- Video
-
Club Roar
Captured a great grassroots sporting moment? We want to see it!Content Collections
The Roar Community
- Join
- Login
Roar Rookie
Joined October 2019
0
Views
0
Published
4
Comments
Published
Comments
Thanks for this interesting approach.
Couldn’t let the inclusion of Silvagni go without a response. He is clearly a very average player and wouldn’t get a game at WCE, Richmond, Geelong and a number of other teams.
There is no possible way he is in the best 11 players at Carlton. If he is, Carlton are years away from success.
What if Carlton and Collingwood joined forces?
What club I support is irrelevant. The article is about Chris Scott and particularly highlights his disastrous finals record. One of the points I was making was that Geelong might benefit from playing more games on the MCG which is 138 metres across rather than the skinny Kardinia Park which is 116 metres across. After all to become Premiers you have to win on the MCG.
Chris Scott: Success or failure?
What an appalling finals record which is not likely to get any better given the loss of Kelly and an ageing list.
It probably doesn’t help Chris Scott that he comes across as arrogant, carries on endlessly about playing finals at Kardinia Park and tries to play infantile mind games.
Playing at Kardinia Park with its peculiar dimensions is an interesting point. Although it helps get Geelong into the finals, you would have to wonder if more games at the MCG would help their finals cause.
Time for a change at the Cattery.
Chris Scott: Success or failure?
Hey Peter maybe you and Neil need to get a room……..
On the verge of an unlikely dynasty