Do fans drive our sports heroes to despair?
By John Leicester, 15 Nov 2009 John Leicester is a Roar Rookie
- Tagged:
- Crowds, depression, Robert Enke, Sport
Hands up all those who have shouted at the television or snorted with derision from the stands when a footballer, or any athlete for that matter, fluffs a pass, lets in a goal or gets knocked out in the first round?
Thought so, pretty much everyone.
Now hands up those who’ve really taken any time to consider what it feels like to be on the receiving end of such pressure, how it can hurt those who don’t have thick skins?
Thought so, far fewer.
Demanding fans aren’t to blame for the suicide this week of Germany’s goalkeeper Robert Enke. But living in the public eye, subject to adulation one minute and scorn the next, can make depression harder for sports people to bear. In mourning Enke, football and the millions who follow it would be wise to examine their roles in such tragedies.
Because top class athletes seem so strong and blessed, it gets forgotten that they can be as fragile as the rest of us, that their winning outer persona can hide inner torment. Their physical skills don’t make them any less human, nor does their wealth and fame immunise them from the illness that affects an estimated 121 million people, making it one of the world’s leading causes of disability. Depression doesn’t care if someone has a powerful right foot or left hook or a bulging bank balance.
Among the highs and lows of Enke’s sporting life was an unhappy stop at Turkish side Fenerbahce in 2003. He left after playing just one match – a 3-0 defeat where Fenerbahce fans jeered at him. The team said Enke’s one-year deal was cancelled because he “didn’t fit in.” Enke, crippled by anxiety and fear of failure, first sought treatment for depression that year while at Spanish club Barcelona, where he struggled before being loaned to Fenerbahce.
How cruel that train of events seems now. Footballers can’t afford off days.
“They always have to perform under the eyes of hundreds or millions of people and this increases the psychological load,” notes FIFA’s medical chief, Michel D’Hooghe. “They are confronted by press comments that can take them from the highest mountains to the lowest valleys.”
The absolutes of competitive sport, where winning is everything and losing simply failure, make it a tough world. As Britain’s Queen Victoria was told when watching the yacht race in 1851 that spawned the America’s Cup, “Your Majesty, there is no second.”
Athletes can be their own worst enemies, binding their self-esteem to their on-field performances. Even after a good game, “they will remember the one errant pass or save that they make,” says Peter Kay, CEO of the Sporting Chance Clinic in England that treats footballers and other athletes for mental illnesses and behavioural problems.
Injury can factor in depression, too, as it takes sports people away from their life’s purpose, from teammates, from physical exercise and from the mental nourishment of competing and winning.
Nine-time Grand Slam winner Monica Seles binged in secret on junk food, becoming bloated and haunted, after a deranged fan of Steffi Graf’s stabbed her in the back with a boning knife. The year before winning the 800m and 1500m at the 2004 Athens Olympics, a depressed Kelly Holmes locked herself in a bathroom and hacked at her arm with a pair of scissors, “one cut for every day I had been injured.”
Athletes can be slow to seek help because they figure they should tough it out and that admitting to depression could be seen as a sign of weakness. Enke’s widow says her 32-year-old husband worried about the reaction, that he would lose “his sport, our private life,” if news of his illness became public. While sports psychology is now more mainstream than it used to be, athletes haven’t always had the help they need.
Stan Collymore, who was Britain’s most expensive footballer when Liverpool bought his goalscoring talents in 1995, says his depression went undiagnosed for three years. The illness was “like pulling the thread of a jumper,” Collymore told the BBC, “unravelling day by day by day.”
Later, after moving to Aston Villa, the striker spoke to a club doctor, “who said, ‘Well, you’ve got a game this afternoon, if you score a couple of goals, you might feel a bit better.”‘
So much for sympathy.
Strikers, in a way, are lucky, because they are at football’s glory end, scoring goals. ‘Keepers, in contrast, are the last line of defence, with fans breathing down their necks, often scrutinised more for the goals they let in than those they save. Psychologists in Norway who studied column inches devoted there to first division football last season say that ‘keepers got only two per cent of the coverage and that it is invariably negative.
So the next time a player shoots wide, misses the winning basket or lets in that goal that puts your team out, think a few moments before muttering, “Idiot.”
© AAP 2012Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
The Crowd Says (4) | Page 1 of Comments
Have Your Say
- Explore:
- Crowds, depression, Robert Enke, Sport

megatron said | November 15th 2009 @ 5:48am | Report comment
Brilliant article! Very important for people to read and remember… it’s just sport.
James W said | November 15th 2009 @ 11:10am | Report comment
Very interesting. You wonder how much of the insults stick and how long it takes to develop that think skin they need.
Hazey the Bear said | November 16th 2009 @ 6:42am | Report comment
This is an absolutely essential piece for any sports fan to read and understand. Thanks, John.
One of the dark sides of sporting and athletic events is the desire to win “at all costs” and the consequences of what happens if you don’t, especially considering the pressure from fans. I remember hearing the story of Kathy Ormsby who was the collegiate record holder for the women’s 10000 metre run, and ran in the 1986 NCAA track and field championships in Indianapolis. When she fell behind and couldn’t catch the front runners, she ran off track and jumped off a bridge, leaving her paralyzed from the waist down. It’s a sad thing when not winning has such an effect on a person.
Some of the sports mentalities that are going around are so far removed from “It’s not about winning, it’s about having fun” that we’re taught as children.
Mushi said | November 16th 2009 @ 1:58pm | Report comment
I wrote about this before with regards to how we seems to have this ludicrous hypocrisy where we expect our sports stars to be infallible and loyal when we the fans will turn on them in an instant.