Today’s discussion, ladies and gentlemen, is about when it’s okay to steal.
Yes, we could talk about Kevin Roberts’ departure from Cricket Australia, but I’m going to go out on a limb and say a hell of a lot more cricket fans care about highlights provider extraordinaire Robelinda, aka Rob Moody, than the outgoing chief executive or his replacement.
We’re all familiar with Moody’s work; his Robelinda2 YouTube channel is the destination for anyone wanting to watch a particular cricket video from summers past, his Twitter account the place to request something obscure you can’t find.
Unfortunately, it’s no surprise when that same Twitter feed bears the bad news of recently filed takedown notices, issued after complaints from various cricket boards. Which is exactly what happened on Tuesday morning thanks to the England and Wales Cricket Board and CA.
Thankfully, Tuesday’s takedown notices, or at least the ones from Cricket Australia, were sent erroneously and retracted later that morning.
That’s the news every cricket fan wanted to hear, and credit must go CA’s way for handling it so quickly.
Even if this episode was nothing more than a case of an overzealous attorney, it doesn’t change the fact Moody has been a frequent recipient of these takedowns from multiple boards. In addition to the ECB on Tuesday, just last November he was sent 23 copyright claims from Cricket Australia, while the ICC sent a barrage of takedown notices Moody’s way this March and have prevented him from ever uploading ICC tournament footage again.
Of course, Moody doesn’t own the copyright on the footage he posts (he also doesn’t make any money off his work, publishing videos ad-free because “It just seems really dodgy. It would also be extra hassles with legal matters.”). That’s not the point.
The point is Moody provides a service for fans which the boards and broadcasters do not. There is no other publicly available archive – paid or free – of cricket highlights which comes close to his YouTube channel.
He’s essentially doing the boards’ jobs for them, promoting the sport for no personal gain. And it’s awfully hard to work out what harm exactly he’s doing.
It’s not like Moody’s work impacts broadcasters. He’s not running pirate streams of live matches, and the highlights he posts can rarely be found elsewhere – so much so that Channel Nine apparently used to use clips he’d uploaded, Robelinda watermark and all, on the Cricket Show.
For a sport so rich in history, it is downright bizarre for someone who provides an easy and accessible link to the game’s past to have been hounded the way he has.
Contrast this with the NBA. A global sporting megalith, the best basketball league in the world pulled in a nine-year, $USD24 billion broadcast deal in 2014, second in yearly value in the States only to the NFL. Their YouTube has a massive 14 million subscribers.
They also give fan-run YouTube channels pretty much free reign, as long as they don’t encroach on live broadcasts.
“Look, this is where the world is going,” NBA commissioner Adam Silver reportedly said when deciding against suing YouTube for copyright infringement a few years ago. “At a certain point, if we’re not there, does it mean we don’t exist to this new fan that’s growing up on YouTube?”
That’s a question every governing body in the cricketing world would do well to ask themselves. It’s fine for the ICC to say they’re opening up their archive for broadcasters during the pandemic – as they did in March, a move which miraculously coincided with the notices sent to Moody – but that doesn’t necessarily translate to more access for fans.
And they’re the most important stakeholders in any sport. Governing bodies don’t own a sport, fans do. The boards which run the codes are gatekeepers whose primary purpose is the health of their game. Or at least they should be.
They’re also not-for-profit organisations. So again, what’s the harm of someone like Moody posting thousands of cricket videos that fans couldn’t otherwise watch?
Let me answer that one for you: there is none. It promotes the game, particularly in times like these when there’s no live cricket to watch.
It’s worth remembering that one of the main cricketing discussions over the past few months was kickstarted by a Robelinda video. Never mind it was the latest time Shane Warne took his “Steve Waugh = selfish” hobby horse for a ride, but it did show how these videos get people talking about cricket.
Again, well done to Cricket Australia for acting on this morning’s notice so quickly. Not many expected that episode to play out the way it did.
If CA have got the message for good now, fantastic. Keep it that way. Tighten up processes to make sure make no more erroneous claims are made.
While they’re at it, maybe pass the word around that the work Moody does for cricket should be celebrated by governing bodies around the world the same way it is by fans.
Dwanye
Roar Rookie
Hi everyone and I agree with all, the guy needs an order of Australia. The main the from the article for me is ‘ He’s essentially doing the boards’ jobs for them, promoting the sport for no personal gain’. It’s sad, that’s how hopelessness of it.
Derek Murray
Roar Rookie
Here's a thought for CA. Hire the guy and let him see if he can gain revenue by opening his stuff up to advertisers.
Tony Hodges
Roar Rookie
It’s so obvious it’s ridiculous, but it won’t happen.
Tony Hodges
Roar Rookie
I think anyone theoretically could, but in practice probably not. At least, not without investing an enormous amount. The quality of the archiving is the thing that makes pulling out precise rarities quickly feasible, and there’s just no way to do that quickly or cheaply.
Pedro The Fisherman
Roar Rookie
Well you can Paul so why not old orange complexion?
DaveJ
Roar Rookie
Well said. By the way, the latest Waugh-Warne controversy wasn’t fuelled by a video but one of the stats lists that Rob Moody occasionally adds to his Twitter feed. Unlike his fanstastic videos these are often misconceived extractions of aggregate-based data from Cricinfo or similar. Listing who was involved in the most run outs is a bit like saying Alistair Cook is the best ever batsman because he scored 50% more runs than the likes of Bradman.
Train Without A Station
Roar Guru
It was also better because it didn't have to worry about making money because other sports didn't offer 18 year olds good money and IPL and County Cricket didn't offer the money to make it worthwhile to not play for your country without decent pay.
josh
Roar Rookie
I don't think Warne ever bowled properly in the Sheffield Shield.
josh
Roar Rookie
I'm not sure why CA haven't monetised their back catalogue. During lockdown i would have paid to watch complete old matches on YouTube or wherever. And I don't think I would have been alone. Compare to the US, where some high profile fan accounts have been either employed directly by a team/organisation or by a major broadcaster. The CA approach is really backwards.
T Bradley
Roar Rookie
Great article. I’m with you Dan. I’m allergic to bureaucrats. Would a GoFundMe campaign help Robinda?...I’d certainly put in for it
Ruairidh MacDonald
Roar Rookie
*fewer (the title)
Tim Ponnusamy
Roar Rookie
Great article Daniel! Robelinda has been a tremendously positive force in the world of cricket for all of us that love the game. Sad to see this being undermined, legalities or not. In a world where the game, particularly in it's longest format is being challenged constantly by other sporting codes around, it could do with more promotion and not less.
JGK
Roar Guru
Is it CA's archive or the ABCs?
13th Man
Roar Rookie
Robelinda is fantastic. I absolutely love his channel. I really hope his channel isn't deleted by the ridiculousness of the ICC. Glad Cricket Australia saw the worth of his videos.
Micko
Roar Rookie
Is that you Rob?
Micko
Roar Rookie
With all the titles I'd seen with anti-aussie sentiment I was sure Rob was a pom or a kiwi at first. Then I realised that since the aussies are usually the cricket villains, they work a treat as clickbait to get all the Indians/south Asian viewers on board. :stoked:
GCCTV
Guest
Hell YES!! :thumbup:
GCCTV
Guest
I get the same sort of grief from CA, ECB, BCCI, Pakistan CB or willow tv (an American tv channel) whenever I post highly editEd footage of Aaron Finch videos to YouTube... at the end of the day it’s archival, we don’t want to make money from it, we just want to spread the amazing accomplishments of our heroes as we can’t view them because as you say the boards won’t post any of the footage!
JGK
Roar Guru
They should hire me - given all the cricket I've watched over the years, I reckon I could find most "moments" in Australian tests since 1982 in pretty quick time :stoked:
JGK
Roar Guru
I remember that match at North Sydney Oval. It was peak Steve Waugh. Amazing that Warne can't find a spot for Steve in the best 25 players he saw.