The Roar's A-League Men tips and predictions: Round 21

By Stuart Thomas / Expert

After another tricky week of predictions for A-League Men’s football, the competition now enters a five-match round before taking a wee 13-day break before resuming on March 29.

There was little change on the tipping ladder after last week’s action, with Texi Smith faring the best and scoring three from seven across an extended weekend.

Battling Western United open up the round against Melbourne Victory in an interesting and newly created derby, the Jets and Adelaide United seek to keep their finals hopes alive in the Hunter on Friday night and the Phoenix, after losing for the first time in some while, host the white hot Sydney FC on Saturday afternoon in New Zealand.

Daniel Penha of Western United FC team and Thomas Christopher Beadling of Western Sydney Wanderers. (Photo by Luis Veniegra/SOPA Images/LightRocket via Getty Images)

Brisbane Roar cannot afford to lose against Macarthur FC on Saturday night and the round ends when the Glory host an embattled Western Sydney, with all eyes on Marko Rudan and his response to the embarrassment that took place on Tuesday night against Melbourne City.

Good luck with your tips for the round and be sure to enter them in the sheet below to have a say in the competitive voice of the people, as the A-League enters its final seven home and away rounds.

Here is the way the panel sees all the action unfolding across the weekend.

Texi Smith

United, Adelaide, Sydney, Brisbane, Perth

What a difference a couple of weeks makes. Form team Western United at AAMI Park up against neighbours Victory who returned to winning ways themselves last week with a great win in Adelaide.

This Thursday night fixture, at a time of year that shows us exactly why football is played in the summer when stadiums are available, is set to be an all-time classic A-League encounter. Victory start the game off looking like Brazil, devastating wing play and a high tempo has their fans expecting a deluge of goals.

Melbourne Victory’s Zinedine Machach celebrates with Bruno Fornaroli. (Photo by Jonathan DiMaggio/Getty Images)

However, when Bruno Fornaroli pokes wide from two yards and Zinedine Machach shoots straight at Matt Sutton from right in front, the signs are there that it might not be their night. The game continues as a training drill, Victory attack against United defence, but the appearance of Nikita Rukavystya has Victory on high alert and Daniel Penha strolls through to open the scoring midway through the second half. All hands on deck from the home team sees them shut out Victory for an unlikely win and a clean sheet to send Adelaide to the bottom of the table.

Newcastle Jets welcome a wounded animal to McDonald Jones Stadium for Friday night footy, and this really is the same Adelaide United who were flying high earlier in the season. It’s not often that a team loses five games on the bounce in the A-League but today’s visitors are staring at it down the barrel.

Apostolos Stamatelopoulos to smash the opening goal after only five minutes to remind us of his goal scoring pedigree on the eve of the World Cup qualifiers, only for Hiroshi Ibusuki to level, popping up unmarked at the far post to head home.

The battle for last place comes alive when Nestory Irankunda is thrown on with half an hour to play, but it is teammate Zach Clough who steals the points with a dramatic winner to break Newcastle hearts and send the home fans away unhappy.

Adelaide United’s Zach Clough celebrates a goal. (Photo by Sarah Reed/Getty Images)

Wellington on the back of a rare defeat that knocked them off top spot, Sydney FC having done well to contain Brisbane Roar after Jake Grirdwood-Reich’s first-half dismissal. What a prospect in Auckland at the famous Eden Park.

Phoenix will channel their inner Wellingong, playing at home away from home for old time’s sake and in the backyard of their newest rivals and will dominate early as expected, a much-changed Sydney FC going for solidity rather than extravagance.

Luke Brattan and Hayden Matthews perform heroics in front of Andrew Redmayne, while Rhyan Grant keeps old teammate Kosta Barbarouses quiet with some uncompromising defending. Its left to Ben Old to ignite the home fans, hitting the bar and post, before the most unlikely of goals straight after the break, Anthony Caceres chasing down a through ball and ricocheting Alex Paulsen’s clearance into the unguarded net.

Joe Lolley then adds a second as Wellington have their pockets picked on the attack, and there’s no way back for the former league leaders as Sydney FC control the final ten minutes to ease to an unusually comfortable victory.

Brisbane Roar take on Macarthur FC at Ballymore Stadium and must be confident of a win after seeing their opponents well and truly demolished at home to the Mariners last weekend.

Being away from Suncorp will help too. Still somehow sitting in 4th position, the Bulls will be keen to erase last week from the memory, but they will have a tough afternoon, Roar going close to the win at Allianz Stadium last week to remain unbeaten in three and within striking distance of the top six. Almost a six-pointer, Tom Waddingham’s mis-hit shot will be enough to give Roar the lead at the break.

Ulises Davila of Macarthur FC. (Photo by Damian Briggs/Speed Media/Icon Sportswire via Getty Images)

Valere Germain will be at his annoying best in the second half, but his teammates will be on a different wavelength, Daniel De Silva missing from five yards, Lachlan Rose hitting the underside of the bar and Ulises Davila missing a penalty.

That leaves Marco Rojas to wrap things up with a spin and shot in the box to seal the victory in a key result that closes the gap between the two teams to one win.

The weekend concludes on Saturday, and not even in Perth’s favourite night-time slot. Glory looked positive after starting badly last week and deserved their draw against the Jets. Wanderers are playing like a bunch of strangers; full of skill, willing runners, but without cohesion or communication.

Their two healthy defeats last week will have the Rudan-haters frothing, and he will put faith in fading superstar Milos Ninkovic to spark his team into action. Indeed, Lachlan Brook opens the scoring against the run of play, but it’s not long before the busy Stefan Colakovski stabs home an equaliser.

The Wanderers coach looks on ashen-faced once more when Mustafa Amini sets up Adam Taggart for 2-1, and his head is bowed when Daniel Bennie powers past two static defenders to smash home a third late in the game.

Stuart Thomas

Victory, Newcastle, Wellington, Macarthur, Perth

Tipping is supposed to get easier throughout the season, yet that has not been the case in 2023/24. Surely Victory are too good for United this evening? I cannot see any other result playing out. I’ve given up on Adelaide, go the Jets. For some reason, the Reds simply cannot find any momentum and they look set to finish outside of the top six in what will be a disappointing season.

Kosta Barbarouses celebrates a Wellington goal with Tim Payne. (Photo by Matt King/Getty Images)

Wellington should be able to manage Sydney FC at home, especially considering the big crowd and Premier’s Plate at stake, whilst Brisbane and Macarthur looks a lively affair. I promised not to tip Brisbane but they are a decent side. Not as decent as the Bulls though.

The idea of Perth beating Western Sydney after another week of turmoil is an attractive one. The sooner the club as a whole realise that the issues stem from within, the better of the A-League will be.

Andrew Prentice

Victory, Newcastle, Wellington, Macarthur, Perth

Our slightly shortened round kicks off with the “other” Melbourne derby. Western United are still not hosting, but are on a run of form that belies their occupancy of the league cellar.

Victory on the other hand are flying high competition-wise, but form-wise they’re as scratchy as my vinyl copy of ‘Full Boar ’82’ (still a classic compilation). What they do have is Bruno Fornaroli with the scent of goals back in his nostrils, after his double sunk Adelaide last week.

He may be the catalyst Victory need to jump the needle onto a better-sounding track. It’s that and their positions on the ladder that compel me to pick Victory to win this, but Western are definitely on the improve.

Friday night in the Hunter sees two teams that need to jog their memory to recall their last win. At least the Jets have recorded three draws in their last five starts and will be kicking themselves for letting Perth off the canvas at HBF Park.

Rhyan Grant of Sydney FC and Angel Torres of Central Coast Mariners challenge for the ball. (Photo by Mark Kolbe/Getty Images)

It’s hard to understand what has gone so wrong at Adelaide. Remember early in the season when they thumped Melbourne City 6-0 and were playing dream factory football? It seems like a different planet now for Carl Veart and his charges, and this one is one of those hostile worlds the Jupiter 2 used to crash into frequently on “Lost In Space.”

They came close in the Original Rivalry, and Nestory Irankunda would have pleased his future employees at Bayern (but not enough for them not to loan him out to a Belgian club none of us have heard of). Clayton Taylor seems to be back in form after his injury absence. At home, the Jets look likely to add to Adelaide’s list of hostile worlds.

An absolute cracker in prospect on Saturday afternoon, but maybe a shame it’ll be held in Auckland, where the Phoenix do draw a great crowd, but now have a rival to contend with.

Given all they’ve done to hoist themselves into finals contention, Sydney will be desperate not to slip up and allow their chasers a chance to catch up. The Phoenix lost top spot with their defeat to Melbourne City last week, and striker Oskar Zawada was a notable and puzzling absence from the squad. While they’ve maintained their lofty table position without him for the most part, his goalscoring is something the Phoenix need if they are to maintain the cross-Tasman rage.

Sydney played with 10 players for 65 minutes against Brisbane after Jake Girdwood-Reich was red carded, but they still looked likely to win. His suspension will leave a hole in their defence. Wellington might settle for a draw, but a big Eden Park crowd should spur them onto greater things.

Adam Taggart celebrates a goal for Perth Glory. (Photo by James Worsfold/Getty Images)

The Roar were insipid against 10-man Sydney FC and are still all over the shop form-wise. But they are only one win outside the top 6. Their visitors Macarthur were cleaned up by Central Coast last Sunday despite the Mariners midweek AFC Cup commitments.

As a former coach of mine used to say, “they were lucky to get nil.” It was un-Bulls-like for this season and I’m tipping them to bounce back against the Roar. They’ll have to do it without youngster Bernardo Oliveira, whose season has sadly ended due to an Achilles injury. Ulises Davila and Valerie Germain combined can’t surely be kept quiet in consecutive weeks. Macarthur by two.

Where do you start with the Wanderers? I’m not sure many are opening Wonka Bars for a golden ticket inside the doors at Wanderland after the club’s humiliating 7-0 loss to Melbourne City midweek, and it’s hard to see where the improvement will come from.

They face a Perth side who are just about out of touch with the finals places, but might rate themselves an outside hope if they collect three points on Saturday night. The Wanderers did get Marcus Antonsson back from the start on Tuesday night after his late substitute appearance last weekend.

A win would, despite the recent disasters, see the Wanderers back in the top six. They’ll have to keep out a scoring-again Adam Taggart if they’re to cross the Nullarbor with the spoils. And at the moment, that’s a little hard to imagine.

Here’s the latest scores and as always, use the form below to get involved as part of The Crowd and take on The Roar’s expert tipsters.

Matchday 21 Texi Stuart Andrew The Crowd
WUN vs MVC WUN MVC MVC ?
NEW vs ADL ADL NEW NEW ?
WEL vs SYD SYD WEL WEL ?
BRI vs MAC BRI MAC MAC ?
PER vs WSW PER PER PER ?
Last week 3 2 1 2
Total 53 51 53 53


The Crowd Says:

2024-03-16T14:57:09+00:00

Blood Dragon

Roar Rookie


What a load of Rubbish 1. Union does not need Football they have more than enough connections to get what they want Roar games at Ballymore give QRU some extra income, but they don't need them. 2. Kayo Stadium did not get upgraded because of Roar it got upgraded to Shore Up the Vote for the local Federal MP Luke Howarth's and was funded via sport rorts. 3. Football is not a vote winner in QLD Rugby League is. 4. The only strength that Football has when it comes to getting funding is the very strong Grassroots Participation Rates. 5. The only Political Connection in Football in QLD I'm aware of is The CEO of Football QLD Robert Cavallucci was a Minister in the Newman Government, but he is/was (not sure if he is still a LNP Member) a Moderate in the LNP and the Moderates have basically no power in the LNP plus Cavallucci's priority is lining is pockets.

2024-03-16T06:00:15+00:00

Stevo

Roar Rookie


Hahahaha, Costa now gives Nix 2:1 lead against Smurfs FC at 69min !!! So much for all the high pressing from the Sydney mob :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

2024-03-15T13:10:07+00:00

Brainstrust

Roar Rookie


Ibusuki is hopeless, all the interest has been generated by Sydney letting him score that hat trick. Halloran his assists where in that match as well. Why not mention the real issues Tunncliffe is a joke defensively. Newcastle they looked like they were their to do a repeat of Sydney with Ibusuki but he missed. Mauk is a hot head, and puts the refs off side and cant pass any more. I think he also made Newcastle try a lot harder than usual.

2024-03-15T13:01:20+00:00

Brainstrust

Roar Rookie


I was suprised actually how good Carvalho delivery was from the left. He could have had a couple of assists.

2024-03-15T11:16:28+00:00

Hudddo

Roar Rookie


He isn't leaving, Peter prior say it isn't happening, he'll be in the know.

2024-03-15T11:15:25+00:00

Hudddo

Roar Rookie


There is no Nisbet move, it's being denied by members in the know at CCM.

2024-03-15T11:13:04+00:00

Hudddo

Roar Rookie


There travelling 24 hours on a plane in 4 days. They played in ridiculous heat and terential rain. If the Mariners play half of them would be red lining.

2024-03-15T10:44:19+00:00

BennoFootball

Roar Rookie


That’s why I’m NOT going …. Rugby Union uses Football, like Rugby League did at Redcliffe ( Not Because it was Too Far BS ) to extract over $12million to build it’s new stand a few years ago and then use Football so they could get a NRL Team …. + This Moronic Labor State Government even more reasons to NOT promote Football for every other sport …. Time for Football in this City to politically use it’s Strength and Power to tell ALL Governments of any persuasion that WE FOOTBALL Will NOT support you if you don’t Support US in Football. FORZA BRISBANE ROAR FOOTBALL CLUB!!!

2024-03-15T09:14:55+00:00

Brendan

Roar Pro


I do quite like the provided photo for this article. The referee & Glory player are comparing something, I think. :stoked:

2024-03-15T08:57:17+00:00

Brainstrust

Roar Rookie


Newcastle are trying to give away goals, two players let the ball across goal.

2024-03-15T04:20:04+00:00

Tekkers

Roar Rookie


Whose the other A-league team? Do you reckon the chances of him leaving the Mariners are high for Nisbet? imo I don't get why he wouldn't wait until at least after the AFC cup final assuming we win and take the prize money, allowing us to surely offer him a bit more than what he's probably been already offered (probs around 200-250k?) how much is the difference between what the Mariners are wiling to pay and Melbourne city? and or the other interested party.

2024-03-15T04:15:13+00:00

NickA

Roar Rookie


Sport is for everyone, and I've never had a problem with teams wanting to make a point of it for minorities - particularly those who experience systemic discrimination through race, sexual orientation etc. Why is it such a big deal for everyone? If you don't like it - it's probably not for you. If fans decide to walk away for the Club for that reason - it's hypocritical. It's not as if Josh wandered into Aus news rooms and said hey by the way I am the gay footballer & i recently got engaged, can you guys run a story about it?

2024-03-14T23:05:01+00:00

TheSecretScout

Roar Guru


he is one of the 'original' melbourne city academy boys (you know a player that actually came through there system, not one they took from interstate) a move back to city, who will be looking at potentially a brand new midfield would be an option as well

2024-03-14T23:02:48+00:00

TheSecretScout

Roar Guru


if you play to his strengths (which adelaide seldom seem to do) he is an excellent point man & also not on a massive salary (400k+) remember joe lolley is on more thatn 3 times ibusukis wage this season

2024-03-14T23:01:27+00:00

TheSecretScout

Roar Guru


from what im aware trewin has an agreement in principle to join city upon completion of the season (i would've liked him to move to europe as he has all the talent to play overseas) the city move is a backwards step for me. the nisbet move is a lot more complicated because there is another a league club challenging city for him.

2024-03-14T22:13:18+00:00

chris1

Roar Rookie


I like the strip - very Inter Milan'ish. And you are right about the logo. It tends to get lost with the consistent black and blue across shirt and logo.

2024-03-14T22:05:42+00:00

chris1

Roar Rookie


That would be a shame if Mariners lose Nisbet. If he does move to City I hope he doesn't end up on the usual bench rotation they have at City.

2024-03-14T21:53:02+00:00

Tigerinthetank

Roar Rookie


Understand that Nisbet has signed or is close to signing with City for next year and also same with Kai Trewin. SS can you confirm? Also wonder if Delianov comes back to City where he played youth. Not sure if Young will be there agin next year or if they start using Beach. Beach has gone off with the Olyroos but we have'nt seen him this year so not sure if Beach or Delianov is the better keeper.

2024-03-14T10:11:19+00:00

Waz

Roar Rookie


No, you misinterpreted my post. If I wanted to complain about Ballymore I would have said: - the place is a dump - there’s not enough cover from the wind, rain or sun - there’s not enough facilities: toilets or catering (the new stand only has 22 urinals :laughing: ) - there’s not enough gates, lines will stretch far and wide even for a small crowd - the location is poor: infrequent public transport, poor train services, not enough busses - insufficient car parking - Roar playing at Ballymore reduces the likelihood of Perry Park getting upgraded: QRU use it as justification for further investment in their facility not Perry Park - if it rains (and we had weekend rain last week when the forecast was fine) then the hill closes, where does the Den go then? - The Hill is a dangerous place to put active support - there’s insufficient space for away support (won’t be a problem this weekend thankfully). That what I would have said if I were complaining about Ballymore … I wasn’t though, I was complaining about the absurd decision to play a fixture at a ground with no working floodlights, sell tickets to a 4PM ko game, then change the time to 3PM. Incompetent it is.

2024-03-14T09:58:01+00:00

Garry

Roar Rookie


Still a great result for Sydney :stoked:

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar