- Video
-
Club Roar
Captured a great grassroots sporting moment? We want to see it!Content Collections
The Roar Community
- Join
- Login
Melbourne Heart have sacked manager John Aloisi after a miserable run of 16 matches without a league win, but the former Socceroo stalwart’s sacking masks a bigger problem – not many people actually care about them.
The Heart were founded and immediately planted into the A-League for the 2010/11 season. Since then we’ve witnessed 10 Melbourne derbies, and it cannot be denied that there is a genuine buzz about the fixture.
Unfortunately, the rest of the time Melbourne pays virtually no attention to the red and white team. Looking at average attendances for the three full seasons that the Melbourne Heart have existed, most would say, “that’s not so bad”.
In 2010/11 Heart averaged 8,312, in 2011/12 they rose to 9,082, while in 2012/13 attendances dropped to 8,560.
It’s a solid base to build from, but closer investigation of these statistics reveals a major concern for Melbourne’s second A-League team.
It’s Melbourne’s ‘contrived’ derby which continues to prop up the club’s end of season attendance stats. The Heart’s rate of patronage plunges markedly when the derby match is removed from their attendance records.
Averages for 2010/11 without the derby were 5,825. In other years the impact has been similar.
The problem, apart from the Heart’s limited on-field success, is their lack of identity.
As I sit here in my Sydney office I ponder, “Why would someone support Melbourne Heart?”
Reason one: an individual prefers red over blue.
Reason two: an individual is an anti-soccer fan who fears Melbourne Victory’s rising icon status.
While I too prefer red over blue (a graphic arts teacher once told me it symbolises passion), it’s not the kind of reason that inspires long term loyalty, or requests for life memberships.
Yes, Melbourne Heart have a solid base and if on-field success arrives numbers may swell, but the FFA have long talked about Geelong as a location for an A-League club.
What would happen to Heart’s flimsily founded supporter base if Geelong did arrive?
Most Victorians scoff at ‘AFL mad’ Geelong being awarded an A-League license, but even if it’s unlikely the Melbourne situation must be resolved.
Sydney’s derby works on a good old-fashioned geographical separation, which divides the so called ‘working class’ from the ‘silvertails’.
Melbourne’s derby is about nothing, and when the blue team aren’t in town no one cares.
Despite all those in the south harping on about Melbourne being Australia’s ‘sports capital’, or even the world’s sports capital, the Melbourne Heart provides little evidence.
The solution is to move the Heart out of the city centre.
Are you the ultimate team manager? Pick your own superstar team and go head to head with other football fans for glory and cash prizes on Draftstars. Imagine what you could be buying instead. Set a deposit limit.