Robert Kubica’s Renault test is a win-win

Michael Lamonato Columnist

By Michael Lamonato, Michael Lamonato is a Roar Expert

Tagged:
 , ,

7 Have your say

    Robert Kubica on the podium back in 2010. (AP Photo/Yves Logghe)

    Related coverage

    It began years ago as a pipedream. Before too long it morphed into a fanciful hypothetical. More recently it became a rumour. Today it stands as an achingly reachable reality.

    Robert Kubica, Formula One’s first and only Polish driver and a man ranked by Fernando Alonso as the best of his generation, could be on the cusp of making an unlikely Formula One comeback.

    Once upon a time the Pole had all before him. His burgeoning reputation, boosted by an ultimately derailed title tilt in just his second full season in F1, was opening doors at the top of the grid. Greatness seemed inevitable.

    But a grizzly rally crash on 6 February 2011 robbed Kubica of his bright future when a metal guard rail pierced his car and partially severed his right arm at the Ronde di Andora rally.

    A long period of rehabilitation followed, but the loss of strength and dexterity in the affected arm was thought to bar him from entering the confined space of a single-seater cockpit. He took to rallying with mixed success, including the 2013 World Rally Championship-2 title, but quietly he plotted a course back to the pinnacle of motor racing.

    Kubica tested his abilities in Formula E and GP3 cars earlier this year reportedly untroubled — bear in mind that GP3 cars have no power steering — but it was an apparently cancelled marketing day that gave him the opportunity to step up to F1 machinery, albeit a 2012 car.

    When his 115 laps in the Lotus E20 featured times better than those set by Renault reserve driver Sergey Sirotkin, who was also present, a second test was quietly planned for the shadows of the British Grand Prix.

    It too was a rousing success.

    “I can still tell you he’s very quick,” Renault boss Cyril Abiteboul reported back at Silverstone after Kubica completed 90 laps. “He’s still very consistent and, more importantly, he still has the energy and drive and enthusiasm he always had and carried to him and to the team.”

    Though he acknowledged the incidental positive publicity bonus generated by putting the popular Pole in one of his cars, Abiteboul was keen to downplay expectations — “There is a big reality that it is a Formula One car from 2012 with demo tyres, with V8 engine,” he said — but Kubica himself immediately felt at home in top-tier machinery.

    After just the first test he told Auto Express that he ranked his chances of a return at “80 or 90 per cent”, and after the second he told L’Equipe, “Physically there are no problems. My doubts about my capacities have disappeared with these two days of tests”.

    The only step missing in the Kubica comeback is a test in modern machinery, in particular 2017’s demanding high-downforce cars.

    Happily one of the sport’s precious few in-season tests is set for immediately after this weekend’s Hungarian Grand Prix, and the regulations allow Kubica to take the wheel on one of the two days.

    Naturally enough Renault has confirmed Kubica will take his place in the car next Wednesday, the second day of the test — and its aim, for the first time, is clearly stated.

    “After this test we will carefully analyse the collected information to determine in what conditions it would be possible for Robert to return to competition in the upcoming years,” Abiteboul said in a statement — but don’t be surprised if Renault acts more decisively than by merely considering “upcoming years”.

    The 2017 season may be a rebuilding year for Renault, but its lowly eighth place in the constructors standings is nonetheless off target.

    Unfortunately for Jolyon Palmer, he must shoulder most of the blame, for had he scored as heavily as teammate Nico Hülkenberg in the opening 10 rounds of the year, Renault would be a clear fifth on the table.

    Given Kubica couldn’t score fewer than Palmer’s zero points and given Renault has no championship pressure to consider this early in its reconstruction anyway, a midseason switch between the Pole and the Englishman — providing Kubica were to test successfully in Hungary — carries no risk as the logical option.

    A Kubica substitute offers only two potential outcomes. The first is that he returns to F1 effortlessly and picks up his career where he left off, delivering one of sport’s all-time great comebacks and a beautiful narrative for Formula One.

    The second is that Formula One proves beyond Kubica’s injuries, in which case he and Renault can part amicably after nine races knowing they tried but that the comeback ultimately wasn’t to be.

