The Roar
The Roar

MNEAL18

Roar Rookie

Joined March 2017

1.7k

Views

2

Published

12

Comments

A lover of all sports. Lived up and down the East Coast and enjoy watching all sports. North Melbourne supporter

Published

Comments

Too slow Gibson.

Hawthorn Hawks vs Geelong Cats highlights: AFL live scores, blog

It looks as though the king of the short hit up leads, the 15m kicks just dont have the skill anymore. How many targets have they missed already

Hawthorn Hawks vs Geelong Cats highlights: AFL live scores, blog

Have a feeling that the Hawks may be able to get this one. Happy to be wrong but it like poking the sleeping bear, it will wake up and hurt you.

Hawthorn Hawks vs Geelong Cats highlights: AFL live scores, blog

I agree that Bontempelli will be an absolute champion of the game but if Fyfe gets back to his form of early 2015 no one can match him for the mantle of number 1 player in the game. He is every bit as good as Bontempelli with midfield craft, maybe not as silky. I would rate Fyfe a better mark, especially contested. That is what sets him apart. We may have forgotten how good Fyfe was/is due to his injuries since his early 2015 form

Marcus Bontempelli will end the year as the AFL's best player

Might be a break out season for Cockatoo. Looks like he has developed over the summer. I am not a huge Geelong fan but I do like a few of the kids

Geelong Cats vs Essendon Bombers: JLT Community Series Live scores, blog

The boys are struggling with cramp. Great mark McCarthy. like him

Geelong Cats vs Essendon Bombers: JLT Community Series Live scores, blog

Essendon experienced players are the ones making mistakes, a bit rusty

Geelong Cats vs Essendon Bombers: JLT Community Series Live scores, blog

He couldnt stay at West Coast. That was poison

Recasting the 2001 draft: Hodge or Judd?

The point I was trying to make was everyone was hounding Hawthorn after Judd exploded onto the scene, they said it was a mistake. As you have said longevity and leadership would mean Hawthorn would not change a thing.

Recasting the 2001 draft: Hodge or Judd?

Good stats, I forgot about Luke Ball with osteo pubis, it was just Judd was so electric early, but did have some good cattle around him compared to Ball and Hodge. Still think Hawthorn would not change a thing. You can get a footballer but with Hodge they got the lot.

Recasting the 2001 draft: Hodge or Judd?

Would still rate Hodge as good as a player as both of them and far superior in big games. His on field leadership stands out. Both MItchell and Swan never played on anyone in their lifetime. Hodge also had ability to shut down opposition players and still have positive effect on game. Judd, in early days was far better than any of them.
I just think Hodge has longevity, leadership, big game player and the team stats (of which he was leader) to back it up.

Recasting the 2001 draft: Hodge or Judd?

I think the big loser out of the entire draft was St Kilda. Luke Ball was a very good player but not in the same league as these 2. St Kilda could only dream of what might have been, imagine Judd and Reiwoldt in same side.

Recasting the 2001 draft: Hodge or Judd?

close