Why Brad Green must be Melbourne’s next captain
By Justin Rodski, 20 Aug 2010 Justin Rodski is a Roar Guru
- Tagged:
- aaron davey, AFL, Brad Green, Brent Moloney, Cameron Bruce, Melbourne Demons
Related coverage
The Demons next club captain is a hugely important decision and one that could be crucial to Melbourne achieving the ultimate success in the future. Melbourne’s young, exciting and emerging team is ready to take the next step, but to do so, they need a strong, inspirational and passionate leader to set the example.
That man is Brad Green.
I think Melbourne want a player who has the ability to do something special in the heat of the battle, a certain aura around him that demands respect, whilst being a leader that automatically allows his teammates to walk taller every time they head down the race.
For all his admirable qualities, this is an area that James McDonald perhaps lacked in.
McDonald has done a wonderful job ‘filling the void’ during the clubs rebuilding phase and yesterday announced his semi-forced retirement effective at seasons end.
While he is extremely gifted and blessed with natural talent, he won’t be remembered for his leadership or superstar quality, but rather as an honest and hard working footballer that got the most out of his potential.
He should be applauded, however, for having the courage to take on the Melbourne captaincy when he did. At the time, the Demons were struggling both on and off the field, and the outlook was grim.
To his credit, he can walk away from the game with his head held high, both for the way he played and his role leading the club through one of its darkest periods.
But right now, he’s not the right fit as the club embarks on a new era.
It must have been a tough call for coach Dean Bailey to push McDonald into retirement, but ultimately I think it was both a brave and rational decision that is in the best interests of Melbourne.
There are obviously all different types of leaders and styles of leadership in football, and I’m sure McDonald was highly valued internally. But in my opinion, the Demons’ next captain must have a bigger presence and authority, on and off the field.
Brad Green has all the attributes and qualities the Demons are looking for in a leader and it would be a major mistake if he were overlooked for the role.
This season his football has stepped up to a whole new level and he will surely earn All-Australian selection as a result.
He can play in any position on the ground, takes strong pack marks, never backs away from a contest, leads from the front and consistently performs acts of bravery on the field that defy courage itself.
At 29 years of age, he has the right mix of experience and time left in the game to be able to lead the side for at least the next three years.
While Aaron Davey, Cameron Bruce, Brent Moloney and even Jack Grimes would be considered for the position, none of the above has the complete package Green has to offer.
Davey is more of a spiritual leader, Bruce is a bit old and too similar to McDonald, Moloney has had a lot of injury problems and Grimes is probably a bit too young to be able to handle the responsibility.
I would make Brent Moloney vice captain and put Aaron Davey, Jack Grimes, Tom Scully and Jack Trengove all in the leadership group to help fast track their development as future leaders.
It would be a huge mistake if Melbourne looked past Brad Green as its next club captain.
Recommend this story.
The Turkey 10
The Turkey 10 teams have now been selected, as Wild Turkey Bourbon's sport sponsorship kicks into the next exciting phase.
Choose which side you're going to support and get in the running to win $2,500!
Simply visit Wild Turkey Australia on Facebook for your chance to win.
Find out more.
The Crowd Says (6) | Page 1 of Comments
Have Your Say
- Explore:
- aaron davey, AFL, Brad Green, Brent Moloney, Cameron Bruce, Melbourne Demons



August 20th 2010 @ 10:56am
Tony said | August 20th 2010 @ 10:56am | Report comment
Pretty fair call. And since Green cracked the sooks a couple of years ago, he has bounced back magnificently.
August 20th 2010 @ 11:52am
Michael C said | August 20th 2010 @ 11:52am | Report comment
Green was missing from the leadership group in 2008 (a playes vote – and he had been injured across the pre-season). He’s certainly now a valuable leader, playing super consistant footy – - exceptionally consistant. He doesn’t seem to have a bad day – - simply, now and then he’ll do what he does and get 5 goals out of it!!!
James McDonald sadly had to finish up. Green does look a natural choice. However, were Grant Thomas coach, he might rotate Colin Sylvia into the role to help his development.
btw – Just drawing attention to the fair call back on Aug 3 The Dockers look safe in the top five.
Would the Dockers contemplate ‘throwing’ a game to ensure a fifth place finish?
.
Obviously the injury to Sandilands has helped make up their minds.
And whilst StKilda did last year pull the same trick and still managed to win – it’s doubtful the Dockers this time around could pull off a Launceston miracle.
August 20th 2010 @ 1:33pm
Chip said | August 20th 2010 @ 1:33pm | Report comment
Completely agree with your choice of Brad Green for next captain, but I’m not sure Junior should have been given the nudge. He’s had a pretty good year when he hasn’t been injured. There’s a lot of heart and good feeling around the club at the moment, and I think giving Junior another year, and a chance to have a send-off playing in the finals, would have been good for him and for the club.
August 20th 2010 @ 1:33pm
Chip said | August 20th 2010 @ 1:33pm | Report comment
Maybe he could have played on for one more year as player, and appoint Green as captain
August 20th 2010 @ 1:42pm
Michael C said | August 20th 2010 @ 1:42pm | Report comment
You need to move on a certain number of players…..who do you move on otherwise??
McDonald’s hammy’s are related to where tissue was removed for his knee op, and perhaps that’s just becomes an old man hammy’s now that he may not fully shake going forward??
August 20th 2010 @ 3:22pm
Justin Rodski said | August 20th 2010 @ 3:22pm | Report comment
Chip, I like your idea of him staying on as a player but passing on the captaincy to Green.
McDonald is such a quality person and to have him around the club would be invaluable for that reason alone.
Maybe they will offer him another role in retirement…..assistant coach?