By Spiro Zavos
April 20th 2007 @ 9:35pm
Duncan Fletcher: hero or culprit?
Duncan Fletcher, the hard-nosed, cranky and obdurate Zimbabwean, has stepped down from his prestigious and lucrative job as England’s cricket coach.
He had a year to run on his contract. But he jumped before he was pushed. The euphoria of the Ashes victory two years ago has now become a historical footnote.
The story that identifies him now is the rather plaintive account of Michael Vaughan asking for some batting advice from Geoff Boycott and then begging the former blocker to make sure Fletcher didn’t hear about it.
Vaughan, and his backers like Boycott, a batsman who clung to the batting crease with all the energy of a barnacle and who is surely the last man in the world you’d seek out for advice on the one-day game, are now blaming Fletcher for England’s dismal performances at the Cricket World Cup. This rather neatly avoids Vaughan’s own part in England’s fall from Ashes grace. And Fletcher’s part in the Ashes triumph.
There are two complaints about Vaughan: first, he never allowed Andrew Flintoff to establish himself as England’s captain after he was injured. There was Vaughan in the England dressing room during the last Ashes series in Australia acting as a sort of ghost at Banquo’s (Flintoff’s) wedding. Flintoff was a poor captain, anyway. The sight of Vaughan hovering around the team all the time, unwilling to let go, must have been unnerving, nevertheless. Second, Vaughan’s batting was totally inadequate. He batted too slowly (in the Boycott manner): however, he did not compensate to some extent for the snail-like batting rate by scoring a huge volume of runs (something that Boycott did, in fact, do).
So where does Fletcher’s resignation fit into all of this?
Ian Chappell is adamant that coaches are a waste of time at the international level. Senior players, especially the captain, are there, according to Chappell, to give what advice is necessary. Under this sort of regime, the coach is relegated to the manager, the general dogs-body who makes sure that the gear arrives on time and that the players don’t miss their flights.
Against this is the Bobby Simpson view that coaches are critical to the success of individual players and, especially, to teams. It was Simpson who breathed life into the Australian cricket team in the 1980s when things fell away with the Packer revolt and rebel tours. Simpson revolutionised cricket coaching by using the techniques of the football codes to get players fit, aerobically and mentally. He devised interesting new tactics and field placings which obedient captains put into operation.
Fletcher prided himself on being a Simpson type of coach, hands-on and running everything the team did, except when players were on the the field. Accordingly, he accepted the plaudits when England re-gained the Ashes. And now he seems to have accepted the brickbats over England’s dismal World Cup tournament. Fletcher’s tough and uncompromising approach to the way his teams played played an important part in the Ashes triumph. But in the end the players got tired of the dourness, tired of sullenness when things weren’t going well and tired of mind games being played on them.
Coaches, like politicians, can stay too long in the job. And the case of Duncan Fletcher is a good example of this truth. John Buchanan’s decision to leave after the Cricket World Cup tournament looks to be about as exquisite a piece of timing as a Ponting six over long-on.
Get Australia's best Cricket opinion emailed daily.
Like this content? Buzz it up!
Free Email updates:
Our daily emails are only sent if there is content for the sport or that author. You can subscribe to multiple daily emails; or get the daily Roar email with all our content in it. We value privacy. More...

(2)
![There are a lot of easy targets in the Sonny Bill Williams saga: the headstrong runaway who’s done the dirty on his mates, the conniving managers, and the aloof CEO hypocritically demanding support from an enemy that has been savagely plundered by his predecessors for over a hundred years.
All of them make great caricatures for [...] Garth Hamilton: David Gallop, it’s time to merge the codes](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2008/05/david-gallop-th.jpg)
![As we wait on edge to see what the Socceroos will achieve in South Africa, the only guarantee we have is that they won’t look good doing it. That’s the overwhelming consensus following the release of the away kit the Socceroos will wear at the World Cup and beyond that has left many Australian fans [...] Adrian Musolino: Socceroos to be the ugly ducklings at World Cup](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/vince-grella-socceroos-shirt-th.jpg)
![While the Australia 2018-2022 bid might have taken some succour from the withdrawal of Mexico from the race for hosting the World Cup, there looms a significant event on the horizon that will pose a whole new challenge: the official launch of the Russia 2018-2022 bid by the Russian Football Union before the October 10 [...] Jesse Fink: The Russian bear roars](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/10/the-russian-bear-roars-th.jpg)
![Only 7,677 fans attended the Brisbane-Sydney clash at Suncorp Stadium on Sunday. The average for that fixture is almost 25,000. It’s a huge drop off, one that can be attributed to the controversy over the price of tickets, but also highlighting several important lessons about A-League crowds.
What the disappointing drop in crowd numbers highlights is [...] Adrian Musolino: Accepting some home truths about A-League crowds](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/which-chants-acceptable-th.jpg)
![Some might not have you believe it, but the most pressing story to come from Australia’s 1-0 win over Indonesia on Wednesday night was not the emergence of Tommy Oar on the international scene. Oar stole the headlines, but a more pertinent issue remains: the Socceroos’ inability to turn its domination into more than a [...] Paddy Higgs: Socceroos goal scoring problem still not solved](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2008/02/joshua-kennedy-th.jpg)
![The umpires were wrong to stop Dave Warner, generally a left-handed batsman, from shaping up right-handed in the last Twenty20 match against the West Indies and then belting the next delivery by switching to his left-hand stance.
The argument used by umpires Bruce Oxenford and Rod Tucker to stop this ploy was that the West Indies [...] Spiro Zavos: Dave Warner is right, batting right or left-handed](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/12/david-warner-th.jpg)
![AFL stars and fans are declaring war on Channel 7. And for good reason. The network has confirmed it won’t be showing Friday night AFL matches live, as it’s committed instead to Better Homes and Gardens.
The continuation of delayed coverage has the AFL world fuming and has already sparked discussion over the AFL’s [...] Adrian Musolino: Battlelines drawn over live Friday night footy](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/01/grant-birchall-hawthorn-th.jpg)
![Tonight, UEFA Champions League football returns to the Emirates, 113 days since its last appearance at Arsenal’s home ground. On that occasion, Gunners fans held up giant placards that spelled “believe,” before seeing their team humbled by Manchester United.
This time round it will be the away fans clinging to hope with Arsenal expected to [...] Davidde Corran: As history repeats, there’s no way back for Scotland](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/05/a-league-celtic-scott-mcdonald-th.jpg)
![When Football Federation Australia chairman Frank Lowy announced that Australia were hoping to both host and win the 2018 FIFA World Cup you could almost hear the sniggers echoing around the globe.
The Socceroos squad that made such great inroads in Germany 2006 might have been filled with players of European quality like Viduka, Kewell and [...] Davidde Corran: Socceroos 2018 aspirations to begin in Egypt](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/09/socceroos-2018-egypt-blatter-lowy-th.jpg)
![My lovely wife, a self-labelled cricket widow (and for another two weeks at least, dear), who doubles as my chief proof-reader, has stated in recent weeks that she was getting a little tired of reading about cricket. I guess that’s fair enough, it has been a long summer.
This meant, as I explained to her at [...] Brett McKay: Super 14 is so much more watchable this season](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2010/03/digby-ione-reds-th.jpg)
![So South Africa has become the first team to defeat Australia in three successive bilateral ODI series’. Pity the poor West Indies. Their many Tri-Series successes in Australia seemingly do not count in this context.
On top of this comes the news that, at least until the present series concludes, Australia has (deservedly) slipped to third [...] Greg Russell: Decline of Australian cricket due to many factors](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/04/decline-oz-cricket-andrew-symonds-th.jpg)
![1993 was a good time to be an Australian in Britain, especially if you were the sort of Aussie who likes sport. Which, really, is the only sort of Aussie who ends up in Britain.
The Wallabies had just backed up the Rugby World Cup win with a successful tour of Ireland and Wales, marred only [...] Matthew Horan: How I missed cricket’s Ball of the Century](http://www.theroar.com.au/wp-content/uploads/2009/08/how-i-missed-cricket-shane-warne-th.jpg)




Mitch said | April 21st 2007 @ 11:42am | Report comment
I’d just like to say that it is extremely elitest to think that the there is no need of a coach at the senior level of cricket. It is big headed and cocky to think that senior Australian players cant learn something and receive advise from someone older than them with more experience. Who do some of them think they are? It is a fact of life, not just sport, that we learn, learn and keep on learning until our last breath. Keep coaches I say!
sheek said | April 21st 2007 @ 6:21pm | Report comment
Mitch,
I’m a huge fan of Ian Chappell’s, & if he says cricket doesn’t need coaches, then I agree with him. It’s a case of “horses for courses”.
Chappelli isn’t being elitist, he’s just being his blunt, direct self. Football codes require coaches because the interaction of players is constant, & needs to be replicated on the training paddock.
A cricket team is together only half the time, that is, when bowling & fielding. A manager is perhaps better required for cricket, whereby his primary function is to co-ordinate training practise & drills.
Coaching is still available via specialists, for example, ex-players. BTW, Chappell & Simpson didn’t get on. I read once when he first came into the Australian team under Simpson’s captaincy, Chappell blamed Simmo for giving him some wrong advice on batting.
They don’t forgive easily, those Chappells!