'Can see the entire XI changing for the next Test': South Africa skittled for 96-year low, India lose 6-0 on day of disaster

By The Roar / Editor

South Africa closed an extraordinary see-saw first day of the second and final Test against India at Newlands on 3-62 in their second innings, trailing the tourists by 36 runs after 23 wickets and several records fell.

Aiden Markram (36no) and David Bedingham (7no) will hope to bat on and set India a challenging target on the second day, with the hosts’ captain Dean Elgar believing they can still win if they can set India a target of 100 or more after what he called “a really crazy day of Test cricket”.

Seamer Mohammed Siraj took a career-best 6-15 on Wednesday as the visitors skittled their hosts for 55 in the first innings after Elgar elected to bat on a wicket offering plenty of assistance to the bowlers.

The score is the Proteas’ lowest in a Test since 1932, while not since 1889 have they mustered a lower total after winning the toss and batting first.

The horror show comes after Cricket South Africa controversially named a second- or even third-string side to tour New Zealand for two Tests later this year, with only players without a contract in their local SAT20 competition permitted to travel.

After winning the toss, Elgar, filling as captain in his final Test for the injured Temba Bavuma, described the pitch as an “interesting wicket with a few snakes in it”.

India’s seamers were able to get movement off the wicket, but there was also variable bounce at a venue where there have been many low scores.

New Zealand were bowled out for 45 in 2013 and Australia for 47 in 2011.

South Africa’s previous lowest innings total against India in Tests was 79 at Nagpur in 2015. At home it was 130 at the same Newlands venue in 2018.

India were going well at 4-153 in reply before they lost six wickets without scoring a run – the first time that has happened in Tests. 

The list of unwanted milestones did not stop there for the visitors as they had six batters dismissed for ducks – which equalled the previous Test record.

The first two innings lasted 349 balls, the second fewest in 147 years of Test cricket. 

The only shorter instance was 287 deliveries between Australia and England in 1902.

South Africa lost Elgar twice in the day before his retirement, which he announced ahead of the series. He scored four and 12.

Mukesh Kumar (2-25) grabbed Elgar’s wicket in the second innings, and that of Tony de Zorzi (2 & 1), while Jasprit Bumrah removed debutant Tristan Stubbs (3 & 1) as the home side were left teetering at the close.

Yet Elgar feels he could still bow out on a winning note. “I would take 100 (to win) all day,” Elgar told reporters. “When our bowlers click they can rip through any batting line-up and on this wicket that is possible.

“I didn’t know the wicket would play in that way, though. With the naked eye it did not look so bad. 

“I don’t know what to make of this pitch.”

South Africa were pegged back in their first innings by a superb nine-over spell from Siraj, who bowled an impeccable line and length and made full use of the movement off the surface.

The home batters were at times the architects of their own downfall as they made poor decisions around shot selection, especially the lower order, who tried to hit their way out of trouble but only fell deeper into it.

India made a fast start in reply, led by captain Rohit Sharma (39) and Shubman Gill (36), before Virat Kohli struck a fluent 46.

But just as they looked to be taking the game away from their hosts, seamer Lungi Ngidi (3-30) took three wickets in an over as he found extra bounce off the wicket.

Panic set in for the visitors in a dramatic collapse during which they lost six wickets in the space of 11 deliveries, including the needless run out of Siraj.

Kagiso Rabada (3-38) and Nandre Burger (3-42) were also among the wickets for the home side.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

South Africa won the first Test in Pretoria by an innings and 32 runs.

with AAP

The Crowd Says:

2024-01-04T08:48:08+00:00

BigGordon

Roar Rookie


I gather Dean Elgar was in a complete state of shock with the days play. He was saying the pitch looked like a pretty good one and they batted first because they were concerned it would turn quite a bit, late in the game!!

2024-01-04T07:16:44+00:00

Opeo

Roar Rookie


Weirdly South Africa won the toss and chose to bat.

2024-01-04T07:09:36+00:00

Echo Ferret

Roar Rookie


The fact that Starc is a number 10 bat , at number 8 isn’t good. Australia’s tail is long / soft

2024-01-04T06:00:31+00:00

DTM

Roar Rookie


So far, 23 wickets for 270 runs = an average of 11.7 runs per wicket. Of course, South Africa also featured in the Brisbane test last summer when 34 wickets fell for 504 runs (at 14.8 runs per wicket). Remarkable that 6 Indian wickets fell for zero runs in the space of just 11 balls!

2024-01-04T03:21:49+00:00

DaveJ

Roar Rookie


. I lived there for several years and you can’t generalise like that. Lower revenues have affected competence of grounds preparation in SA.

2024-01-04T02:06:55+00:00

Brian Westlake

Roar Rookie


but they've made it an art. Starts in high school games

2024-01-04T02:04:45+00:00

Brian Westlake

Roar Rookie


basically looking at real estate Jacko. The rand vs NZ$ is quite nice. The chats with the bookies would also have been interesting around newlands

2024-01-04T00:23:10+00:00

BigGordon

Roar Rookie


I'm not having go at your comment because this is a stock standard response from curators, but I get the impression the general public's being taken for fools. Pitch preparation is treated as some sort of dark art, known only to a precious few, so when something goes wrong, we're left in the dark about the entire process, simply told the weather was to blame. I've been involved in pitch preparation over the years and can only remember one occasion when challenging weather conditions affected a wicket and that was down to really high winds lifting the covers (lifted and sent over 100 yards away), allowing rain to flood the wicket, the night before the pitch was due to be used. Just once I'd love to know exactly how the pitch was being prepared, what specific issue caused the problem, why it caused the problem and why that problem could not be fixed to the point where we had a reasonably competitive cricket wicket.

2024-01-04T00:17:51+00:00

BigGordon

Roar Rookie


This should read "NOT a problem unique to South Africa"

2024-01-03T23:52:39+00:00

Good Grief

Roar Rookie


Challenging weather for pitch preparation in Sydney.

2024-01-03T23:41:12+00:00

Jacko

Roar Rookie


JN dont blame cricket. Blame the team thats doing this to cricket. Cricket seems to still hold a place in Aus atm. Its in SA they have decided to value T20 more than tests as a association. Cricket SA fast losing its creditability as a serious sporting nation . Yep Im still dirty at SA cricket for their treatment of the test tour to NZ. Were the players distracted? Had other things on their minds perhaps?

2024-01-03T22:36:35+00:00

BigGordon

Roar Rookie


Sounds remarkably like the SCG pitch from a few weeks ago when NSW played Tassie. From memory, at least 20 wickets fell on day 3, when the Blues made about 120 and Tassie were shot out for 68. Somebody obviously got something wrong when preparing this pitch but it's a problem unique to South Africa.

2024-01-03T22:34:58+00:00

jameswm

Roar Guru


I just watched the SA dismissals. Pitch didn't look that bad. Some played on, caught down leg, pulls to mid wicket when not on. And a few snicks too.

2024-01-03T21:39:54+00:00

josh

Roar Rookie


The only thing worse than this Day 1 (which wasn't that bad) is the hand wringing from all the casuals.

2024-01-03T21:03:46+00:00

Linphoma

Roar Rookie


That was carnage last night in Cape Town. It must have resembled a 19th century match with uncovered wickets.

2024-01-03T20:35:42+00:00

Brumby Jack's acquaintance

Roar Rookie


23 wickets on day 1. It'll be all over on day 2

2024-01-03T18:42:53+00:00

Just Nuisance

Roar Rookie


Bookmakers would have made a killing ..Cricket fast losing its creditability as a serious sport .

2024-01-03T13:44:03+00:00

Don Freo

Roar Rookie


It's diaspora in WA adds a lot to our economy.

2024-01-03T12:54:07+00:00

Damo

Roar Rookie


Yeah, test cricket is the least of their problems as a country.

2024-01-03T12:25:32+00:00

The Late News

Roar Rookie


Africa is always Africa. Having lived there many years ago I don't have a lot to add.

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar