Kelly Slater is the greatest sportsperson of all time
By JazzyJase, 28 Jun 2012 JazzyJase is a Roar Pro
- Tagged:
- Cricket, Darren Lockyer, Kelly Slater, muhammad ali, Shane Warne, surfing
Many sports fans who frequent bars will remember the familiar argument about which player was the best ever in your chosen sport. But what about the best athlete ever, in any sport?
I have compiled a list of who I think are the best athletes to ever grace a sporting field/court/ring.
Boxing
My first recollection of a fight was in the late 70s when big time boxing was a staple on the Sunday afternoon television. Muhammad Ali was winding up his career, however still could float like a butterfly and sting like a bee.
His greatest triumphs were well before my time when he overcome the world’s biggest villain in Sonny Liston and then of course the Rumble in Jungle and the Thriller in Manilla. Ali’s footwork was to behold and drew inspiration from Sugar Ray Robinson. His hand speed, power and evasiveness were unparalleled.
One of the most exciting eras of boxing was seeing Sugar Ray Leonard, Marvellous Marvin Hagler, Tommy Hit Man Hearns, and Roberto Duran taking turns in going at each other hammer and tongs.
Make no mistake about it, while a genuine nice guy out of ring, Sugar Ray was as vicious with his hands as he was silky with his moves.
Hagler was a pure pugilist of the highest calibre. Hearns, who later fought in multiple divisions, looked as bad as they come and Roberto Duran was merciless with his hands of stone.
My Dad would also tell me of Jake La Motta who just kept on coming forward and I have seen grainy footage of him doing just this. Lionel Rose conquered the world, leading a path for Jeff Fenech to follow. Kostya Tszyu was at one time the greatest, pound for pound.
Boxing has never recovered since Iron Mike Tyson’s reign as the baddest man on the planet. He was so ferocious and looked like he would never be stopped.
My best: Muhammad Ali, he was the greatest.
Cricket
First and foremost, no cricket list has any authority without reverence to the Don. I can’t compose anything that has not been written before. Simply, the Don is in another stratosphere.
When it comes to cricket, I am unashamedly patriotic.
Steve Waugh epitomises Australian cricket. Let’s face it, we are the greatest ever cricket nation in the universe and that’s because we play to win and never take a backward step. Yes his breakthrough series may have been against the Poms when he scored century after century, but let’s face it, the Poms weren’t much chop back then.
In my mind, his zenith was the Caribbean tour when he was tougher than a $2 steak. He stared down Curtly Ambrose, who was at his throat demanding he “turn around and bowl”.
It was a 200 that inspired a shirtless (and likely rum fuelled) Greg Ritchie to leave his supporters group on the hill and run onto the ground to shake his hand. Waugh was mentally tough and had such great cognitive powers he could disintegrate his opposition.
He may not have been the flashiest and will never win the best ever athlete, but he is a personal favourite.
Putting aside Australians for the moment, Viv Richards was the player I would love to see the Aussies get rid of. From the comfort of my lounge, I would muster up a monumental send off in pointing to the sheds whenever DK or his mates would get one past Viv’s bat.
Viv was a colossus, the king of cool with a swagger that had not been seen before and has not been seen since. A panther in the field contributing to 1975 World Cup glory with his tracer like arm throwing down the stumps.
Of note, I loved it when Steve Waugh had the intestinal fortitude to bounce Viv at the Gabba.
My best: Well I can’t go past the Sheik of Tweak, the Sultan of Spin, Shane Keith Warne. What a competitor, never say die. Just wish he’d start eating pizza and baked beans again as he appears to be going soft since hooking up with Liz.
Less spray tans too please Shane.
Rugby league
In an era of toughness one player stood out for me – Les Boyd. He destroyed the Pommies on Kangaroo tours; he was incredibly quick off the mark and had amazing ball skills. Locally, he would be targeted by the opposition packs but never took a backward step.
Ironically, despite his toughness, Boyd may be remembered for two cheap shots when elbowing an unprotected jaw and attempting to remove the eyes of his opponent.
Nonetheless, this is a personal choice and Boyd would have been the player I wanted to play like.
Andrew Johns was a sensational player. An inspirational leader, he could tackle like a second rower, was without peer in passing, had a shrewd kicking game and was always brilliant reader of the tempo of the game. He was brilliant and the best I have seen.
Billy Slater does some freakish things on a field, Cameron Smith is consistently sublime and more often than not, Greg Inglis is just too good.
I’m sure this may raise a few eyebrows, but Darren Lockyer gets my gong as the greatest player. I have never seen a playmaker lead a team around the field the manner that Lockyer did. His record speaks for itself. He was durable, tough and just a champion player.
AFL
I am from NSW and spent most of my life in Sydney. According to AFL nuts from Victoria, South Australia and Western Australia, my vote will not really count for much in any case. I’m going to keep this short and sweet – Wayne Carey is the greatest. Big, strong, imposing and inspirational. That mob of Kangaroos that raised him sure taught him how to kick straight. I was at Telstra Dome when the King played against his old firm for the first time. Crows won and the villain got away with it.
Tennis
I enjoy the rivalry and tradition of tennis. Granted, the commentators can get carried away a little when they too frequently describe a bass line dominant match as a “real war” or a “slug fest”.
Federer, Nadal, Sampras and possibly Djokovic to follow have all time Grand Slam records.
Rod Laver was considered a great in an era when the Aussies were rampant.
For the sheer theatre and competitiveness of the man, my pick is the Superbrat John McEnroe. The streetwise New Yorker would cheat to win, would play to win and would often win. While not up there with the Federers, Lavers and co, McEnroe was brilliant.
Motorcycles
Hailing from the South Coast, Wollongong Whiz Wayne Gardner took on the world and won again and again. He opened my eyes to the world of 500cc.
When he retired, I was still a fan: he drove a V8 sponsored by Donut King. I like donuts.
Mick Doohan took over the handlebars when Wayne hung up the leathers. Like Wayne, Mick dominated in a highly competitive era. He was shrewd with his tyres and a fine tactician.
Soccer / Football
I have heard good things about this Pele bloke and as a kid I bought his soccer game for my Atari. There is no denying his place in world football and even as one of the greatest icons of world sport.
I won’t kid myself or anyone else here, I do not follow soccer. In my defence, I have titled it “football” to appease the world game devotees.
I admit I was caught up in the euphoria of Germany World Cup when Australia rose to another level. Mark Schwarzer doesn’t seem to get the kudos as the Kewells and Cahills (probably because he is a goalie) however he has proven himself a player of world class. I also recall Craig Johnston sporting a premier mullet when playing the FA Cup for Liverpool.
Swimming
It is one of our nation’s most successful sports and one of our most favourite recreational pursuits. It is an incredibly demanding sport with hour after hour of dedicating oneself to following the black line. I have supreme respect for these athletes.
Dawn Fraser was apparently a bit of a larrikin and a terrific swimmer.
Thorpey had a set of big feet, a bigger motor and a really big trophy cabinet. A master of many disciplines.
Just nudging many great talents for my best is Kieran Perkins. He held the blue ribbon title for two olympics and was written off at Atlanta. After scraping in for the final, he emerged triumphantly after blitzing his opposition. A true Aussie battler win for the ages.
Cycling
While it was on too late for me to watch I have to admire the Tour De France victor Cadel Evans. Like Perkins at Atlanta, he was written off in the final stages and could have been afforded another, near enough result. He took the bit between the teeth and stared every one down in his penultimate time trial. A beast on wheels, Evans turned around an unsurmountable deficit into his lead.
One cannot mention Tour De France without Lance Armstrong. While there may be a current cloud over his head, cycling overall for that matter, I’d like to believe in miracles. To overcome cancer and compete in such a gruelling encounter is achievement in itself. To come back and win shows an extraordinary human being.
My greatest of all time
Robert Kelly Slater – even those unaccustomed with Pro Surfing have heard of Kelly Slater. 11 World Titles to his name and at 40 years young, shooting for number 12. Like this list, surfing is incredibly subjective. There is no hoop to have a ball dunked into, no net for a ball, no goal posts, no defined arena. This is what makes surfing such a challenging sport and Slater’s achievements all the more remarkable. Slater wins in all conditions.
How hard and demanding is surfing compared to other sports? Is it sport or a recreation? Try holding your breath in a washing machine for minutes on end then free-fall down the side of multi-story building and regain your feet with significant consequences if you fail to do so. Yes elite surfers overcome these obstacles but their athleticism is without question.
His recent victory in Fiji where the conditions were all time is an example of Slaters greatness. Slater has overcome many eras and rivalries in surfing and is still the benchmark for the new breed.
The Comaneci of the Curl, the Nureyev of the wave. He is perfection. (Editors note: He also plays off a scratch handicap in golf)
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
Other Sports articles
- Nadal, Serena affirm favouritism for French Open (15)
- Cheap Seats Podcast: episode two (14)
- Durant is a superhero, but not super enough (13)
- Can boxing great Pacquiao return to his former self? (12)
- Protecting sport or an infringement of human rights? (12)
- Will Mayweather vs Pacquiao happen? (11)
- French Open preview: Men’s draw most open in years. (10)
Recommend this story.
- Explore:
- Cricket, Darren Lockyer, Kelly Slater, muhammad ali, Shane Warne, surfing

June 28th 2012 @ 11:56am
Pogue Mahone said | June 28th 2012 @ 11:56am | Report comment
Ali can’t possibly be in contention as the greatest athlete in history since he wasn’t even the best boxer. Ray Robinson is the greatest boxer to ever lace on a pair of gloves, always has been, always will be. Ali may not even be the greatest heavyweight. Joe Louis statistically was better and we know for a fact that Joe Frazier was Ali’s equal when they fought their trilogy in the 70′s.
June 28th 2012 @ 12:19pm
johno said | June 28th 2012 @ 12:19pm | Report comment
Of course this article is based on the authors personally held beliefs and those sports people who inspired him and made him look at their sport in a completely different way. I would differ to his opinions on most people nominated here, with one exception – Ali.
for mine – Rugby League would be Mal Meninga, followed closely by King Wally Lewis. They defined what rugby league was to me in the brief daliance I had with the sport. Meninga was just unstoppable and the dominance he ahd with the Raiders was a golden era in the game. It was when origin burst onto the national scene with Mal leading the cane toads onto the field of battle. Just a beast of a player.
Cricket – you can’t pick a single player without looking at the different disciplines for mine. batsmen, pacemen, spinners and keepers. First and foremost is the Don. Unrivalled even by Tendulkar or Hobss. Pacemen are my favourites and will always hold Lilllee, Ambrose, Holding, Marshall, Akram and Thommo in the highest regard. For spinners there is Warnie and Murali, with Kumble statistically close behind. But what about O’Reilly and Laker (1944 first class wickets in his era is outstanding). Overall though the Don will always stand at the peak.
Tennis – you can’t ignore the ladies – Margaret Court, Navratilova and Serena and Venus have been the standouts. But overall what was achieved by Laver, two gland slams (in the true meaning) 10 years apart and being a key player in the professionalism of the game leaves him peerless in the game. That Federer holds him in the highest regard shows just what a player he was.
Aussies rules is where I get a bit nostalgic for my child hood heroes. Stephen Michael was a player that few outside of WA ever saw but those who did understood how good tihs bloke was. Polly Farmer redefined the game, the Krakouers and Maurice Rioli broke it apart in the 80′s for the wave of indigenous players to come. But my best of all comes from Geelong. Gary Ablett was just a force of nature.
Swimming. You can’t go past Dawn. Three times the Olympic 100 metre champion. She holds off stiff competition from Mark Spitz, Phelps and the host of aussies including Perkins, Gould, Hackett and Thorpe.
In cycling I bow to those with better knowledge than I and put up the name of Eddie Merchx. 5 times tour de france champ, 5 times Giro d’Italia puts him streets ahead of Lance in most purists eyes.
The best of all time? That is almost impossible to pick. But for sheer record breaking and gut running it would be hard not to put up Haile Gebrselassie who after almost 20 years at the peak of athletics is still winning, taking out the Vienna half marathon this year in a time of 1 hour and 52 seconds. This man is seemingly unstoppable.
June 29th 2012 @ 10:42am
JazzyJase said | June 29th 2012 @ 10:42am | Report comment
good read johno, Polly Farmer recently elevated to legend status
June 28th 2012 @ 12:21pm
Brick Tamlin of the Pants Party said | June 28th 2012 @ 12:21pm | Report comment
Kelly Slater was 15 years of everbody else in the nineties,the scary thing is he doesn’t even take surf comps serious anymore yet he still wins them and world titles.
June 29th 2012 @ 8:11am
JazzyJase said | June 29th 2012 @ 8:11am | Report comment
G’day Johno, yes purpose of article is my personal beliefs from my context. Clearly Mcenroe wouldn’t stack up on paper to Sampras, Federer etc but he is my favourite athlete.
the thing that stands Slater apart in my view is as mentioned by Brick Tamlin of the PP and BennO, they have changed the criteria for judging to include innovative moves. Slater is still light years ahead of the new breed. He is on the other side of 40, and is still dominating new eras.
the thing about Slater also, he has a solid foundation. While all the younguns are going for big airs and show pony moves, Slaters basis is at the core of surfing.
Again, just my personal views, I’m not silly enough to pretend i could pick the greatest
have a good day mate
June 28th 2012 @ 2:13pm
BennO said | June 28th 2012 @ 2:13pm | Report comment
Kelly is definitely GOAT in my view. The clincher for me is that every other best ever sportsman or woman would die in his arena but the same is not the case for him.
Imagine ali paddling in at 15 foot pipe. Maybe perkins could survive a wipeout at solid chopes but maybe not. Warnie dropping in at the eddie? He’d be a goner. Literally I think they would die.
Sure kelly would come last at the tour de france but he wouldn’t die.
Add to that, 20 years of dominance in a sport where the conditions of the playing field change every event, and during events, and you’ve got an athlete like no other in sport. He’s seen off 3 generations of competitors and resoundingly beaten them all.
June 28th 2012 @ 3:02pm
nick said | June 28th 2012 @ 3:02pm | Report comment
You think Kelly Slater could go 12 rounds with 1974 era George Foreman? He’d die inside 2 with that colossus beating on him.
Slater wouldn’t finish the tour de france let alone come last.
Strange argument
June 28th 2012 @ 3:13pm
BennO said | June 28th 2012 @ 3:13pm | Report comment
I agree it is a strange argument but it’s true. I reckon he’d go down after one hit from George and the fight would be over, but he wouldn’t die.
The point is though, that he’s a tremendous athlete who has dominated his sport like few others have in their own, and he does this in a sport that would be life or death for any of the others. Pretty awesome.
June 28th 2012 @ 4:13pm
Brick Tamlin of the Pants Party said | June 28th 2012 @ 4:13pm | Report comment
I’d rather be hit by a boxer than being pulled into some of those things at teauphoo.
June 28th 2012 @ 9:12pm
Nick said | June 28th 2012 @ 9:12pm | Report comment
Boxers die in the ring from time to time. Fairly confident a surfer would be a prime candidate to die if he caught one in the wrong spot from a power hitter like foreman
June 28th 2012 @ 5:12pm
Saint EC said | June 28th 2012 @ 5:12pm | Report comment
Surfing is an elite sport only popular in certain parts of the world where the conditions are right for surfing. Slater may be easily the best surfer ever, but it’s a really long stretch from that to say he’s the best sportsperson ever.
There are probably 100+ times more recreational football (soccer) players than surfers in the world, so the best footballers are much more likely to be overall better sportspeople.
June 28th 2012 @ 7:58pm
Brick Tamlin of the Pants Party said | June 28th 2012 @ 7:58pm | Report comment
Maybe he is the best in the individual sports department, a team game is a whole different thing.I mean the greatest footballer at the minute in my opinion is Messi but would he so great if he didnt have Xavi and Iniesta beside him?Football is my favourite sport but i think when it comes to the best ever sports person i’d give the nod to someone who’s out there on their own.
June 28th 2012 @ 7:20pm
Swampy said | June 28th 2012 @ 7:20pm | Report comment
Slater is amazing.
Greatest athlete of all time however is Michael Jordan.
–
Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download The Roar’s iPhone App in the App Store here.
June 29th 2012 @ 8:15am
JazzyJase said | June 29th 2012 @ 8:15am | Report comment
Hi Swamp, i regret leaving Jordan out of this discussion. Never seen a man walk on air like Mike did
June 28th 2012 @ 8:56pm
The Great G Nepia said | June 28th 2012 @ 8:56pm | Report comment
The greatest of all time has to be hulk hogan.
June 28th 2012 @ 9:14pm
Nick said | June 28th 2012 @ 9:14pm | Report comment
Fantastic.
Obviously it’s Richie McCaw though
June 29th 2012 @ 8:17am
JazzyJase said | June 29th 2012 @ 8:17am | Report comment
Hello Hulkamaniac, mate, fairly subjective given Balboa gave it to him in that exhibition fight
June 28th 2012 @ 8:56pm
Swampy said | June 28th 2012 @ 8:56pm | Report comment
Brick, is Roger Federer greater than Wayne Gretzky because Federer is an individual and Gretzky was only part of a team?
–
Comment left via The Roar’s iPhone app. Download The Roar’s iPhone App in the App Store here.
June 29th 2012 @ 3:21pm
Brick Tamlin of the Pants Party said | June 29th 2012 @ 3:21pm | Report comment
Well if i were to make my own personal list individual sportsman would head that list,doesn’t mean im right.My favourite sports are team sports but i have a different respect for your Boxer,Tennis player,Cyclist,Sprinter etc because they’ve got no-one to lift them if their having a bad day(your fave Jordan had Scotty Pippen for instance in those Bulls glory days but of course Jordan was a superior player).So yeah i’d put Federer ahead of Gretzky personally.I wonder where Usain Bolt would sit amongst the all time greats if he indeed runs 9.30 seconds at the Olympics like he says he will,surely being the fastest human being to walk the earth counts for somethiing.
June 29th 2012 @ 8:41am
The Bush said | June 29th 2012 @ 8:41am | Report comment
Sorry, I just can’t agree;
1. As mentioned above, Slater competes in a sport who’s “talent” pool to draw on is incredibly small. Unfortunately, rightly or wrongly, athletes that particpate in minor sports are at a disadvantage because they have so little competition. Slater is clearly the best athlete to ever get on a surf board, but how few of them have?
2. He particpates in a sport based on judging. This may be just me, but I find it difficult to accept anything as a sport which requires a judge (though the skeptics would say a referee is a “judge”).
3. I’m not really sure what a World Title is in surfing – though I assume it means he won the most points over tournaments throughout the year? In that case, why not consider the fact that from about the end of 2003 until sometime in 2010, a period of give or take seven (7) years, Roger Federer was essentially the World Number One the whole time. Isn’t that the equivalent of a “world title”, by staying World Number One for the majority of a year?
Roger Federer open wins from 2003 to 2010;
2003 – WI
2004 – AU, WI, US
2005 – WI, US
2006 – AU, WI, US
2007 – AU, WI, US
2008 – US
2009 – FR, WI
2010 – AU
That period from 2004 to 2007 is simply phenominal for anyone athlete to be so dominant for so long in such a competative sport. In his time he has also won six (6) ATP World Tour Finals, a tournament at the end of the year involving the worlds best players, a sort of straight “the best” tournament each year.
I’m not saying Federer’s the greatest sportsman ever, but he did all that in a sport that has a world footprint a hundred (100) times larger than surfing and he wasn’t awarded it by judges either…
June 29th 2012 @ 9:26am
BennO said | June 29th 2012 @ 9:26am | Report comment
No one will change your mind on the subjective vs objective point, The Bush, and fair enough. It’s a good point. But as for raw results, I think Slater is superior to Federer. For starters he’s been world number one 11 years not just 7, and he’s done it in two different decades.
Slater won the world title (finished the season ranked number 1 after multiple surf contests) in 1992, and then continuously from 1994 -1998. He then retired for a few years. He came back in 2002 and his results are as follows:
2002: 9th
2003: 2nd
2004: 3rd
2005: 1st
2006: 1st
2007: 2nd
2008: 1st
2009: 6th
2010: 1st
2011: 1st
2012: currently 2nd
He’s won 50 ASP contests over 20 years, where there are about 6 – 8 a year that count toward the world title. Surfing is different from tennis in that only certain contests count toward the world title so you’re always competing against the whole field.
Regarding numbers…it’s true there are more professional tennis players (there’s a lot more money in it) but there are a lot of surfers on this planet! There are apparently 3 million surfers in Australia alone. Got a board in your garage yourself? You’re a surfer competing with slater
I’m just mucking around there. I pretty much take your point about player numbers.
June 29th 2012 @ 11:49am
The Bush said | June 29th 2012 @ 11:49am | Report comment
BennO,
Don’t get me wrong, the bloke is clearly the Bradman of surfing, but just like I’d be loathe to call Bradman the greatest athlete ever (though there is a fantastic argument for it which I’d love to have), I struggle to see how Slater could be considered so as Surfing is just such a small sport.
I’d also not suggest that Federer is in the same class within his sport as Slater, but when you consider how many other athletes of true sporting ability he has to compete against, a reign at the top like that is pretty damn amazing…
June 29th 2012 @ 10:20am
JazzyJase said | June 29th 2012 @ 10:20am | Report comment
Fair comment The Bush.
Federer’s stats speak for themselves.
Surfing is a subjective sport – and my greatest ever athlete is a subjective opinion.
I would question though your comment regarding talent pool and surfing being a minor sport. the competition structure is incredibly demanding these days and a bit more involved than what you may perceive
June 29th 2012 @ 11:54am
The Bush said | June 29th 2012 @ 11:54am | Report comment
JazzyJase,
I’m not here to change your opinion, like you said, this is a subjective conversation, I just can’t agree.
I didn’t meant to belittle Surfing as a sport, but to even suggest that the number of high quality athletes that enter surfing would represent 1% of the high quality athletes that enter tennis would simply be false. When it comes to a worldwide talent pool and thus a true representation of sporting ability, it’s hard to go past golf, tennis, basketball, track and field and of course football (soccer).
This is why the Olympics are so fantastic when you really think about it, because it is truly pitting “the best against the best” for so many sports.
June 29th 2012 @ 12:12pm
JazzyJase said | June 29th 2012 @ 12:12pm | Report comment
loving the discusssion The Bush, all good mate. Looking forward to the Olympics and some late nights too
June 29th 2012 @ 11:18am
TheSuperhighway said | June 29th 2012 @ 11:18am | Report comment
Firstly, great article Jazzy. First time caller, long time listner.
I must say, my work efficiency drops dramatically whenever you pen another one of your bonzer articles. Keep ‘em coming please.
Usually these GOAT articles are pretty insular so it is refreshing to see someone cover multiple sports.
I’d like to point out that Nick is catergorically correct. This article could be composed of two words: Richie McCaw.
If my life were on the line he would be the bloke I would have open the batting (by himself), at first drop and wagging the tail. A true living legend in my eyes.
p.s. I also like donuts. Incidentally, what are your thoughts on nachos?
June 29th 2012 @ 12:20pm
JazzyJase said | June 29th 2012 @ 12:20pm | Report comment
Hi The Superhighway aka first time long time,
appreciate the feedback – i would struggle to pen an article claiming to have the definitive all time greatest athlete….just too difficult to quantify.
i use to enjoy watching them rexona athlete challenges where nrl players, ironmen, soccer players etc would compete on even grounds. Bit hard to do on a global stage and even the selection process would be hard for who would qualify.
Have to concede that Richie Mccaw is a amazing competitor and leader.
Donuts are out of this world and to the first Aztec who crushed some corn and covered in cheese with a dollop of guacamole – i salute you
June 29th 2012 @ 3:55pm
nick said | June 29th 2012 @ 3:55pm | Report comment
Richie is so good he could bat both ends and open the bowling to himself, and his other self at the other end.
It goes without saying he’d be the umpire too