The Roar
The Roar


Why Geelong, Sydney and Hawthorn will miss the finals

Autoplay in... 6 (Cancel)
Up Next No more videos! Playlist is empty -
Roar Guru
19th March, 2019

One day before the AFL season commences, it’s time to do a quick season preview – including ladder predictions, premiers, runners-up, Coleman Medal, Brownlow Medal and Rising Star award winner as well.

1. Richmond – 19 wins, 3 losses (132.3%)
The Tigers had a misstep failing to make the 2018 grand final against eventual premiers West Coast, losing to Collingwood in one of the biggest shocks of the 2018 finals series.

Jack Riewoldt of the Tigers celebrates kicking a goal during the 2017 AFL Grand Final match between the Adelaide Crows and the Richmond Tigers at Melbourne Cricket Ground on September 30, 2017 in Melbourne, Australia.

(Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

Richmond will struggle early, but beyond Round 7 will be hard to beat with the likes of Tom Lynch firing in his first season, and a potent forward line of Josh Caddy, Jack Riewoldt and Jack Higgins.

2. Melbourne – 18 wins, 4 losses (132.9%)
Melbourne will have a defining season and will be one of the hot favourites with a favourable draw heading their way towards the latter part of the season. Melbourne will hold top spot over the weeks during the middle of the year.

However, they’ll fall away, lose a few games against Collingwood and Richmond, and finish second. Watch out for Clayton Oliver who is a heavy favourite to take home the Brownlow.

3. Adelaide – 18 wins, 4 losses (112.9%)
The big movers of 2019, after a 2018 to forget due to the pre-season camp from hell.

Adelaide will join Collingwood as the two undefeated sides after Round 9, and will remain undefeated in season 2019 until Round 11 when they will be beaten heavily again by the Demons in Alice Springs.

Watch out for Eddie Betts and Josh Jenkins to have a good season up forward, the midfield will gel without ‘Tex’ Walker as captain and Sloane will lead the charge heading towards September.


4. Collingwood – 17 wins, 5 losses (123.7%)
Similar to Adelaide, they will be looking good up until their first loss to Sydney in Round 10.

Collingwood will then crumble to teams like Melbourne, Richmond and West Coast in the latter part of the season.

The Pies look the goods with a strong showing in the JLT Series, and can definitely create headaches in September.

5. West Coast – 17 wins, 5 losses (120.6%)
Nothing split Collingwood and West Coast. The Eagles will be flying over the course of the season and the return of Nic Naitanui from a second ACL injury will see the Fijian look stronger and more dominant than he has ever been.

Nic Naitanui

(Photo by Paul Kane/Getty Images)

West Coast will just finish outside the four, but only by percentage – even if they beat the Crows comfortably, who finish higher and will be in the top echelon regarding team form.

6. GWS – 13 wins, 9 losses (111.8%)
GWS will fortunately have a more consistent season than their one in 2018, but won’t be anywhere near the top and will be the team that stays steady in the top eight from the start of the season right until Round 23.

Josh Kelly and Stephen Coniglio will go toe-to-toe on Brownlow Medal night, stealing votes off each other as they will make up the spine of the Giants midfield, Jacob Hopper will show why he was part of the GWS academy with a career-defining season.


7. Essendon – 13 wins, 9 losses (106.3%)
The Bombers will play finals in 2019 with the acquisition of Dylan Shiel, who will fit well into the Bombers best 22 and perhaps be their No.1 midfielder at the end of the season.

Jake Stringer looks more comfortable in the red and black, and will fire up forward for the Bombers, returning to the form which he had back at the Bulldogs during the 2016 season.

8. Brisbane – 11 wins, 11 losses (103.6%)
Brisbane will be playing September football, and even though they’ll fall to Richmond in Round 23, they will have a high enough percentage to edge out the teams finishing ninth, tenth and 11th.

Chris Fagan has turned this Brisbane side around with smart trading and smart drafting and will be everybody’s biggest shockers of 2018.

The Lions will pull off some upset wins, and turn the Gabba yet again into a fortress, which will make it difficult for the away teams.

9. Geelong – 11 wins, 11 losses (103.5%)
Geelong will have a tough start to 2019, losing their first three games of the season. Geelong will be near or edging the top eight from the middle part of the year.

Chris Scott Geelong Cats AFL 2017

(Photo by Scott Barbour/Getty Images)

Even with a good win against Carlton in Round 23 at GMHBA, Chris Scott’s men miss out on the finals on percentage.


10. Sydney – 11 wins, 11 losses (102.0%)
Sydney will be the biggest sliders in 2019, they will slip to eight losses from their first nine games with the loss of Gary Rohan being a big blow.

‘Buddy’ Franklin is the one to look out for as the key to Sydney’s forward line. They’ll need to rely on the likes of Ben Ronke, Will Hayward and Sam Reid when Franklin doesn’t play crucial games.

Sydney also don’t have the best draw early on in the season, but similar to 2017, will make their move up the ladder. However they will fail just on percentage this time around, marking ten years since they last missed finals.

11. Hawthorn – 11 wins, 11 losses (99.5%)
The Hawks have a good draw early on heading into the first five rounds, where they will be kissing the top four.

Then form and a lack of urgency will see them drop down the ladder, and lose crucial games middle of the season.

Jaeger O’Meara is destined to finally have a first fully fit season in Hawks colours, and can play all 22 games if injury-free.

12. Port Adelaide – 9 wins, 13 losses (99.0%)
Port will have another inconsistent season, and it’ll see the Power fall out of the discussion of finishing in the top eight.

Port will terminate the contract of Ken Hinkley at season’s end. Michael Voss and John Barker will be considered for the senior role as coach of the Power, leading the boys from Alberton next season.


13. North Melbourne – 9 wins, 13 losses (94.6%)
North Melbourne will be one to look out for, but unfortunately North will have a down season in 2019.

North will lose plenty of close ones where they’ll be competitive, but still lacking that midfield urgency after Andrew Gaff decided to stay west and decline the offer North put on the table for him.

Ben Brown

(Photo by Quinn Rooney/Getty Images)

Ben Brown will be a danger for defenders as he and Jack Riewoldt will be vying for the Coleman Medal, Aaron Hall and Jared Polec having great first seasons for North, and Jack Ziebell leading the midfield.

14. Carlton – 8 wins, 14 losses (87.2%)
The Blues will be improvers and 2019 will see the rebuild start to shape up as Charlie Curnow, Patrick Cripps, Zac Fisher and Jacob Weitering have better seasons.

Mitch McGovern will settle nicely into the forward line alongside his partner-in-crime Harry McKay.

Blues should begin to press for finals in 2020, and scare a few teams over the course of the year.

15. Fremantle – 5 wins, 17 losses (82.1%)
Fremantle will have a challenging year as they begin what seems to be a rebuild of the side, which is a far cry from the squad they had challenging for the flag in 2013.


Rory Lobb will begin to fit into the squad as their new No.1 ruckman replacing Aaron Sandilands, their forwards will again improve with Matt Taberner tipped to have a career-defining season, Griffin Logue will become sharper down back for the Dockers and Jesse Hogan will be one to look out for after being stood down due to alcohol-related issues before Round 1.

16. Western Bulldogs – 4 wins, 18 losses (77.2%)
The Bulldogs are an interesting side, and can excel with more wins than slated here.

However, the Bulldogs did play a boring brand of football last year which saw them win just eight games and finish 13th.

The Bulldogs had an atrocious away record of three wins and eight losses, and will struggle against the improvers of Carlton, Brisbane and Essendon alongside a tough draw at the beginning of the season.

Expect Marcus Bontempelli and the leadership of Easton Wood help the young Dogs improve in all areas of the field, and definitely push to a eight-to-ten win season in 2020. New recruit Sam Lloyd will fit perfectly into the forward line for the Dogs.

17. St Kilda – 3 wins, 19 losses (79.2%)
Sorry to the Saints fans, but this will be a bottoming-out season for the boys from Moorabbin.

Paddy McCartin St Kilda Saints AFL 2017

(AAP Image/Tracey Nearmy)

Paddy McCartin and Dylan Roberton are two big losses, Jake Carlisle is out of form, and let’s hope Jack Stevens can get back out on the field – he will be your saving grace.


Dan Hannebery coming over to the Saints won’t pay off, and a lingering hamstring issue will see him miss half the season with the nagging injury that plagued him in Sydney.

Alan Richardson will be given his marching orders in the middle part of the season, and Brett Ratten will become caretaker coach before becoming the boss full-time.

18. Gold Coast – 1 win, 21 losses (63.3%)
Stuart Dew will have such a task on his hands as the Suns will register only one win in season 2019.

Their solitary win will come in Round 2 against Fremantle at Metricon, and unfortunately that’s where it ends for the Suns.

The new recruits of George Horlin-Smith and Anthony Miles plus new draftees Izak Rankine and Jack Lukosius will be the telling signs of where the future could be for the Suns in season 2019.

Expect Dew to again go to the draft and the AFL to give the Suns another compensation pick to help fast-track their rebuild.

With the 18 teams decided on where they’ll finish in season 2019, here are the other quick picks.


Premiers: Melbourne
Runners-up: Richmond
Brownlow Medal: Carlton’s Patrick Cripps, edging out Clayton Oliver and Josh Kelly
Coleman Medal: Tom Lynch (65 goals)
Rising Star Winner: Sam Walsh (Carlton)
Biggest improvers: Essendon, Adelaide and Brisbane
Biggest sliders: Port Adelaide, Hawthorn, Geelong and Sydney
Biggest news story: John Barker to become coach of Port Adelaide in 2020 after edging out Michael Voss in the coaching interviews