- Video
-
Club Roar
Captured a great grassroots sporting moment? We want to see it!Content Collections
The Roar Community
- Join
- Login
Roar Rookie
Joined August 2023
0
Views
0
Published
233
Comments
Published
Comments
Defense was soft and lacked aggression
Brumbies end 15-year drought against Crusaders as 80th minute penalty try seals remarkable finish
yeah think both Slips and AA are not 100%. A win is a win I suppose but the scrum needs urgent attention.
Brumbies end 15-year drought against Crusaders as 80th minute penalty try seals remarkable finish
yeah can’t judge the line out based on the wind but the scrum was poor and has been for a few weeks.
Brumbies end 15-year drought against Crusaders as 80th minute penalty try seals remarkable finish
Lolesio had his best game so far this season.
Valentini had his best game for some time.
Swain put in another good shift.
Brums scrum is a real issue. Has been for a the last few weeks. Some real issues with the front row. I can only guess that Slips and AA are still not 100% fit.
Overall the Brums defense lacked physicality and lost too many meters thru ineffective tackling. Bernie might be happy with the effort but this will not get the job done against Canes or Chiefs.
Brumbies end 15-year drought against Crusaders as 80th minute penalty try seals remarkable finish
Charlie Gamble is a good call.
Five burning questions: How many Tahs and Force players will end up in gold, and is this farewell Melbourne?
Something is obviously very wrong when the state that produces 50% of Australia’s rugby talent (according to some contributors) performs so poorly on field. And I don’t accept the argument about the injury list. They have been poor for many seasons. Even if the Rebels go under and contribute talent to the Tahs, is the picture going to be any different. Unfortunately the Tahs performance has been a very poor advertisement for the centralization model that RA is trying to sell. It seems that the franchises that have remained independent and make sound business decisions, not polluted by RA policy, are having the most success. I would like to see a strong and competitive Tahs franchise but based on the available talent they are really under achieving. A very frustrating situation for Tahs supporters.
Tahs in turmoil: Hanigan and Harrison jump sinking ship, skipper forced to stay, CEO complains of 'tricky' task
Yeah, he has always looked pretty good behind a winning pack.
'Triple threat' Donaldson leads Force to massive win over Drua to keep Super Rugby finals hopes alive
Over exaggeration is sadly something that Oz rugby supporters have become very good at given the dark days we have fallen in to. We are always looking for the next savior who will lead us out of the rugby wasteland. KB simply represents another solid play maker, a second threat that needs to be watched. He is a good pickup for the Force based on his experience and utility. He also provides a solid backup for BD. Whilst Cron has him at 15 he does have the flexibility of playing along side BD in the backline.
'Triple threat' Donaldson leads Force to massive win over Drua to keep Super Rugby finals hopes alive
hard to look good as a 10 when your forwards are going backwards all night. Before criticizing a 10 you really need to see what’s happening in the engine room. Slow or poor delivery to the 10 takes away time and space. The 10 just becomes an easy target. Was glad to see Jack Debreczini get a run. Different 10 to NL but didn’t look that bad in an uninspiring effort from the Brums.
'Triple threat' Donaldson leads Force to massive win over Drua to keep Super Rugby finals hopes alive
yeah Drua looked like a different team. Possibly spent from last weekend mentally as much as physically.
'Triple threat' Donaldson leads Force to massive win over Drua to keep Super Rugby finals hopes alive
well said Jack. They all have significant skills and potential. We need to develop these guys not bury them. They are a scarce resource that needs nurturing.
'Triple threat' Donaldson leads Force to massive win over Drua to keep Super Rugby finals hopes alive
“dominant loss” seems to best describe the Tah’s season. They looked strong and dominant through the whole game but just don’t seem to be able to points on the board. In contrast the Brums seem to score easily off very few opportunities. The Tahs backline don’t seem able to convert from the possession and territory provided by the forwards. Possibly the game management from the 9 and 10 is not working as it should. JG is a great 9 but not sure if they need a more experienced 10 to organize the offense. Brums played below average and will not beat the Blue’s or Cane’s with that performance.
Brumbies beat Waratahs in monsoonal conditions as injury toll goes from bad to worse
A strange game to say the least. Reds just lacked enthusiasm for most of the game. They woke up for brief periods in the second half but were still mentally not in the game. The Rebs scrapped and disrupted any semblance of Reds structure. Not pretty but still a good contest.
'Perhaps it's surgery': Reds win ugly over Rebels to keep top four hopes alive as big-name Wallabies forced off
Face facts. We don’t have a perfect 10 that will select themself. We have 3 young promising candidates who are not perfect but could grow into the position given time and space. For me, it has been impossible to evaluate either NL, CG or BD at test level simply because the team as a whole has performed so poorly.
Forget the old guard. We need to look to develop each of these young guns (possibly Lynah too). We need to keep each of these guys engaged and developing within Australian Rugby. Don’t put the pressure on these guys. Help them to develop and gain confidence at test level.
The five candidates for the Wallabies No.10 jersey - and the old heads who may sneak in to join them
Yeah for sure MO. Putting aggression into the big fella’s is just about impossible. Would rather take a naturally aggressive lock, let him mature and dial him back a bit. Hope Bernie has not made a mistake with Darcy because I think his best days might be ahead of him.
'Toughest decision': Wallaby's blunt admission over form as Force land Brumbies lock, teammate brought to tears
Naive how some people on this thread believe the Brums only live off players from other franchises. What they fail to recognize in that narrative is the role the Brums have played in taking rejects from other places and developing them into champions. The Brums first title was based on rejects from other franchises.
'Toughest decision': Wallaby's blunt admission over form as Force land Brumbies lock, teammate brought to tears
Sad to see him leave the Brums. Have been critical of him over the years but I think he has started to mature and at 26 still has a lot of rugby left in him. Positives are that he remains in Oz rugby, he helps strengthen the Force. He also has the opportunity to start a fresh in a new franchise under new coaching staff. The Force can obviously see a diamond in the rough which I believe he is. The Brums, on the other hand, have lost their most aggressive lock. The remaining locks while technically adequate are not aggressive or intimidating (and never will be).
'Toughest decision': Wallaby's blunt admission over form as Force land Brumbies lock, teammate brought to tears
He is more of a distributor rather than a line breaker. Depends what you want from a 10. He is listed at 89kgs but his upper body needs some bulk.
Brumbies breathe sigh of relief after holding on against physical Drua pack as super sub saves the day
yeah. That’s a shame. 😢 Still only young and maybe a good move. He still has plenty of time to mature as the player I always thought he could be.
Brumbies breathe sigh of relief after holding on against physical Drua pack as super sub saves the day
As soon as you play an unreliable goal kicker at 10 at test level you are compromised. CG must learn to kick before he will be an automatic selection at 10. I also have not been that impressed by his form this season. NL needs a few more kgs but his game management and kicking is superior to CG. NL needs a kicking coach like an Andrew Mehrtens to fix his kicking. The Wallabies need two reliable 10’s to build around over the next few years.
Brumbies breathe sigh of relief after holding on against physical Drua pack as super sub saves the day
Fiji is just going from strength to strength. Not too much missing from their game apart from a bit more experience. They have achieved a great balance between aggression and discipline which resulted in the lop-sided penalty count. The Brums failed to match their physicality and aggression at the break down and spent the majority of the game back pedaling as a result of penalties or a pack on roller skates. Mick Byrne is doing a great job with these guys. Exciting to watch but glad the Brums got up 🙂
Brumbies breathe sigh of relief after holding on against physical Drua pack as super sub saves the day
Crusaders with out Scott Barrett are not that competitive. It was a real competition until he went off injured. I thought without him the Crusaders still put up a decent effort in front of their home crowd. But congrats anyway to the Reds. They are proving to be competitive against kiwi teams.
Reds snap 25-year drought in Christchurch to beat Crusaders as Wilson, Ryan star
Spot on. Not sure but I think Bernie was resting a few players. But that nearly burnt him. Can’t play the likes of Fiji without mobile on ballers like Reimer. Horses for courses and the run on pack was not the right composition. This was clear and obvious after the first 15 minutes. The Brumbies scrum was just disappointing and that is my biggest worry going forward. They just went backwards all night. I hope the reason Swain didn’t start was because he was being rested. He is the form lock for Brums at the moment by a long shot.
Brumbies breathe sigh of relief after holding on against physical Drua pack as super sub saves the day
Needs a bit more weight but he is looking really good. The whole pack is looking strong with AA back. Nice blend of youth and experience.
Brumbies knock over Hurricanes in statement win as Wright shines again behind forward pack
Gamble was disappointing. The whole team is just going through the motions. They just want this season to end. No point in trying to analyze a performance where players have just given up. What I saw last night was team that had completely lost any and all belief in each other and their coach. Just sad.
Force kill off Waratahs' final hopes once and for all as Donno comes back to haunt old side