Live scores
Live Commentary
| 2:00

RATHBONE: Review of concussion protocols no brainer

Clyde Rathbone Columnist

By Clyde Rathbone, Clyde Rathbone is a Roar Expert

 , , , ,

44 Have your say

    A medical doctor attends to Lachlan Turner. (AAP Image/Sergio Dionisio)

    Related coverage

    Make no mistake about it – the Lions series was great! Rugby really was the winner, unless rugby is the nickname for George Smiths brain.

    Four days after my ‘head injury’ column, George delighted us all with one of the great noggin’ smashing moments in living memory!

    Look, I love a good brain injury as much as the next guy. The mouth agape in slack jawed confusion, the groggy snake leg shuffle, eyeballs rolled back and the general “where am I – ahem – who am I?” expressions on the faces of the latest hapless victim really is priceless.

    I get it, people, brain injuries are the new black.

    How else could one explain return-to-play timeframes reduced from three weeks to five minutes! The public need entertaining and there’s only so much the Tabbot and Kruddy can do to bring raucous laughter into our homes.

    All I’m suggesting is that to keep ‘the game they play in heaven’ off life-support we need to ensure our players avoid it too.

    Think about it: if we don’t do something soon there will be nothing left but soccer mums and the ultimate brain damage sport – the NRL.

    Rugby might have the Foxkopter, but the NRL’s robot – Tom Waterhouse – is far more impressive. Five minutes of Tom will have you booking a lobotomy, and his advertised service provides generous odds on the likely success or failure of the operation. But I digress.

    We know brain injury is amusing, but we don’t yet have a great understanding of it. At least not to the extent that there is consensus regarding return-to-play protocols. This fact alone should mean that guidelines err on the side of caution and are weighted in favour of player welfare. It would be useful to have an independent panel of experts design evidence-based return-to-play protocols.

    With all this talk of brain damage it would be remiss of me not to mention James O’Connor. Plenty of people seem delighted by JOC’s fall from grace, but the reality is that we’re all the poorer for his form – both on and off the pitch.

    Rugby in Australia needs players like JOC thriving. Instead he seems intent on playing russian roulette with his career. During televised interviews JOC does not come across as stupid as his actions suggest. And where there’s smarts there is hope.

    To see if intelligent life exists on planet JOC, I turned to the one thing intent on extinguishing it – social media.

    JOC has 165,000 followers on Twitter, so I thought I’d hang out there and see what he is all about. After about 20 minutes I left convinced that JOC might also be a German robot intent on harming my brain.

    My dad once told me that my life would be much easier if I just stopped doing stupid things. My dad likes taking his pants off for photographs but his advice is still sound.

    While I’m not quite old enough to be James’ dad I guess, I could be an older, more handsome big brother. With this in mind I’d like to offer him some words of wisdom. It would be unfair to overload James with too much information so I’m going to identify a force multiplier – one factor that has a transformative advantageous effect.

    Drum roll please…

    Stop. Making. Moronic. Hand. Signs. In. Photographs. It makes you look very dumb indeed.

    When a privileged white kid makes gang signs we can be sure of one thing – irony is either deeply valued or completely lost on that person. While I concede JOC’s hand sign fetish may be an attempt at self deprecating satire, I reserve my doubts.

    I would just shelve the entire experiment. I understand this may be a little difficult to begin with, so if you feel your hands need some sort of weening off period, I would suggest the good old vanilla thumbs up. Trust me – your brand will thank you for it.

    If abandoning gang signs is the bad news the good news is very good indeed. The good news is that you, James, have all the potential to become one of the best rugby players of your generation. What that makes you is incredibly fortunate.

    A little humility and perspective means that instead of material possessions, image, fame or power you might come to realise that the most important thing is the positive difference you make in the lives of others.

    What you decide to do with this opportunity is entirely up to you.

    Follow @ClydeRathbone on Twitter

    Clyde Rathbone
    Clyde Rathbone

    Former Wallaby & Brumby Clyde Rathbone retired from rugby in 2014. Clyde is a writer, speaker and technology startup founder. A Roar columnist since 2012, you can follow Clyde via his Twitter page.

    Have Your Say

    If not logged in, please enter your name and email before submitting your comment. Please review our comments policy before posting on the Roar.

    Oldest | Newest | Most Recent

    The Crowd Says (44)

    • July 16th 2013 @ 1:44am
      cm said | July 16th 2013 @ 1:44am | ! Report

      Great article, Clyde. Your best yet. Thanks!

    • July 16th 2013 @ 5:27am
      Billy Bob said | July 16th 2013 @ 5:27am | ! Report

      Very funny Clyde, ‘

    • July 16th 2013 @ 5:37am
      peterlala said | July 16th 2013 @ 5:37am | ! Report

      Timelty article, Clyde. Well done. For the record, I’ve seen so many head knocks, and become so aware of their long-term effects, I don’t find it funny to see someone staggering around semi-conscious.

      I find it literally sickening that return-to-play guidelines were reduced from three weeks to five minutes, as you say.

    • July 16th 2013 @ 6:10am
      Runit said | July 16th 2013 @ 6:10am | ! Report

      Clyde that is brilliant, master of satire, let’s hope JOC gets the message

    • July 16th 2013 @ 8:13am
      Seagull said | July 16th 2013 @ 8:13am | ! Report

      Clyde that is a completely brilliant post. Funny, poignant and insightful.You have real talent as a writer mate – not that there was any doubt. I hope you’ve got the book started!

    • Roar Guru

      July 16th 2013 @ 8:56am
      M.O.C. said | July 16th 2013 @ 8:56am | ! Report

      What I think is interesting about Smith’s case against the Lions was that return to play following his “passing” the pitch-side concussion testing.

      Smith should never have undergone the test in the first place as he lost consciousness in the tackle. (From a Paul Lewis article in the New Zealand Herald states “A player is withdrawn instantly (no PSCA needed) if he exhibits ‘tonic posturing’ (when a player is knocked out, he sometimes raises an arm while prone, almost like signalling a bus); if he has a traumatic convulsion; or if a doctor confirms a loss of consciousness through ‘direct observation’

      Surely anyone who saw his head knock and subsequent fall must be certain he lost consciousness and therefore been automatically excluded and should have hot have even been given the PSCA test.

    , , , ,