The joy of Rugby World Cup celebrations only ruined by Eddie Jones’ final act

By Brett McKay / Expert

This week’s column is not going to start the way I wanted it to. A wonderful Rugby World Cup Final on Sunday morning Australian time led to a day of reflection of some fabulous moments through this tournament, and with that, the seeds of a column were taking hold.

Then the latest – and hopefully last – episode in the whole sad saga that Eddie Jones’ second coming as Wallabies coach played out on Sunday night.

When the reports came through on Friday that the Jones camp had informed Rugby Australia they’d be open to a mutual parting of the ways, there was only even going to be one ending. The point had probably been reached already, in fact.

Selfishly, I didn’t want the new to break for a few more days. Because the whole Eddie Jones saga has become so wearying, so draining, so disappointing, that I just didn’t want it to happen on the weekend of the final.

But here we are. Jones has now resigned, and the Wallabies recovery can begin. Who will oversee that recovery is anyone’s guess, and I actually hope RA don’t just default into making another kneejerk reaction to solve the problem caused by the last kneejerk reaction.

But the slate will be wiped clean again and individual ambitions of playing for the Wallabies will be reset.

I’ve mentioned it a few times on the podcast in recent weeks that I feel most sorry for the ten or so players who have been in Jones’ squads and even in his Wallabies teams this year but suddenly found themselves on the outer – some of them only a matter of days before the squad headed for France in August.

Wallabies head coach Eddie Jones speaks to the media during a Rugby Australia press conference at Coogee Oval on October 17, 2023 in Sydney, Australia. (Photo by Mark Metcalfe/Getty Images)

The youngest of that group is Harry Wilson, who is 23. Jed Holloway is the oldest at 30. Most are younger than 26, and all of them are about to enter the prime of their professional rugby careers. All will come back into the 2024 selection frame in they should never have been out of in 2023.

To the very end, Jones maintains he has no regrets and but also maintains a disappointment at his portrayal by the rugby media, and particularly the questioning of his commitment to Australian rugby.

Regrets aside – because which professional coach still wanting future employment would admit to any? – his media portrayal is completely self-inflicted.

All the good work and positive publicity he’d brought Australian rugby’s way in 2023 was brought undone over the course of six lost Tests in July and August. Jones chopped and changed, and switched tack midstream, and never explained anything. Just expected the Australian rugby public to keep swallowing it up.

But the ridiculous press conference banter masked a broader issue of Jones either not knowing how he was going to achieve his stated ambitions, or a realisation that he’s grossly overstating them from the outset.

In the end, he was committed to Australian Rugby until he wasn’t. His denials of the Japanese approaches were flimsy at best, and only invited further investigation. Which in turn produced more reporting, more denials, and more questions from Wallabies fans as to just how committed to Australian Rugby the bloke with the five year contract really was.

Now, at least, we have an answer. Jones says things that needed to be delivered in order for him to do his job weren’t likely to happen, so he didn’t see a lot of point hanging around trying to make a bad situation better.

That is, he was fully committed to Australian Rugby, but not the hard work that might be involved in getting the Wallabies back to where he said he’d get them.

At least the book can now be closed. Au revoir, indeed, Eddie.

And the great shame in all this is that it really has been a seriously enjoyable Rugby World Cup.

Not even the ungodly hours and minimal sleep involved, or all the work that was done in those ungodly hours, and not even the disappointing Australian results will dampen these last two months.

The aftermath of the final and all day Sunday to reflect, and all I could think about was the joy of it all.

Cheslin Kolbe had a roller-coaster last ten minutes of the final, for one very obvious example, and his relief as the celebrations began was instantly visible.

Siya Kolisi and Cheslin Kolbe of South Africa pose with the Webb Ellis Cup during the South Africa Winners Portrait shoot after the Rugby World Cup Final match between New Zealand and South Africa at Stade de France on October 29, 2023 in Paris, France. (Photo by Adam Pretty – World Rugby/World Rugby via Getty Images)

Earlier, after copping a yellow card for a deliberate knock-down in the 73rd minute, he spent much of his time in the naughty chair with his head buried in his jersey, not willing to watch a result get away from his team that he would have felt responsible for. The pain was real, and you couldn’t help but feel for him in that moment.

So when Wayne Barnes blew the final whistle and the Springboks’ historic fourth RWC crown was confirmed, it was actually beautiful to see the sight of skipper Siya Kolisi running not to the far side of the field where the game had just ended, but to Kolbe swamped in his own relief just a few metres from where he’d been seated for the seven incredibly anxious minutes before.

It speaks for Kolisi the leader, certainly. In that moment, he could have gone to any teammate, any coach, any fan even, for the first emotional embrace. Instead, he went to the guy whose relief was flooding all over the Stade de France right there and then. Genuinely heart-warming.

Cue the big moment on stage, the Springboks were there ready for Kolisi to bring the William Webb Ellis trophy to the centre of the stage, and Kolbe had secured a prime position right near where his skipper would stand and hold the fabled trophy aloft.

Kolisi arrived, regripped the Cup, the team built it up, Kolbe is there ready, the little gold trophy is trust into the Paris sky and… the flag Kolbe’s carrying completely covers his head!

In all the trophy money shots, Kolbe will forever be the one in the front row under the colours of the Rainbow Nation.

This tournament has been so good for so many reasons.

The rise and arrival of Fiji has been wonderful and there just can’t be any excuses left for the addition to The Rugby Championship. Simon Raiwalui was a completely deserving inclusion among the four nominees for the World Rugby Coach of the Year ultimately won by Andy Farrell on Sunday night, and what he has been able to achieve with a committed squad and luxury of time has been nothing short of extraordinary.

What they achieved was outstanding, but what come next is crucial. The revamped Pacific Nations Cup starting next year, again comprising the three island nations and Japan, and with Canada and the USA coming in is one thing, but World Rugby needs to be actively scheduling and ensuring Fiji and all these nations get more than quadrennial exposure to the top teams.

We saw Chile, who knocked the USA off to qualify for their first ever Rugby World Cup, more than prove their worthiness in this environment, and outgoing Argentina coach Michael Cheika is bang on when he says the South American countries need the same sort of support. They definitely do.

So does Georgia. So does Romania. So does Namibia. So does Portugal.

Apart from having one of the very best playing strips for the tournament, Portugal provided one of the great moments of the pool stage when they beat Fiji in their final game. The Stadium de Toulouse had its roof lifted when veteran scrumhalf Samuel Marques kicked the match-winning conversion barely a minute from time, and it hopped up and down for hours afterwards once the win was confirmed. It was wonderful.

Simon Raiwalui, Head Coach of Fiji, gives the team instructions during the warm up prior to the Rugby World Cup France 2023 match between Fiji and Portugal at Stadium de Toulouse on October 08, 2023 in Toulouse, France. (Photo by Stu Forster/Getty Images)

The joy of the little things. Like Romania scoring the first try against Ireland and celebrating like they’d won a semi-final. It didn’t matter that they conceded eighty points thereafter; they paid out on the first try-scorer against the best team in the world.

It’s just been a wonderful tournament, and some high-ranking people within Rugby Australia – maybe the highest – need to reflect on what these last two months have given the rugby world. They should start by asking themselves if what they have been doing in recent years is what will get the Wallabies back in amongst this joy of rugby.

And if it’s not, then they should follow the coach out the door.

Australian rugby has been through too much in 2023, and on the biggest weekend of international rugby in the last four years we learn it’s all been a complete and utter waste of time.

It has been exhausting and it has been infuriating, and I for one am looking very much to just not thinking about rugby at all for a few months.

Have a good off-season, Roarers, and all the best for the holiday season. Your support of the columns and especially of the podcast this year has been so, so appreciated.

I’m off to watch some cricket and play some golf. See you in 2024.

The Crowd Says:

2023-11-03T07:30:54+00:00

Handles

Roar Guru


In Marseilles in 2007, in the 63rd minute of an intense and entertaining World Cup Quarter Final, Percy Montgomery kicked a penalty to put South Africa, the eventual winners of the Cup, ahead 23 - 20, over Fiji. I was there, so I know it happened. Fiji beat Wales in the pools to make the finals. They first beat Australia in 1952. They beat France in 2018 and Scotland in 2017. So for the last 6 weeks, it gets under my skin every time people talk about the "rise and arrival" of Fiji. And it got under my skin every time the Stan commentary clown car talked about them like they were a sevens team who weren't used to XV rugby. What is true is that if we continue to ignore them, and exclude them from prime time rugby, they are unlikely to get a lot better. What isn't true is that they have just arrived as a disciplined, fit, entertaining and top class side. They've been that often.

2023-11-02T02:46:15+00:00

HiKa

Roar Rookie


You're correct - it was Jordie B. on the outside.

2023-11-01T03:06:39+00:00

Muzzo

Roar Rookie


TBH RT, I'm so looking forward to that happening. Many say he hasn't the international experience, but as we know, apart from having to start somewhere, he does have the experience of coaching age group AB's & the Baabaa's, in which he did pretty good. No doubt we'll see many that should've been already in the AB's given a go, as wasn't the case previously.