    It would be a harsh blow for Palmer, but the Briton, bluntly, has not performed to the standard mandated by a manufacturer team, marking himself superfluous to Renault’s long-term plans.

    It adds up to a simple conclusion: a Kubica-driven Renault is a win-win proposition for both — and for one of Formula One’s great unfinished narratives.

    Michael Lamonato
    Michael Lamonato

    Michael is one-third of F1 podcast Box of Neutrals, as heard weekly on ABC Grandstand Digital nationwide. Though he's been part of the F1's travelling press room since 2012, people seem more interested in the time he was sick in a kart — but don't ask about that, follow him on Twitter instead @MichaelLamonato.

    Oldest | Newest | Most Recent

    The Crowd Says (7)

    • July 25th 2017 @ 6:49pm
      Simoc said | July 25th 2017 @ 6:49pm | ! Report

      Kubica back in F1 would be great. He is so lucky to be alive as I think the video of the crash shows. Palmer has been poor (to be polite) and Hulkenburg is making to many mistakes. I think Kubica would force him to lift his game and the result would be podiums to Renault. They should be measuring themselves against Red Bull and they’re a long second. Kubica could help change that.

      • Columnist

        July 27th 2017 @ 12:33am
        Michael Lamonato said | July 27th 2017 @ 12:33am | ! Report

        It was a very serious crash, and certainly, he’s lucky to have escaped without losing his arm. It would be a phenomenal comeback story, particularly if he was as competitive as he was.

        I think he’d be an ideal partner for Hulkenberg, but I don’t agree that Nico has been making too many mistakes. He’s been a solid performer so far this year — needless to say he’s held the team up. I wouldn’t expect Kubica to be on his pace immediately, but Hulkenberg would be a good benchmark for him should he arrive back in Formula One in the next six months.

    • Roar Guru

      July 25th 2017 @ 10:18pm
      Mark Young said | July 25th 2017 @ 10:18pm | ! Report

      Well done Michael, nailed this in one.

    • Roar Guru

      July 25th 2017 @ 10:24pm
      Mark Young said | July 25th 2017 @ 10:24pm | ! Report

      There has always been an unwritten rule of the sport, that if you beat your teammate year in, year out, you will eventually get your chance in a race winning car and a shot at the title.
      Barring misfortune of course.

      That Robert Kubica missed that chance, WAS the greatest missed opportunity for we fans in the last 20 years. Imagine Lewis Hamilton having injured himself seriously two races into 2007, or a young Sebastian Vettel spinning off and being seriously hurt at Monza 2008.

      Bobby K should have spent the last decade duking it out with Lewis, Fernando, Seb and Daniel as a top dog. Maybe this dream isn’t over,

      • Columnist

        July 27th 2017 @ 12:34am
        Michael Lamonato said | July 27th 2017 @ 12:34am | ! Report

        Thanks, mate! You’re spot on, he should’ve been one of this generation’s great talents, and that he was lined up for a Ferrari drive only emphasises how serious a contender he could’ve been. Perhaps we’ll find out after all!

    • July 26th 2017 @ 4:46pm
      Mad Dog said | July 26th 2017 @ 4:46pm | ! Report

      Nice article Michael, agree 100%. Palmer hasn’t done enough to really keep a seat and the reality is that even if Kubica gets 0 points this year its still not a bad move because I’m sure he’ll be more useful in terms of car development than Palmer is. Also, if he does prove in the tests that he is worthy of a seat it’ll be important for Renault to get him before the likes of Williams who im sure are looking for a replacement for Massa

      • Columnist

        July 27th 2017 @ 12:36am
        Michael Lamonato said | July 27th 2017 @ 12:36am | ! Report

        Thanks, buddy — I think you’re right to say that there’s not really any down side in replacing Palmer with Kubica next month. The team would lose very little overall — with all due respect to Palmer — while potentially locking down a front-running driver in time for it to enter the race-winning phase of its rebuild.

    Have Your Say



    If not logged in, please enter your name and email before submitting your comment. Please review our comments policy before posting on the Roar.

    Explore:
    , ,