Who’s the A-League’s Karmichael Hunt?
By Jesse Fink, 31 Jul 2009 Jesse Fink is a Roar Pro
- Tagged:
- AFL, football, Gold Coast AFL, Karmichael Hunt

Australian Danny Allsopp, left, fight for the ball with Indonesian Hariono, right, during AFC Asian Cup 2011 qualifiers Group B at Gelora Bung Karno in Jakarta, Indonesia, Wednesday, Jan 28, 2009. AP Photo/Achmad Ibrahim
Along with most of Australia, I was stunned that Karmichael Hunt has been poached by the AFL to play for the new Gold Coast AFL “franchise” in 2011. It’s either the most brilliant piece of recruiting in Australian sport – ever – or indisputably the dumbest. I am not sure which way to lean.
What is becoming clear, though, with the innumerable defections of rugby league footballers to union and the switching of players from union and AFL to boxing, is that old barriers in Australian sport are tumbling down.
Anything is fair game.
The prevailing belief of administrators and moneymen, erroneous though it may be, is that if you’re tall enough and big enough and catch a ball, you can just about do anything.
There is some credit to the idea.
There was Deion Sanders, of course, who managed to excel at the top of America’s two biggest sports, Major League Baseball and the National Football League, for the better part of two decades.
But equally there was Michael Jordan, the greatest basketballer of all time, who retired when he was at the peak of his career to play baseball.
The experiment was a failure. Jordan never made the transition to the MLB, languishing in the minor leagues, and went back to the NBA with his tail between his legs, chastened and just a little embarrassed.
My own view is that the AFL’s aggressive pursuit of the Brisbane Broncos fullback has been motivated as much by its avaricious desire for publicity and the commercial benefits that flow on from it as much as its genuine belief that Hunt can “cross over”. Judging by the amount of newsprint the story gathered today, they’ve already made their money back.
So why stop at Hunt and rugby league? It got me thinking about what A-League players the AFL might pursue – and there would be plenty of reasons to do so: after all, isn’t the A-League and football the real threat to the preordained might of Australian Rules?
Danny Allsopp seems a likely contender.
Still youngish, at 30, he stands over six feet and, as John Kosmina well knows, packs a bit of muscle. He’s quick for a big man, good with his feet and could be rebuilt as a sort of poor man’s Barry Hall if the AFL’s lab rats got to him in time. There doesn’t seem to be any international future for him with the Socceroos, so I’m sure he’d consider a good offer.
Or his Melbourne Victory teammate Archie Thompson, also 30.
Elastic with explosive pace and a hound’s nose for goal, you can picture the guy in a midfield scrapping and collecting role, and importantly, like Allsopp, he has Buckley’s of making it to South Africa 2010.
Former A-League player Bruce Djite, now with Genclerbirligi in Turkey, is in my opinion the true Karmichael Hunt of Australian football – 22, six feet tall and a big unit – but unlike Allsopp and Thompson, he’s got the world at his feet.
He will make it to the World Cup – and no amount of money would persuade him to defect, especially when he has the potential to make ten times more as a professional player in Europe.
Allsopp and Thompson, however, are ripe for the plucking.
If Hunt can cross over, they certainly can – and better still, the AFL would be driving a dagger through the heart of the biggest football club in the country if they pursued the pair, striking a massive blow against the fastest growing sport in the land.
Football Federation Australia: you have been warned. Start shoring up your defences.
Enjoy sports? Enjoy a bargain? All Sports Online has your favourite sporting brands at up to 70% off. Online only, premium quality sporting goods and merchandise at discounted prices. Get a deal now.
- Explore:
- AFL, football, Gold Coast AFL, Karmichael Hunt

MarkyG said | July 31st 2009 @ 2:28am | Report comment
I don’t know the average age of AFL players, but I’d imagine 30 is still rather old for that game. Plus Danny and Archie have it sweet at the Victory. Biggest footy club in the land and both have roles with the club in the future, perhaps not like Muscats coaching future but certainly ties to the club that can not be broken.
I’m not sure whether this article is serious or is one of the best examples of subtle humour I’ve read in a while.
It seems like bait, designed to stir up the fanboys and fangirls of their respective games and provide another reason for a shouting match in ALL CAPS.
Either way, I had a good laugh. Keep up the good work.
Michael C said | July 31st 2009 @ 6:20am | Report comment
Ahem – yep, MarkyG, it is an obvious humour piece.
Viewing it as such – the only thing I take umbridge with is the word ‘poach’. After all – Hunt isn’t breaking a contract – and in fact is heading off to play Union first. Perhaps the AFL is actually ‘poaching’ him from his ‘Union career’ that hasn’t even started yet…….
Gaz said | July 31st 2009 @ 7:19am | Report comment
I would have thought Danny Tiatto and Kevin Muscat would be the best options for AFL clubs. They both have a good solid kick, as many a swollen ankle will attest. Both would be ready to start a lucrative new career, and neither of them minds getting stuck into the mauls. And those flying elbows might come in handy too!
albe said | July 31st 2009 @ 7:47am | Report comment
a big lol at the thought that any half-decent footballer would want to play an eggball code. Talk about limiting your options
Though i guess if u want to be a big fish in a small puddle, then its probably not a bad route to take !
Pippinu said | July 31st 2009 @ 8:43am | Report comment
Well done Jesse – a very funny piece! Someone needs to bring the temperature down in this Hunt busines!
In a different life, I can certainly imagine Danny going from centre-forward to centre half forward, and I thiink you’re right, Arch does strike me as a bit of an in and under, scrapping goal sneak (which is a positive in aussie rules).
Dukes could have crossed over as a 17 year old without a problem (he’s from Melbourne and can actually handle the sherrin reasonably well) – of course, he would have missed out on millions of dollars and worldwide recognition.
Pippinu said | July 31st 2009 @ 8:45am | Report comment
Albe
it’s actually not a bad option for anyone who wants to have a professional sporting career (if you’re good enough).
There are 15 yo kids on scholarships as we speak earning $40,000 per annum (pretty much the average wage in Australia).
That ain’t bad for a game only played at the arse end of the world.
AndyRoo said | July 31st 2009 @ 8:46am | Report comment
Well if we are serious the battle of codes tends to come when there around 16 and 17. If a 17 year old is offered $$$ from the AFL and only a NYL contract from footbal some will take the $$$ (depending on how much I would too).
I think it’s fun if you imagine an alternative reality where Frank lowy was made president of Soccer Australia 30 years ago or kerry packers proposal got up… meanwhile the AFL got Charlie Dempsey as there CEO where would we be.
Which AFL players would you have liked too see how they went in football?
I know from rugby league i would want too see how Andrew Johns, Nathan Balcklock, Preston Cambell and Matt Bowen went if they were given a football at an early age instead of a stedden.
I am not saying they would make it, but It would be interesting too see how good they could have been.
MyGeneration said | July 31st 2009 @ 10:53am | Report comment
Umm, I’m sure you meant “given a sherrin at an early age instead of a steeden”. A steeden is a football
AndyRoo said | July 31st 2009 @ 11:07am | Report comment
Steden make the rubby league balls. The players I mentioned were league players…since I don’t know much about AFL
MyGeneration said | July 31st 2009 @ 11:27am | Report comment
Oh, sorry, now I see you were talking about association football. They’re still all footballs to me (and it’s Steeden with two ‘e’s).
macavity said | July 31st 2009 @ 3:08pm | Report comment
Andrew Johns was a very good junior soccer player, as was his brother – no doubt they both could have made it.
something seemingly lost on a lot of people is hand/foot/eye coordination and athleticism are not exclusive to one code – skills can transfer very well with dedicated training.
David said | July 31st 2009 @ 9:23am | Report comment
not only the A-League – AFL and the rugby codes should start scouting basketballers. It has been done – Mark Sinderberry played with the Canberra Cannons (sadly defunct) before moving to rugby union and representing the ACT, pre-Brunbies.
Can you imagine some of those big basketballers, like Nathan Jawai, playing at full-forward or ruck in AFL or playing No.8 or lock in union?
Ben of Phnom Penh said | July 31st 2009 @ 10:51am | Report comment
It already happens, David. A number of young ruckmen have been drafted from basketball and are given a year or two to adapt to the game (as it takes tall men a bit longer to be physically ready for AFL, particularly in the ruck).
Michael C said | July 31st 2009 @ 11:45am | Report comment
Yep, important point – tall players tend to take longer to develop and both skills wise, and physically mature.
Current examples of Basketball converts include Dean Brogan (Adelaide 36ers), Kurt Tippett and Sean Hampson (from QLD both), Todd Goldstien, – - all ruckmen/tall forwards.
and Scott Pendlebury at Collingwood – is a tallish midfielder, but, from Sale, he played junior footy on and off and focussed a bit more on basketball for a year or two.
Kazama said | July 31st 2009 @ 3:32pm | Report comment
Also the Crows have Ricky Henderson, a basketball convert from Trentham, on the rookie list.
http://www.afc.com.au/tabid/4417/default.aspx?newsid=79367
Brian said | July 31st 2009 @ 10:00am | Report comment
Yep good humour. Although having said that wouldn’t 18 yo Natanui from West Coast make one impressive goalkeeper. His height, agiliity and ball control are all top shelf. Someone should tell him there’s much more money and fame to be made playing for Fulham than West Coast
Pippinu said | July 31st 2009 @ 10:07am | Report comment
AndyRoo
you’re point is all about good administration, and it’s very true.
At the club level, it’s the same story, you rarely achieve club success without solid administration.