Prime Minister’s XI v West Indies: Live updates from Manuka Oval
By Brett McKay, 29 Jan 2013 Brett McKay is a Roar Expert
- Tagged:
- Cricket, Prime Minister's XI, Ricky Ponting, Usman Khawaja
340 Have your say
Australian Test cricketer Ricky Ponting announces his retirement during a press conference on the eve of the third cricket Test between South Africa and Australia in Perth. (AFP PHOTO / Greg WOOD)
In years gone by, this match has been the National Capital’s one big day on the cricket calendar, when the touring side take on the notional selection of the Prime Minister.
Join me on The Roar for live updates and scintillating discussion from around 2:00pm AEDT today.
However, with Australia taking on the West Indies in a one day international in Canberra next Wednesday, the first time the Australian team has ever played at Manuka Oval, the annual PM’s clash has taken something of a backseat this summer.
The PM’s game still takes on an extra significance of its own, though. It’s not just today’s match, for starters. The erection of six 47m state-of-the-art HD-broadcast quality light towers at a cost of more than $5 million means that, for the first time at Manuka, it’s tonight’s match.
Venue history aside, the match also has several little sub-plots within, all of them worthy of closer attention.
For the West Indies, this match represents the first outing in Australia since they took out the ICC World Twenty20 in Colombo last October. But this limited overs tour of Australia will also be about redemption, as the Windies look to bounce back from the series loss to Bangladesh in December.
The Windies squad arrived in Canberra over the weekend to prepare for this match and the tour, and is largely as expected, personnel-wise.
Darren Sammy will lead a team that is reasonably well-known locally, with Chris Gayle, Kieron Pollard, Kemar Roach, and Sunil Narine returning after playing in the Big Bash League, while Dwayne and Darren Bravo also return.
The facial injury to Marlon Samuels has allowed the return to international cricket of Ramnaresh Sarwan, who hasn’t played for the West Indies in more than 18 months.
In Prime Minister Julia Gillard’s side, the focus will largely fall on two batsmen at the opposite ends of their international careers.
For Ricky Ponting, who will captain the PM’s XI, this match represents his final outing on the international stage. After 17 years of first class cricket and more than 560 appearances for his country, Ponting will lead a national selection one last time, and will play in only his second PM’s team, albeit 20 years after his first.
Naturally, all eyes will also be on Usman Khawaja, as he further presses his claims for inclusion in the Test team for the tour to India.
With so much commentary being made about Khawaja at the moment, I feel like I really don’t need to say much. Suffice to say, this match represents another opportunity for him on the national stage.
Young Tasmanians Alex Doolan and James Faulkner will be looking to leave an impression at this level, with both of them being mentioned as possible bolters for the Indian tour. The retirement of Mike Hussey and the obsession with finding an all-rounder is opening doors all over the country.
The PM’s side has had one forced change, with South Australian quick Kane Richardson replaced by Queensland’s Alistair McDermott. Richardson is still undergoing remedial action on his run-up after being removed from the attack during his ODI debut in Adelaide a fortnight ago.
Local eyes will look towards former Queanbeyan, Australia National University and Test wicket-keeper Brad Haddin, who, in his fourth PM’s XI appearance, will also be keen to keep his name in front of national selectors for the tours to India and England.
ACT Comets Captain Jono Dean was on the Melbourne Renegades’ supplementary list for the BBL, and the opening bat will also be using this match to put his name in front of state decision-makers that count.
Young quick Nick Winter is the PM’s 12th man, a nice reward for a successful ACT grade season with local club Eastlake. Winter was also one of the leading wicket-takers at the recent national under 19s championships.
Brett McKay is a former non-tackling scrumhalf and not-quite-1st Grade middle order stalwart. A rugby and cricket expert for The Roar since July 2009 (having joined in Sept 2008), Brett has written for Inside Rugby and Cricket Australia, and is also PLAY Canberra's rugby correspondent. He tweets from @BMcSport
The Crowd Says (340) | Page 1 of Comments
The Roar Live Blog: Latest comments displayed at the top of the page | Click here to jump to leave a comment
Have Your Say
- Explore:
- Cricket, Prime Minister's XI, Ricky Ponting, Usman Khawaja

11:13pm
Rob Barrow said | 11:13pm | Report comment
Agree with Nihar. Khawaja and Doolan continue to impress me and i think Khawaja can now get ready to get called up on Thursday with a fine 69 today. Doolan’s 87 was very good though he was dropped at 45 but still well done. Khawaja’s fielding was sharp and Red Kev has been saying for a while that the kid can field and we saw it tonight.Faulkner will be our test allrounder soon as well.
1:11am
Richard said | 1:11am | Report comment
I’d like to believe that Rob, but with the drunken sailors at the helm at the moment you wouldn’t know who they would pick. Maybe someone who cracked a funny joke, or who has -”something about him” which translates as “well connected and on the inside” . If Cricket Australia is going to start being run by private school types then we can expect to become the same as the Wallabies. A national laughing stock.
If we are going to be successful (against England) its really important to keep the private schools out of our national cricket set up(or at least marginalized), especially in test cricket. Leave them to oversee T20 and ODI’s where they can drink champagne and chuckle to their hearts content and take home the cash.
We need hard core people at the heart of Australian cricket, people schooled in the public system like Bradman and Keith Millar who was from Sunshine Melbourne pre war for christ sake. We need Waughs and the Pontings and the Borders in charge of our national game at the moment
11:01pm
Nihar said | 11:01pm | Report comment
Fantastic work by Faulkner and well desrved man of the match. Khawaja continues to impress not only with his 70 but also brilliant fielding to show that he has got this part of the game right now. I am hoping now we will see him in the Indian tour as our number 6 on Thurssday. And how good is this Deans, get him into one of the state squads.
11:32pm
Rob from Brumby Country said | 11:32pm | Report comment
That knock by Jono Dean was the highlight of the game for me. He just slaughtered the bowlers early on and took the match by the scruff of the neck – no hesitation, no inhibitions, it was thrilling to watch. Davey Warner couldn’t have done it better. Gilly could have… Just.
10:20pm
Brett McKay said | 10:20pm | Report comment
And that’ll do me here from Manuka Oval, it’s been a great day and evening of entertaining cricket, north of 650 runs for the day.
Great to part of history for ACT Cricket too, nd all bodes well for the one-dayer next week.
See you online soon…
10:44pm
Jake said | 10:44pm | Report comment
Another dropped catch from Usman, perhaps he hasn’t been working on his flaws as much as we have been told.
11:02pm
Nihar said | 11:02pm | Report comment
Jake that was hardly a catch, he was diving full length forward, time to give Khawaja credit where its due mate, his run out was brilliant and his general fielding today exceptional.
11:08pm
pope paul v11 said | 11:08pm | Report comment
Yep Khawaja’s the only one wth flaws. Not like Wadey “Come on Gary this bloke’s got no idea! Oops aw crap. Sorry Nathan”.
12:04am
Rob Barrow said | 12:04am | Report comment
I am sure Jake didn’t even see the catch it was a half chance.The Fox comentatrs said Khawaja fielded very well nd thiswill be a big plus for him in India, well done young man
10:17pm
Brett McKay said | 10:17pm | Report comment
PMs XI 333
West Indians 310
Powell 92
Sarwan 63
Russell 54
Faulkner the pick of the bowlers, taking 4/54.
10:15pm
Geoff Lemon said | 10:15pm | Report comment
Some knock from Russell though. 54 from 24 balls, 3 fours, 5 sixes.
10:14pm
Brett McKay said | 10:14pm | Report comment
BOWLED HIM Faulkner gets Tino Best neck and crop, and Kieron Powell isn’t coming back out, so the PM’s XI have won by 23 runs..
10:32pm
Jake said | 10:32pm | Report comment
Hey Brett, great coverage today. What players stood out the most to you today? I’m a big fan of Faulkner and by the sounds of it really took his chance. Has Moses/Maxwell just gotten company for the vacant spot in the test team?
10:13pm
Geoff Lemon said | 10:13pm | Report comment
Ah, Russell’s gone. Game over.
10:12pm
Brett McKay said | 10:12pm | Report comment
GOT HIM! Russell holes out, not getting a pull shot properly, putting it down Jono Dean’s throat at deep midwicket. Another wicket fro Faulkner, he’s got 3/51 now, and could be a smokey for MotM..
WI need 24 from 9..
10:08pm
Brett McKay said | 10:08pm | Report comment
ON THE ROOF! RUssell puts Ahmed onto the Bob Hawke Stand roof, that one’s OUTTA HERE!!
WI need 28 from 12..
10:08pm
Geoff Lemon said | 10:08pm | Report comment
Russell is killing it here, 48 from 22 balls.
10:09pm
Geoff Lemon said | 10:09pm | Report comment
And raises his 50 with another six.
