The Roar
The Roar

Jimbob1972

Roar Rookie

Joined April 2015

0

Views

0

Published

3

Comments

Published

Comments

Jimbob1972 hasn't published any posts yet

Totally agree.
The comparison with Chris Scott is brilliant.
Chris Scott has man management skills in abundance .
Eddie needs to accept responsibility for the failure of his coup

Where to now for Collingwood?

Could not have put it better myself mate.
You are 100% correct.
He alienated the so called ” rat pack ” who all played for Malthouse. Loved Malthouse. They did not adhere to Buckleys Robot philosophy’s. These guys actually had personality and Buckley wanted them out so he could mould his own team.
Why ? We had a young list at the top end of the ladder. Why do it ?
Buckley systematically moved on Daisy, Didak, Jolly, Dawes, Shaw,Wellingham, Beams etc etc

The game plan has been atrocious for 5 years. The man talks in riddles, like on 360 , Chris Scott answers questions clearly and precisely yet Buckley is smug and cryptic. No wonder the players do not play for him. He cannot relate . He has no people skills. I can see why Geelong play so well under Chris Scott. He is to the point and open.

Eddies succession plan has failed dismally and he is too proud to admit it. For this reason he must go.
Buckley must go . Any other coach would be long gone.

Lock it in: Bucks and Eddie, it's time to go

So you were a member when Carlton were Buying their premierships and have jumped off since because the club doesn’t know how to run a successful accountable business. Fair enough. I agree that Collins lined his pockets on that deal.

Navy Blues continue to resemble a sinking ship

close