Big name? Big game? Fine

By Matt Cleary / Expert

Righto, Sammy. Let’s go with it. Let’s make penalties for misdemeanours on the field relative to the weight of a man’s name and profile in the game, and the importance of upcoming fixtures.

Let’s make it that if you’re a big name ahead of a big game, that whatever went on that warranted involvement by the Match Review Panel and judiciary, if it’s on the low end of the naughty scale, you only get fined.

Fine.

It would mean Jared Waerea-Hargreaves would not miss the Roosters’ preliminary final for his trip, and you would not have missed Souths’ match against those Chooks after pulling old mate’s hair.

Let’s go with that. Let’s make the size of a player’s profile and the weight of the game they might miss how we adjudge the severity of penalties in rugby league.

Righto! Go to it! Tonight at ANZ, pull every Manly bastard’s hair. Trip them. Rip off all that relatively minor stuff, confident in the knowledge that you’ll only be fined. Because, Sammy, you are you. And a preliminary final against the Raiders in Canberra for a place in the grand final is a Big Game.

And you won’t miss it. Because you are you. And that’s a Big Game.

(Photo by Will Russell/Getty Images)

Run riot, champion.

For consistency’s sake, of course, Manly’s Big Names – let’s say Martin Taupau and Jake Trbojevic – will be open slather too, of course, to trip and grab and lightly tweak your nostrils, all game.

A little eye massage there, a little ear pull there. All that stuff – what’s it matter? A player shouldn’t be rubbed out for that, Sammy, should they?

No – blokes like yourself and JWH and big Marty, ‘tough guys’ and ‘enforcers’ who the fans love, and hate, and love-hate, the big units who skate close to the line, the nature of your footy means you’re going to be up in front of panels and judiciaries, and all that.

That’s footy, right?

So tonight against Manly – open slather, baby. You’re a big name, next week’s a big game, go for your life.

And then week after that, should you beat the Sea Eagles and make it through to the preliminary against Canberra, it’s open slater then, too. Grab ‘em where it hurts! Tweak and poke, and trip and whack. All that tough stuff. Let ‘em know you’re there.

Because of course, being a big name in a game before the biggest game, a grand final, you should not, of course, be rubbed out.

Fined? Of course. Players, as you said, will pay whatever. Or their clubs will. Or rich benefactors will as horse owners sling a bonus to a jockey.

Does that go on? Would it come under the salary cap?

Don’t answer that.

Regardless, no way known should a Big Name be rubbed out before a grand final for finger bends or nostril stuffs, or anything outside a head-high shot that concusses their best player and rubs him out of the game.

And even then? If you didn’t mean it. I mean, it’s a grand final next week. And you’re a big name. And big names sell the game, as you said.

Look at Billy Slater last year. Preliminary final, took out a winger by screaming across in cover and bracing his shoulder and obliterating old mate into touch.

Saved a try.

Match review panel declared: shoulder charge.

But then, through a legal defence that included wearing a suit, releasing photos of himself on a private jet poring over documents like a crack paralegal – and the kicker, being future Immortal Billy Slater prior to his last ever game, and that game being a blinking grand final – Billy convinced relevant old boys that it wasn’t a shoulder charge and played in said grand final.

And why all fullbacks aren’t now screaming across in cover to take out wingers with shoulders bunched for contact in shoulder-charge fashion I don’t know.

Actually no, I do. It’s because it’s against the rules. And they are not Billy Slater before his last ever game a grand final.

And they know it.

And you know it, too.

But! You are Sam Burgess, and that has to count for something, right? You’re a high-profile and fabulous footy player, and clearly the rules for suspensions, as they stand, should not count, because you sell the game, and all that little stuff, what’s it matter?

So mate – get into it! Let loose. Shoulder charges. Headlocks, hair pulls. Only be a fine. Big fine, maybe, for you have the form of Phar Lap.

But just a fine.

And it’ll be the same for Marty and Jake and even spunky little Daly Cherry-Evans, and all the game’s Big Names can bop about ANZ Stadium and rip off all manner of grubby junk, and be sure that come the preliminary final, they’ll be sweet.

And the game will look equal parts like a dockyard brawl and the 1980 grand final in which barely a tackle was made in which forearms didn’t connect flush with cheekbones, and if a man fronted the judiciary with the bloke whose ear he’d bitten, neither could remember what happened.

No suspensions then. And next week, be it Round 4 against Newtown or grand final against Saints, the man was free to play.

As a man should be today.

Unless he’s Hudson Young.

The Crowd Says:

2019-09-21T09:18:18+00:00

elvis

Roar Rookie


As WG Grace supposedly said on blatantly cheating to get another life at the wicket, "They have come to see me bat, not you bowl" And as a neutral supporter I don't really care if Sam pulls someone's hair or touches their balls, I'd prefer to see him play. Totally hypocritical I know, but at this stage of the season I am representing 11/16ths of the tv audience, and it's all about the audience!

2019-09-20T06:46:22+00:00

Jacks

Roar Guru


Was on the podcast he does. Always a good listen if you wanna feel a bit of anger at the gym

2019-09-20T05:54:22+00:00

paulie

Guest


Referee's are suppose to rule each match without bias or tips sheets. There fore a players history should be of no influence to any decision unless it occurs during the same match. Reintroduce the 5min Sin bin for any discretions not deemed to be good sportsman ship and I think the problem will sove itself.

2019-09-20T05:17:30+00:00

Nat

Roar Guru


So big Marty can deadlift about 300kg. That's about the equivalent of the Burgess melon. Here's hoping Sammy gets grabbed by the wheels and the hair and thrown into 1975 where he belongs. We know ol' 'up-to-the-knuckle' George will run with his above the belt Hoppa impression ready to go to help big brother so Cherry can throw the leg out and trip him up where he'll smash his head on the side on AFB hip and it'll all be play on.

2019-09-20T05:08:14+00:00

watda

Guest


Question for big Sammy, "does the player maketh the grub or the grub maketh the player'?

2019-09-20T05:06:44+00:00

Ben Lewis

Roar Pro


What a complete pig-headed idiot. If Gould really did say that, it proves beyond doubt how far out of touch they are with the game.

2019-09-20T03:28:07+00:00

steveng

Roar Rookie


It might be funny and sarcastic to you 'Matt Cleary' but, as you and many know that the NRL are just dictatorial and full of nonsense, which has escalated this to its CEO Greenberg, who is only counting the cents and not the dollars about this situation! Now tell me, why are the NRL and Todd Greenberg letting players and managers make contracts a joke? That is the current and biggest problem in the NRL? As and instead, Todd Greenberg is making a fuss about Sam Burgess for coming out and speaking his mind and telling the truth! Why doesn’t Todd Greenberg do something about Wests Tigers second-rower Ryan Matterson and his manager? Or Jack Bird being pushed out the door up there in Brisbane etc etc these are much bigger things then this nonsense that Greenberg is going on with 'Sam Burgess' especially before the most important weeks in the NRL comp!

2019-09-20T03:24:43+00:00

Tom G

Roar Rookie


I agree with Burgess and his hallelujah chorus when they say that the fans deserve to see the biggest players in the biggest games. I think it’s a shame that players of this calibre can be rubbed out over stupid indiscretions Here’s a really easy to follow tip on how this can be avoided ... stop the stupid stuff. You never know it might just work. Whilst I agree that the NRL is a shambolic mess of inconsistency they are not the guilty party. Fans of these clubs deserve better from their stars so it is they that should cop the scorn not the NRL. If anyone can tell me with a straight face that fines will act as a deterrent, then I’m afraid you’re a fool to yourself and a burden to others. Fines are nothing to these guys

2019-09-20T01:54:53+00:00

Red Rob

Roar Rookie


YES, and this nonsense too https://www.theroar.com.au/2019/09/19/big-sam-should-be-applauded-for-standing-his-ground-with-the-nrl/

2019-09-20T01:53:02+00:00

Red Rob

Roar Rookie


:thumbup: :thumbup: :thumbup:

2019-09-20T01:45:22+00:00

Old School

Roar Rookie


For any of these events where there's a big outrage that someone has been charged, or someone gets off lightly, I always think "Ok, but what if everyone did it? What if it was done in every tackle". They would come down hard and stamp it out because foul play is foul play! And repeat offenders are treated more harshly with each offence because they don't learn their lesson and they're repeat offenders!!!

2019-09-20T01:14:56+00:00

Albo

Roar Rookie


Well done Matt. The whole Sam, Gould, Joey staged outrage agenda, needs to be ridiculed just that much.

2019-09-20T00:55:39+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


Spot on Matt Cleary. ''stuff happens on the field'' according to Sam. ''Stuff'' also happens in the judiciary midweek. It's very easy way to stop the mid week ""stuff''. Can't wait for the comedy when he does something silly again.

2019-09-20T00:23:30+00:00

Jacks

Roar Guru


The argument put forward by the likes of Burgess, Gould and to a lesser extent Andrew Johns make me question their actual knowledge of the game. I heard Gould say yesterday what did it really matter if Vinivalu's fingers touched the touch line when we can have a grand stand finish? I mean come on, why have any rules? Burgess and Jwh's records are not a good look and they both deserve the extra attention that they are given by the MRC in my opinion. If Burgess didn't wanna miss a week leave the hair alone its easy, its not a split second decision like a player falling into a high shot.

2019-09-20T00:00:48+00:00

Stormy

Roar Rookie


Just brilliant, Matt - ABSOLUTELY BRILLIANT!!!!!

Read more at The Roar