The Liebke Ratings: Australia vs India, fourth Test

By Dan Liebke / Expert

During the closing overs of that fighting draw in Sydney, Tim Paine told Ravi Ashwin he couldn’t wait for him to get to the Gabba.

After five nail-biting days of the fourth Test, we now know why. It’s because Paine, ever the generous host, was excited to have Ashwin witness a thrilling conclusion to a magnificent series.

Here are the ratings for the final Test between Australia and India.

Potassium
Grade: B-

Australia batted first and soon lost David Warner and Marcus Harris, yet again allowing the hosts to play to their strengths by leaving everything up to Marnus Labuschagne and Steve Smith.

This time it was Labuschagne who came to the rescue, bringing up his fifth Test century, as he surged past 1800 Test runs (an astonishing tally from a man who has surely played only, what, like, half a dozen Tests?)

The secret to his energy – he ran multiple all-run fours in his ton (as well as, of course, threes, twos and several all-run singles) – was revealed during a drinks break drone-interview when he was spotted devouring a sneaky banana. A classic case of ‘bananas in da Marnus’.

Hundredth Tests
Grade: D-

Despite Labuschagne’s potassium-fuelled runs, his eventual wicket, caught by Rohit Sharma off the bowling of Washington Sundar, left Australia in trouble at 5-213.

And when Cameron Green, a wily old veteran compared to the bowlers that injury-ravaged India were forced to select in the Test, fell for 47 and Pat Cummins departed shortly after for 2, there was only one man who could save Australia’s first innings.

That man was Nathan Lyon, playing his hundredth Test. Before the match, he’d talked about the milestone and how it had him ‘pinching himself’. And yet it’s somehow Smith and Labuschagne who are the team oddballs.

With the phrase ‘GOAT ton’ on everybody’s mind, the Gabba was abuzz. A century in his hundredth Test? A fitting reward for one of the great Ricky Ponting impersonators.

Sadly, he fell 76 runs short as Australia were bowled out for 369.

(Photo by PATRICK HAMILTON/AFP via Getty Images)

India fightbacks
Grade: A-

Australia went to work with the ball, regularly chipping away at India’s batting order. At 6-186, with ICC top ranked babysitter-batsman Rishabh Pant dismissed by Josh Hazlewood, it looked like India might be bowled out for around 200.

Instead, debutant Sundar and former debutant Shardul Tharkar combined for a record seventh-wicket partnership, showing the kind of admirable fight that has won India so many fans over the course of this summer.

Thakur made 67 in the 123-run partnership, while Sundar finished on 62, matching the debut Test innings of Will Pucovski in the previous Test. Pucovski, however, refused to take a single wicket at the SCG, let alone the four that Sundar eventually picked up here. Advantage Washington.

Great fight from the depleted India side, who showed that they could dominate Australia at the Gabba like few teams before them, impressing everybody with their determination and resolve to take a commanding first innings lead of -33 runs.

But if you thought that was impressive, you hadn’t seen anything yet.

Declaration speculation
Grade: D

Australia had the fourth day to set a target for India, with rain forecast for both of the last two days of the Test.

It was a tricky balance for Paine, looking to time his declaration to properly balance likelihood of winning with risks of losing. He was helped when David Warner and Marcus Harris got Australia off to a flying start.

But the openers fell as part of a mini-collapse of 4/34. Warner, trapped plumb in front by that man Sundar, showed none of the haste of his batting when reviewing. He dawdled his way to the T, eventually forming it at least a second too late.

A shame for Australia, because it cost the side a review. Perhaps Labuschagne should have reviewed the timing on Warner’s review and tried to get the review back.

But Paine wasn’t concerned about reviews. He was concerned about timing his declaration.

The calculations would have been a lot simpler if India had been all out for 36 in their second innings a couple more times this series. Unfair, really, that Paine was forced to adjust his thinking because of India’s shocking inconsistency.

Eventually, much like Warner’s review, Paine left the whole declaration too late and Australia were instead bowled out for 294.

Sports opinion delivered daily 

   

Heroics
Grade: A

All of which left Australia needing ten wickets and India 324 runs to win on the final day.

As ever, Pat Cummins led the attack, steaming in all day. Bit of an environmentally unfriendly way to bowl for mine. Surely, in this day and age, Australia’s best quick should be solar-powered. Get onto it, Alinta Energy. (Of course, Green bowling has been proven to be nowhere near as reliable. Therein lies the challenge for carbon-concerned cricketers.)

But while Cummins sealed the Player of the Series award with his 4-55, it was the remarkable Pant who sealed the match, the series, the Border-Gavaskar Trophy, top spot on the World Test Championship table, Player of the Match, and ownership of a now-defunct Gabbatoir with a fearless 89* to guide India to a masterful three-wicket win.

In the process, Pant also passed a thousand Test runs. Or, as I like to call it, one kilorun. I expect at least half a dozen more kiloruns from this incredible talent.

India’s series victory was easily the greatest performance by any visiting side to Australia and rightly celebrated by a jubilant Indian squad.

And to think, poor old Virat Kohli was sitting at home, watching it all on television.

Boy, I sure hope that baby’s cute.

The Crowd Says:

2021-01-22T03:56:32+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


Thanks Tim, I'll have a read.

2021-01-21T02:44:54+00:00

Kurt S

Roar Pro


The carbon concerned cricketers, the review’s review and Kohli’s baby were right up there with Stoneman, Wood and Mason Crane from the 2018 ashes series ????

2021-01-20T11:24:37+00:00

Tim Carter

Roar Pro


Thanks Pontiff. My first reply isn't showing, but I linked a script Dan wrote last year that provided some context

2021-01-20T11:21:15+00:00

Tim Carter

Roar Pro


Pontiff, thank you. To understand what I was writing about, Dan wrote a sitcom last April, which I tried to revive. It's in here. https://www.thenightwatchman.net/news/the-birth-of-the-pinch-hitter

2021-01-20T07:29:58+00:00


Remember that Aus HAD to win this game to take back the trophy...Losing was no different to Drawing and that never achieved anything......Paine HAD to gamble no matter what the acceptable total was and most times the total would have been good enough...

2021-01-20T07:27:19+00:00


he lifted the last one here in Aus Willow.....I think he will be absolutely chuffed with the boys and their achievements and Im 100% sure he will have valued his experience of having his first child...

2021-01-20T06:34:52+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


Love it Timmy. The Who were massive Lillee fans.

2021-01-20T06:03:16+00:00

Dwanye

Roar Rookie


People talking of a five test series now Indian give us such a good competition. Sure, sure add another test we could lose.

2021-01-20T05:37:32+00:00

Tim Carter

Roar Pro


Hey Dan, I ended up writing the LockDon Christmas Special. The Roar weren't interested, partly because of the script format, but also due to me not submitting it until January 3rd and then unashamedly calling it a 12 Days of Christmas Special. Here's an example of the 'humour' involved: ANNOUNCER: Yes, give him a round of applause. An all round talent, that was Kallis with Milkshake. We'll try to bring him back later to actually do a song. Our next musical act stars Dennis and Gubby as Lillee Allen! (Camera cuts to backstage as Pitches of Lillee plays in background)

2021-01-20T05:36:45+00:00

Pope Paul VII

Roar Rookie


Top stuff Dan. Declaration Speculation is much funnier after the fact. To a man Aussie greats and not so greats suggested 270 was the number. Lord save us. India might have got that late on day 4.

2021-01-20T04:49:50+00:00

The Late News

Roar Rookie


Dan...you very nearly lost me with potassium.. but you got me back. Sure many of us were all hoping for Pants down on the second innings but a belt was secured and up he stayed.

2021-01-20T04:10:57+00:00

WillowWiz

Roar Rookie


I reckon Pujara's nickname is "The Rock" and not "The Wall"? That last one belongs to a certain Rahul Dravid, I think :happy: Isha Guha kept referring to Pujara as The Rock - as did Kerry O'Keeffe :)

2021-01-20T04:07:24+00:00

WillowWiz

Roar Rookie


Boy, I sure hope that baby’s cute.” Terrific end to a terrific article, Dan. Kohli will never admit it, but I reckon he may have, in hindsight, wished to have been the one holding that trophy up instead of Rahane :laughing: :laughing: :laughing:

2021-01-20T01:50:29+00:00

Sgt Pepperoni

Roar Rookie


Thanks Dan, I needed cheering up after that

2021-01-20T00:16:26+00:00

Waxhead

Roar Rookie


@Munro yeah add on Warner as another dud. I'd call Lyons disappointing rather than a full on dud. So the Aussie duds were Warner, Burns, Starc, Harris, Head and Wade. That's half the team :thumbup:

2021-01-19T23:19:27+00:00

JOHN ALLAN

Guest


India approached “the improbable & unlikely target” on Day 5 in a thoughtful & professional manner. Ravi Shastri is obviously a master tactician however he was relying on some inexperienced players to support Rahane who is unbeaten as captain & Pujara whose nickname “The Wall” is appropriate. Bat to lunch with wickets intact, lift the run rate in the second session & reassess at tea. Gull’s innings was vital whilst having Pant fearlessly playing his strokes were vital ingredients in the victory. India however couldn’t have made history without the assistance of our bowlers who were wayward & ineffective. Perhaps it was a blessing in disguise for India being forced to select virtually a new bowling attack who had something to prove whilst our attack appeared worn out & devoid of a Plan “B”.

2021-01-19T23:05:36+00:00

Munro Mike

Roar Rookie


......Warner....... and N.Lyon, 9 wickets at 55. And as good as we want to present Cummins and Hazlewood..........yet again........where were the LBW's and Bowleds. Where was the attack on the wood work? S.Smith Adelaide/Melbourne and M.Labuschagne for passing 20 in all but one hit, passing 40 on 5 times.......and reaching triple figures just once and even then not going big (due to shocking shot selection). I see A.Finch at the 'Gades lament "dumb batting" and "dumb cricket".....sad to say the Australian test side suffered the same malady.

2021-01-19T22:05:10+00:00

bigbaz

Roar Guru


As usual , a great read.

2021-01-19T21:18:33+00:00

Waxhead

Roar Rookie


@Dan yeah good summary. India had a more well rounded team even without Kohli. All their replacements were good/great. Australia had far too many duds in Starc, Harris, Head, Burns and Wade - all were poor. Congrats to India :happy:

2021-01-19T20:31:24+00:00

Tony

Roar Guru


Bananas in da marnus How did you come up with that one

More Comments on The Roar

Read more at The Roar