belter on Burton only for Dec Casey to score on the next play.

The goalline D has been a major issue this year, but wasn’t readily tested by a Dogs side that failed to accumulate pressure. Canterbury did manage to put on plenty of attack from range and the desperation was clearly there to meet them. 

They’ll get tougher tests than this, but the early signs are there that the weakest part of Cronulla’s game is picking up. 

If the defence can be better, they’ll have plenty of attack. This was the fourth time in eight rounds that they’ve topped 30 points and they’re currently top of the comp for line breaks.

Nicho has picked up seamlessly from last year, Nikora has matured into one of the best strike backrowers around and Kennedy has exploded in the last month. 

In wins against the Roosters and Eels, they have shown their ability to mix it with the best, and this result was never in doubt.

Last year, the Sharks were able to exploit a lack of Origin players and a soft draw, but were ultimately undone by an ability to defend with the very best, conceding over 30 points in both of their Finals games. 

Defeating a depleted Bulldogs team won’t go too far towards calming doubts that they are just in that tier below the very best, but the way that they tackled against a side that threw plenty at them should give fans confidence.

Canterbury’s halves swap works

The Dogs were their own worst enemy at times, dropping far too much footy to stand a chance of winning. When they did hang onto the ball, there was definitely something brewing.

All the talk about ‘simplifying his game’ in the 6 jumper seemed to have worked, with Flanagan running his first possession and keeping the theme for the rest of the game. 

Burton was installed at first receiver and played both sides of the field, rather than his usual preference for the left edge, which did plenty for his level of involvement in the game. His running was way down, but still had enough in it to create a try and threaten the line.

“I thought we looked dangerous every time Matt ran the ball,” said Ciraldo. “We’re still a work in progress there. The spine’s played eight games together now and they’re still trying to work it out. It was an improvement on the last couple of weeks.

“(Kyle) saw opportunities to run and play what he saw. We just want him to hold up that right edge and feed the ball to guys like Averillo and give him opportunities. I thought at times we did that and got a try off it in the first half.  I thought Kyle simplified his game and I was happy that he’s running the ball.”

Both the Dogs’ first half efforts told that story. They were fairly standard backline moves that resulted in tries for the wingers, but they’re the sort of try that Canterbury don’t readily score.

Some teams – today’s opponents perhaps being the best example – love to hit to their wingers, but that hasn’t always been the case for this edition of the Bulldogs, who used Burton as a creative spark on the inside and spread wide through Reed Mahoney’s long pass. 

With Burton operating on both sides of the field and Flanagan actually running the ball, the Sharks’ defence was forced to compress, creating space on the edges. Jake Averillo and Hayze Perham showed great hands to get their men over, but they were afforded the room by the work inside.

It’s hard to get a read on a side that is missing so many players and were well beaten by a side in red hot form, but there was a green shoot there that Ciraldo could do well to nurture. 

The Will Kennedy Show

If you feel for Dylan Edwards in his perma-exclusion from rep footy, then what of Will Kennedy?

In a normal time, you’d be talking the Sharks fullback up for rep honours, but the Bathurst native would be third in line even for Country Origin – behind Edwards and Latrell Mitchell – and he’s nowhere near a New South Wales jersey.

Kennedy is right up there with the very best in the NRL on this form and was far too good for the Dogs.

His first half triple had all of his best skills: there was a superb support run for the first, a leaping catch for the second that left Perham flat-footed and a classic fullback’s shape run to complete the set. 

The tries are the standout, of course, but there’s all the other stuff too. Kennedy topped the metre count, was flawless under the high ball and added a smart pass for Ronaldo Mulitalo, who robbed his fullback of a try assist by putting his hand into touch under no pressure.

Fitzgibbon focussed on his all round game rather than the tries.

“(I was impressed by) some of the other stuff he did when they were coming back in the game, defusing those bombs and got his defensive line organised,” he said.

“He kept turning up. You probably don’t notice him chasing kicks and making tackles downfield. He’s everywhere.”

The Crowd Says:

2023-04-23T04:37:09+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


I’m talking about the community of people who are passionate about the Bulldosg…

2023-04-23T04:31:59+00:00

RedcliffeFan

Roar Rookie


Mulitalo needs to focus. Too much of the muglair about him in my view. Too much celebration before tries are scored - sometimes they don't turn out to be tries because he stuffs up. He has blown a number of them this year. The one against the Dogs was a shocker - he has plenty of space. As for the rest of it - a pass mark at best. They played a team decimated by injury and couldn't put them away. Let it 20 points too. Most unconvincing. At this stage Penrith, Broncos and Souths have nothing to worry about.

2023-04-23T04:18:14+00:00

Muzz Manyana

Roar Rookie


I get what you're saying. My thinking is finding ways to score points against very good opposition. Luai is a great player but I find his playmaking predictable. Walker has that freakish edge about him. He can create something from nothing! Hynes is such a positive player. His confidence lifts those around him.

2023-04-23T04:12:47+00:00

Panthers

Roar Rookie


I’m happy for them to pick Hynes & Walker. :stoked:

2023-04-23T04:09:03+00:00

Ben Pobjie

Expert


Wouldn’t be surprised if they can put 36 on the Broncos or the Bunnies…and have 38 put on them at the same time.

2023-04-23T04:05:17+00:00

The Wollongong Ocean

Roar Rookie


My only worry is Walker didn’t do great last time for NSW. Not saying he can’t, he’s so talented and he’s in contention, I just can’t see Fittler picking him.