2023-11-01T00:48:04+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


Yes there is Muzzo. Sure the Akld catchment area will supply most, purely due to population but I’m sure that talent will be discovered elsewhere. It will be very interesting to see how the AB’s will develop under Razor. We might need to wait a few months to see what materialises.

2023-11-01T00:44:44+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


I thought Jordan replaced ALB?

2023-10-31T22:57:51+00:00

kingplaymaker

Roar Guru


Sure Brett. I remember an article long ago by Spiro pointing out the almost inexplicable way Jones could be brilliant then terrible then brilliant etc...and it seems it worked out that way. Could be that Japan gets the brilliant Jones again...

2023-10-31T21:09:34+00:00

Geoff Parkes

Expert


Only just got to this now. Points very well made - and no accident the news broke under the cover of the WC final. Not sure how you coped with all the irregular hours you put in, mate. Enjoy the break!

2023-10-31T19:07:25+00:00

Derek Murray

Roar Rookie


Good article, Brett. I'm so tired of Eddie that I almost didn't read it. I'm weary of the Australian rugby pantomime. Cricket it is

2023-10-31T18:50:53+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


Yes Harry Nostradamus Jones saw it all coming. In vivid technicolour. Would he like a Chairman job?

2023-10-31T11:00:33+00:00

Nick Maguire

Roar Rookie


Thanks for everything BMac, hitting some nails on the head even as you sign off for the year. Enjoy your summer

2023-10-31T10:38:28+00:00

Rob Williams

Roar Rookie


Australia beat South Africa twice under Dave Rennie

2023-10-31T09:30:26+00:00

Ankle-tapped Waterboy

Roar Rookie


Brett, you know when we were told, "you don't have to watch"? Thanks for watching, and for writing. Have a great New Year!

2023-10-31T08:58:58+00:00

Mike88

Roar Rookie


At this rate - poor old Brett Hodgson! I'm looking at Phil Waugh's wording now that Eddie has gone and it seems a lot stronger in tone noting the failures at the RWC. I'm further concerned about Waugh's comments on the next coach. So many names again being thrown around and 'considered'. Surely, someone, somewhere has an idea on what we want to be rugby wise. They can bang on about attack all day. If you want to win important tests our defence must be better. So go get the best seems a reasonable strategy to me. Build up from there.

2023-10-31T08:08:34+00:00

Rocky's Rules

Roar Rookie


@Brett I'm not excusing Eddie in any way - we agree he stuffed up big time. I'm saying the Aust media (not you) played a large part in the Eddie disaster. Media did their usual and stupidly portrayed EJ as the returning messiah. They hung on every word he uttered and they (the Media) made Eddie the story – not the WBs, or the RWC. The click bait junkies put Eddie on an absurd pedastal before he arrived. Eddie then made the error of letting them do it, perhaps even encouraging it – it's collective responsibility imo. Then when Eddie stuffed up the media went in for massive overkill – Eddie the disaster, Eddie the traitor – blah blah. All typical Aust media cynical click bait silliness. Like the mythical Jesus, Eddie was never a messiah – he was just a naughty boy who’s being crucified this week. Collective responsibility owned by RA, Eddie, the Aust Media and gullible fans. Those who watch these juvenile games play out from afar saw this disaster coming as soon as Eddie announced his RWC squad. The pattern of events is a very common feature of Australian life now :happy:

2023-10-31T07:49:33+00:00

Rocky's Rules

Roar Rookie


@Brett I'm heavily censored here and can only discuss further with you in private discussions :happy:

2023-10-31T07:18:46+00:00

Muzzo

Roar Rookie


Watching the NPC & a few other games, I do think there is a fair spread of talent coming through RT. I realise Auckland is our biggest city by far, but there is outside talent coming through

2023-10-31T06:34:07+00:00

Rugby Tragic

Roar Rookie


All speculation at the moment but I think a lot more will be known by end of November.

2023-10-31T06:16:03+00:00

Rusty

Roar Guru


With Cotter and dare I say Schmidt in and Razor out… is next season theirs?

2023-10-31T06:14:01+00:00

Ken Catchpole's Other Leg

Roar Guru


The old shifting narrative trick Brett. It works well until someone turns the lights on. And here we are.

2023-10-31T06:09:35+00:00

Rusty

Roar Guru


Having been here for 14 of those 15 and seen the quality and investment you have put into your work - you deserve it mate

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar