When Mick Malthouse was appointed Carlton’s new coach we all expected him to instantly work magic. The team would be better drilled and adapt to a new game style that would result in improved consistency and greater success.
It’s now a time for reflection.
Is Mick the messiah we expected? Was Stephen Kernahan the only supporter of Brett Ratten who, now looking back, had the Blues firing on more cylinders and playing exciting footy until injuries struck?
Is a paranoia now creeping into the minds of Carlton supporters?
Carlton defeated Collingwood very easily in 2012 and now, with Mick at the helm, Carlton has been easily defeated in 2013 in their opening three matches.
What if Mick had a better team at Collingwood and more flexibility? Will it take all year to implement a new defensive game style, which doesn’t look like the players are adapting to?
The players appear to enjoy the ‘roll-the-dice’ game style for which they are well suited. It’s not working for much of the game, so they are being out-scored due to defensive inadequacies.
Why didn’t Carlton participate in the pre-season draft? Did Mick want to see what the existing players could do first?
Blind Freddy knew Carlton had no big forward or someone who could dominate the contest to the extent the Eddie Bettses of the team could capitalise on.
It’s not surprising we are sitting here looking down the barrel of four and zip as it all stacks up.
One can’t help thinking, what were Carlton thinking about for 2013?
Mick’s media conferences seem to indicate he’s not concerned and so do the players. It’s as if they are Melbourne or a team re-building, but they cannot afford to use 2013 season as an experiment.
Like all things AFL it’s possible after Round 4 the scrutiny will be more severe on Mick (and the club hierarchy), which may not be ameliorated by a win over Melbourne.
Carlton needs to fix its deficiencies quickly and become a team that can defeat top teams consistently and not every now and again.
This should be their goal and not the ‘we focus on the process’ and ‘it’s not about how many wins’ tripe that Mick has reiterated recently.
Is Mick really the messiah?
Who’s in your ultimate team? Pick the best team and compete with other fans for daily prizes on Draftstars. For the best odds on the game try out Aussie bookmaker PlayUp. Think. Is this a bet you really want to place? Set a deposit limit.
"That's the worst sound in footy!"
Nick Daicos' moment of brilliance to seal the win needed some equally magnificent commentary. Enter... 3AW's Anthony Hudson!
As a Carlton supporter, this is probably Sam Pang's idea of Hell!
Sometimes after 120 minutes of blood, sweat, tears and momentum swings, our game makes it so that none of that really matters. With three…
Luke Hodge certainly thought so!