2023-04-23T04:01:43+00:00

Panthers

Roar Rookie


Fandom ? Fandom refers to a community of people who are passionate about something.. That one? :stoked:

2023-04-23T03:32:48+00:00

Muzz Manyana

Roar Rookie


What’s impressive is that they can lift their intensity and arrest the momentum back. They did against the Chooks and successfully upped the tempo last night we they needed to.

2023-04-23T03:20:56+00:00

Muzz Manyana

Roar Rookie


I'd like to see either Hynes or Cody Walker playing alongside Cleary in the Halves. We need more than what Luai has to offer.

2023-04-23T03:07:35+00:00

KenW

Roar Rookie


It seems a big call on that showing. They did what they had to, occasionally looked good doing it, occasionally looked pretty vulnerable too.

2023-04-23T02:09:08+00:00

Randy

Roar Rookie


Sharks are electric when they are on, can score points very quickly but they switch off too often. I really enjoy watching them play though. Hynes and Moylan are true ball playing halves.

2023-04-23T02:04:02+00:00

The Wollongong Ocean

Roar Rookie


Luai is a fine player, but it’s hard to ignore Hynes. Is Luai there just because Cleary is? (Which is a valid argument to select him). End of the day need to pick the best 17 players eligible for NSW and give them a jersey. Good luck Freddy

2023-04-23T01:55:23+00:00

Tetley

Roar Rookie


Poor old doggies. Tried hard but just no troops. Must be disheartening for fans. Sharks just coasted all game.

2023-04-23T01:31:43+00:00

Train Without A Station

Roar Guru


Yeah it’s ludicrous the proposition that they would ask Cleary. They should consider Cleary (ie. maybe Hynes wouldn’t complement Cleary) but what Cleary wants shouldn’t be relevant

2023-04-23T01:09:57+00:00

Renegade

Roar Guru


The sharks cruised through that game and really only lifted intensity whenever the scoreboard got close. And that’s fine, that’s what you want the good sides to be doing at this time of year - controlling games at their pace and getting the win. The sharks were accused of peaking early last season and it was seen as accurate when the finals rolled around. If they now have switch for when to lift in order to ride momentum/absorb pressure. That’s a good thing, but defence still requiring work - Finucane & Toby do a lot to tighten up the middle but I think Oregon Kaufusi & Hamlin-Uele have done well the last two weeks. Good exposure for them that will help later in the year. Agree with TB on Kennedy, the way the sharks style of play is - Will is actually the perfect fullback for it and wouldn’t swap him for any right now, massively underrated in an era of superstar fullbacks. Briton Nikora on the other hand has developed from a 21 year old debutant a few seasons ago into now one of the premier backrowers in the comp. He is hitting hard and running lines like Luke Lewis in 2016.

2023-04-22T23:44:10+00:00

The Barry

Roar Guru


Surprised that you are so big on the Sharks’ defence? This is the first time in five weeks the Dogs have got to 20 x and the first time they’ve looked close to be honest. Also missing key attack players JAC, Kiraz and Kikau There were times the Sharks defence looked almost as brittle as the Bulldogs. Both teams scrambled well and there were some brilliant desperation try savers at either end. Preston strolled through the Sharks right edge and metres weren’t that hard to gain at times Hynes is in sublime form. There was a set in the first half were the Sharks were set right but Hynes went short side three times in a row, including a kick. Each play was probing something he’d seen. It was over in a few seconds and nothing eventuated so it won’t show up on a highlights reel but it was a great example of him playing eyes up and willing to go away from the game plan to ask a few questions of his own Will Kennedy is great. He’s rightly ranked in terms of fullbacks but I’m not sure the Sharks would want to swap him for too many others - even the guys ranked above. Latrell is the most obvious guy. Not sure his style works for the Sharks. You’d probably swap Kennedy for Turbo and maybe Edwards but I’m not sure of too many others Dogs handling was terrible. Gave up hard earned field position way too easily and put ourselves under pressure too frequently. Gave up some papier-mâché weak tries He’s had an impressive start to the year and his career but it looks like Alamoti has a bit of an issue in defence that other teams will be looking to exploit. Nikora got to his outside way too easily. Alamoti’s lateral movement and turning speed were awful. Not sure if he’s carrying a niggle that may have contributed? The Sharks were always comfortable in this game despite the Dogs closing the gap a couple of times. Still a few ‘what ifs’ for the Dogs. What if ball control was a bit better? What if the defence had hung a bit tougher on some of those soft tries - particularly early? It’s tough fandom at the moment but can’t question the heart at the moment. Dogs are getting to the point where it’s obligatory to mention the word ‘brave’

2023-04-22T23:43:53+00:00

Cam

Roar Rookie


The try Will Kennedy scored over the top of Hayze Perham impressed the hell out of me and the skill involved can't be overstated. To have the ball coming over your shoulder is such an unnatural way to catch a bomb and Kennedy's timing and balance is elite-level. There is a reason we will only see a couple of these tries per season.

2023-04-22T23:21:22+00:00

farkurnell

Roar Rookie


They get to play the Ponies in a months time ,so your theory will be tested .They dont play the Bunnies n Panthers till August. - we'll know then whether they are Contenders or Pretenders

2023-04-22T22:56:49+00:00

Duncan Smith

Roar Guru


I'd have Hynes in my team for sure.

2023-04-22T22:25:59+00:00

Dumbo

Roar Rookie


"Cronulla can be as good as anyone" Hmm. No. At least, not on today's showing against the Canterbury Reserves. Two decent consecutive weeks, but that's all. I can't see them matching the Panthers, the Broncs or the Bunnies, on today's show.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar