Do you have a feel for rugby league? Take the refs' quiz and find out!

By Ben Pobjie / Expert

There’s no use pussyfooting around: rugby league has become soft.

In stark contrast to the good old days, when every weekend you could depend on seeing several all-in brawls and at least half a dozen instances of severe head trauma shrugged off by real men, today every game in the NRL resembles a kind of badminton and jazz ballet hybrid.

It’s a game played by metrosexual cowards whose first instinct after a compound fracture is to go to a doctor, instead of just gathering up the splinters of bone, slipping them in your pocket, and scoring in the corner.

The reason? The same reason for everything that has ever gone wrong in the game: referees. Frankly, they have no feel for the game. It’s like they’ve never even sat in the stands screaming obscenities.

What is needed is a comprehensive re-education for all referees, so they can learn the central truth of rugby league officiating: it’s about the spirit of the rules, not the letter.

When given a choice between making a decision based on what the rules ‘say’ and what the rules are, deep down inside, thinking, always go for the latter. That’s what they need to be taught.

We love blaming NRL refs, but is it fair? (Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

To that end, I’ve prepared a handy test for all NRL match officials – and aspiring NRL match officials – to take. Anyone who can successfully answer every question is ready to take the field with whistle in mouth.

Anyone who fails on any point needs to go back to the re-education camps that Phil Gould is setting up under the Panthers carpark.

Take it now and see if you’ve got what it takes!

Question 1
The attacking team puts in a kick towards the tryline. As attackers and defenders alike race to reach the ball first, one of the defending team reaches out and pulls the jersey of an attacking chaser, preventing him from competing for the ball.

As the referee, do you:

a) award a penalty to the attacking team and sin-bin the defender for a clear professional foul.
b) award a penalty to the attacking team, but don’t sin-bin the defender because it was only a little jumper-pull and you’d probably have done the same and nobody’s perfect are they?
c) award a penalty against the attacker for deliberately running faster than the defender, forcing him against his will to commit an offence, which is entrapment.
d) get both players to fight each other and award the penalty to whoever’s left standing.

Question 2
A player slaps another player in the face. As the referee, do you:

a) penalise the player for slapping, because that is against the rules.
b) penalise the other player for getting slapped, because clearly he was asking for it.
c) penalise the player for slapping, because a real man would’ve thrown a punch.
d) slap both of them yourself.

Question 3
A grown man actually pulls another man’s hair. Literally. He pulls his hair. In a football game. Grabs his hair and pulls it. As the referee, do you:

a) blow a penalty and probably sin-bin him as well, because for god’s sake, hair-pulling, seriously?
b) call play-on as hair-pulling is very much within the spirit of rugby league and a good flowing game needs to tolerate the odd hair-pull.
c) tell the player whose hair was pulled to get a hair cut as he looks like a girl.
d) high-five the hair-puller and congratulate him on his astounding manliness.

We love blaming NRL refs, but is it fair? (Cameron Spencer/Getty Images)

Question 4
A player trips another player with his leg. As the referee, do you:

a) penalise him and give him a stint in the bin, because you remember Phil Gould demanding referees crack down on trips.
b) let the game go on, because you remember Phil Gould demanding referees stop being so harsh on trips.
c) rule no infraction, because the trip was below the shoulders.
d) award a penalty try to whichever team you like best.

Question 5
A tackler attacks the head of his opponent with a swinging arm, connecting sickeningly with his face, shattering his nose and causing a severe concussion. As the referee, do you:

a) send the tackler off immediately to send a strong message.
b) put the tackler on report, in case someone accuses you of sending a strong message.
c) warn the tackler that if he does that four or five more times you might consider giving a penalty.
d) check whether it’s a State of Origin game or a final, and if it is, penalise the tackled player for being soft.

Question 6
A player is lifted upside down and dropped directly on his head, creating a serious risk of permanent spinal damage and paralysis. As the referee, do you:

a) send the tackler or tacklers off, because the risk this type of tackle poses to the wellbeing of the tackled player is so extreme that the very harshest sanctions must be applied in order to stamp it out of the game.
b) do as specified in a), but only if it’s not at an important point in a close game, because that would be unfair.
c) consider doing as specified in a), but withhold judgment until you have spoken to the tackler’s friends and family and any members of the media who might have met him once, to check whether he is a decent bloke who does great work in the community. If this is the case, let the tackle go, as you’re sure he didn’t mean to hurt anyone.
d) submit the video to the producers of a new compilation series, Footy’s greatest piledrivers, poleaxings and punch-ons.

How did you go?

I won’t tell you the correct answers: if you’ve got what it takes, you know what they are.

Happy reffing!

The Crowd Says:

2019-09-26T00:19:36+00:00

Footy Fan

Guest


e) The fact we have all these rules shows that we're living in a white-coat nanny state. Ignore the rules and go with common sense. If you've played the game, you'd know that the odd well-chosen professional foul or bit of careless violence boosts team spirit and gives fans something to cheer. Let the game flow. Even if the off-sides, 'over-effort' in tackles and PTB, forced gymnastics via grapples, actions off the ball and concussions plus injury treatment and replacements sometimes slows that flow to a trickle. e) All the way.

2019-09-25T06:04:49+00:00

BLACKTOWN

Roar Rookie


Great writing should be compulsory reading for the channel 9 blowhards.

2019-09-25T04:01:40+00:00

Cadfael

Roar Guru


Did A for the lot.

2019-09-25T03:38:33+00:00

Forty Twenty

Roar Rookie


Must be the funny camera angle because it looks to me like scrums are fed into the lock forwards boots. Surely they're not ignoring the rules because it makes sense? Can't wait to see a penalty for the offence in the GF , which swings the game. Can't complain because the rule says feed it square? JWH head butts a Manly player in the 13 GF but isn't penalised or sent off. Why not? Because it wasn't with any great force. Refs used some discretion. Doesn't make the blatant forward pass correct and all the other dodgy calls but most accepted the ref viewing the incident with a dash of grey. A player is one inch off side on the opposite side of the field in the last seconds of a GF. Does the ref award a penalty, with directions from the touchy, which could alter the result or use his 'feel for the game'?

2019-09-25T00:29:15+00:00

Dogs Boddy

Roar Rookie


Outstanding. 1 (D). But afterwards I would penalise both players and send them to the bin for fighting. We do have standards to uphold. Then blow a penalty for whichever team is closest to the bottom of the ladder because they need the help. 2 (C, then D) Everyone loves a good slap, just make it a backhanded Archie. 3 (C) I would also grant a penalty against the pullee if he is sporting a manbun. 4 (C) So long as he intended at some point to possible include his arms in a potential tackle, and is willing to swear to this under question by the ref then it’s ok. 5 (C) Because all we want is consistency, and I am sure he didn’t mean it. 6 (C) See my answer to question 5. This should also be done while arguing with the offending teams captain about how the injured player is just “milking it”.

2019-09-25T00:15:14+00:00

William Dalton Davis

Roar Rookie


D to all

2019-09-25T00:03:02+00:00

Edward Kelly

Roar Guru


Nice one Ben.

2019-09-24T23:37:19+00:00

Censored Often

Roar Rookie


Mistakes are part of the game but an official offering multiple outcomes to the same scenario within an 80min period is entirely different.

2019-09-24T23:06:58+00:00

Rellum

Roar Guru


I would have assumed all the answers would be "What ever Phil says" Can you get his to take the quiz so we know what real league is?

2019-09-24T22:44:56+00:00

Tim Gore

Expert


I look forward to your piece on the MRC.

2019-09-24T22:39:04+00:00

jimmmy

Roar Rookie


You, me and Bart Simpson.

2019-09-24T22:23:44+00:00

Paul

Roar Guru


Terrific piece Ben. Some of your suggested answers are a pretty sad indictment on what's happening in the game at the moment. I particularly like answer c) in question 6.

2019-09-24T22:11:31+00:00

Arcturus

Roar Rookie


Woohoo! I love quizzes. No need for answers, I always go b) in multiple choices anyway.

2019-09-24T22:03:16+00:00

bazza200

Guest


if in doubt do A :) although you missing sending the slapper off to the bin so they can think about how much better it would of felt to at least punch them rather than slap and go for a 10 minute rest in the bin :)

Read more at The Roar