10:06pm
Brett McKay said | 10:06pm | Report comment
Fawad Ahmed back in from the Manuka Pool end
a dot ball is followed by some sloppy fielding on the boundary, Doolan let’s it through.
37 off 15
10:07pm
Red Kev said | 10:07pm | Report comment
Sounds like everyone is fielding poorly
10:05pm
Captain StatsObvious said | 10:05pm | Report comment
Andre Russell now third in most 6s in a limited overs match at Manuka
1. Gayle 8; 2. Cooper 6; 3. Russell 5.
10:10pm
Geoff Lemon said | 10:10pm | Report comment
May need to equal Gayle’s record if they’re to win this. 28 needed off 12.
10:04pm
Brett McKay said | 10:04pm | Report comment
BOOM! Another big one from Russell, into the hill stand again. Can hit a big ball.
And then follows it with a great boundary along the carpet behind point.
WI need 41 from 18..
10:02pm
Brett McKay said | 10:02pm | Report comment
WICKET! McDermott strikes, Thomas lets one get big on him, and McDermott takes the top edge himself
WI need 51 from 20, and I think it might be getting away on them now..
9:59pm
Brett McKay said | 9:59pm | Report comment
McDermott back on at the southern end, Windes need 53 off 24 balls. Andre Russell has to be the man..
10:06pm
Allanthus said | 10:06pm | Report comment
Pretty good death bowling at both ends (oops may have gone a bit early…)
Thanks Brett for the commentary by the way. Hope you’re getting paid per post…..
9:59pm
Geoff Lemon said | 9:59pm | Report comment
Is Powell not allowed to come back after retiring hurt? He only had cramps.
10:00pm
Brett McKay said | 10:00pm | Report comment
He is, but the unofficial word is they won’t risk him tonight..
9:57pm
Geoff Lemon said | 9:57pm | Report comment
Sarwan has only scored off 43 of his 83 deliveries, for 63 runs.
9:56pm
Brett McKay said | 9:56pm | Report comment
WICKET! Sarwan’s gone this time, holing out at long-on. McDermott takes the catch, and Faulkner again is showing his death-overs ability
WI need 59 from 28
9:53pm
Brett McKay said | 9:53pm | Report comment
About the only thing that might slow Russell is his continuing knee problem; he had to come from the field after bowling earlier, but it’s not hampering his ability to swing th bat!
WI need 59 from 30…
9:51pm
Geoff Lemon said | 9:51pm | Report comment
Russell has dragged that required rate back under 12 for the moment.
9:54pm
Brett McKay said | 9:54pm | Report comment
42 off the last 3.1 overs apparently..
9:51pm
Brett McKay said | 9:51pm | Report comment
SIX!! Russell goes again, this time caught three rows from the top of the stand at the southern end. Big bomb..
WI need 65 from 34
9:48pm
Brett McKay said | 9:48pm | Report comment
So the equation with six overs to go is that the Windies need 72 to win off 36 balls
Not an impossible task, but….
9:47pm
Geoff Lemon said | 9:47pm | Report comment
More like Ramnaresh Slowan, am I right fellers?
9:49pm
Brett McKay said | 9:49pm | Report comment
I see what you’ve done there, nice…
9:43pm
Brett McKay said | 9:43pm | Report comment
SIX SIX!! Russell goes bang-bang, sending two well over midwicket into the south-western stands..
9:44pm
Brett McKay said | 9:44pm | Report comment
The scond of the two was taken by a man in an orage shirt, a really good running catch along the concourse. And he’s still milking it, and over-and-a-bit later…
9:48pm
Allanthus said | 9:48pm | Report comment
There you go, another one. It’s like cricket followers all around the country have been out practising their high catches all summer!
9:38pm
Brett McKay said | 9:38pm | Report comment
WICKET! Sammy goes this time, giving Ashton Turner his first wicket for the night.
Gurinder Sandhu – who’s not had the best night in the field – has taken the catch, but did his best to drop it. He’s let the elbows get away from him, coughed the ball up, and then regathered mid-fall to claim the catch and then hit the ground. Spectacular, if a little clumsy..
Windies have lost 4/42, 5/47 if you count Powell going off hurt..
WI 5/230 after 41
9:28pm
Brett McKay said | 9:28pm | Report comment
West Indies 4/219 after 40 overs now,
Sarwan 45*
Sammy 0*
9:36pm
Allanthus said | 9:36pm | Report comment
Finally got a look at the telly for 20 mins and… nothing much happening!!! Seems like there’s no intent or urgency in the run chase?
9:39pm
Brett McKay said | 9:39pm | Report comment
They’re in the middle of a collapse, actually..
9:27pm
Brett McKay said | 9:27pm | Report comment
Official crowd figure is 9583, which is a little less than I thought was here, but healthy nonetheless..
9:25pm
Brett McKay said | 9:25pm | Report comment
Of course, having just said that…
WICKET! Pollard skies one and Handscomb takes the steepler, which was pretty tough actually, he had to make a couple of adjustments as it swirled in the air..
9:23pm
Brett McKay said | 9:23pm | Report comment
PMs fielding in general has been a bit off in the last ten or so overs, Khawaja’s dropped chance, Handscomb’s drop off Ahmed earlier on, and some sloppy ground fielding at times, too…
12:06am
Rob Barrow said | 12:06am | Report comment
Brett Khawaja’s chance was a half chance, he fielded brilliantly tonight including a very good run out and you failed to mention Doolan’s terrible ground fielding, cummon mate show some fairness in your commentory.
9:11pm
Brett McKay said | 9:11pm | Report comment
The PMs XI are getting rid of the right man, while ever Sarwan is taking his time, the pressure will stay on the other bat to do the damage..
WI 3/201 after 36
Sarwan 36*
Pollard 0*
9:13pm
Rhys said | 9:13pm | Report comment
If they dismiss Pollard cheaply the PMs XI should get the money. If Pollard stays in for 10 overs the Windies will win.
9:20pm
Geoff Lemon said | 9:20pm | Report comment
If Pollard stays in for 10 overs he’ll chase anything.
9:21pm
Brett McKay said | 9:21pm | Report comment
And Khawaja’s just dropped him at backward point, too, Rhys. It was a sharp chance, but Khawaja had a good view of it and got both hands to it. Probabaly should’ve taken it..
9:10pm
Brett McKay said | 9:10pm | Report comment
BOWLED HIM! Dwayne Bravo goes to Faulkner, who got one through the defences.
Pollard comes in, and he’s got some work ahead of him with the required RR now abouve 9rpo..
9:03pm
Brett McKay said | 9:03pm | Report comment
SIX! Dwayne Bravo’s wasted no time in getting set, putting Sandhu over long-off for six.
The Windies have brought the 200 up as we go to drinks in after 35 overs, and this is already shaping as the key partnership if they’re to get close to the required 334..
WI 2/200
Sarwan 36*
DJ Bravo 18*
8:58pm
Geoff Lemon said | 8:58pm | Report comment
Evening, Brett. Sarwan soaking up too many dots here, isn’t he?
9:06pm
Brett McKay said | 9:06pm | Report comment
we’ve jut been saying how he’s been in the mid-30s for a while now – he’s 36 off 54 balls, so yeah, he’s taking his time. Mind you, if the other end’s swinging, he’s probably doing the job..
8:55pm
Brett McKay said | 8:55pm | Report comment
DROPPED! Dwayne Bravo goes for big booming drive and is missed by keeper Handscomb. Heartbreak for the hard-working Ahmed, deserved better than to be let down by his Victorian squad team-mate..
8:58pm
Red Kev said | 8:58pm | Report comment
Bummer, his figures make it look like he’s bowling well.
9:08pm
Brett McKay said | 9:08pm | Report comment
His flight looks good Kev, but I’m not sure what his line’s like from square-on where I am. Mr O’Connell watching on tv just tweeted to me that he looks pretty good..
9:01pm
Rhys said | 9:01pm | Report comment
Handscomb has had a bit of a shocker this match. That waltz down the pitch to be out stumped effort was definitely a brain fade of the highest order.
8:49pm
Brett McKay said | 8:49pm | Report comment
WICKET! Ahmed gets Bravo, well caught by Doolan at deep backward square for 6..
WI 2/179 in the 31st
Sarwan 35*
Dwayne Bravo replaces Darren..
8:47pm
Brett McKay said | 8:47pm | Report comment
West Indies 1/173 after 30 overs
Sarwan 34*
Darren Bravo 1*
The spinners hae looked OK, youn Turner’s got 0/33 from his six and has nice flight about him, and Fawad Ahmed has 0/35 in his 7th. Ahmed has a really useful wrong’un too, it’s deceived sevearl tonight..
8:43pm
Brett McKay said | 8:43pm | Report comment
Kieron Powell has been strggling wih cramp from the last 15 minutes or so, and theyve taken ther toll, forcing him to retire hurst on 92* from 97 balls..
Darren Bravo the new man in..
8:44pm
Red Kev said | 8:44pm | Report comment
So there are going to be over 600 runs scored this match and no-one will make a century … odd.
8:37pm
Brett McKay said | 8:37pm | Report comment
So we’re very much into that stereotypical middle section of the innings, with Powell and Sarwan batting without much risk and making sure they’re there fro the chrage at the end. With the Bravos and Pollard still to come, the Windies certainly can’t be ruled out just yet.
After 29 overs, West Indies are 1/169
Powell has moved smartly to 90
Sarwan 33*
8:36pm
Captain StatsObvious said | 8:36pm | Report comment
Tino Best’s figures were the second worst of any visiting bowler in the modern era
9:58pm
Brett McKay said | 9:58pm | Report comment
Ha, I’ve just worked out who this is…
8:29pm
Captain StatsObvious said | 8:29pm | Report comment
James Faulkner’s 44* was the highest by a number 7 against the West Indies, passing Brian James’ 22 in 1960/61
9:38pm
Atawhai Drive said | 9:38pm | Report comment
That 1961 match ended in a tie.
8:24pm
Brett McKay said | 8:24pm | Report comment
Right, apologies for that short delay, out getting some snaps…
West Indies are still going along pretty comfortably, thought the required run rate is gettng up toward 7.5 runs an over…
WI 1/150
Powell 75*
Sarwan 29*
8:34pm
Red Kev said | 8:34pm | Report comment
I don’t imagine they’re too far behind the PMs XI but the question will be if they can accelerate like Haddin and Faulkner did.
8:40pm
Brett McKay said | 8:40pm | Report comment
no, they’re probably not Kev – and I haven’t got the equvalents handy – and certianly if these two can get though to the 40th, then they’ll be rigt in the bx seat..
7:54pm
Brett McKay said | 7:54pm | Report comment
West Indies 1/108 after 19, with Drinks coming onto the field the old-fashioned way. No oversized bottles on segways, thankyou…
Powell 56*
Sarwan 7*
7:47pm
Brett McKay said | 7:47pm | Report comment
Fifty for Kieron Powell off 53 balls, rather taking us by surprise; he’s batted without much fanfare too, but has been accumulating nicely..
West Indies 1/102 after 17
Powell 54*
Sarwan 5*
7:43pm
Brett McKay said | 7:43pm | Report comment
At the end of the 15th, the Windies are 1/94, which is still pretty close to the required rate.
Powell and Sarwan look like they’re already into that ‘middle over’ mode, and as long as they can keep the Jack Fingleton Scoreboard ticking over, they can put the Windies well on course..
7:43pm
Dadiggle said | 7:43pm | Report comment
I bet the Windies brought that party atmosphere with them. They can light up any place
7:38pm
Brett McKay said | 7:38pm | Report comment
My Captain Obvious stats man has just advised that if the Windies get the required 334, it’ll be the highest ever run chase at Manuka under lights…..
7:35pm
Brett McKay said | 7:35pm | Report comment
Fawad Ahmed is into the attack from te southern end, and Ramnaresh Sarwan is the new man to the crease..
7:33pm
Varun said | 7:33pm | Report comment
And who said khawaja has fielding issues, fantastic runout from point diving head on
7:31pm
Brett McKay said | 7:31pm | Report comment
WICKET! Here’s one for the Khawaja fans, some great fielding of his from point has seen Charles run out for 35
West Indies 1/83 in the 12th over..
7:37pm
Allanthus said | 7:37pm | Report comment
Sounds like a great day’s entertainment so far. Somehow beats sitting at a desk working, then making dinner and – hello, the cherry on top – “why don’t you fold the washing while you’re waiting?” Yeah, great idea, now why didn’t i think of that first…?
7:40pm
Brett McKay said | 7:40pm | Report comment
so far so good, yeah. Good first innings, hopefully a good second dig too…
7:26pm
Brett McKay said | 7:26pm | Report comment
We have a change of footwear for Johnson Charles currently, presumably going tfor the longer spikes…
Powell’s just played Sandhu through mid-wicket before, with a real David Gower appearance to the shot. Four off the bat..
7:25pm
Dadiggle said | 7:25pm | Report comment
This game could be over in 40
7:28pm
Brett McKay said | 7:28pm | Report comment
It’ll be highly entertaining batting if it is! They’re currently going at a bit over a run-a-ball, and they needed more than 6.5 from the outset..
7:24pm
Dadiggle said | 7:24pm | Report comment
Powell is warming up lol
7:19pm
Brett McKay said | 7:19pm | Report comment
Ashton Turner is coming into the attack, replacing Faulkner at the Manuka Pool end.
West Indies are 0/57 after 9..
7:17pm
Brett McKay said | 7:17pm | Report comment
Charles is still providing the highjlights reel so far, with an equal mix of brutal and agricultural..
West Indies 0/50 after 8
Charles 29*
Powell 13*
Faulkner 0/24 from his 4
McDermott 0/21
Gurinder Sandhu is into the attack…
7:14pm
Dadiggle said | 7:14pm | Report comment
44/0 after 7 Charles Smashing sixes how big is that ground? Charles ain’t this good IMO
7:17pm
Brett McKay said | 7:17pm | Report comment
Bigger than the MCG…
7:23pm
Dadiggle said | 7:23pm | Report comment
So bigger than a postage stamp got ya
7:03pm
Brett McKay said | 7:03pm | Report comment
0/29 after 5 overs, just a measily 305 to get from the remaining 45…
7:11pm
Dadiggle said | 7:11pm | Report comment
Windies got big hitters hows the Aussies bowlers?
6:59pm
Brett McKay said | 6:59pm | Report comment
Johnson Charles seem to be taking on the role of Chris Gayle tonight, playing a couple of booming bombs down the ground already, wth a real stand-and-deliver method. Might be one to keep an eye on for the ODIs..
6:55pm
Brett McKay said | 6:55pm | Report comment
West Indies 0/14 after 3
Powell 4no
Charles 7no
Both openers are looking a touch tentative, which is probably understandable for the first hit of a tour..
6:51pm
Brett McKay said | 6:51pm | Report comment
SIX! And there’s the first maximum of the West Indies, Johnson Charles putting Faulkner over the same section of rope that Faulkner himself was clearing before the break..
6:46pm
Brett McKay said | 6:46pm | Report comment
Wow, we’re back already. That went quickly..
Alistair McDermott started with two legside wides, and it appears that Peter Handscomb has the gloves on instead of Brad Haddin.
West Indies 0/3 after the first over..
6:18pm
Brett McKay said | 6:18pm | Report comment
This is how the last over went:
49.1 – Faulkner slashes behind point for 4
49.2 – 4 wides!
49.2 – 1 to Sammy at mid-off. Faulkner goes to 43 off 26 balls
49.3 – WICKET Haddin bowled trying to whip fine down the leg side..
49.4 – dot ball, an agricultural swing from Ashton Turner
49.5 – 3 behind point, Faulkner ran superbly to get back for three, the ball only made it 3/4 the way to the boundary
49.6 – DROPPED! Johnson Charles nearly takes another screamer, but Faulkner gets the single
PM’s XI finish with 6/333 from their 50 overs
Doolan 87
Khawaja 69
Dean 51
Faulkner 44no
Haddin 39
Narine 2/32
Pollard 2/37
DJ Bravo 1/75
Best 1/84
Windies will need 334 to win under the new lights at Manuka, and I’ll be back in half an hour with the chase..
6:17pm
Red Kev said | 6:17pm | Report comment
Pretty good score (333). Somewhat strange that no-one went on to get the hundred, all of them getting out trying to push the pace. Will be very interesting to see how the Windies bat – I know Sir Viv was talking down (lambasting maybe) their bowling attack when interviewed this summer – is their batting good enough to chase down that score, if Faulkner bowls well he could be MoM.
6:23pm
Allanthus said | 6:23pm | Report comment
Agreed, good solid score, will take some getting without Gayle to kick start.
Brett, enjoy your party pie and can of fizzy drink…
6:56pm
Brett McKay said | 6:56pm | Report comment
full size pie, and hot too, which isn’t always the case..
6:11pm
Dadiggle said | 6:11pm | Report comment
Where are they playing btw?
6:20pm
Brett McKay said | 6:20pm | Report comment
Manuka Oval in Canberra. Maybe that should have been in the heading…
6:46pm
Jake said | 6:46pm | Report comment
Who’s playing? Maybe you should have put that in the heading too! Ha.
7:00pm
Brett McKay said | 7:00pm | Report comment
Ha..
6:08pm
Dadiggle said | 6:08pm | Report comment
42 need 8
6:05pm
Dadiggle said | 6:05pm | Report comment
On 37 can he get his 50 lol
6:05pm
Brett McKay said | 6:05pm | Report comment
Last over to come, the PMs XI are 5/319. Good call, 320…
6:04pm
Brett McKay said | 6:04pm | Report comment
Faulkner’s gone over cow corner again, and very nearly found the extended hand of Pollard on the rope. Next ball, he waits for a slower one from Dwayne Bravo and smashes it through point for 4…
6:00pm
Dadiggle said | 6:00pm | Report comment
I just love these blokes who score 1 from 6 balls then suddenly smash a couple to the boundary haha
5:57pm
Brett McKay said | 5:57pm | Report comment
Haddin and Faulkner have pushed things to 297, with Faulkner putting a massive six over cow corner just before. My 320 is looking pretty good again..
6:04pm
Red Kev said | 6:04pm | Report comment
Faulkner is cutting loose, I think your 320 is looking a little light-on Brett.
5:53pm
Allanthus said | 5:53pm | Report comment
Brett, sorry for all the questions, but Haddin? How’s he looking and do you consider him still in the mix?
5:57pm
Varun said | 5:57pm | Report comment
Surely khawaja and Doolan are ahead of Haddin
6:00pm
Allanthus said | 6:00pm | Report comment
Agreed Varun. But perhaps wiser heads than us on the NSP might consider Wade ahead of all of them as a batsman, and Haddin the best keeper. Not saying I agree with that but the way things have been going you never know what can happen…
RK already onto this below…
6:24pm
Varun said | 6:24pm | Report comment
Mate I am sure that after today khawaja and Doolan will be well ahead of Doolan
6:25pm
Varun said | 6:25pm | Report comment
Well ahead of Haddin, typo
7:07pm
pope paul v11 said | 7:07pm | Report comment
Well not wiser surely
5:59pm
Dadiggle said | 5:59pm | Report comment
Sssh he put the mockers on him too
5:59pm
Red Kev said | 5:59pm | Report comment
Haven’t the selectors already said he is the second wicketkeeper for the Ashes? Or do you mean as a specialist bat? With Inverarity and Arthur in charge I wouldn’t put it past them to reinstate him as keeper and play Wade as a bowling allrounder.
6:01pm
Brett McKay said | 6:01pm | Report comment
No probs at all Allanthus, keep ‘em coming..
He’s looks like he always has, to be honest, so my argument would be that if he wasn’t good enough to take his place back after the Caribbean tour, then nothing’s changed to make him a better player now. He probably will go as the second ‘keeper, but I’d still argue that Paine or someone else would be a better long term bet..
5:53pm
Dadiggle said | 5:53pm | Report comment
Faulkner showing Handscomb what to do when you get to the pitch have a sighter first
5:43pm
Dadiggle said | 5:43pm | Report comment
Brett do you have the Tony Gregg curse with you? Seems that you put the mockers on Doolan
5:46pm
Brett McKay said | 5:46pm | Report comment
I even called it beforehand, too, that’s the worst of it…
5:46pm
Red Kev said | 5:46pm | Report comment
Still the top three reads 51, 69, 87 – wouldn’t you love to see that on an Australian scorecard?
5:50pm
Dadiggle said | 5:50pm | Report comment
At moment take away the 1 9 and the 7 thats a Aussie scorecard
5:41pm
Brett McKay said | 5:41pm | Report comment
James Faulkber is the new man in, and here’s one for the stats hounds – James Faulkner, along with Alistair McDermott today, complete the first father-son combinations for the PMs XI in the modern era. That is, since Bob Hawke reintroduced the game back in the early 80s..
5:45pm
jameswm said | 5:45pm | Report comment
Faulkner? He had a dad who played?
5:49pm
Brett McKay said | 5:49pm | Report comment
Yep, Peter, who was a top order bat for Tassie in the early 80s, and played for the PM’s side in 1983/84.
Craig McDermott played in 1985/86, if my mail is correct..
5:45pm
Allanthus said | 5:45pm | Report comment
I thought Craig McDermott was Alistair’s dad? James Faulkner looks too young.
5:49pm
Rob from Brumby Country said | 5:49pm | Report comment
Haha classic!
5:50pm
Brett McKay said | 5:50pm | Report comment
well played that man…
5:37pm
Brett McKay said | 5:37pm | Report comment
OUT! And there’s the kiss of death, Doolan goes to a cracking full-length dive from Johnson Charles at point. 87 strikes again!
5:42pm
Red Kev said | 5:42pm | Report comment
Pollard got both Doolan and Khawaja, both of whom it seems from the commentary were trying to go after him – I hope the ODI squad take note of that.
5:42pm
matt h said | 5:42pm | Report comment
Poor form Mr McKay, to rob the young man of a century like that
5:35pm
Brett McKay said | 5:35pm | Report comment
Have to say, I’ve been imressed by Alex Doolan. He started a little slowly, but has looked pretty comfortable since the thirties. Offered the chance on 45, which Pollard dropped, but has been faultless since then.
He’s accumulated really well though, and suddenly, without much fanfare, he’s 81 and looking set for three figures, kiss of death pending…
EDIT – without much fanfare, did I say? Have a flat six over mid-wicket!!
5:37pm
Rob from Brumby Country said | 5:37pm | Report comment
What did you do?!
5:45pm
jameswm said | 5:45pm | Report comment
Thanks for taking my mantle Brett.
5:33pm
Brett McKay said | 5:33pm | Report comment
That’s Narine’s spell done, 2/32 off his ten overs and has bowled very well. He was main contributor to bringing the scoring ate down today, he’sgong to be the difference between the Windies needing 6 an over tonight, as opposed to the 7+ as was lookin likely ealy on..
PM’s XI 4/253 in the 43rd..
5:33pm
Dadiggle said | 5:33pm | Report comment
Doolan seems to be doing well the last couple of seasons. Is he too good to play for Australia?
5:39pm
Red Kev said | 5:39pm | Report comment
Nah this is the first year he’s really looked the goods. Last year he averaged a tick under 30, the year before a tick under 40.
This season he’s averaging 50-odd in the shield and got a 161* in the tour match against the South Africans; got himself an 87 here; but hasn’t performed well in the other formats or in other years.
5:41pm
Varun said | 5:41pm | Report comment
I think based on this games 69 and superior shield record it had to be khawaja at number 6 with Doolan as backup batsman
5:43pm
Red Kev said | 5:43pm | Report comment
Arthur is on espncricinfo talking up Wade at 6 and Maxwell at 7 in tests – someone should take a cricket bat to the side of his head.
5:48pm
matt h said | 5:48pm | Report comment
Nooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
7:12pm
pope paul v11 said | 7:12pm | Report comment
Someone should definately cricket bat him
5:51pm
Disco said | 5:51pm | Report comment
Oh, Uncle Arthur…
5:46pm
Dadiggle said | 5:46pm | Report comment
Seems like the guys who are performing well do not do well in the test arena. Maybe vice versa
5:26pm
Dadiggle said | 5:26pm | Report comment
Question why they call it a Prime Ministers XI?
5:30pm
Allanthus said | 5:30pm | Report comment
It was because Hawkey and then Little Johnny H fancied a game, and the only way they could get a run was if they picked the team themselves…
But that sort of fell through after Hawkey got sconned, and so PM’s had to stick to safer pursuits instead. Like swimming off Portsea/Cheviot back beach…
5:31pm
Red Kev said | 5:31pm | Report comment
Shame – I would like to have seen Johnny Howard bowling to Chris Gayle
5:32pm
Atawhai Drive said | 5:32pm | Report comment
Incumbent PM picks the team. Cricket tragics Menzies, Howard and Hawke actually did it themselves. I imagine Whitlam, Fraser, Keating and possibly Gillard needed a little help.
5:34pm
Dadiggle said | 5:34pm | Report comment
Its a wonder Campo is not in the team. Oh he loves her…….
5:36pm
Rob from Brumby Country said | 5:36pm | Report comment
I don’t believe there were any PM’s XI matches under Whitlam or Fraser.
5:39pm
Allanthus said | 5:39pm | Report comment
The other reason is because if the NSP picked the team Khawaja wouldn’t be in it and Maxwell would be…
5:40pm
Atawhai Drive said | 5:40pm | Report comment
Quite likely that the concept lapsed for some years.
5:44pm
Red Kev said | 5:44pm | Report comment
The NSP gives “guidance” to the PM on selections. It is basically an Australia A fixture nowadays.
6:58pm
Jake said | 6:58pm | Report comment
Hardly a Aus A team, mate. More of an up and coming team with a few oldies thrown in for appeal. Not too sure how many players in that 11 are pushing for Test selection, Red Kev, one maybe 2 at most…
6:55pm
Jake said | 6:55pm | Report comment
Because the PM selects the team.
5:24pm
Brett McKay said | 5:24pm | Report comment
ten overs to go, 4/237 now..
5:27pm
jameswm said | 5:27pm | Report comment
Narine has one over left, push it around for 4 or 5 and no wicket, and go at the others.
5:22pm
Brett McKay said | 5:22pm | Report comment
FOUR! Haddin plays a nice square drive to the point fence, and looks like he might be getting ready to go.
Doolan still looks solid, and he’s just played a beautiful back foot drive through cover for four…
5:35pm
matt h said | 5:35pm | Report comment
Oh Dear, he’s passed Khawaja’s score! Two international innings and two big scores for Doolan.
5:20pm
Atawhai Drive said | 5:20pm | Report comment
Are exhibition/friendly matches of this type usually televised? Were they ever on FTA TV?
5:23pm
Brett McKay said | 5:23pm | Report comment
AD, Fox started covering the PMs game a few years ago, but it’s never been on FTA..
5:20pm
Dadiggle said | 5:20pm | Report comment
Surely in the 38 over 300 should be easy.
5:18pm
langou said | 5:18pm | Report comment
Did I read that correctly…
Did Handscombe just go the charge down the pitch first ball?
5:20pm
Brett McKay said | 5:20pm | Report comment
You did and he did…
5:21pm
Dadiggle said | 5:21pm | Report comment
He was doing the Waltzing Matilda
5:16pm
Brett McKay said | 5:16pm | Report comment
There’s a bit of a slow feel about things suddenly, that maybe 300 might even take some getting from here. At 4/221 in the 38th, these two could push things past 300, but a few more wickets might see 270-280 even out of reach.
Narine’s bowling really well, no loose deliveries..
5:18pm
jameswm said | 5:18pm | Report comment
Is he actually turning it at all?
What was Handscomb thinking, charging him first ball?
5:19pm
Red Kev said | 5:19pm | Report comment
maybe he was channeling his inner Glenn Maxwell?
5:15pm
Dadiggle said | 5:15pm | Report comment
Ponting out for 15. Still better than the Aus no 3 avg haha
5:08pm
Brett McKay said | 5:08pm | Report comment
OUT! Ponting’s played all around from Narine, and is out bowled for 15.
PM’s XI is 3/215, Peter Handscomb is the new man in..
AND HE’S GONE TOO! Handscomb has tried to come down the track but missed by a lot, and was pretty comfortably stummped..
Brad Haddin come in on a hat-trick
5:02pm
Brett McKay said | 5:02pm | Report comment
PM’s XI 2/214 after 35 overs
Doolan 64*
Ponting 15*
Dwayne Bravo and Narine are still the pick of the bowlers, the quicks are going the journey, generally speaking..
5:04pm
jameswm said | 5:04pm | Report comment
even if we only go 6 an over for the next 5, we’ll be 245 with 10 to go. I think we’re loking at 320-320, unless either we lose some wickets or someone really gets going. But do we have any of those types left? Can Punter still do it, like that world cup final innings against India?
5:06pm
Red Kev said | 5:06pm | Report comment
No, no he cannot
7:00pm
Jake said | 7:00pm | Report comment
So you’re projecting a score of between 320 and 320?!?
5:02pm
Dadiggle said | 5:02pm | Report comment
Ponting to come out of retirement getting selected then avg 9 and back to retirement again….
4:59pm
Brett McKay said | 4:59pm | Report comment
SIX!! Vintage Ponting pulls in front of square, but dropped by the man in the first row of seats.
5:01pm
Allanthus said | 5:01pm | Report comment
Is it just me or has the quality of spectator catching really improved this season? (With the notable exception of this goose)
5:03pm
Brett McKay said | 5:03pm | Report comment
No-one’s beat that young bloke in Adelaide with the Farmer’s Union tucked underthe arm…
5:07pm
Allanthus said | 5:07pm | Report comment
Yes that was outstanding – bet he’s still pulling beers off his mates for that effort.
But, in all seriousness, there’s been some other good ones too.
4:56pm
Rob from Brumby Country said | 4:56pm | Report comment
The strike rate for the innings has just dipped below six runs an over for the first time since the start of the match. Ponting is trying to get his eye in, but I sense that even Doolan has checked himself. These two aren’t going to chance their arms too early, even with Handscombe and Haddin to come.
2/202 after 34 overs
4:56pm
Brett McKay said | 4:56pm | Report comment
Right, I’m back, network demons stuck again…
on Khawaja’s dismissal: Have to say, that dismissal won’t help his cause. With 20 overs left, it was a soft dismissal from a guy who was settled and should’ve been looking to really go on. Probably his only bad shot fot he innings, but you can’t help but think it might count against him…
On Doolan, he’s looking better and better, and even old man Ponting, it needs to be said, still hits the ball very well. 300+ is still within reach, and these two should push them well toward that mark..
4:59pm
Allanthus said | 4:59pm | Report comment
Brett, your secret’s safe with us mate. If you go to the bar and don’t post for a few overs it’s ok with us. Really.
5:09pm
Brett McKay said | 5:09pm | Report comment
5:00pm
Rob from Brumby Country said | 5:00pm | Report comment
Yep, no amount of polished fifties will get Khawaja back into the Baggy Green. He needed to go on with that innings, I think he might be guilty of another concentration lapse.
Perhaps his immediate international future will be determined by the performance of one of these batsmen currently at wicket?
5:31pm
Varun said | 5:31pm | Report comment
Let’s not look for reasons not to pick him, well made 69 and he should be definitely in the Indian squad, remember that Doolan got dropped to a sitter at point at 44
5:03pm
Red Kev said | 5:03pm | Report comment
Well again it depends on if they are looking for reasons not to pick him or not. Which says more about their own mindset (favourites, prejudice whatever you want to call it) than about the candidates. Doolan was dropped short of his half-century, does that get ignored if he scores a hundred? No-one else really has a clue what the NSP are thinking, even after they make press statements.
5:40pm
Varun said | 5:40pm | Report comment
Brett Doolan out for 87, would you have the same concerns for him not converting
That you had in khawaja, I say both batted well
But Doolan had luck at 44 whereas khawaja didn’t, khawaja still for me for the number 6 spot in India
5:11pm
Pope Paul VII said | 5:11pm | Report comment
No Matter, On cricinfo, Uncle Arthur is praising Glenny Maxwell’s net bowling. So there goes one spot.
5:18pm
Red Kev said | 5:18pm | Report comment
Form in the nets – what a fkn joke
5:19pm
Brett McKay said | 5:19pm | Report comment
As long as that’s the only place he bowls…
4:48pm
jameswm said | 4:48pm | Report comment
Well, I said below I’d be happy if we got to 2 for 200 off 35, to set a good platform for the last 10-15 overs. Assuming no more wickets lost in the next 4 overs, we’ll exceed that.
They should consolidate at 4-5 an over for the next 3, then start building.
4:44pm
Rob from Brumby Country said | 4:44pm | Report comment
… and that’s fifty up for Alex Doolan. He looks set.
4:46pm
Red Kev said | 4:46pm | Report comment
And a fifty from each of the top three /sigh when was the last time our national side managed that?
4:48pm
Christo the Daddyo said | 4:48pm | Report comment
Maybe when Gillard gets turfed out of the Lodge later on this year she can join the NSP…
4:52pm
Rob from Brumby Country said | 4:52pm | Report comment
At least she’d pick Khawaja…
4:53pm
jameswm said | 4:53pm | Report comment
Just as a token you mean, Nova style?
5:34pm
Christo the Daddyo said | 5:34pm | Report comment
Captain’s pick…
4:51pm
Rob from Brumby Country said | 4:51pm | Report comment
Not sure, but they’ll get their chance next Wednesday. This strip is doing nothing for the bowlers. That’s Manuka for you.
When they had a pitch inspection earlier, you could say emphatically that there was no grass on it. There were quite a few interesting looking cracks on it, but they haven’t done the Windies much good so far.
4:58pm
Brett McKay said | 4:58pm | Report comment
Rob, the whole wicket square is very green, and the pitch itself has a green tinge to it, but it’s always been a hard and relatively fast track…
5:01pm
Rob from Brumby Country said | 5:01pm | Report comment
Really? It didn’t look very green on the plasma!
5:11pm
Brett McKay said | 5:11pm | Report comment
It’s a pretty typical Manuka deck, plenty of grass but rock hard with the ball coming on nicely..
4:43pm
Varun said | 4:43pm | Report comment
Well batted khawaja, ticket to India must be his now
4:45pm
Red Kev said | 4:45pm | Report comment
We’ll find out on Thursday I guess
5:00pm
matt h said | 5:00pm | Report comment
If Doolan outscores him ….?
5:16pm
Red Kev said | 5:16pm | Report comment
As I said above, it depends on if the NSP are looking for reasons not to select Khawaja or evaluating on merit.
Doolan has played better in the Shield this year, but his overall first-class record is not close to Khawaja’s, he’s older and less accomplished and has never played in the county competitions. Usman has also been consistently good across all three formats this summer which speaks well of form, technique and temperament. And I do like the look of Khawaja’s innings wagon wheel on the CA livescores site.
However if they want Doolan they can justify it.
5:35pm
Varun said | 5:35pm | Report comment
Khawaja’s record across Ryobi, shield and bug bash is far superior though I wouldn’t be against both khawaja and Doolan going, the thing I like most about khawaja is that his runs in shield have come on some real difficult decks
4:42pm
Rob from Brumby Country said | 4:42pm | Report comment
Khawaja is out, he has miscued a lofted drive over long on. Possibly he tried to turn it a bit squarer and the ball has fallen short as a result.
In any case he is out for 69, and Ricky Ponting has come to the crease.
4:47pm
jameswm said | 4:47pm | Report comment
Geez that will hurt Khawaja’s chances of touring India, he can’t go on from a start to get a big score. Just like his test career.
4:29pm
jameswm said | 4:29pm | Report comment
WI bowlers – Narine and Bravo a combined 10 overs for 37, all the others 6, 7, 8 or 9 an over.
5:05pm
Brett McKay said | 5:05pm | Report comment
Yeah, and they did a good job of taking the pace off and making the batsmen force the pace. Which they’ve still been able to do, of course, but the openers were really able to use the pace with ease earlier on…
4:26pm
Elisha Pearce said | 4:26pm | Report comment
If these guys bat much longer what are the odds on Ponting letting someone else (Haddin to get his moment to impress selectors again) come in before him?
4:28pm
Red Kev said | 4:28pm | Report comment
I would say very high, now he’s retired Ponting will want others to be getting a chance. The CA site has Ponting listed at 9 in the batting order.
4:47pm
Christo the Daddyo said | 4:47pm | Report comment
Looks like very low. Ponting probably wants to prove to everyone he’s still got what it takes…
4:56pm
The Bush said | 4:56pm | Report comment
I’ve heard of dropping down the order to avoid a bouncer, but that’s a bit ridiculous…
4:26pm
Brett McKay said | 4:26pm | Report comment
Just on the selectors, I’ve just heard John Inverarity is here today. And would be impressed with what he’s seeing currently, I’d imagine..
4:33pm
Christo the Daddyo said | 4:33pm | Report comment
Is Khawaja doing something he hasn’t being doing all summer?
4:41pm
Red Kev said | 4:41pm | Report comment
Scoring when it matters? The final Shield game before the break (and subsequent selection of Ponting’s replacement) he scored 0 & 8. In his first ODI he got three. Regardless of fairness, I daresay the selectors want to see scores when they are watching. 69 … shame he got out really.
4:40pm
Elisha Pearce said | 4:40pm | Report comment
Inverarity, sitting bold upright looking down his nose at the field, “I could informed-ly manage the absolute **** outta these players! Pup! You and Bailey need to decide which matches you’re going to sit out – use rock, scissors, paper for all I care – these guys are coming into the extended, then trimmed, before being elongated one-day squad for the first 2 matches!”
4:24pm
Brett McKay said | 4:24pm | Report comment
DROPPED! Doolan’s first real loose shot of the day should have been taken easily by Pollard at point, but he’s grassed it..
4:23pm
matt h said | 4:23pm | Report comment
Are all the Khawaja lovers sticking pins in a Doolan doll at the moment? Can both make the India tour?
Before I get jumped on, Khawaja for mine every day of the week … honestly … please don’t stalk me …
4:26pm
Red Kev said | 4:26pm | Report comment
There are two spots on tour, someone has to replace Watson when he comes home to be a daddy.
4:31pm
Allanthus said | 4:31pm | Report comment
Or springs a calf muscle – whichever comes first….
4:18pm
Elisha Pearce said | 4:18pm | Report comment
ALERT: Honest Khawaja question for Brett, that isn’t “I think he should play”:
In the opening pair Khawaja wasn’t seeing an even half of the strike, and with Doolan, again, he seems to be seeing less than half the strike. Would you consider this to be Khawaja’s improvement in rotating the strike? He’s just getting off strike regularly and happy to tick the score over rather than wait for a bad ball to smash?
I noticed that was one think he was good at in the domestic matches I saw him in. Just get some runs off the first or second ball you face instead of waiting around for a ball to hammer to the boundary.
4:22pm
Brett McKay said | 4:22pm | Report comment
Elisha, early on he was just doing to logical thing and letting Jono Dean go while he was hitting them well, but certainly now, he and Doolan are looking like they’re trying to build a partnership. Doolan would be getting the lions share of the strike – he’s catching Khawaja for sure – but they’re batting relly well together. Neither of them are getting bogged down, the scoreboard’s still ticking, and they’re looking comfortable as a flow on..
4:28pm
jameswm said | 4:28pm | Report comment
They’ve put on 83 off 15 at 5.5 an over. Solid consolidation…
4:30pm
Brett McKay said | 4:30pm | Report comment
that’s why I didn’t saying ‘slowing’
4:17pm
Brett McKay said | 4:17pm | Report comment
PMs XI 1/153 after 25 overs, and looking pretty good. My earlier prediction of 320 being par might even be a bit conservative, if the wickets remain in the shed..
FOUR! Khawaja cracks a superb four in front of sqaure, a very classy shot played up over the infield, but with no risk at all..
4:12pm
Brett McKay said | 4:12pm | Report comment
Doolan’s looking a lot more comfortable already, he’s suddenly moved to 35 without any great theatrics. Khawaja has the look of a man readying to dig in for a long one..
4:17pm
jameswm said | 4:17pm | Report comment
Dare I say Brett Khawaja is building an innings? Or is that turning a Hughes thread into one about Khawaja too?
4:18pm
Brett McKay said | 4:18pm | Report comment
That ship sailed last week mate, you’d just be joinging the bandwagon..
4:07pm
Brett McKay said | 4:07pm | Report comment
Talking about vaue for shots, Doolan just straight drove a four that he just didn’t get at all but it beat te man at mid-off and raced away.
Worth adding that the Windies fielding has been a touch lazy today, there’s been a few toekn efforts and balls accompanied to the boundary..
4:10pm
Red Kev said | 4:10pm | Report comment
Well there’s no doubt this will be a loosener game for them – probably saving their energy for their primary disciplines, probably only the keeper is awake in the field.
4:13pm
Brett McKay said | 4:13pm | Report comment
no doubt at all Kev, they’re certainly getting into the festival match feels of things…
3:59pm
Brett McKay said | 3:59pm | Report comment
Fifty for Khawaja, bringing it up off 58 ball, and dare I say looking pretty comfortable…
1/130 after 21, Khawaja 50* Doolan 19*
4:02pm
boes said | 4:02pm | Report comment
do you have any info on this Khawaja guy, seems like he could be handy?
4:05pm
Brett McKay said | 4:05pm | Report comment
I know a lot of people that would b more than happy to tell you all about him!!
4:07pm
Christo the Daddyo said | 4:07pm | Report comment
Any of the NSP at the ground?
And paying attention?
4:09pm
Brett McKay said | 4:09pm | Report comment
Not that I’ve seen Christo, only the CA heirarchy: Sutherland, Howard, etc…
4:06pm
jameswm said | 4:06pm | Report comment
boes I think he may have played the odd test, but the inside word seems to be he needs to work on his fitness, running between wickets and fielding.
4:11pm
boes said | 4:11pm | Report comment
If he’s a good guy to have around the team and hitting them well in the nets he could be a chance.
4:07pm
Elisha Pearce said | 4:07pm | Report comment
I heard he’s trying to book a plane ticket to India and they keep making him jump through hoops before they give it to him. No wonder so many airlines struggle. Poor service.
7:09pm
Jake said | 7:09pm | Report comment
Just ask any of the Indian sounding names of Roarers who cannot make a post without dropping Khawajas name. There is a few below…
4:09pm
Red Kev said | 4:09pm | Report comment
I’ll say it again (just for Brett), I like Khawaja’s consistency this summer. He has been averaging just over 40 regardless of the format of the match. He’s also got himself a half-century (and a wicket) against Sri Lanka in the Chairman’s XI match and now a half-century against the West Indies in the Prime Minister’s XI match.
4:26pm
Matt F said | 4:26pm | Report comment
A wicket? The selectors may just decide to play him as our new all-rounder!
3:53pm
Brett McKay said | 3:53pm | Report comment
Khawaja and Doolan are just consolidating a little now, though the run rate is still quite healthy at 1/118 after 20 overs.
Khawaja (44no) looks to be building his innings nicely, a nice mix of deft hands and booming strokeplay. Doolan (16no) looks to be feeling his way in as well, but has played some nice shots too..
3:54pm
Allanthus said | 3:54pm | Report comment
And what about the bowling? Sounds like it might lack some venom? Or is it more a case of good batting on a good track?
4:01pm
Brett McKay said | 4:01pm | Report comment
Allanthus, Sammy and Best were bowling really quick to open up with, but Manuka has always been a happy batting track and they’re getting good value for shots..
3:48pm
jameswm said | 3:48pm | Report comment
Still 6.5 an over after 18. If they can score at 5ish an over till 35, and keep wickets in hand (say the loss of max 1 more wicket), they’re going really well. That’d be 2 for 200 with 15 to go.
That should be their aim. I wonder if they aim at numbers, or just go with the flow. The latter I’d guess.
3:57pm
Brett McKay said | 3:57pm | Report comment
Manuka can produce some big scores James, the PMs side made 5/399 against the Windies in 09/10, and 7/347 against England in 05/06, so 330-350 wouldn’t be out of the question at this rate…
3:58pm
jameswm said | 3:58pm | Report comment
Wow. You said the ground is big Brett, is the rope far in from the fence?
4:04pm
Brett McKay said | 4:04pm | Report comment
yeah, it’d be a good five or six metres in..
3:44pm
Rob from Brumby Country said | 3:44pm | Report comment
There’s some rain that’s just come on in Aranda. Manuka’s a fair way away, but there might be a few drops on the way, Brett.
3:46pm
Brett McKay said | 3:46pm | Report comment
Thanks for the update Rob, heading to the BOM radar now..
3:43pm
Allanthus said | 3:43pm | Report comment
RK gone a bit quiet, frantically searching for any reference that proves Jono Dean is actually a Queenslander….
3:47pm
Red Kev said | 3:47pm | Report comment
I laughed, well played sir.
3:54pm
Elisha Pearce said | 3:54pm | Report comment
From Bathurst according to someone I saw on my Twitter feed a few mins ago.
4:00pm
jameswm said | 4:00pm | Report comment
Did they move the border so Bathurst is in Qld? Like they did with Narrabri, according to Chris Latham?
4:06pm
Dan said | 4:06pm | Report comment
Def Bathurst, lived in Canberra for a while now. Great Cricketer, I know him well and wish I was at the game to watch him play!
6:33pm
John said | 6:33pm | Report comment
Yep, a Bathurst guy, played junior cricket with Trent Copeland. They attended Bathurst Public School and won the Brian Taber Shield in 1996. Had a few seasons with St George then moved to ACT. Jono played for NSW Under 19′s in the Aust C’ships when David Freedman was coach.
3:42pm
Brett McKay said | 3:42pm | Report comment
Think I might’ve erred before, that drinks score can’t ave been after 16overs, as they’re 1/112 after 17 now…
3:36pm
Brett McKay said | 3:36pm | Report comment
OK, at Drinks the PMs side is 1/105, after 16 overs
Khawaja 38 no
Doolan 10no
Dwayne Bravo has the figures for the Windies, 1/8 off 2 ov..
3:39pm
Allanthus said | 3:39pm | Report comment
Brett, you do realise that if Ussie sticks around for even another 20 mins your wish for “Khawaja free” posts will be shot to pieces?
And heaven help if he gets a 100!!
3:45pm
Brett McKay said | 3:45pm | Report comment
Ha, yeah you might be right Allanthus! I’m not against the Khawaja talk, of course, what I’m getting sick of is every crickt thread – like my one on Hughes batting in one-dayers last week – being hijacked into yet another Khawaja debate. More so when the comments are just “I think Khawaja should play…”
Anyway, I digress…
3:46pm
Red Kev said | 3:46pm | Report comment
The Roar has automatic moderation if you use certain offensive trigger words, maybe Khawaja should be added to the list
3:52pm
matt h said | 3:52pm | Report comment
Khamaja, Khawaja, Khamaja, Khawaja, Khamaja, Khawaja, Khamaja, Khawaja, Khamaja, Khawaja, Khamaja, Khawaja,
4:02pm
Terry Kidd said | 4:02pm | Report comment
Maybe we should add Red and Kev to the list. Sorry RK, just joking.
3:22pm
Allanthus said | 3:22pm | Report comment
Yes “Skinny fingers” Tim has kept a very low profile up until that effort yesterday.
Lucky that Billy Bowden didn’t become a urologist instead of a cricket umpire….
3:31pm
Brett McKay said | 3:31pm | Report comment
The press box view is that he’s trying to become Australia’s Prince Phillip…
3:36pm
Allanthus said | 3:36pm | Report comment
Maybe, but I suspect that the Queen will still be around for much longer than the PM…
3:20pm
Brett McKay said | 3:20pm | Report comment
Alex Doolan is the new bat, and I have to admit I’ve not seen a lot of him..
3:19pm
Brett McKay said | 3:19pm | Report comment
WICKET Dean has holed out to Jason Holder down at long off, gone for 51 to the bowling of Dwayne Bravo. Dean’s picked out Holder perfectly down on the fence, he didn’t have to move..
PM’s XI 1/87 in the 13th
Khawaja 31no
3:20pm
jameswm said | 3:20pm | Report comment
31 off 34, still solid.
3:30pm
Red Kev said | 3:30pm | Report comment
Sounds like Deans’ innings would have been quite a spectacle (51 off 40)
3:32pm
Brett McKay said | 3:32pm | Report comment
certainly was Kev, looked very good and played some great shots..
3:17pm
Elisha Pearce said | 3:17pm | Report comment
Without wanting to be hyperbolic, at this point I think we’ve stumbled on our best ODI opening partnership since Gilly/Hayden.
3:19pm
Brett McKay said | 3:19pm | Report comment
Just for humour value Elisha, could you add some hyperbole?!?
3:32pm
Elisha Pearce said | 3:32pm | Report comment
Hyperbole? I can do hyperbole!
Deans and Khawaja are the next saviours of Australian cricket – 0/80 is going to be a yawn fest for the next decade while these two are around – the likes of Gilchrist and Waugh chasing down 200 without loss is a mere fuzzy warm-up to REAL cricket.
3:33pm
Brett McKay said | 3:33pm | Report comment
Gold..
3:53pm
matt h said | 3:53pm | Report comment
And in their spare time they will solve the Greek financial crisis
3:15pm
Brett McKay said | 3:15pm | Report comment
evidently I’m having keyboard issues, too…
3:13pm
Brett McKay said | 3:13pm | Report comment
Jono Deans just brought up his 50 off 36 balls with a great pull shot for 6 down a side alley next to the Bradman Stand. Its at this poin I’l mention Manuka Oval still has a igger playing surface than the MCG and the ‘Gabba…
Khawaja is starting to go with Dean, too, he’s moving along nicely..
PMs XI 0/87 after 12
Dean 51no
Khawaja 31no
3:11pm
Jason said | 3:11pm | Report comment
Interesting match this. The Ganjas v the Rangas.
3:08pm
jameswm said | 3:08pm | Report comment
By my count Jono Dean has scored 38 of his 45 runs in boundaries! 8 4s and a 6.
3:11pm
Red Kev said | 3:11pm | Report comment
Half-century up according to CA’s livescores thingy – Jono Dean = new cricketing cult hero
3:08pm
Brett McKay said | 3:08pm | Report comment
Sorry guys, I’ve only just got back online, seems we’re having some technical issues – perhaps the power for the lights is coming from the media box…
3:07pm
Allanthus said | 3:07pm | Report comment
Brett, do you think the WI bowlers are struggling due to having their prostate’s examined yesterday?
3:14pm
Brett McKay said | 3:14pm | Report comment
you make one joke about slender fingers….
3:05pm
sandal said | 3:05pm | Report comment
Jono Dean is on fire!
3:04pm
jameswm said | 3:04pm | Report comment
2 overs for 2 (first each by Narine and russell). So then 8 overs for 54, still nearly 7 an over.
Then first two balls of Russell’s 2nd over hit for 4 by Dean, now 43 off 22.
2:52pm
Red Kev said | 2:52pm | Report comment
0/52 off 6??? The NSP should have called this lot in to play the T20 last night.
2:56pm
jameswm said | 2:56pm | Report comment
Yeah Finch and Marsh both looked like rabbits in the headlights.
3:03pm
Elisha Pearce said | 3:03pm | Report comment
If I remember correctly Marsh was on 8 after his first 18 balls last night – almost single-handedly submarining the run chase. And here’s Khawaja anchoring the top order at 90% strike rate without giving a chance. Khawaja better get a shot against the WI in the 5 match series.
2:51pm
Brett McKay said | 2:51pm | Report comment
At the end of the 6th over, the PMs XI is 0/52
Khawaja 16*
Dean 32*
Best has 0/28 from his 3
Sammy 0/23 from 3
Andre Russell is into the attack for Best..
2:48pm
Brett McKay said | 2:48pm | Report comment
Big Appeal ct behind on Dean, but given not out..
Jono Dean still on the charge, he’s moved to 25* now
SIX! make that 31* big six over midwicket onto the hill off Sammy.
Getting difficult to keep up!!
2:51pm
jameswm said | 2:51pm | Report comment
Looks like 24 off his last 7 balls, including a caught behind appeal. a 6, 4 x 4s, a 2 and the appeal.
It’s all happening, get Bill Lawry out there!
Brett is he slogging, or are they good cricket shots?
2:53pm
Brett McKay said | 2:53pm | Report comment
Mostly just good shots. A bit airy, but just good shots..
3:00pm
josh said | 3:00pm | Report comment
There aren’t any fielders in the air.
2:42pm
jameswm said | 2:42pm | Report comment
Wonder if it’s the plan for Dean to chase it and Khawaja be more steady, or it’s just working out that way.
2:49pm
Brett McKay said | 2:49pm | Report comment
It’s just working that way James, Dean is a naturally agressive player, and Khawaja has barely faced a ball in the lat few overs..
2:49pm
Red Kev said | 2:49pm | Report comment
It’s probably one of the few times he gets to play in front of national selectors, so he may as well go for it – 25 off 16.
Not knowing anything about him it may just be his natural game though, certainly Khawaja’s natural game is slower and steadier.
2:52pm
jameswm said | 2:52pm | Report comment
But still a run a ball Kev. UTK is 16 off 17 now.
2:42pm
Brett McKay said | 2:42pm | Report comment
BANG BANG! Dean’s just belted two fours off Best, the first throught the vacant backward point, the second straight down the ground. Outfield is lightening fast..
0/31 in the 5th
Khawaja 11*
Dean 17*
2:38pm
Brett McKay said | 2:38pm | Report comment
0/16 now in the 4th over, Khawaja 5no, Dean is 9no.
An update on Chris Gayle, too, we’ve just heard he was a bit stiff in the back after the 36 hour flight, but will be fine for the first ODU in Perth on Friday..
2:34pm
Brett McKay said | 2:34pm | Report comment
Jono Dean’s not going to die wondering, he’s just sliced Best over about fourth slip for another four.
Both Best and Sammy are looking pretty sharp already, the ball’s coming on nicely, and considering the rain around last night, the outfield looks bloody fast.
For the nostalgists, Windies ‘keeper Devon Thomas is out there in a floppy hat, Jack Russell-style..
2:41pm
Red Kev said | 2:41pm | Report comment
Although I didn’t actually watch much of the WI tour last year I heard that their wicketkeeper was a genuine gloveman in stark contrast to the trend towards keeper-batsmen in the rest of the world. Is that the same guy? Awesome that he’s wearing a floppy though, it’s one of the things I miss most about seeing Mark Waugh and Richie Richardson play – they always rocked the white wide-brim hat.
2:55pm
Brett McKay said | 2:55pm | Report comment
it’s a maroon floppy, Kev, but a floppy nonetheless..
2:29pm
Brett McKay said | 2:29pm | Report comment
BANG!! Jono Dean puts his first ball over cover for four, off Darren Sammy from the Cathedral (southern) end..
2:33pm
jameswm said | 2:33pm | Report comment
Brett can you tell us about Jono Dean? Is he a local too?
You must love this annual Canberra game.
2:35pm
Brett McKay said | 2:35pm | Report comment
James, he’s the ACT Comets Captain and plays for Queanbeyan in the ACT Grade comp. He’s probably one of the best bats in the region, he’s been a heavy runscorer for the last couple of grade seasons, and for the ACT in the Futures League, too..
2:21pm
Brett McKay said | 2:21pm | Report comment
So we’re about to get underway, Khawaja will face Tino Best from the Manuka Pool (Northern) End..
FOUR: Khawaja pulls the third ball beautifully behind square..
0/5 after the first over..
2:02pm
Brett McKay said | 2:02pm | Report comment
FoxCopter in the house!!
2:01pm
Brett McKay said | 2:01pm | Report comment
Usman Khawaja watch can commence shortly he’ll open with ACT Comets Captain Jono Dean.
Rest of the order as listed is Doolan at 3, Ponting, Handscomb, Haddin at 6, Faulkner, Turner, Sandhu, McDermott, Ahmed. Nick Winter is still 12th Man..
1:58pm
aggregated drupe said | 1:58pm | Report comment
Will be watching Khawaja, Doolan and Faulkner.
1:57pm
boes said | 1:57pm | Report comment
Can anyone offer some insight into Ashton Turner – I know he played in the U19 world cup, but not much else.
2:24pm
Brett McKay said | 2:24pm | Report comment
Boes, from my media guide (because otherwiseIve got nothing) I can only tell you that he bowls RA offies, and is yet to make his First Class debut..
2:27pm
boes said | 2:27pm | Report comment
Thanks – I guess we will all know a little more by the end of the days play…Ashes bolter?
2:30pm
Brett McKay said | 2:30pm | Report comment
Let’s not too far ahead of ourselves!!
1:54pm
Rabbitz said | 1:54pm | Report comment
Hey Brett,
Have you caught the TV Commercials Nine have be running for the WI tour?
They mention all the great names of the past, Richards, Garner, Roberts, Holding etc etc etc. Then go on to say that none of them are in the team! Anyone got any idea on what they were thinking?
“The West Indies used to be formidable, come and see just how far they have fallen!!”
1:57pm
jameswm said | 1:57pm | Report comment
You’d think Gayle would be a big drawcard.
2:04pm
Brett McKay said | 2:04pm | Report comment
I have Rabz, It’s a rather tenuous ad even desperate ad from Nine..
2:16pm
Atawhai Drive said | 2:16pm | Report comment
Rabbitz and Brett, is there any way of seeing this ad without having to actually switch over to Nine?
I’ll have a look on YouTube.
2:27pm
Brett McKay said | 2:27pm | Report comment
AD, I’d like the think the YouTube community could be spared…
2:28pm
Pope Paul VII said | 2:28pm | Report comment
Bonkers
1:50pm
Brett McKay said | 1:50pm | Report comment
Right then, so Ricky Ponting has won the toss and the PMs side will bat.
West Indies: Kieran Powell, Johnson Charles, Darren Bravo, Ramneresh Sarwan, Dwayne Bravo, Kieron Pollard, Devon Thomas (wk), Darren Sammy (C), Andre Russell, Sunil Narine, Tino Best.
1:41pm
Atawhai Drive said | 1:41pm | Report comment
How times change. The West Indies used to star at peak of Australian summer. Now they’re just a postscript, tagged on after the holiday season.
Wonder what sort of crowds and viewing figures they’ll attract.
3:56pm
matt h said | 3:56pm | Report comment
Well I’ve got my tickets for the 20/20 in Brisbane. Excitement machines or train wrecks, there’s always something facinating about the Windies
1:32pm
Brett McKay said | 1:32pm | Report comment
Bright and sunny here at Manuka now, happily, no delayed start and the ground looks a picture.
The big news is that Chris Gayle is NOT playing for the Windies. PM’s side is as listed, I’ll have the Windies team shortly..
1:09pm
Frankie Hughes said | 1:09pm | Report comment
Nice to see Ronnie Sarwan back after the idiots in the West Indies board left him out for nearly 2 years.
12:54pm
Red Kev said | 12:54pm | Report comment
No rain issues in Canberra?
1:04pm
jameswm said | 1:04pm | Report comment
I was wondering the same. You wouldn’t get close to hosting a game in Sydney right now
BOM says 60% chance of rain today, isolated showers.
1:13pm
Christo the Daddyo said | 1:13pm | Report comment
Considering the fear the umpires were consumed by with such little rain in the recent games in Sydney and Melbourne (which let’s be honest, was little more than heavy dew), they would be catatonic about the rain in Sydney today!
1:24pm
Red Kev said | 1:24pm | Report comment
It will get interesting, as I am sure the Gabba and the SCG are supposed to host Ryobi Cup and Shield matches in the next week.
3:57pm
matt h said | 3:57pm | Report comment
Given the rain this week, umpires have already decided the outfields in Sydney and Brisbane are too wet to play cricket until mid 2014
1:56pm
Brett McKay said | 1:56pm | Report comment
Kev, it’s looking great, we may get a shower later, but otherwise it’s pretty well clear skies and quite warm.
12:49pm
Varun said | 12:49pm | Report comment
Looking forward to seeing punter and khawaja bat together
12:54pm
Disco said | 12:54pm | Report comment
Let’s hope Ponting doesn’t run him out again.
1:04pm
Varun said | 1:04pm | Report comment
They are both good runners, I think gayle will
Have a big game as some of the small boundaries will suit him