Is Sandilands the best Ruckman in the competition?
By Mark E, 14 May 2009 The Crowd is a Roar Guru
- Tagged:
- Aaron Sandilands, AFL, Carlton Blues, Fremantle Dockers, Judd, Sandilands
Some experienced commentators are coming over to the view that the 211 centimetre giant from the West is towering over the rest of the competition not just in height, but now in effectiveness.
Saturday’s night game against Carlton may have confirmed what Dockers fans have been saying for a while, that when Aaron realised his own potential, he will be virtually unstoppable. He racked up an incredible 42 hit-outs in a dominant display.
However, it was the effectiveness of the taps that was most impressive. If there has been a criticism of Sandilands, it is that much of his good work is ‘sharked’ by opposition midfielders. Rucking to a rejuvenated Hasleby, the tallest man in the league found his target, frustrating Judd and other Carlton midfielders.
When not involved in the ruck, Sandilands was making life difficult for opposition back men, positioning his long reaching arms in the forward 50. With new rules prohibiting the chopping of the hands, Aaron pulled in some great marks, and kicked goals, building his tally to 25 touches.
With Cox far from his best, spending most of time building up statistics and not much else in the back half, Aaron may finally be getting the recognition Freo fans have been clamouring for.
Recommend this story.
Do you have what it takes to become a sports writer? Write for the roar
AFL articles
- Giants prepare to christen new AFL home (182)
- The players are right: bring back AFL State of Origin (144)
- Could an AFL player make it in the NRL? (82)
- My colleagues are wrong: AFL State of Origin is a terrible idea (81)
- GWS Giants deserves more credit (71)
- What AFL can learn from other sports (67)
- The most even AFL season in years (60)
- Neeld needs time to find his halo (0)
- AFL pundits need to start biting their tongues (3)
- Melbourne Demons’s problem is a lack of effort (23)
- What AFL can learn from other sports (67)
- Carlton and Melbourne: don’t believe the hype (4)
- Dear AFL: Give us a break (22)
- What is the best structure for a sporting league? (27)
- Explore:
- Aaron Sandilands, AFL, Carlton Blues, Fremantle Dockers, Judd, Sandilands

May 14th 2009 @ 11:45am
Kick2kick said | May 14th 2009 @ 11:45am | Report comment
I agree that Sandilands is finally getting the attention he deserves but the best ruckman? Not quite yet, easily the second best and both WA ruckman are miles ahead of any other ruckman in the competition.
Thing with Sandilands is that he has only been effective for the last two/ three weeks where Cox has done it for the last four years.