Lords and masters of Pakistan
By Vinay Verma, 12 Jul 2010 Vinay Verma is a Roar Guru
- Tagged:
- Australia, Azhar Ali, Cricket, Kamran Akmal, mohammad Aamer, mohammad asif, Pakistan, Pakistan cricket, Saeed Ajmal, Shahid Afridi, shoaib malik, umar akmal, Umar Gul
Australia’s opponents at Lords tomorrow night, Pakistan, will be looking to redeem themselves after their ‘banana peel’ skid-row performance down under. Do they have the steel in their backbone to fight for a win, or will they be capricious and play for themselves?
With the hindsight of Karma, sport is not cruel. It is the fairest arbiter of human endeavour known to man. It cares not for statistics. Injuries may curtail or end a promising career. On the flip side is the opportunity for someone else. It is not for nothing that thespians say “I hope you break a leg”.
In the bigger scheme of things life is never a disaster. Only opportunity. Steven Smith will make his debut courtesy of an injury to Nathan Haurtitz. Peter George may also be the ‘lucky loser’ of Ryan Harris’s over-exertions. Tim Paine is already a beneficiary of Haddin’s misfortune.
Cricket is littered with the broken china of misfortune. It is also fired by the life force of new beginnings.
The individual brilliance of Umar Akmal is not in doubt. He is the only Pakistan player with a Test average in the 40’s. But the rest of their batting looks green with the absence of the Y factors: Younis and Yousuf.
Pakistan cricket was a force for the decade from 1985-1995. It had until then been ruled by The House of Mohammed and the House of Khan. Now it resembles the House of Shuttered windows where cobwebs fight with dust for ascendancy
Salman Butt will have a new opening partner and may be under pressure to shield him. This will make him vulnerable and leave him exposed to Johnson and company.
Shahid Afridi will not be allowed the latitude of the shorter format and he has not played Test cricket for a long time. I also suspect his mindset is not geared to the longer format and this will tell on days two and three. Australia must not be sucked in to playing one day cricket.
Watson and Katich at the top of the order need to convert their starts and score big. Pakistan has decided not to include Shoaib Akhtar in their Test plans and may regret this. If they could have fielded their Triple-A fastmen, Asif, Akhtar and Aamer, they may have bested the Australian batting.
But in the absence of the Rawalpindi Express they have a workmanlike attack, at best.
Kaneria and Ajmal will not have much impact on a Lords wicket that will play true but without much turn. Pakistan may only play Ajmal and rely on Afridi to bowl some legspin. For Afridi to be effective he will have to slow down his delivery. He was never a Test match bowler and will struggle.
Mohammad Asif is the man that can help Pakistan. Unfortunately his off-field line and length has not matched his control with ball in hand. He has had more scandal in his three years of cricket than Peyton Place.
There is always intrigue surrounding Pakistan and the Pakistan cricket team.
Shahrayar Khan, (former head of Pakistan Cricket) writes in “Shadows across the Playing Field” more in hope than in conviction:
“Cricket can be the glue that holds Pakistan together.”
In the end the Pakistan people have been failed by their leaders, both civilian and military. Dr. Ashraf (Butt’s predecessor) is comfortably ensconced in the USA and his benefactor Pervez Musharaff (ex-President of Pakistan) was recently on a lucrative world speaking tour.
The politicians and generals have systematically propagated politics of hate and, one suspects, brazenly increased their Swiss Bank balances.
Can Afridi unite a team where the politicians cannot unite a country? Can Afridi feel comfortable with the people around him? He has also not played Test cricket for some years and Pakistan’s form against Australia is dismal.
The last time Pakistan beat Australia in a Test was in 1995 at the SCG. Since 1998 Pakistan have played Australia fifteen times for two draws and thirteen losses, twelve of these losses in succession. One would think the bets are off and this is a one horse race.
Australia’s form on paper is good but they have looked far from the champion side that dominated world cricket from 1995 to 2007.
Pakistan has the bowlers to worry Australia. In Umar Gul they have a practioner of the toe-crusher that would land him a walkup start in Underbelly. Pakistan has in Mohammed Aamer the next best thing since Wasim Akram. “I was even skinnier than him when I was 18”. Wasim has high hopes for this young man.
Steven Smith is the most exciting youngster I have seen since Doug Walters. He is effervescent and fields like Jonty Rhodes and Colin Bland combined.
He must play.
Whether he bats at 6 or 8 will depend on what the selectors do with North. The conservative approach would be to retain him. The attacking approach would be to drop him. If your top five cannot do the job then you are in trouble anyway.
Dropping North may also take the Australian batsmen out of their comfort zone. We may finally see them converting their starts into big scores. This was their Achilles heel last summer.
Pakistan’s likely XI will be Butt, Hameed, Azhar Ali, Umar Akmal, Shoaib Malik, Shahid Afridi, Kamran Akmal, Mohammad Aamer, Umar Gul, Saeed Ajmal and Mohammad Asif. Perhaps Imran Farhat will get the nod over Hameed.
Australia will go with Katich, Watson, Ponting, Clarke, Hussey, North/Khawaja, Paine, Smith, Johnson, Hilfenhaus and Bollinger.
Khawaja and Peter George may have to wait till one of the incumbents breaks a leg.
This Test series will tell us more about Pakistan than it will about Australia.
© AAP 2013
July 12th 2010 @ 8:53am
Kersi Meher-Homji said | July 12th 2010 @ 8:53am | Report comment
Vinay,
Written with fact and tact, balance and epigrams.
But to describe Steven Smith fielding like Jointy Rhodes and Colin Bland combined is going over the top. I admire him but let us not put too much pressure on him.
I also admire Afridi’s guts. He is what Pakistan needs. But then he does silly things. Hope we see the Dr Jekyll Afridi and not Mr Hyde Afridi.
July 12th 2010 @ 12:22pm
Vinay Verma said | July 12th 2010 @ 12:22pm | Report comment
Kersi,pressure is character building and I think SS can cope. Afridi will have to perform with bat and ball. He has only taken one 5w haul in tests and has never been a matchwinner with his bowling. However he can change a game with his batting..unfortunately,he may be coming in at 4 for not many and then it becomes a lost cause. His fielding can be inspirational but I have a feeling he may be the weakest link in the chain.
July 12th 2010 @ 9:17am
Brett McKay said | July 12th 2010 @ 9:17am | Report comment
“With the hindsight of Karma, sport is not cruel.”
Wow Vinay, wow. And I haven’t had my morning coffee yet…..
Agree on your preview though, generally speaking, and it’s a real glimpse of the future in this Australian team. First time in Australian cricket history that three Tasmanians feature in the First XI. No Queenslanders, no Victorians and no South Australians.
North is safe for this series, he’s coming off a last-start Test century, and with Paine and Smith to follow him in the order, on debut, and at Lord’s no less (is there a better place in world cricket to make your Test debut?!?), they’ll need the experienced heads of Hussey and North in the middle to help the young pups through.
Your assertion that this “series will tell us more about Pakistan than it will about Australia” is spot on, in my view. Afridi is an interesting choice as Test captain, and this series could make or break him as a Test cricketer. Hasn’t played a Test since 2006, and with a batting average only a few runs higher than his bowling ave (does strike at 86+ though!). Where he fits into the grand scheme of things will be inetresting..
July 12th 2010 @ 10:53am
Vinay Verma said | July 12th 2010 @ 10:53am | Report comment
Brett,something about the water in Tassie. They also make the best beers and whites. I would like to see Khawaja for North but it is unlikely.
Pakistan have not been consistent since the demise of Bob Woolmer. There is something about the work ethic of subcontinental teams that only improves with an Aussie or Saffa coach. Bayliss,Siddons and Kirsten. As you know Dav Whatmore is the head of the Indian Academy and has a lot of input. So perhaps Pakistan missed a trick with the premature exit of Geoff Lawson. I also doubt that any of the Pak bowlers have an average under 30.
July 12th 2010 @ 9:54am
Whiteline said | July 12th 2010 @ 9:54am | Report comment
Nice work Vinay.
I’m going to agree with Kersi on his comment about Smith. Jonty Rhodes?? Please Vinay, I know you can get excited but Jonty was one of a kind. I didn’t have the plesure of seeing Bland but I read he was in the top few.
I guess this is a good series to bring Smith in as I suspect he’ll get a few wickets against the undisciplined Pakistani’s which will help relieve a bit of pressure on him. He is a bowler after all, isn’t he?
July 12th 2010 @ 10:57am
Vinay Verma said | July 12th 2010 @ 10:57am | Report comment
Whiteline, I did say “fields Like…” Not better than….Bland was top drawer..had people hit high balls to him in practice…then lie down prone on his back and catch the ball inches from his nose.
Smith is being picked as a bowler but can easily bat in the top six. That is why North is upsetting the balance of the side. Playing Smith at 6 would allow Australia to have four front line pacemen. I do not believe Watson can be the fifth bowler.
July 12th 2010 @ 11:01am
Whiteline said | July 12th 2010 @ 11:01am | Report comment
I agree that North is surplus to requirements. I’d like to see Smith bat at 6 and given an extended run in the team. If the selectors believe he is the real deal (ala Steve Waugh) then leave him there for as long as it takes. He may turn out to be a batsman only…or an allrounder – who knows at this stage.
July 12th 2010 @ 6:21pm
Lolly said | July 12th 2010 @ 6:21pm | Report comment
North is peculiar, isn’t he? He was an odd pick for the SA tour, but has played better than expected at times. I think his bowling was expected to have been more useful than has proved.I don’t believe that we can afford him and Hussey in the same team while Punter isn’t that reliable anymore.
It would be good to see Khawaja get a game but that is unlikely. I don’t like seeing the hype around Smith, he hasn’t got the bowling stats yet to justify it, but that is international cricket these days and he has to deal with it and become his own player.
One last thing, the weather will probably be very much ‘English conditions’ and I am hoping so as I love watching Asif bowl in helpful conditions. He can be unplayable.
July 12th 2010 @ 6:31pm
Vinay Verma said | July 12th 2010 @ 6:31pm | Report comment
Lolly, I have tried to be fair to North as he is an intense “young” man and is probably trying too hard to make every innings count. He has certainly proved he is capable of scoring hundreds but I am not convinced he can set up games for Australia at number six. I have not looked at his first innings stats because this will tell the story. I know he has played well but I believe it may have been in the second innings. His bowling is definitely not Test Class.
As far as Smith is concerned I just have that feeling watching him live that he is someone special. I will go with this gut feel till I am proved wrong. His effort in taking five for and bowling NSW to victory at the end of the last season showed how far he has come in his bowling. You only get better with bowling to better batters. Warne took 1-150 in his first Test. Admittedly he was playing against Shatri,Tendulkar and co.
Asif can be devastating..on and off the pitch. He is a class act when he gets it together..how Afridi gels with him is going to be important.
July 13th 2010 @ 1:08am
Lolly said | July 13th 2010 @ 1:08am | Report comment
This was a nice all-round article about both teams, Vinay. Should have said that in my first response.
Warne wasn’t following on and getting all the press comparing him with the great ‘Warne’ if you get my meaning. There is a lot of pressure on young Steve Smith, but that is international cricket, isn’t it? Everybody is to desperate for a new young star. I really think he will learn better at international level than in State cricket in Aus at any rate. Most state teams appear to be happy to thoroughly mistreat and undermine their spin bowlers.
I live not far from Lords and the weather is very changeable to put it mildly. If it is like this tomorrow, the bowlers might be far happier than the batsmen, but that makes for fun cricket.
I am curious about Watson. He hasn’t been bowled since the first ODi and hasn’t been in good nick with the bat. If he can’t bowl and Smith bowls ordinarily, lots of work for the three quicks. I am taking it for granted of course than MJ won’t lose the plot again.
I quite like Afridi. One never knows what he will get up to, but he is very enthusiastic, talks to his bowlers a lot and isn’t likely to leave them with too defensive fields.
July 13th 2010 @ 2:57am
Rod said | July 13th 2010 @ 2:57am | Report comment
Mr VV (not Luxman)….thouroughly enjouyed your preview with anecdotes, wit and insight…as a betting man – would you assume a result in this match – or will the elements hovering over Lord’s have the last say??
The more i see of Australia…the more the bars of the once invincile team start to dissapear…the no-nonsense , tough guy approach of the likes of Waugh , Warne and McGrath are amiss…
July 13th 2010 @ 7:52am
Vinay Verma said | July 13th 2010 @ 7:52am | Report comment
Rod,never bet on sport involving humans. OK with the horses.
The weather could play a part but the bowlers will still have to bowl in the right areas. Yesterday in helpful conditions the Bangladesh bowlers bowled too short and after the first 10 overs life became easy. And you don’t have to be express..Bopara with his military mediums took the bowling honours for England.
July 13th 2010 @ 11:48am
Vinay Verma said | July 13th 2010 @ 11:48am | Report comment
Lolly, The weather for the next four days is forecast as showery with a top of 16 degrees. The toss becomes crucial. Bothe sides will want to bowl. Australia must resist the temptation to bat if they win the toss. Pakistan’s strength is their bowling and should not be given first use..presuming Punter wins the toss. Afridi will definitely want to bowl. You may get your wish,Lolly.
In fact the match is likely to be a cracker and first innings runs will be at a premium.
July 14th 2010 @ 4:14am
Lolly said | July 14th 2010 @ 4:14am | Report comment
Bingo!
At least Punter can’t cop any flak. Losing the toss means he can’t get the tutting that he got at the SCG. Considering what I thought when I saw the weather this morning and found out about the toss, I actually think that 9/229 isn’t that bad by our standards.
Young Aamer is such a talent. And Mr Asif did as I expected.
July 14th 2010 @ 7:57am
Vinay Verma said | July 14th 2010 @ 7:57am | Report comment
Lolly,you got your wish, Asif started slowly,as if he needed miles in the legs. He warmed to his task later and had the ball talking an audacious language. And Aamer had the ball swinging,both Reverse and Perverse.
July 13th 2010 @ 11:54am
sledgeross said | July 13th 2010 @ 11:54am | Report comment
Im looking forward to the headingley test, where it will really be a “Home crowd” for Pakistan. I remember ducking into Gangsters takeaway on Kirkstall lane plenty of times and listening to the young blokes talk up the Pakistani team, and also how they love to see teh Aussies beating the Poms!
July 13th 2010 @ 12:03pm
Vinay Verma said | July 13th 2010 @ 12:03pm | Report comment
sledgecross, I am looking forward to Ponting batting..will he hook early on or won’t he?
July 13th 2010 @ 2:30pm
sledgeross said | July 13th 2010 @ 2:30pm | Report comment
Of course he will mate! He will want to tame the (potentially) lethal young lions of the Pakistan bowling.
July 13th 2010 @ 4:56pm
Vinay Verma said | July 13th 2010 @ 4:56pm | Report comment
sledgecross,talking of Lions Imran was widely known as the Lion of Lahore. He was a strong captain and a lot of his strength came from the fact that the President then ,Zia ul Haq,gave Imran free reign. There was no mucking around with selectors. The selectors gave Imran the team he wanted. In many ways Imran picked the team himself. Maybe in a dictatorship that is the way to go.
But this current team is picked by pussycats and the captain may well be a paper tiger. We shall see.
July 14th 2010 @ 6:01am
Ian Noble said | July 14th 2010 @ 6:01am | Report comment
Losing 8 wickets for or so says something about Aussie batting. Tomorrow rain in London and humid weather will probably even things, pity Aus hasn’t a “Massie”.
July 14th 2010 @ 8:01am
Vinay Verma said | July 14th 2010 @ 8:01am | Report comment
Ian, It was difficult batting out there. If Pakistan had bowled the right length and line in the first 13 overs they could have had Australia 3 or 4 down for not many. This will be a low scoring match and I am confident the Australian bowlers will not let Pakistan get away.
Hilfenhaus can do a Massie if he gets it right. He swings it at pace and I have great expectations of him.